We were staying at the one hotel and decided to give this restaurant a try as it was right downstairs in the lobby. When we arrive, we're told that there were no reservations however, once we went back into our room and checked, we saw there were available reservations. Once we brought this to the attention of the hotel staff, we were able to be seated at the restaurant at the chefs counter due to a mistake with the website. The place was packed on a Saturday night and you are super happy to be seated. The food was amazing. We had the pizza, steak and shared an appetizer with some drinks. The place had a good vibe and the staff were very friendly. We will definitely be returning if we are ever in the area. read more

Barbuto Brooklyn - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Absolutely disappointed, we came here for Father's Day! When I took my children to the bathroom it was a large co ed bathroom. My 4 year old daughter had to use the same toilet a man used, this bathroom has access to the streets of Brooklyn, anyone can come and go into the bathroom, no security not to mention it's just a gross idea, when I asked the front desk they told me their being with the times. My response was and what does that mean? My little children had to be in the bathroom with men they do not know? When I mentioned it to our waitress she said she also feels unsafe, maybe the newer trend should be increased intelligence! read more

Great Sunday brunch atmosphere and vibe. Food was excellent, The pizza and chicken were amazing. Even the kale salad was epic. One of the best Bloody Mary's I've ever had. Service was good. read more

This place is less than a week old but already impressive. It used to be The Osprey at One Hotel but under new management with a new menu etc. We came on Sunday and sat outside with the dog and were well looked after by Britney. The tuna carpaccio was chefs kiss delicious and my swordfish was cooked to perfection. So tender and juicy. My friend got the veggie bolognese which was not good at all. Avoid! And almost made this a 4 star, but the tiramisu and the fact the manager came over to make sure everything was going ok put this back up to 5. The tiramisu is the best I've tasted outside of Italy. I'll be back! read more

See all

In A Nutshell: -Barbuto is a really good place to warm up & enjoy a great breakfast while taking in the view of the Brooklyn Bridge. -Their Montauk Shrimp & Grits tasted freshly caught & the added poached eggs are a nice touch. -The American Breakfast features several large, crispy bacon, crunchy sourdough, a flat hand sized hash brown & a couple of eggs your preferred way. Overall, the service here is outstanding. They represent the city extremely well! read more

See all

Went for brunch. Ordered bagel which was inedible. At least 3 days old. Food was not fresh. English muffin was grocery bought. Juice was also 14 dollars for plastic bottled juice. Pizza was suppose to have burrata as described in menu but there was no burrata in the pizza. Staff was not attentive. Poor food quality, poor service. Terrible place. Will not be going back. read more

5/5 stars! Absolutely would recommend to everyone! The food was incredible and the service from Nash was phenomenal! We tried the chicken, seafood salad and tiramisu, and the pizza al mare was sooooooo good. Definitely a must try in Dumbo! read more

See all

Great location but mediocre food! I'll start with the positive - the location in the Brooklyn Bridge Park is lovely especially if the weather is nice and you can eat outside. Also waiter, Akshay, was great. He was nice, efficient and helpful. Now on to the negative ... First, our food took forever to come out of the kitchen and our waiter had to apologize several times. The restaurant was only about 60% full and the kitchen was unbelievably slow. In addition, the kitchen informed our waiter that my swordfish was no longer available only after about 25 minutes after I gave my order! Now on to the quality of the food. My husband and I started with a salad which had a dressing that was so acidic that it ruined the flavor of the greens. My husband's vegetarian bolognese had no taste, which was amazing for an Italian restaurant. To add insult to injury, my side dish of broccolini was served totally cold. The only nice dish was my tilefish, which was properly cooked and seasoned. Our waiter graciously offered us a pistachio cake to compensate for the wait and all the disappointments but, alas, that too was a disappointment. The cake was covered and filled with the type of pure sugar icing from my childhood and there was hardly any flavor of pistachio. We live 5 minutes from Barbuto Brooklyn and were excited to be getting a nice restaurant in our food starved neighborhood but we won't be going back. read more

Had a really great experience at this new restaurant in Dumbo. The service was attentive and very empathetic. Its refreshing to see people so passionate about what they do. The Roast chicken does not disappoint, and the kale salad is a great take on a Ceasar salad. I really enjoyed the budino for dessert, a decadent chocolate pudding, a small pot enough for two. We dined outside and had beautiful views of the Brooklyn Bridge. Really a spectacular evening. read more

If I can give the restaurant 0 stars I WOULD! This restaurant is a 0 for everything except This place is stealing your money, giving you shit food....chicken, pork, pasta dishes....all terrible. This is joke Italian food. It's all a fancy, expensive gimmick. DO NOT give this restaurant your business- you will be disappointed. it doesn't deserve to be high priced restaurant in DUMBO Brooklyn. A hole in the wall spot with a proven reputation for A FRACTION of the price, has food 1000x better than this place. Don't get me started on the service! It's like these waiters and waitresses never served a table before. Every table was getting wrong dishes and they barely tried to fix anything. The whole place was a mess. There were a million staff workers around, and no one was doing anything. This place just looks like another money grabbing restaurant looking to look the part and lure patrons in but not deliver on food or service. They do not deserve a spot in the one hotel and they certainly will NOT make it in this spot. I can't wait for them to shut down and move on bc they're honestly a waste of space in this area. They're also SNEAKY!! WATCY THE BILL...we ordered a plate without dairy in it bc we have one dairy allergy. Of course, they completely disregarded it and gave it with cheese in it. We had to send it back for the obvious reasons and they gave us a new one. On the bill, if we ordered 2 of something it would say "item x 2" on the receipt. When we ordered the pasta- They SEPARATED the charges on our long group bill and hid the second pasta charge somewhere else hoping we would miss it and pay. NOTHING ABOUT THIS PLACE IS ATTRACTIVE, DONT WASTE YOUR MONEY ON THIS MONEY HUNGRY SPOT. Chef Jonathan waxman is a sham. read more

Maybe the Manhattan location is as excellent as they say, but we went here for brunch and it was just...bad. We got the sense they were having growing pains from just opening, but it was overwhelmingly mediocre food (and service). As context, we're all locals, and decided to try the restaurant because someone in our party had booked a massage at the hotel for their birthday and we figured we'd go to the connected restaurant for brunch, despite being fans of the many excellent local eateries in the area. That was a mistake. The good: we were a larger party and the staff didn't rush us when two of our party showed up late. And everyone was generally pretty nice. The space is beautiful. The drip coffee is okay. And the toast is good. The bad: Where to begin. We ordered the American breakfast, the avocado toast, and the scrambled eggs with truffle. The first two were mediocre but not offensive -- just very bland. Like continental breakfast quality. The scrambled eggs with truffle ($28) were just offensive. The table next to us had ordered a side of scrambled eggs and they were the same size as the truffle egg entree, which came with two scrambled eggs and a tiny amount of sprinkled truffle flakes (not the nice large slices you would expect for the portion). All the other egg entrees came with toast and this was just a small plate of eggs. When we flagged for the waiter and asked if we were missing something, he assured us that we must have gotten the side order instead of the entree, and then came back looking somewhat guilty to confirm that this was, in fact, our entree. When we ordered toast to supplement, it came out burnt--like, black burnt. The espresso drinks had a weird metallic taste. The poached egg on our avocado toast was cold. You get the picture. As an aside, we thought they were appropriately handling a dairy and berry allergy, but then the servers placed the only berry dish in front of the person with a berry allergy, and then looked confused when we asked them to confirm which American breakfast entree was dairy free (since two identical ones were delivered to the table). At that point, we were eager to just get out of there, but I think we were all somewhat disappointed that our friend who was celebrating a birthday got no acknowledgement from the staff. For a luxury hotel like the 1Hotel, that was pretty surprising and was the final nail in the coffin. So: the headline is, go to Colonie, go to Boutros, even just go get a pastry from Breads around the corner and walk along the promenade. Go anywhere but here. read more

By all means avoid for breakfast. This is NOT a place to go to start your day. The "Scrambled Eggs with Wild Mushrooms" that I ordered as an entree turned out to be a single overcooked egg with a few pieces of mushroom served on a tiny side plate. No salad, no toast or anything else included. They two people I was with had ordered the same. Fortunately we also shared a large chopped kale salad. I guess their forte is lunch and dinner. They shouldn't be serving breakfast. The restaurant that formerly occupied this space was a much better choice for that. read more

The service (Raul) was outstanding friendly, attentive, and made us feel truly welcome. The lobster pasta was incredible ,perfectly cooked, rich, and full of flavor. Definitely one of the best meals I've had in a while! read more

My husband and I just finished a delicious dinner at Barbuto. We sat in the bar area overlooking the Brooklyn Bridge, so romantic! Our very knowledgeable and charming bartender River took great care of us. He recommend some delicious dishes (carpaccio and the skirt steak) and made a killer Negroni. River also recommended perfect pairing wines which we thoroughly enjoyed. We'll be back! read more

Had an incredible experience! Our server, Matheo, was knowledgeable, friendly, and made the evening even better. The food was absolutely amazing JW Pollo was my favorite, with the seafood pizza and tuna carpaccio being total standouts. We started at the bar, where the bartenders were super cool and welcoming. The vibe is unreal those jungle-like views make you forget you're in the middle of the city. Definitely coming back! read more

Amazing service from start to finish. Food was amazing and the wine selections were great! Will definitely we back - great addition to the neighborhood! read more