Never tried a Lox before but I always wanted to try it so my friend brought it for me and it was the most delicious and satisfying lox bagel ever and the macaroni salad side was so creamy! I have to say, I don't usually review a lot of places, but Bagelicious is a great bagel place and it is worth your while. Everyone needs to seriously try their lox bagel. read more

When on Long Island bagels are a must!! This place is rally good & has a nice variety. Wether breakfast or lunch, you have a lot of yummy things to choose from. read more

See all

I can not recommend this place for bagels. The bagels and the eggs are not worth it for the price you pay. I only go to this place if I have to, but will never be back here. I called In for a bagel, and I had to give my card over the phone, and they charged me a $3 fee to take the credit card over the phone. I have never heard of this before. Such an absolute rip off. Do yourself favor and don't go here. Also an update they sent me the smallest miniature bagel that I have ever seen, and I paid full price read more

They put the tiniest bit of butter on a bagel and there was no rush because there was only 2 other people in the store. Explains why no one was here on a day off getting breakfast. Skip this place all together. read more

Bagelicious - I ordered an everything bagel with butter, and this is what I got.... never again. - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

I have been coming here for years. It was one of my favorite bagel shops when I lived in NY and now its the one my husband and I go to every time we are visiting there from CA. The location is very convenient but I also love their bagels! I usually get an egg and cheddar cheese on an everything or egg bagel. Sometime I go for the egg bagel with cream cheese. I love how they load on the cream cheese! But this last visit I was super excited to see they had rainbow bagels. I'm pretty sure it was just a plain bagel but it was so colorful! I couldn't resist. I also tried for the first time the egg white and turkey bacon on the bagel. It was really good. I would definitely order that again. This place is more than just bagels, however. They have a full deli with a huge selection of Boar's Head deli meats. And they have a variety of pastries. I got a black and white cookie when I was there over the weekend. So tasty! read more

Bagelicious - Rainbow bagel sandwich. Colorful and yummy. - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Bagelicious is definitely a classic, bringing back great memories of the bagel shops I used to go to as a kid growing up on the South Shore of Long Island. The bagels are fresh out of the oven, with that combination is what makes a great bagel a great bagel - a nice crunch on the outside while soft on the inside. I treated myself to a lox and cream cheese this morning, on a nicely encrusted everything bagel with lots onion and garlic goodness perfectly complementing the fresh lox and cream cheese. You've got tons of coffee choices here as well - the coffee's really great and served piping hot, exactly as it should be. Bagelicious is about more than just bagels, with a full breakfast and lunch menu, lots of fresh appetizing, and incredibly nice people behind the counter who make sure you've got everything you need to start your day off the right way. There's a good amount of seating, and the music is vintage 70s - the stuff we used to listen to when going to either Point Lookout or Jones Beach. It's a popular morning meet-up spot, and you'll know exactly why once you try them out. Bagelicious is a five-minute drive from the Long Island Marriott, so for those of you visiting, skip the hotel restaurant, hop in your car, and make the short drive for a great breakfast - you'll be glad you did! read more

See all

I always get the same thing from this place, and almost every single time they give me bad avocados or my order is not what I asked for. I gave them the benefit of the doubt but it happens every single time so I had to share with yelp. :( read more

Bagelicious - Always bad avocados. No good Bagelicious :( - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

I'm quite certain, this it where it all began! - "John & John" had a vision! - This place is truly an East Meadow "Institution" that has lived on for generations! We have been coming to this place . . . . Well, these guys have literally watched me grow up. The Bagels are truly excellent. Service is quick, local, friendly and efficient and they always get your order right. I support this place 110% - because Bagelicious cares about the community and the people of the community. I have personally witnessed their generosity to the East Meadow community. The "Institution" truly represents what a "Mom & Pop" business is all about . . . . Giving back, being part of the community - with the belief that if a business does the right thing . . . success will follow. Even though I no longer live in East Meadow, I'm always keen to pop in. You won't be disappointed. If you can and your lucky, try to catch those bagels when they pop out of the oven. Don't be a "Putz" - who toasts a fresh bagel? ;-) read more

See all

First time coming to bagel licious and it was amazing!! I had a sausage egg and cheese on a plan begal I ordered on phone when I got there my order was hot and ready with refills of any coffee and my discount for being a college student definitely recommend trying them out read more

I am so impressed with my experience this morning! I wanted a Cobb salad so they pulled it out from the case & rang me up. As I was about to walk away, a man came over & looked in bag & asked the other person if they checked salad in detail. He took it & examined it & even though it did look quite good, he said give me 1 minute. I want to make you a fresh one. Once it was finished, I thanked him for paying attention to such detail & he assured me that they pay attention to every detail & it's imperative that the customer always gets the best & freshest salad always. I am impressed. Good job Bagelicious!! I can't wait to eat lunch now because their balsamic vinaigrette is awesome too!!! read more

The most disgusting breakfast I've ever had in my life. Serving an old freezer burned, soggy microwaved hash brown patty and then having the audacity to give an attitude when we're paying for it, is an insult. Egg sandwiches were also trash, tasted like they had been sitting out all day and didn't even make them how I asked. Would never go back here again. read more

The cold and rain put me in the mood for a nice warm and buttery bagel. This is my new go to spot for delicious bagels. They have a big selection of bagel flavors. Their bagels and nice and crunchy on the outside and soft and chewy on the inside. I just love it! Great coffee selection as well. I saw a strange flavor yesterday....chocolate raspberry. if you are adventurous try their unique coffee flavors. To be honest the Regular is soooooo good sometimes it is best to just stick to the basics. I couldn't believe their cream cheese flavors and how many food options they have. They pretty much have it all covered for whatever you are craving! I had to refrain myself from they daily fresh baked goods. That was nearly impossible! They have an ATM, they sell Lotto and scratch offs, they deliver and they cater! Bagelicious does it all! read more

See all

Bagel not just a Bagel. Quick location to grab something too go. Few friends introduced this place too me. Bagel made on site. Fresh., love various bagel options as well as spreads. read more

Bagelicious - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

See all

I ordered catering trays for 20 people including 40 bagels, salads, spreads, cold cuts and a veggie tray for my mother's shiva. Neil helped me to select what I needed and placed the order quickly for delivery the next morning. The pricing was not cheap, but turned out to be reasonable given the very generous portions. The trays arrived exactly on time and were beautifully prepared. While the occasion for this catering order was not happy, my positive experience with Bagelicious made things a bit easier and I intend to use them again. read more

One of the few bagel places in this area. I would take these anyday over Dunkin Donuts. Having said that, the bagels and cream cheese are okay. If you want really good bagels, Bagel Boss is still the place to go in this area. The veggie cream cheese is different and chunkier here, they actually have chives and small pieces of other vegetables. read more

Things here are just average. Not up to the NYC standard. They do offer a variety of cream cheeses and overall the bagels are good but I would not go out of my way read more

I hadn't been here in awhile as I am never thrilled when I go but its local so we gave it another shot. Mediocre bagels with very unprofessional service. The college aged girl behind the counter was loudly talking about her personal life to a coworker while there was a line out the door. Our order was wrong, veggie cream cheese instead of scallion and we were told the slicer wasnt working although i think the staff just didn't know how to use it. Poorly trained staff, not the cleanest store....not A a real NY bagel. Ive reviewed their other location on Bellmore ave....just as bad. Also, skimpy portions on the meat end if you order a sandwich. Other then it being convenient, its not a winner. Rather go to my local deli for an egg sandwich.....and they also have bagels! read more

This is where I got my first bagel. I've tried every kind of bagel from here to all the hype in the city and this one still tops them all. The service is very friendly and they have a very good cup of coffee. I don't know what magic they inject into these little guys, but I hope they keep it going for generations to come. Thanks!!! read more

Good spot for an average new York bagel. They offer a variety of bagels and assorted spreads as well as your other typical breakfast and lunch foods. Food always seems fresh and the staff is always friendly. They also have a good coffee selection for those coffee lovers. read more

Been coming here for years. Bagels are good. Salads and spreads are good. Heres my problem: When you are paying $10 for a Bagel Sandwich, it should leave you full and satisfied. These days barely a 1/4 pound of tuna/egg/chicken salad is put on your sandwich. I blame the new owner as he instructs his staff to put on this small amount. Dont be stingy and give the people what they want and deserve or you will lose business. Keep your customers happy and they will return! read more

I believe in supporting local businesses for the good of the community. This business makes it very difficult to maintain that belief. Prices change at any given time. The breakfast sandwich combo with a small coffee should be $5.6x plus tax. To be told it was $6.90 is insulting. The price should not have exceeded $6.20. While $0.70 won't alter my lifestyle, it adds up over several times a month. There are other bagel shops in Levittown and Bellmore that would love new customers. Avoid Bagelicious and this nonsense. We deserve better. read more

This place is sucks. Be Aware they are charging false price. I order pancake it come with Egg and coffee price is 8.99 But she charge me 9.99 plus coffee for 2.53 Also charge credit card fee. Everyone check your receipt. When I confront she said I gave you one dollar back why did you do that instead of apology she said Ewe to me . Never go back again . read more

They always mess up our order. The takeout containers they put their food in is always soggy and the paper peels and gets in the food as well as they put the plastic silverware in the same container on top of the food which is so unsanitary. Will NEVER go there again! read more

From the variety of bagels to sandwich options, great spot to stop for breakfast. Fast moving atmosphere, so be ready to make a quick decision. Good smells and deli options. Nice, fresh bagels and easy to be in and out. read more

Always busy and crowded... for a good reason! Fresh, soft slightly chewy bagels... Amazing! Fresh cold cuts, salads, cream cheese and of course coffee! (And several freshly brewed flavors). Occasionally the girls that prepare your order can be curt, but it's probably due to the hectic pace they need to keep up with. All in all a reliable place for the perfect New York bagel! read more

This is the second time I have visited Bagelicious...and it is also the 2nd time that I have found a hair in my food. The first time I thought "eh...it happens" and decided to go back again. Now I'm over it. The food would be great if I wouldn't keep finding hair in my food. For that, I'm giving them 1 star. Not going to visit again. read more

Delicious! We just moved to the area from AZ and have been exploring different bagel shops. We stopped in and ordered two breakfast sammies. One with one scrambled egg (more than enough), bacon, and American cheese on a plain bagel and one was "the Danyel." The service was quick and they were incredibly patient while helping me navigate the menu - which I couldn't quite see because I forgot my glasses. Prices were reasonable, the food came out quickly, and was well wrapped so it was still hot after the walk home. Will definitely return. read more

Bagelicious - Crispy bacon, one well fluffed egg, properly melty American cheese. - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

(This is the Bagelicious by Marshalls) I come here mostly ever other weekend because there breakfast is amazing. The workers there usually have attitudes but we never pay mind since there job is to assist us with our order. (Not to mention the fact that most of the time they tend to mess up our orders.) Like today. I had asked for a everything flagel and the girl gives me a regular everything bagel. I go back and tell her she gave me the wrong one and still charges me the difference. If you ask me, I shouldn't be paying for someone else's mistake. I had asked for a flagel from the starts and she messed up my order. (As all of this was happening she was giving me an attitude.) I honestly thought that was unfair and I would've spoken up if I wasn't already running late for work. Nonetheless, I don't plan on going back unless it's for coffee since only I can mess that up. So, would I recommend this place? Yes. But if you have time to deal with moody people who mess up your orders, than think about it twice. read more

If I could give zero stars I would. This place is awful. Overpriced, bagels are far from fresh, and they give you as little for your money as possible. Charge over five dollars for a bagel with a special cream cheese and then give you the tiniest amount they can scrape on there. Has happened to me multiple times. Find another place if you can read more

Ordered a bagel sandwich and it comes with free side salad so I ordered the health salad cucumbers and tomatoes which I found a bug looked like a roach or silverfish but I almost threw up. Never again. They didn't see that in the salad. So disgusting and ruined my appetite. Should get zero stars. Unacceptable!! read more

Ive been here a few times now and not sure about the low rating here. This place is awesome! They have tons of options and can customize your bagel anyway you want it. I've always gotten my order in less than 5 min. I think it's a little bit on the pricy side for some of the bagel sandwiches but the portions are so big, it's worth it. And they have great cream cheese selection. I can definitely keep coming back here read more

Loved the Pope bagel-Sammie! Filling and delicious. Took a dozen bagels home because bagels made in New York are better than any other bagels in the world! Friendly eager staff. They knew we were visitors and asked what brought us into their shop. If I get back to this area of Long Island - I'm stopping in. read more

We ordered 5 different types of bagel and all of them were so bland. I've had better bagels at Dunkin' Donuts. Probably the best bagel from the 5 we had would be the tuna. Bagels are too hard read more

We are now regulars! Cant say enough about bagelicious! Food is perfect, service is perfect.....and the coffee is out of this world =) read more

Oh, Bagelicious. Now that I live in California, I have no perspective on New York Bagels, or New York Delis, for that matter. I love them all. I don't know if I will ever figure out what it is that people everywhere else get wrong when they make bagels, but if I do, I will gain at least 200 pounds and inspire the pity of every Atkins-crazed dieter within fifty feet of me as I stuff my face with carbs. Since I appreciate any NY bagel, as well as the generous hand of NY bagel-people, who know that when you say butter or cream cheese, it's okay to put on enough to clog your arteries by just looking at it(Really, I give you the A-O.K. there, buddy, 'cause if I want less, I'll just wipe it off, but if you don't give me enough, my whole bagel experience is ruined), I rely on my mom's bagel-advice as to which are the best in proximity to her house. Bagelicious always comes up in the top 5. read more

2 bacon egg and cheese bagels + 1 plain w/cream cheese, $13.75! Food was fresh and tasted a little better than"Ok" but the price was ridiculous for the taste. 4 stars for quality and overall cleanliness of the establishment. read more

Got an onion bagel, with cream cheese, a medium coffee, a Newsday, and I sat down at one of the many tables. The bagel was one the best bagels I've ever had. The coffee is good. Then took a long walk in Eisenhower Park, aka Salisbury Park, the entry of which is about 4 long blocks from the bagel place. Then I went to the Mitchell Field museums, including the air museum. These museums are located near Nassau Community College, which is about 1/8 of a mile from Salisbury Park. read more

Ordered many times for delivery and have been in the store. Everything is fresh and tastes great. Delivery is usually faster than what is stated on Eat24. This is my go to bagel store! UPDATE: Ordered online at EAT24 and now Delivery Fee is up from $5.00 to $10 to go maybe 1/2 mile from my house. I find that a bit ridiculous. read more

Fresh, fresh, fresh! Great variety. Always friendly and accommodating. Best chicken salad loaded with apples and cranberries. Their coffee is outstanding. Numerous salad and bakery choices. Always busy, always delicious! read more

I only gave them 2 stars because their food is actually good. I can't even count how many times they've gotten my order wrong. I don't call or go back to the store because it's not worth the hassle or wait. Some of the staff members don't even write down your order if it's not a kitchen order, no wonder it's wrong. Last time I ordered for two people, they mixed up the bagels, and put the wrong cream cheese on the wrong bagel. I've been to this place MANY times. I won't be going here anymore even though the food is good, it's not worth getting frustrated over. read more