Food - 4**** Tasty spaghetti and chicken. Ravioli and Gnocchi was a little tougher than I prefer however maybe that is their el dente. My lean cut of tenderloin was cooked more well than I asked. Friendly Customer Service - 3** my dad thinks they steer you toward the bar bf tell you that there is no room on the dining room to buy more drinks. The Lambrusco was served cold which I would not recommend. The bar tender and hostess were friendly however our server was pretty shy but she was cute at least. I don't think she knows what vinegar and oil is because I asked for that as my salad dressing but she said they didn't have that. Almost every restaurant has that, especially if you do Friday fish fry. Clean ambience & friendly 5***** read more

Bartolettis - Saturday special tenderloin, fries and salad. - New American Near Me - Niagara, Wisconsin

Arrived at 4pm , 15 people came in behind us in different groups and every single one of them were seated before us , that's uncalled for , very poor seating service ! read more

Always good spaghetti. The service is good. Normally a good crowd but service is quick.

Waiting and seating is complex and outta whack for timely seating. Bar service is great but the wait for food was not worth the heartache and torment. Second visit with same observations. Not returning. read more

Very good food and drinks, never a bad meal. Great service. Always seat you asap. The best place to eat and drink

Absolutely one of the worst dining experiences I've ever had--and we didn't even make it to a table. My fiancé and I were traveling through the area and made a special stop to try this place. Big mistake. There's zero direction when you walk in. Just an empty host stand and confused guests waiting to be acknowledged. After standing there for 5+ minutes, the hostess handed us a buzzer and told us to wait at the bar. So we did--for over an hour. During that time, we watched countless parties who arrived after us--clearly regulars--get seated immediately. When we politely asked the hostess for an update, she gave us attitude, no real answer, and basically blew us off. We left. And we're glad we did. Everyone working there looked miserable, clearly didn't want to be there, and couldn't care less about basic hospitality or customer service. We ended up having an incredible meal at the steakhouse up the street instead where we shared a story with a local couple who also refuse to ever eat at this establishment. Save yourself the time and the frustration. Skip this place. read more

Crazy place. They need to hire more people. Some food is decent. Service would be better with help.

We found out about the $5 all you can eat Broasted Chicken & Spaghetti dinner special on Mondays a few weeks back, and decided to give a try. Don't get me wrong, the food was decent, but the way things are done once inside definitely make first timers and tourists feel out of place. When going in, there is a line. Okay, whatever. What's not said, or posted, is that the little podium is where you need to go, to get yourself checked in, and get a buzzer. After seeing people just walking in then going there, skipping the people already in line waiting to check in is a kick to the butt! So, that's done. After an hour and twenty minutes, watching the person running the seating board grabbing people that she apparently knew, who came in after us, to get seated is a bunch of crap. When confronting her, she gets defensive and rude, like it's our fault we're being skipped over. For $5 Broasted chicken, I've honestly paid more and had worse than what's served here. But, the experience from walking in to being seated left too much to desire. read more

Nothing in this restaurant is made fresh. Had the Italian Wedding soup and it was out of a can (you can always tell when the meatballs look like clones). The bang bang shrimp was rubbery and I believe it was microwaved. The steaks were overcooked, under seared, and flavored with so much Lawry's Seasoned Salt it could double for a salt lick. The gnocchi like wise was not fresh it was clearly machine produced and frozen, it was overcooked and rubbery and the marinara sauce was a flavorless thin red liquid that was a little thicker then tomato juice but with less flavor. The waitress was attentive and funny; the bartender less so (seemed like he would rather be anywhere but work), those raggedy T-Shirts need to go, they are old, stretched out, and stained. Not sure why the locals flock here, they must have forgot what good food tastes like. read more

In town on business. Looking for Broasted Chicken dinner and stumbled upon this place. Service is good. Spaghetti is good. Chicken was excellent! Come on Monday night for AYCE Broasted chicken and spaghetti for $5! read more

Previously I have given them a 5 star review, but after tonight I have to change that to 1 because of my experience tonight. Ordered the deep fried cod dinner and they served me 3 1 inch by 1 inch pieces with hot, discolored tartar sauce. When I asked a waitress that was passing by if I could get some refrigerated tartar sauce she literally said I will have to see what we have. NOT A GOOD SIGN. She did bring some and just tossed it on my table and when I said thank you she said mhm. My waitress for my table however was very kind. read more

Always great food, and good service! We live in lower Mi. but have a house in Kingsford, Bartolettis is always on our must do list when we are up this way! read more

Food cold, service neglectful & unfriendly, unwelcoming atmosphere. MICROWAVE offered if you do not like to eat cold food. Police threatened if you do not want to eat cold food or pay for neither the cold food served or microwaved food as their accommodation. Staff yelling, waiving their hands goodbye, mocking, laughing, telling you to never return if you're not happy with cold food or microwaves. This happened to my husband and I on our anniversary April 30th 2023. The food was inedible and without even eating the food we requested something be done besides throwing our steaks and soup in the microwave... we were met with three confrontational staff members, two waitresses and one bartender who watched their staff behave like animals while he sneered and laughed. This has got to be the worst experience of my life and unreal that multiple members of staff would behave in such ways. My husband had to wipe the waitress' spit off his face because she ran up on him telling him he would either pay or the police would be called. This is unacceptable and downright disturbing. We've been returning customers who clearly hold no value to the business. Unfortunately, there are not many restaurants to choose from in our area. However, we will NEVER STEP FOOT IN THAT RESTAURANT AGAIN!!! Shameful!!! I cannot put enough emphasis into this review. THAT PLACE NEEDS TO BE SHUT DOWN!! Not to mention the rest of the issues... serving water that sat all day with a quarter chip of ice cube in it... the water was discolored and warm. Unreal!! This is sad! Please do not make the mistake of going to this restaurant if you've never been and consider how their staff treats their customers if you're a regular. They are downright obnoxious and many others have similar and different experiences that are not good. Their staff is always ignorant and lazy. If I could give them negative stars I would. read more

They have some of the best steaks in this area. Their pasta is really good and their seafood is great. They also have the best prices around here. read more

The food was delicious. It's a nice little place. The service was prompt. Casual, we went after golfing 18 holes.

Went for a nice anniversary dinner but had the WORST service ever! This waitress Wendy came to the table as soon as we were seated and asked for our orders. We ordered a drink, which they didn't have the alcohol to make a drink I wanted, which was no big deal, but instead of giving me time to think about a different drink, she looked annoyed so I just ordered water. She never actually greated us either. She never smiled. Just plain had a resting bitch face!!! I have never left a crappy tip, but tonight she is lucky I gave her the 3 dollars I did. And no it is not because she might be tired tonight. I have had her multiple times and she had always been the same. Tonight I was going to get up and leave, but my hubby calmed me down, but there will not be a next time!!! read more

Food was tasty...price was great! I'd definitely go back! I had the 6 oz filet with Gnocchi and vegetable beef soup. They also have a full bar, so I tried a cocktail as well...that hit the spot too. Service was great to top it all off! read more

I had heard good things about Bartoletti's but I was very disappointed with their food. The salad was adequate but only that. The prime rib was done as ordered, but they had no horseradish cream to go with it (the cut was okay, but had a bit of gristle). I didn't care for their gnocchi-it seemed heavy. They had a chicken special advertised for another day that was a super good price. I might be willing to try Bartoletti's for something like that with the family, but I won't go there for a special dare night again. read more

This was our first time eating at this restaurant. Unfortunatly, the food was a complete let down. The waitress was not rude but also was not kind, attentive or knowledgeable. The portion sizes were pretty big but the quality, taste and sauces(tasted cheap) were all more than disappointing. We each had different items off the menu and both barely took even a few bites. It was date night so it was a bit of damper. But on the one positive note, the wine was only $3 a glass and they poured generously. Probably will never return to this establishment. read more

This place is a local favorite for the 70+ crowd, but the food is downright horrible. I ordered the chicken Alfredo, and it was pretty much inedible. It was like a flour and water paper mache paste with no seasoning, yuck! My husband got the steak, and was happy with it, mostly because of the cheap price. Also the decor was super dark and dingy and the service was inattentive. We haven't been back. read more

Terrible. First it's dirty, seats and table cloths have holes. Waitresses are rude. No smile, no nothing. Served me a lobster under cooked, when I sent it back she didn't even say sorry. Came back like rubber, I didn't even eat. Steak, had ZERO seasoning. And wasn't cooked at all! Only the outside was browned. Very low class place. Will never go again. Oh and a 30 min wait and hardly no one sitting in dining room. Ick! read more

Decent food does not make up for biased service! My party of 3 waited over an hour after being told we wouldn't wait more than 30 minutes. I suppose the hostess was referring to the parties which arrived AFTER us that were seated in under half an hour. Unless she failed to notice either our name on the list or the fact that we were standing right at the front of the line, I can think of no excuse for this deplorable service. read more

Great restaurant. Excellent food at a really good price. Steak, pasta, and seafood. Good service. Bartolettis is a place you'll be visiting ten times a year. they keep you wanting more and more. read more

Consistently good food and very good service. Broasted chicken specials on Sunday and Monday are good deals.

told my server I had a dairy allergy my steak came out with it soaked in butter ..they made me a new one that one came out rare to med rare it was suppose to be medium..Asked to have it taken off the bill and pretty much told no can give you 10 off since they wasted 2 steaks... I honestly would never recommend them to anyone... my steak was not the only that came out soaked in butter... I told my server about the allergy for a reason read more

Really good food, ok service. Specials are great but they run out quickly. Some of the seating sucks but I would recommend it.