The owner was sooooo friendly and welcoming... Plus, it was matched by the delicious bagels. Even the young man that made my bagel was cool to talk with. Definitely, looking forward to coming back. This place is a WINNER!!! YUM!!! read more

Cute bagel shop in Alpharetta. It seems that they have something of a following as lots of customers are regulars! Good bagels and great choices of coffee. Service is however somewhat hectic! Cheese and everything bagel was great!! read more

See all

Food is always delicious and today's bagel sandwich and service experience was perfect from start to finish! I have been coming here nearly 10 years and the addition of Jess out front has been such a plus for the whole vibe of the place. She is always welcoming and greets everyone with a smile. read more

What a great way to start your Sunday ! or any day !! Bagel boys makes The best bagels in town !!! Worth the trip and buy some for the week too!!! Owner is Sweet and supports local schools - just fantastic all around and some great coffee too !!! read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - Toasted cheese bagel with egg and cheddar- sooo cheesy! - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

See all

I don't know if management changed here or what. But I can't tell you how many times I've ordered a bagel to eat there and they ring it up as a to-go order. No big deal but then they forget half of my order every single time. Make sure you check the bag if you do get it to go, 99.9% of the time if you order a salad they will NOT give it to you. And then the guy tried to question how I paid $20 for two bagels. Not sure if I want to keep coming here esp since they put the cream cheese in the bagel when they double toasted it and it was just like queso pouring out of the bagel. Super gross, couldn't even finish it. read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - Burnt bagel with grossly melted cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Ok but nowhere near B and B bagels. Disappointing that these weren't any better hopefully next time we visit

I love this place and frequent often. Today was not so great as one of the individuals working behind the counter, Jess, was horribly rude and angry and said some very demeaning things to me while I was ordering. I told the man on duty and he saw and heard this and said he would report to John the owner. Too many people want and need jobs to have someone that is so miserable waiting on people. Other than that, bagels are delicious and their food is delicious. read more

Food was terrible. My bagel barely had any cream cheese on it, and what was there tasted old and like it had been sitting in a fridge too long. The roast beef was dry and tough. I even skipped a side and asked for two pickles instead and got none. If they can't get the basics right, I definitely won't be coming back. read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - Roast beef sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

See all

Mixed review. Can be very good for Atlanta, Georgia area but you get here there very early or you get leftovers which are not the best. Bagel Boys are still a somewhat good choice for this area. read more

I ordered a catering package for a close friend at North Fulton Regional Hospital and they were spectacular. The manager reached out to ensure they had the right information to get the order to the patient, it was on time, and my friend and his family said the food was bountiful and delicious (this was the Lots of Bagels & Sweets package). Thank you so much for being such a great help! read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

My family and I love Bagel Boys Cafe. Whether we eat there or to-go the staff is efficient & friendly. The food is delicious- we love their bagels, bagel sandwiches, the chicken biscuit, muffin, and the drip coffee is also phenomenal. Cannot recommend this spot enough! read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - Bagel with Cream Cheese & Breakfast Dog - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Really off putting that asking for 6 bagels to be toasted was like asking for them to give me the moon. Do NOT plan on being able to get a families bagels toasted, or just bring your own toaster. Got the "too busy" to toast bagels at a bagel shop.... read more

Check your order very carefully if you are getting it to go. Look in the bag, open everything up. 85% of the time the order is wrong, and how frustrating to get home and have a meal or bagel you did not order. They give the wrong food to people, and cannot get an order right. It has been an ongoing problem for years. Sad as it's the only bagel place around. Others have also have had similar ongoing issues. We have even told the owner. read more

Excellent bagels and coffee. If only that one very loud customer who was there here when we arrived and still there when we left would use his indoor voice. I was surprised to find such good bagels in Alpharetta. But then why not? Everyone enjoys bagels, not just people who live in the center of the city. These were actually more the size of Montreal bagels -- not so far and puffy. Fresh, cheery with slightly crisp exterior. I'd certainly visit the Bagel Boys again if I were in the area. Way better than chain store bagels. read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - customers at the counter - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

My favorite bagel place, by far! I have tried many breakfast sandwiches and none compare to my order at bagel boys. Perfect and delicious every time read more

Always order plain bagels with berry and maple walnut cream cheese.other flavored bagels are available, but the plain are just perfect.

Outstanding bagels and customer service. 20 years is not an easy thing to accomplish and with 2 locations on each side of town, there's no excuse to not try them out. The moment we walked in, we were greeted by John who helped my friend and I decide on the best matches to our cravings. My friend got the jalapeño cheddar with chive cream cheese, it had a nice kick and i got a tomato cheddar bagel melt with spinach artichoke cream cheese, that came with fresh onions.. a perfect touch. While eating i was able to tell there were so many regulars and the love and care they had for John. Truth mom and pop which Is all i support. We left VERY happy because of these interactions, yes the food was amazing, but the ability to create a returning service in an organic way is rare these days. To many more years to come read more

Great bagels, substandard coffee. The bagels here are tasty, but when the Starbucks next door moved to the other end of the parking lot, the ability to have a great bagel alongside a great cup of coffee disappeared. While they have a wide array of choices (bold, kona, vanilla-hazelnut, cinnamon) it just not that good a coffee. read more

Great menu with great prices. Their bagels are incredible every time and I love their smoothies. The restaurant and bathrooms are always very clean. read more

Not happy! I never write reviews about restaurants but coming from New York City and working in the restaurant industry, this time i'am. Service from the back of house was poor, the orange juice is not freshly squeezed it's concentrated, the food has no taste and my order was completely wrong. The guy in the back didn't want add the ingredients that was in the order. read more

One of the best bagels I've had in this part of Georgia. The Asiago is my go to, it has raisins in it, don't know why that's not said. The cinnamon crunch is delicious. Do not get the cheddar everything, soooooo salty. I stop by whenever I'm in the neighborhood. Oh, and decent coffee read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - Asiago raising bagel and cinnamon raisin bagel - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

We had a small complaint, but someone from Bagel Boys called me within five minutes of posting the review and made it right. read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - Receipt for our purchase - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

I wouldn't come back here. I placed my order and the wait was fine. The staff wasn't the friendliest but I've come to expect that most places. There was ample seating inside but I was taking it to go. I got a ham egg and cheddar on an everything bagel and I paid for cream cheese on it, too. The cream cheese was so scant I had to triple check to make sure it was there. I couldn't taste it at all. The egg tasted and felt like it was microwaved. I have had much better bagel sandwiches. My usual place was out of the way and I was starving after my appointment so I came here and I wasn't thrilled with my breakfast once I'd left. read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - Ham Egg Cheese Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Great food and fast service but the staff always looks like they hate their life. Plenty of seating as well.

Where I live we don't have bagel shops. I love a GOOD bagel that's not from the grocery store. This hit the spot. The place is family owned, very cute inside, great menu, friendly & good coffee! I can tell it's a fun local am hang out. I will be back read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - Everything Bagel toasted with Chive cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

The service is horrible. The staff is rude. I ordered a bagel with 2 different cream cheeses and extra of both to go. When I got home to eat my bagel there such small amount of cream cheese, it was ridiculous. Even less than when I just order the regular amount. I don't think I will be going back anytime soon! read more

The freshest bagels in town! The service is amazing. Hard to find a seat but worth the wait. read more

I was hesitant to leave this review, as I've come to this restaurant for the last 15+ years. I moved out of the area so i was unable to frequent it, but occasionally will make the drive as i love their bagels. The last 3 times i have been over the course of a year, it has been horrendous. I don't say that lightly...the owner used to run the most amazing family friendly business. It has gone so down hill, the only thing i can assume would be the reason for that is the owner is not present in the store like he used to be. The girls and the Hispanic guy who run the front area are so incredibly unfriendly, they do not greet you, they are not welcoming...in fact, they are abrasive and rude. The restaurant is so dirty and run down now. There has been food all over the floor and tables in the eating areas every time I've been over the last year. The bathrooms are unkept and you can barely get into them as the baby changing table that has been broken for a year now will not close. The bagel case is nearly empty every single time I've gone and it has taken a minimum of 20-30 mins to get 2 bagels after ordering. I understand that they have expanded business and opened other stores, but this was the first and the condition of this place is so far from what it started at. This last visit (Father's Day 2025) will probably be my last. The people running this restaurant, or lack thereof, in place of the owner, are seriously going to run them into the ground if it continues this way. read more

I've been going here for years and usually get the same thing. A bagel melt, add lox with extra spread. I was surprised to see the Webb bridge location closer but Haynes Bridge is only a few minutes away so it's fine. read more

Let me start by saying, I really love Bagel Boys' food! Always fresh and delicious. My rating does not have to do with the food! Unfortunately, I did have a bad experience with the last time I was there. It was on a Saturday, I went in about 10 till 2pm and ordered mine and my husband's bagel with lox sandwiches. They were out of many bagels but I did settle on two. The young girl behind the counter acted like I was completely bothering her and was not friendly to say the least. She did not ask me any questions, I even made a slight joke but did not get a positive reaction or any at all. I then asked her what time they close and she responded saying 2pm; I said so that's the reason! Still no reaction. Once I got my food, I left and when I got home I realized that the bagels were not even toasted!! She could not even bother to ask me if I would like it toasted (guess that would take too much time)! I will definitely still return but will be very mindful of the time! read more

Here is a quick tip! The next time you stop by Bagel Boys Cafe make sure you get your loyalty punch card. This will allow you to accrue your punches and receive a dozen bagels. Don't miss out. read more

See all

An everything bagel toasted with cream cheese from BB is awesome. Perfectly balanced with soft and chewy inside, slightly salty, and crunchy on the outside. Been coming here for years and years. Def a favorite of mine. read more

I really like this bagel shop so much for so many reasons! Let's start with the customer service. The cheery employee who took my order was wearing a sweatshirt that said "happy" on it. She was so nice and gave us great recommendations on what to get. I enjoyed an egg white spinach omelet on an everything toaster bagel. It was hot, fresh and flavorful. All the bagels I've ever eaten here are really soft and fluffy. I've been here a number of times and loved it every time. I look forward to coming back soon! read more

Bagel Boys Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

See all

My go-to bagel stop near downtown Alpharetta. Like the sun dried tomato bagel. Limited but functional seating. Order ready quickly.

One of my fav bagel joints. The bagel melt is delicious. Highly recommend visiting. Seating can be a bit limited since it gets busy. The bagels remind me of NYC so that's a plus! read more

The food is good but the service is horrible. The first time I came the staff was extremely rude and not helpful. I decided to give It another chance and this second experience was worse than the first. When asking questions about the menu the lady ( Torra ) at the front was short with me, her body language clearly expressed how annoyed she was with me as she continuing to roll her eyes and sigh every chance she got. This is my second time experiencing her specifically It's very disappointing that this is the service I've received multiple times. To top It all off, she got my order wrong. So yea there's that read more

Had a yummy bagel sandwich for lunch. One thing that stood out- the food was very temperature hot (which I appreciated!!). So many places the food arrives and its warm, this sandwich arrived very hot and yummy! Loved it! read more

See all

Gluten free bagel isn't like eating a napkin. Great service! Online ordering is easy and on time.

Great bagels and a nice menu of sandwiches to choose from. I usually take a dozen bagels home and freeze them ( don't forget to get your card punched for a free dozen after 10 punches) but today I stayed and ordered a Lox and bagel. It was delicious! read more

Great breakfasts and even greater people! Had the pleasure of going there 3x during my trip, it was a hit each time. The staff were friendly and quick and Mr. John, the owner definitely made us welcome and recommended my new love: the SPECTACULAR pistachio muffin! Dude, it totally deserves that description. My sister who doesn't even like sweet stuff loves it and asked for more. Dude, everything we had there was ON POINT! Including the bagels and breakfast sandwiches If you are a local and haven't been there, you are missing out and I am judging you. If you are new to or visiting the Alpharetta area Online order and deliver or RUN, don't walk to this location. We went to Haynes Bridge Road location but there are also Kimball Bridge Rd in Alpharetta & Peachtree Dunwoody Rd in Sandy Springs. Bagel Boys Cafe, Thanks for the great food and warm greetings when my family and I visited! Love and happy belly- From Hawaii read more

See all