We made this a tradition and are not disappointed! We recently had an order of cupcakes but they were eaten so fast that I don't have a picture Went back for another birthday cake! The cakes are so stunning! The cake is the centerpiece for the occasion! Fresh and high quality in every way! Not overly sweet. Moist and again, you can taste every fresh ingredient. A pure talent and a jewel to our neighborhood read more

Baked By Susan - Almond joyful birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

I guess we just got bad luck with this bakery, my wife drove over 2 hours for a cake for my birthday and all we got was a underbaked cake. But definitely ruined my birthday :( read more

Baked By Susan - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

See all

This past weekend, I was attending the Green Ossining Festival and had a pleasant surprise of running into Baked By Susan as a vendor! Susan and her son were there which was a pleasure! They know their merchandise and were a pleasure to talk to!! So were their amazing baked goods! I bought some chicken empanadas which were spectacular! Not to mention the wonderful gigantic soft pretzel! I also bought a regular chocolate brownie, the cheesecake brownie and a frosted cookie. Never a disappointment! That's why I always rate it as one of Westchester's Best Bakeries! read more

Baked By Susan - A marvelous large Chicken Pot Pie! - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

I ordered the strawberry vanilla cake for my son's graduation party. The cake was delicious. The icing was light and not too sweet. Several people commented on how delicious the cake was and we all really enjoyed it. read more

My daughter and I stopped in one day because we were in the area. The menu was a bit confusing to read and I felt like k was annoying the worker because I didn't know what we wanted or what to order. Neither of us were impressed with or selections and my empanada tasted like it's been sitting in the refrigerator for a very long time. It had that stale refrigerator taste. I am willing to give them another try. Maybe they were just off that day. read more

Baked By Susan - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

Food / baked goods/service are amazing every time I visit. It never disappoints. My doggy loved his cake again this year. Thank you so much Susan read more

Baked By Susan - Our Dog Marley - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

See all

Parking, outdoor seating, wifi (solid internet) and treats! I enjoyed a latte and a slice of cannoli cake while working. read more

Baked By Susan - Wifi - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

See all

I sadly do not recommend the vegan / GF apple crumble. It was wayyyy too liquidy and gooey inside, too sweet, too strong a cinnamon flavor and not balanced at all. It ate more like something you'd top onto yogurt or ice cream but on its own almost inedibly sweet. Upsetting as this was our only vegan dessert option at thanksgiving. read more

Great quality for a chocolate Vegan cake. We really enjoyed it as a Birthday Cake. I only wish for more variety in custom cakes. We plan to try to sit-down at the bakery in the future. read more

This is a cute bakery in Croton with indoor and outdoor seating. It's a fairly large pace big enough to accommodate groups. They offer s'more and tea parties too which is really cute. They bake everything from pies, cakes, cookies, breads, fochacchia, and assorted pastries. There's definitely something for every one here. read more

I was in Northern Westchester for my daughter's cheer competition. Checked Yelp for the perfect bakery for the ride home. Sometimes you need a savory treat, cup of tea, and an array of desserts for later. Really glad I found Baked by Susan. Pulled into a good parking lot and walked into a clean and modern shop. Really nice seating area. Gleaming cases filled with delicacies. I was getting a bit of that paralysis of choice, where the fear of missing out on something by selecting something else was kicking into high gear. But then, the nice lady working behind the counter steered me towards a few great choices. I was happy to see that they take tea as seriously as coffee, at some places tea is an afterthought. They serve loose leaf Harney and Sons tea, it was delicious. The empanada is other worldly good. The pastry crust is decadent and the filling was tasty, I loved the black bean and cheddar. Later that evening, I tried the four dessert items. They were stupendous! Raspberry crumb bar featured delicious raspberry jam and great crumb topping. Pumpkin chocolate chip cookie, pumpkin banana donut, and a pumpkin whoopie pie turned my autumn meter up to 11. The people that live nearby are spoiled. I'm looking to return every time I'm passing by. read more

Baked By Susan - Black bean and cheddar empanada was divine. They serve delicious Harney and Sons tea! - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

See all

Nice to sit outside with a cuppa, though coffee shops have better coffee. It's an occasional convenient stop to caffeinate and take little grandkids who like to play with the oversized Connect Four. The bakery items are $$$. Through the Too Good to Go app, I tried a few cake and muffin items that had the mouth feel of extra high fat content, but flavorful. One item Susan should stop trying to make is Jewish rugelach. Susan doesn't have anything close to an authentic recipe. And they were very overpriced. I had one and it was tasteless. The pastry and texture were wrong. The filling was wrong. Everything about it was unrecognizable. I'm offended that she calls what she's trying to pass off as rugelach, 'rugelach,' during the traditional Jewish holiday when they're popular. But you don't need the holiday to enjoy them any time of the year. For this deliciousness, I wish everyone could have an eastern European nana/grandma who could make perfect rugelach every time. read more

Cute bakery, kind staff that always greets you with a smile, and great baked goods. Gluten-friendly options for those choosing to be gluten free. I also love that they stock Harney & Sons tea products. read more

I just had to share--this past weekend, I picked up a cake (vanilla with raspberry jam filling) for my husband's birthday, and it was nothing short of perfect. Not only was the design absolutely beautiful, but the cake itself was delicious. It made the celebration even more special--a perfect cake for a truly wonderful man's birthday. Thanks again for helping make the day so memorable! Warmly,EC read more

Stopped here to get some coffee and a late morning bite before heading to train station to NYC. My son and husband had a yummy croissant delicacy while I tried the gluten free options. For gluten free peeps: try this banana chocolate chip bread. Yummy and very good on the tummy. Also--Iced coffee not bitter -take it from a black coffee drinker: no need to add any sugar or cream! Plenty of parking and outdoor seating. Will definitely remember this place next time we are traveling downstate from Central NY. read more

See all

So delicious! I don't know why I've never heard about this gem before, but I'm so glad I have! I found out about Baked By Susan while attending the Best of Westchester event for my own job. I took 2 cupcakes home with me with no expectations, only to find out they were absolutely delicious! I was actually mad at myself that I didn't taste them sooner, so I could bring more home lol. I promised myself that if I were in their area, I would stop by to get another dose. Low and behold, I was making my way south from Peekskill and stopped in. Their shop is cute and comfy. In addition, there is plenty of seating inside and outdoor, along with ample parking. I was immediately greeted and served upon walking in. The selections are pretty diverse. Not only do they serve a variety of baked goods like cakes, cupcakes, pastries, pies, and beverages, but they also had empanadas. I did not expect that. I decided upon a lemon drop and red velvet cupcake, along with a beef empanada. Everything was ready within 2 minutes. I also checked in using my Yelp app and received 15%. In regards to my treats, let me first say I ate the cupcakes over 2 days and let them sit at room temperature before eating. The lemon drop has become a favorite at this point. I personally don't like baked goods that have a filling but this won my heart over. Firstly, the cake texture is soft and moist. Not overly moist, but enough that you can enjoy it without choking or needing water. The filling isn't heavy either. It's a light lemon curd. The taste is a nice balance of vanilla and lemon without the overpowering citrus taste. I especially loved the frosting. I'm not sure what its made from (assuming its butter), but it is delicious and balances well with the cake flavor. The red velvet was also delicious. The cake was moist with a slight chocolatey flavor and topped with a cream cheese frosting. Secondly, the empanada. Very tasty. I'm honestly surprised at that. I've tasted empanadas in different countries and this was really good for a local variety. It wasn't so much the filling but really the crust. It was flaky and buttery, so when it mixed with the savory ground beef, it just hit the spot. After a long day of working in the outdoor that day, this alone brought joy to my stomach. If you are interested, they have empanadas in a variety of flavors including ones that include meat, chicken, veggies, and fruit. Finally, staff were so kind and helpful. They served me immediately upon walking in and thanked me for supporting them after my experience at the Best of Westchester. The space itself appeared clean and well-kept. The only drawback I found were the charges based on cash versus card. There seems to be a slight upcharge if you use your card. To keep you well informed, they do list the prices depending on your method of payment, for many items. So at least then, you have a heads up. But in this day and age of cashless payment, I think this should not be a thing. Overall, it was a great experience. I'll be returning and I hope to use Baked by Susan for a special occasion one day. Highly recommended. read more

See all

We stumbled on this cute coffee shop after checking out the Croton Gorge park. Cute decor with outdoor seating. Servers are nice & friendly. They have clean bathroom too! Coffee is strong & hot. We ordered tiramisu which not so sweet & to our liking. I love anything with nuts & short bread cookie is my fave. So the pecan bar is really up my alley. We are sure to come back next time we are in the area. read more

See all

My Mom, SIL, and best friend went to a Taste of Westchester class via WCC. We had such a great time! Susan was informative and fun! She sent us home with the fresh bread and a recipe. The bread tasted amazing. On our way out, we also purchased a pumpkin spice tres leches cake and omg it was incredible. There are frozen options to take home and bake later. The BEC empanadas are SO good. You just need to brush with egg wash and bake for an hour. But it's worth the wait! Susan loves what she does and you can taste it in her baked goods. read more

See all

It has been a while but everyone who reads my reviews knows I only do the best and no negatives. Baked by Susan is an institution in the lower Hudson Valley based in the charming Village of Croton on Hudson and situated in the Harmon section of the Village. Always superb in any thing she does and can rise to any occasion with a themed delight. This one takes the "cake." A picture speaks a thousand words so all I have to do is post. Boun Appetite! read more

Baked By Susan - Barbie cake to celebrate 15th birthday - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

I went in again today, as promised when I spoke to Susan after my last review, and tried a small round cheesecake. It's 4" round and 1"high, half cheesecake, half crust. $10.... Which is a lot. The cheesecake was excellent and the crust well made. It's hard to really judge this with so little actual cheesecake to sample on each bite unless I scraped sideways ruining a small portion of the rest of the crust. It was good. $10 good, no. Good enough to go back and get a regular slice from a whole cheesecake, yes. It just left me wanting more..... like unsatisfied. read more

See all

Best gluten free, vegan banana chocolate chip muffin/loaf ever. My family (who is very pro gluten) is also hooked on it! No joke, my stepdad started buying them in bulk Gf/vegan Pumpkin loaf is also delicious! I'm hoping for more gf options one day. Maybe a gf blueberry (or mixed berry!) muffin/loaf?? Fair warning, last I checked: gf products are not recommended for people with celiac/severe allergy because they don't have a dedicated gf oven/surface, etc etc. The base is made with oat flour, and doesn't specify if it's certified gluten free oat flour or not. Personally, I've never reacted to it. But it's up to you! They have a restroom available for customers as well as some indoor seating and plentiful outdoor patio seating with umbrellas! Technically, you could even walk to Susan's from the Croton train station or vice versa (though the roads do get busy, so be careful!) They of course have so many gluten-full options: cakes, pies, cinnamon rolls, bars, cookies, and even empanadas... Can't say I've had they pleasure of trying them though they look delicious! read more

Baked By Susan - Perfect gluten free, vegan chocolate chip banana bread - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

As I wrote my recommendation for Baked by Susan, it quickly reminded me to pay them a visit in the very near future. I know the slice of red velvet is waiting for me;) read more

See all

Friend of ours brought us treats from here and the phenomenal coffee cake stole the show- moist and cinnamony with a great crunch on top! My husband didn't love the chocolate croissant and the cherry cheese Danish was a little sweet for me, but others really loved them. Can't wait to check out the bakery for myself. read more

Susan does it again!! I ordered a large funfetti cake with chocolate filling for my son's 2nd birthday party. We wanted something bright, fun, and classic. Susan did a fantastic job and it goes without saying that the cake delicious. Everyone kept asking where it was from and could not stop raving about how beautiful and delicious the cake was. Our guests requested to take seconds to go haha. It was the first time I didn't have half a cake leftover in my fridge. read more

Baked By Susan - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

I recently bought a cake that underwhelmed us all for various reasons and I want to say that when I called to talk to Susan I was hesitant but thought she should know and she was so gracious and kind about it, offering tastes of the cake, explaining what they do and giving me a gift certificate for the cost of the cake. I so appreciate this kind of service and quality customer care. Thank you so much. I will highly recommend your shop and goods read more

I ordered a modified butterfly preorder cake with custom colors to fit the Barbie themed 25th birthday, plus DELICIOUS GF/vegan cupcakes. Baked by Susan did an amazing job at completing my custom order and everyone enjoyed these amazing treats! It was done quickly in time for the party and beautifully. I highly recommend ordering from here for your next event, big or small! read more

Baked By Susan - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

See all

Last year we ordered a chocolate cake for a birthday, and we received a vanilla cake. Okay, maybe mistakes happen. But this year we ordered another birthday cake and wrote "chocolate" in the email and said it on the phone. And we received another vanilla cake. Feels like chocolate vs vanilla should be a pretty fundamental thing when it comes to cakes. Either way, we won't be ordering from them again. +1 star because the cakes looked pretty good and were well executed in terms of style and quality. Wrong flavored cake is still pretty good cake. And they didn't use fondant, which is appreciated. I just don't think we can abide two cakes where the order form was more or less ignored. (Edit: the order was under my partner's name, not mine.) read more

OMG! You absolutely made my 8 year old Grandsons birthday! He told me exactly what he wanted and it was delivered to perfection! Absolutely delicious! What an amazing job! Thank you so much for your Spot on attention to detail! Can't thank you enough! read more

They don't have black & white cookies. That's not why I gave three stars but that made me sad. The vegan brownie was like a fudgy piece of heaven. The other items were ok. 3 stars because the guy helping us was so lackluster and so not into helping us--even after we spent $50+! We were chatty and asking for recommendations and got none. I don't think I'd return--the baked goods weren't great. read more

See all

I loved this spot! Everything we got was great: the perfect blueberry scone (not too sweet), the glorious microwaved cinnamon roll, the thick and gooey and fluffy morning glory muffin, the bean and cheddar empanada that's like eating pie crust with your Mexican food. Really top-notch ingredients and flavors and tons of outdoor seating. read more

See all

Got my wife's bday cake, it was soo good and there chix pot pie empanadas were so goood!!!

Love this place! They have the best chix pot pie ever, and the cinnamon rolls are not to be believed. Empanadas are great, and my son loves the zucchini bread. You can't really go wrong here! During the mornings I've also gotten really friendly and efficient service from a young guy with glasses. Love supporting this local / family business. read more

I recently got some cupcakes from here for a friend's birthday. I stopped by in the morning without calling ahead, and was able to walk out with fresh cupcakes. The red velvet cupcake was delicious; super moist and flavorful. This place has a ton of baked good options. I'll definitely have to stop in again to try more goodies. read more

Susan made a custom cake for my son's baptism and it was delicious and came out beautiful. I have also tried their homemade empanadas which did not disappoint. read more

Baked By Susan - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

The Petit Fours baked for my 50th birthday were spectacular! Not only were they beautiful they were absolutely delicious! Pink with tiny yellow flowers and so moist! read more

We love Baked by Susan! The empanadas and strawberry shortcake have always been family favorites. Recently they baked a dozen cupcakes to reveal the gender of our second child. The cupcakes were fun and beautiful. The chocolate buttercream in the middle to reveal we were having a boy was delicious... although I'm sure the strawberry in the middle for a girl would have been equally as yummy! They did an amazing job and we are just thrilled to have Baked by Susan as part of our neighborhood! read more

Baked By Susan - Big sister shows off the gender reveal cupcakes! - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

5 stars for the empanadas. I have looked for 12 years since my trip to Argentina for truly good ones in the same style - al horno- baked. Delicious crust! Chocolate fudge cake slice was very rich and pretty good, and apple turnover as well. Everything sure costs a pretty penny. But my guess is most items are worth it. Will definitely return for the empanadas! read more

Had a long wait between getting off the train and my ride picking me up. Short walk from CH Amtrak and found this gem. Susan seems wonderful and very knowledgeable. The iced coffee was good, as was the BEC empenanda and raspberry bar. Tons of goodies and desserts. Definitely give them a try! read more

Baked By Susan - the interior of a bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Croton-on-Hudson, New York

See all

Funny I pass this place a thousand times, cute locale....mentioned it to my brother who lives close by... he did not recommend...went anyway... tried a lemon bar/ square....felt slightly undercooked, tastes ....meh, just okay. I LOVE lemon bars,and willing to drive... to try or if it's that good....this weirdly was NOT! Usually baked good smell good & delicious! This seriously did not! Smelled like old grease/ lard, not remotely buttery or lemony. Very off putting, while trying to eat it... washed my hands , smelled the wax wrapper... but no, it was the item itself that reeked...sorry wanted to like it & the cute spot. No Thank you, I'll stick to baked by me! read more

Delicious savory and sweets! There's nothing I've tried here that I haven't liked, which is rare for me at a dessert place. The chicken pot pie is the best I've ever had. I highly recommend ordering ahead! read more