Nice experience! Had a great bagel sandwich with egg whites and turkey. We even brought a dozen to travel with us. The assortment was still very good even at 11 am. The sandwiches are made to order and the staff was very responsive. Good quality. I can however sense a bit of what folks talk about regarding the attitude but I have to give them a pass as this area has a reputation for being a little "sour"...and oh by the way...if you cross over into NY...let me tell you what the attitude is in a bagel shop! read more

Good bagels, bad staff. Employees are rude and it's not a good start of my day. Would rather get my bagels elsewhere.

I think they are here to stay. Opened around a year ago, they are now a neighborhood breakfast establishment we can rely on aside from Noah bagels. We see many familiar faces when we get our weekend breakfast sandwich. They are willing to take your custom order and I am quite particular about my custom breakfast sandwich. I think they now get their rhythm down. Line moves relatively quickly. Food is nothing spectacular but at least they use real eggs and none of that premix egg (like Noah). They have decent, and I dare say fresh, bagels too which is hard to find in this part of NJ. read more

This used to be in my favorite bagel spot - but the small-town, friendly service has gone out the window. The man behind the counter (larger build with slicked back hair) is not customer-oriented. He's abrupt and rude. While I was there, a young mom holding her child ordered two bagels and asked for them to be sliced - that man refused to slice her bagels saying "it's policy". If that's your policy (which quite frankly I don't understand) then make an exception - she's asking for two bagels to be sliced for her kid, it was not a big ask. During these Covid times, there were times customers were packed in there like sardines without any of the doors being open and no one regulating how many people were coming in. Craig, you have delicious bagels but customer service and safety means more. read more

Delicious bagels. And it's really cool to come here and feel a sense of community atmosphere - it's nice to run into familiar faces or make new friends with fellow townsfolk. The food is good and the options are plentiful. The staff is friendly. It's crowded, yes, but at 10 AM on a Saturday you can't expect a bagel place to be quiet. Good food and good people. read more

Bagels are good. But the prices are nearly 2x my expectations. I've paid $75 for a decent steak and $200 for a bottle of wine without a second thought. $7 for ham n cheese on a bagel, however, is obscene. Is Thomas Keller tossing those loops of dough??? read more

This has been my favorite bagel shop ever since the day i discovered it. And today I learned that I can place my order on their Ap on my iPhone, and simply walk in the store and pick up my already paid for bagels and cream cheese without having to wait at all!! AWESOME service :) Go to Ap store, search "Bagel New Providence" then it will pop up with a swirly drawing of a bagel with black background... read more

Best bagels in the area! I tried a bunch when i first moved here and this place takes the cake. good quality bagels and breakfast sandwiches. read more

Solid spot for breakfast and lunch. This place makes great eggs. Coffee is good as well. Has a good-sized seating area inside and some tables outside too. read more

Good solid bagel joint. We just bought a bakers dozen and a tub of chive cream cheese and I didn't need to toast my everything bagel because it was still warm from the oven. Also the bagels are so big that I don't think it would fit in a toaster. Yum! read more

Go to bagel spot in the area but lately they have drastically cut back on the amount of cream cheese they give you. The prices are the comparable for a tasty bagel but when you get about an 1/8th of an inch of cream cheese and pay almost $4 for a bagel it might be time to go across the street. Also it's chaos as to who's next to order when busy on the weekends. read more

Bagel Cafe - Actual spread measurement - Bagels Near Me - New Providence, New Jersey

Too many times we have found the sesame or cinnamon raisin bagels covered in onion/garlic from the other bagels. Definitely need to find a new bagel shop. Also, I will never go during high volume times as the logistics of the place are not good. read more

Great quality of food. Got exactly what I requested and employees were friendly and quickly attentive. Tons of options in specialty sandwiches department. Other food being made for other customers looked good too, definitely want to try the burgers next time. read more

I'm obsessed with this place! The bagels and bagel sandwiches are FANTASTIC and the coffee is great too! They are so friendly and kind, and I love that you can order ahead online! The french toast bagels are especially amazing! read more

They really care about their quality of bagels and it shows!!! Love their bagels with a cup of coffee! Best bagels in New Providence.

despite popular belief, the bacon egg and cheese is almost non existent within the bagel. it was like a piece of paper i tasted almost nothing. i also had a blueberry bagel here, can't taste any blueberry. it's like making green eggs and ham with your mom when your a kid. only food coloring is saving that bagel. also i heard that the owner takes all the tips. 2 star read more

Heartless place. Don't spend your money at this place! I stopped in for the first and last time. I purchased 2 dozen bagels and 3 containers of cream cheese for the nurses caring for my mother in the hospital. They put 50 lbs of these rocks and cream cheese in a paper bag. It was raining and by the time I got to the hospital the bag ripped in the lobby. I went back the next day to tell them want happened and it was there fault. The man behind the counter was so rude! I said they should have doubled bag it or use a plastic bag for the rocks. He said that is too expensive. I spent $40 for the nurses. They have no heart. Spend your money elsewhere. read more

Great food but the counter help attitude was awful. I went 6/8 for take out bagels and the one employee was so unfriendly and downright rude that I am going to talk to the owner when they are less busy. I would rather go somewhere more friendly. There are many options. Say hi and thanks, it won't kill you! read more

Bagel Cafe catered a brunch at our house recently and the food was great - lox and bagels, tuna and egg salads, plus their signature Springfield salad. Coffee was excellent and their accommodators were wonderful to work with, taking great care of our 60 guests. Thanks so much! read more

Ordered the red eye omelet and western omelet-- took a few minutes, but it was well worth the wait. Better than any other omelets either of us have had. read more

I LOVE the bagels here, however the management has continuously been disrespectful to me, my friends, and my colleagues. As a frequent paying customer, I expect better better management interactions. The only time I've seen the manager is when he has something negative to say towards a customer. Whether it's bringing a cup of coffee from Starbucks to drink with a bagel or finishing a smoothie from another store to have with your bagel from here, there is always criticism. I understand they offer smoothies and coffee themselves, but even if I didn't have my Starbucks coffee I would not buy the coffee from here just out of personal preference and a consumers right to choose what they want. Once again, the bagels are incredible, I'm just disappointed in all of my interactions with management. read more

great bagels and lovely owner the best in all of north jersey

We regularly grab breakfast here and it's always a solid choice. I recently tried the espresso chicken sandwich for lunch and it was outstanding. If you haven't done lunch at the Bagel Cafe, you're missing out. read more

I absolutely love coming here for a great bagel! I was a little disappointed, however, when I was told I was not allowed to sit in the dining area because I had brought a drink from Starbucks next door. I had purchased a bagel from bagel cafe, so I don't see why I shouldn't be allowed to enjoy my bagel there! Overall, everyone is super nice though and I'd go back, I was just a little unhappy about this. read more

Great food and friendly service. Bagels are nice and big and the eggs are cooked on the skillet-as opposed to other places in New Providence that "nuke" them in the microwave. Definitely recommend trying Dahams out read more

I never thought I would see the day where I would find amazing bagels and coffee all in one place. It's sounds crazy but rarely do you get both plus great customer service!!! read more

I paid $2.25 for a mini bagel with cream cheese at Bagel Cafe in New Providence with the advertised price listed as $1.50 - 50% more!!! Doesn't seem like this price list has been updated in a long time. Wonder what any of the items will cost tomorrow?? Is it ok to just state "Prices may change w/o notice"??? My daughter loves their bagels but this is so NOT ok. read more

Coffee at bagel joints is usually just ok. This coffee is awesome. Sweet bagels (french toast and super cinnamon raisin) too sweet, a.k.a. diabetes bagels.. The place is clean, had a great selection of bagels and cream cheese. Staff was a bitt impatient. Long hallway was great for keeping our impatient toddler busy as her dad waited for our order. read more

On my first visit here I was impressed with the entire establishment. The store is well lit, clean and staff friendly but frenetic as the number of customers increased in the matter of 60 seconds. Looks like a well managed operation. I thought a good bagel was a thing of the past but Dahams restored my confidence. Great hand rolled bagels made on site like everything else. The cream cheeses all look delicious Amoung a wide selection of bagels and other tasty treats.. I had an egg bacon and cheese on a poppy seed. See photo.. The bacon crispy and made to order along with fresh eggs and cheese. cooked to my exact request. The best I've had in a while! Coffee is excellent. No tables here just buy and go sit outside at one of the benches around town. This place is a winner in my book!-- update July 2013--- The bagels in this place have changed and are no longer on my best list. Knocking down to 2 stars. read more

Bagel Cafe - Now that's a bacon egg and cheese on a hand rolled bagel! Yum! - Bagels Near Me - New Providence, New Jersey

When we moved here a few years ago I was horrified that the local bagel place microwaved the eggs for my egg and cheese on a bagel... Thank goodness Dahams opened. Great bagels and no microwaved eggs. read more

I love Daham's. Great bagels, great breakfast bagel sandwiches. I come here often to meet with friends in the booth seating they have. Even when busy the line moves quickly, and they have good bagel options, like the whole wheat everything bagel. I don't usually branch out from the sandwiches, but the other day management gave me a complimentary Nutella latte that was great, and I would get again in the future. read more

Coming from the area where O'Bagel is king this place will eventually supplant them as the best bagel in the area, first off the size of their bagel is what O bagel's used to be 5 years ago, O'Bagel has gotten way smaller and charges the same as these bagelmasters. Light on the inside crunchy on the outside. Fabulous sandwiches at a nice price too. Have not tried the coffee or the cream cheese spreads yet but if they keep the size and maintain quality I will take the extra minutes out of my way and forget about O'Bagel read more

Honestly the food here is not bad but I'm never coming back. The customer service is absolutely terrible. Owner included. Been yelled at for bringing in reusable water bottles because we didn't buy a drink here. They yell at you and make faces if you don't come when they call your number even though it's extremely loud in the storefront. The "manager" has rolled his eyes and shook his head if he's called a number more than once. You would think they would have any respect for customers but I feel extremely unwelcome here and absolutely will not be returning. Never mind the insane prices. Absolutely ridiculous! read more

The best bagels in the neighborhood hands down. This is the only place I'll go to for bagels now. The service is a bit spotty which hopefully improves over time. There is plenty of staff for the size of the store. They just seem a bit confused at times. A nova sandwich shouldn't cause any confusion. I don't want lox spread. read more

The very best fresh bagels in New Jersey. Delicious breakfast sandwiches. I have been a fan since day one, but now looks like the secret is out because they have a good line every morning. read more

I went there this past Saturday and ordered a Cuban Panmunjom. It was very good plus they give you a side and pickle. Very clean and nicely decorated read more

By far the best bagels around and excellent breakfast sandwiches. Also has a great lunch selection. Service was fast and polite and storefront is very clean. Would recommend this place to everyone. read more

Great bagels, and with the addition of the brand new Mediterranean/American all day menu with full waiter service, it's certain to be a winner in the area! read more

The bagel sandwiches here are good but this place seriously needs to rework their operations. There are two lines to order, one for bagels only and one for everything else. It creates a lot of confusion for customers ... where to order, where and when to pay, where to wait. read more

Horrible service. People behind the counter are rude and cheap. I spent $40 on bagels and 3 containers cream cheese to bring to a softball game. I asked for a "bunch" of knives. They gave me 3 so I asked for more. They then refused to give me any more knives because it "costs them too much money". I reminded them that I just spent $40, but the guy argued that it's too expensive. I left and went home to find some plastic knives. I will never go back there. Note other reviews below with similar comments. Something is wrong with this place. read more