Awesome bagel place - salt with poppy a (chefs kiss) touch . Always on point quick and great people. Saltpeppaketchup one word read more

I ordered some pumpernickel bagels. I got a light colored bagel. Now,I've eaten many a pumpernickel bagel in my life, and this was too light to be a pumpernickel bagel. The staff insisted that it was pumpernickel. I was a bit rushed so I bought it anyway. It was rye, which accounts for the color discrepancy. I may go back and try some other bagels. Then again, my local bagel shop knows the difference between a pumpernickel bagel, an onion bagel and rye, so maybe I won't. read more

Don't get the local hype. I feel like people from the area that claim this place must not try other area bagels. My real issue is how gross the place is inside. I haven't been in a while. The lost time I stopped in all the glass and the work areas were filthy. That was the last time I was there. Maybe they have cleaned up since. If you do try I would peak in before eating. read more

I recently moved to the area and have been getting bagels here ever since. I've tried other bagels in Verona but the ones here are the best. They are consistently great bagels: good chew, good color, not burnt (as I normally get everything bagels, burnt garlic can be an issue, but hasn't been here). It's not a big shop and can easily get crowded, but it's usually pretty efficient as they have a bunch of people working taking/making orders. Their sandwiches are good (whether bacon & egg, Taylor ham & egg, cream cheese and lox), they have a good selection of bagel "flavors" (including Egg Everything) as well as some specialty bagels (Super Cheddar and French Toast) which are also pretty good. I've also seen some reviews about "bad service" but honestly I've never had a problem. People are nice and efficient, and I get great bagels. I will be coming back for a long time. read more

See all

Stumbled upon this place as we were craving bagels. Bagels are okay, would've been a lot better if they weren't as burnt as it was and if the orders were correct (asked for SPK on the bagels, didn't get any. minor mistakes but those mistakes can make or break a NJ bagel) Staff was very pleasant though and this is obviously a go-to spot for the neighborhood as it was extremely busy. read more

See all

Placed on order yesterday for a dozen bagels (including 2 everything flagels) to be ready for 9 am this morning. The online ordering was seamless and easy. I loved the options for bagels, whole wheat everything, rainbow and flagel. I loved the flagel. They were ready for pick up this morning and made my brunch plans super easy. Everyone commented on how good the bagels were. This place is a teeny bit further from my local bagel spot but worth the extra mile. read more

I moved to cedar Grove last year and have tried a few bagel places in the area. My son ordered from bagelwich and holy shit this might be the best bagel I've ever had, the bagel was soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside and the Taylor ham was very generous. CUDOS !!! I've found my new spot. read more

OMG these bagels are delicious and they still give a bakers dozen. I when there a couple of days ago and wa pleasantly surprised by the variety of bagels from plain all the way up to rainbow mini and bialys as well as specialty bagels. They also have an extensive amount of muffins and pastries which I will get next time. I also orders an everything bagel with an egg over medium with salt and pepper and that's exactly what I got in a short amount of time. Their prices are very reasonable and the quality of the bagels as well as the size is phenomenal. This will be my go to shop when going to work read more

I ordered door dash, and all of my order was wrong. I ordered two taylor ham egg and cheeses on everything bagels with hash browns and received bacon egg and cheeses on both. As everyone may know door dash is expensive, and I waited an hour for my order for it to just be wrong. read more

Bagelwich Bagel Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Verona, New Jersey

See all

Review for bagels only. Perfect crisp on the exterior. Perfect dough. Dense, but not too dense on the interior. Not too sweet, not too salty. Spot on size and shape. Generous, well applied toppings. The epitome of a NJ bagel. I would call this a destination bagel shop. read more

A friend of mine recommended me to this place. I got a bacon egg and cheese on a pumpernickel bagel and it was very good. Made the way I like it. Crispy bacon, melted cheese and holding together and not breaking apart some some others. I also decided to get an everything bagel with a schmear of plain cream cheese. The bagel was flavorful, and had a nice crunch to it from the light toast. The bagel had too much cream cheese on it for me, scrapped some of it off, but overall it was good! read more

Bagelwich Bagel Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Verona, New Jersey

See all

The food has always been very good plus the service is excellent. I've been going here for years and have never been disappointed. Also since they are a family-owned business the consistency has been great. read more

Average bagels...super convenient for the area. Had their garlic with scallion cc. Their bagels are decent. Busy location. Didn't try their coffee. read more

When I moved to Verona from West Orange, Bagelwich became my local bagel shop. Being from New Jersey, everyone knows how important their local bagel shop is! We have almost picked up bagels from here every other weekend for a year and I can honestly say we have never had any issues. Whether we order DoorDash or go to the shop the bagels are always hot and fresh. There is nothing better than that! Their sandwiches are always put together perfectly and the scallion and veggie cream cheeses are so delicious, too! read more

See all

Always in search of good bagel shops, I stopped in at Bagelwich in Verona today. This is a small place with no tables inside, but a couple outside the front door. I decided to go with an everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese. The bagel and cream cheese were very good. Parking on Bloomfield can be tough, but there's a municipal lot right in back. read more

Bagelwich Bagel Bakery - First time here! - Bakeries Near Me - Verona, New Jersey

I grew up on NYC bagels and this is place is the real deal. It's one of only a few places I'll get bagels around here. If you like massive doughy blobs that call themselves bagels, not for you, but if you like crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, flavorful bagels, make a trip soon! Good veggie cream cheese too. read more

This had been my bagel go to when in the area so we recently grabbed bagels from Thai spot on a busy Sunday morning. It was a really chaotic process and I was a bit worried that the order would be wrong....But it was all good. Bagels here remain the right kind of chewy (not too soft or hard) and they have some great flavors like cinnamon raisin and sun dried tomato. All in all - still a GO TO when you are in the are read more

Bagelwich Bagel Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Verona, New Jersey

Extremely busy on a Sunday morning. Indeed chaotic. Good for this Mom and Pop shop on Bloomfield Avenue. Must have been 18 people waiting for their orders and more flowing in. I ordered three bagels to go, one sun dried tomato, one cheddar, one pumpernickel. They were still warm and definitely chewy as a good bagel should be. While I had toppers at home, their cream cheese spreads looked good. Lots of people ordering bagels with Taylor ham. A decent bagel shop in a part of NJ where we are fortunate to have many good bagel options. Their sandwich menu and catering options looked good too. Perhaps calling order in for such a busy place is a good idea. read more

Bagelwich Bagel Bakery - Started off with sun Sundried Tomato bagel - Bakeries Near Me - Verona, New Jersey

This shop is excellent!! the bagels texture, flavors, chewy and light, traditional in the best way and the best we have had!

If I didn't walk a mile hungry to get breakfast, I would've turned right around and walked out. My service was AWFUL! The woman that attended me had a nasty attitude, no eye contact, no welcome, huffing and puffing, sighs, tossing things, shuffling her feet, just a total disgrace. The people waiting even gave each other looks in disbelief. And to top it off, she got my order wrong!! I ordered an everything bagel with cream cheese, and after I walked back home, I found out I had an everything bagel with butter. This isn't a difficult job, be pleasant, take an order (correctly), procure the order, and charge the person. I don't know how she gets away with this behavior with the owner present. I can get a decent bagel almost anywhere in NJ, but this place will put a bad taste in your mouth before you even taste the food. Skip Bagelwich and go to Sam's Bagels instead. read more

I order the same thing once a week via uber eats and always ask for the bagel to be toasted well . Half the time it's not even toasted . Just got an order and again , the bagel isn't toasted at all . . I even call them after the order is placed to ask for the bagel to be toasted well . I don't know why I keep ordering from them need to find a new place . read more

I called for pickup for one bacon egg and cheese at 10am. They told me 10 minutes. I go in 30 minutes. ITS NOT READY. I come back 15 minutes later. The girl tells me she JUST told them to start working on it. Just told them to cancel it. But everyone else is ordering and getting their food!!! TERRIBLE TERRIBLE TERRIBLE . I don't care how busy you are!! A whole hour for a BEC???) there's no excuse for that read more

Worth the long wait in line on weekend mornings. So lucky to have them as a neighbor.

Bagelwich is a local favorite - you can tell by the line that is usually wrapped outside on a weekend! Personally I do not understand the hype. There are many other bagel places in the area, and Bagelwich doesn't stack up. The people who line up on the weekend will tell me I'm wrong, but I prefer my bagels to be bigger and "doughier" than I found Bagelwich to be. All in all, it's not bad. Its still a damn good bagel! But when you have options, I'd pass on this one read more

Bad food. Bad service. Small and not clean store. Non professional staff. Lazy and slow worker. NOT RECOMMENDED.

The only place I order bagels and breakfast to go from!!! Always good food, served hot, order always accurate!

First things first. I hate when I walk into an established and the person behind the counter yells "next" at the top of their lungs. Well gad damn are we in the middle of the fish market? I think not. The place is so small if I held hands with two strangers we could touch wall to wall. That was just me going off on a small tangeent. I was really hoping to like this place since it is not that far away from my job. But unfortunately, it was a let down. When I walked in it was not really busy so I didn't think that it would take that long to get a BLT and a toasted bagel with cream cheese. When I got back to work and opened my BLT there was way more lettuce and tomatoes on the sandwich that there was bacon. It was as if I order a lettuce and tomato sandwich with 5 strips of not so good Ober done bacon. The bagel and cream cheese was just OK. The bagel was good but the cream cheese had an extra sour taste to it read more

See all

Love this place. I love flat bagels and not many places carry them in West Orange/Livingston area, surprisingly. Their hot chocolate is soooo good! Service is swift and friendly. read more

Great bagels but the rude and unwelcoming staff makes this a no. Not a one time experience either or just one person. I've been going here every Sunday for over two months, same ugly service every time, to the extreme I don't even want to go here anymore. I feel uncomfortable and like I am a bother from every person behind the counter with my simple order of two bagels. I just cannot support such poor attitudes to paying customers. I'm not in the habit of bashing a small business, but the service here is atrocious, SKIP IT. read more

The bagel spot to go to in Verona, there is parking in front for curbside pickup but if you want there's a parking behind the the bagel shop so you can just walk around the corner and they accept cash/credit. Definitely quick and expect a line during the weekend seems like the place to go! Enjoy, and if you want, Verona Park is up the block where you can sit and enjoy your bagel. read more

Bagelwich Bagel Bakery - Onion bagel with egg and cheese with ketchup & salt & pepper for under $4.00 - Bakeries Near Me - Verona, New Jersey

Best bagels and LOVE the bagel bread! Service is always quick and efficient. Even if there is a line. Love Bagelwich!

BAGELWICH in Verona is my go to bagel shop. They make the bagels the way I like them. Kind of well done and a little crispy on the outside and soft on the inside with an excellent about of seeds or whatever is on the outside. My favorites are the everything bagel sticks and whole wheat everything bagels. The THEC breakfast sandwiches are excellent too as well as the egg platters. read more

Good sandos mane. Sometimes the staff seems grumpy. Never been let down by the food. The biggest sub on the menu is the one to get. I forget the number. read more

I needed to find a new a bagel spot and this first came up when I was in the area. This is definitely my new and now go to spot for some well made hot breakfast. I ordered Turkey bacon eggs and cheese w/ ketchup and mayo and light grape jelly. I don't have time to go to my local corner store to get it made plus they aren't open at the time I'm out the door for work. This place makes it perfectly. Nothing sloppy one bit. Everything portioned correctly. You can order online , you can in person as well. I didn't get to take a picture of the muffin but it was also good & so was the bagel with cream cheese I had. Definitely going back to them and would recommend BagelWich read more

Bagelwich Bagel Bakery - Bagel wich since 1982 - Bakeries Near Me - Verona, New Jersey

See all

Usually orders are perfect. Ordered June 19 no cream cheese on cream cheese, cinnamon raisin and jelly bagel. Ordered sandwich Swiss cheese full of seeds. I can't have seeds !!!! Very dissatisfied with Bagelwich I used Uber Eats so I could not check at store. read more

See all

If I was rating the bagels and breakfast sandwiches at this place it would have been an easy 5. The bagels are perfect with a nice exterior and a chewy inside. The everything bagel is always my go to and I love that it has seasoning on both sides of the bagel. Sandwiches are also made really well. I go with a basic egg and cheese and it's great. Where they lose stars is the chaos that is inside. It doesn't matter if you call it in, order online or order in person the order is never ready. Everyone is always on the move and polite (i think it's almost natural for them to apologize for the wait as they hand orders) and helping. I also don't think they are understaffed but rather there is no system. Once orders are complete half of them just sit on the counter until someone asks for it again in which case they go around checking all the names. There is definitely room to improve here. I ordered online and went to pick it up 20 mins later, they hadn't started my order and it took another 40 min inside. I guess people like me keep coming back so there isn't a need for improvement? If you go on a weekend expect to be standing outside in line and be waiting a long time. The chaos is just maddening. I especially feel bad for Doordashers and other delivery services who are there picking up multiple orders. It is to no fault of the delivery drivers when they are waiting on orders for so long but ultimately it will effect their tip and rating. I really wish management would see and try to create a better workflow. They have potential to provide great service. read more

Delicious Taylor ham, egg and cheese but need to have a better system for picking up pre-paid orders online. Shouldn't have to wait in line in person to just pick up. read more

Without a doubt, the best bagels in the area as well as the best sandwiches. THEC sandwiches are truly the best in NJ!

This place was so good to come believe it the lady Roseann that owns it was a total chatterbox but she was really really sweet and nice she was able to give my kid what he wants she was happy she was very proud of the little bagel shop and it was so cute we were trying to go to the pizza place next to it because my son loves it but because it was closed we ended up here but I'm glad I spent a lot less than I would in the pizza joint in my kid is happy he got the drinks and a good bagel sandwich I just got a basic bagel with butter Very good! Will recommend read more

Bagelwich Bagel Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Verona, New Jersey

See all

Just moved to the area a couple months ago and needed to find a new bagel shop for a good breakfast sandwich. My first impression was that this place definitely held up to the standard of my old bagel spot. The breakfast sandwiches are tasty and the bagels are really good. I've been here now a decent amount of times. The staff inside are nice and can handle there own when it comes to rude impatient customers especially on the busy weekends. The only reason I'm not giving a full five stars is because I did a Uber Eats order and didn't receive everything that I had ordered. If it's on the order make sure it gets sent. read more