The place is large but, like others have said majority of it goes unused. The staff is friendly and had no issues with the service. Grabbed a cheese slice and a pepperoni roll with a side of marinara sauce. Both were solid, the slices undercarriage was cooked perfectly, the amount of cheese could be better but the slice was solid. It can hang with most places downstate in NYC and LI. The pepperoni roll was good, only negative was the amount of garlic used. I will be repelling all the vampires in the area from West Point, no getting bit tonight. The side of sauce was ok, just a plain marinara sauce not much seasoning added. Overall a solid experience and would definitely visit again. Just next time might avoid the rolls due to the garlic. I like garlic but this was just too much. The ambiance was fine, easy listening music in the background and the tables were fine. read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - Pepperoni Roll and cheese REGULAR SLICE - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

We rolled into the cafe with an appetite. I had the steak and cheese and mint chocolate chip ice cream and they both were tasty! We were hiking Bear Mountain and the path leads to this gorgeous hotel. Someone was having a luxury wedding at the top and The whole event was sprawled out over the rocks! Really gorgeous! We only ate at the hiker cafe but they have a more luxury restaurant. I can't wait to stay here someday. Looks like a really great place for a memorable occasion. read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - Gift shop - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

See all

I have no idea if their food is great or terrible. We called in advance to make a reservation for 9 people and they said it wasn't necessary, just come in. When we got there, they were under construction inside and only had outdoor tables in weather that didn't make that a reasonable option. read more

I've been to this place a couple times when traveling out here and it is by far my favorite pizza place. They used to be in a food truck last time I was here. But inside is very nice now. Our order was perfect and had no issues. The pizza is a 10 out of 10. So good and has a nice crunchy crust. As for the soup, I'll give it a six out of 10. Only because it really didn't have much seasoning or flavor to it. But everything was hot to order and we picked it up. As long as this place is here, I'm gonna stop in. read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - STRACCIATELLA SOUP - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

See all

Got here before they closed. Got two grandma slices, two white slices, and one buffalo chicken. The grandma slices were the standout. Crispy thick crust with a light char, sweet tomato sauce, and cheese. The white pizza was creamy and rich without feeling heavy, with a nice balance of cheese and garlic. The buffalo chicken slice had a kick without being overpowering, and the chicken stayed tender instead of drying out. Slices came out hot because he put them in the oven after I ordered it, and the crust on all of them had that perfect balance of crunch on the bottom with a soft bite on top. Service was easygoing and quick, and the place has a low key, small town pizzeria feel. read more

See all

I tried both the chicken parm pizza and the grandma drunk pizza. I thought the grandma drunk pizza was really good, but the chicken parm pizza was extremely lackluster. It needed more sauce or cheese, as all I tasted was chicken and bread. read more

This place is legit! Pizza is off the chain good. Went here on a West Point visit and totally worth the 10 minute drive. This will be are go to pizza shop for the next 4 years (hopefully). Class of 29 "Hold the line". read more

Hold onto your hats cause this review will blow you away. Been following this place for awhile on Instagram and tonight decided to take the ride from Paramus NJ. Pulled into a packed parking lot and could smell the delicious aroma of pizza as soon as I exited the vehicle. Upon entering we were greeting warmly with smiles and welcome messages from all the employees. We chose our seat and said hello to Providence, got our menus, ordered our wine and started discussing what we would be ordering. Our waiter Vittoli was a real darling and brought us garlic knots to nibble on while we perused the menu. We started with Stracciatella Soup which was served piping hot (the way soup should be served) and was just like my grandmother made....delish! We decided on the Sexy Pizza - Fresh mozzarella, house-milled tomato sauce, fresh basil, and a touch of roasted garlic, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil on a thin crispy crust. OMG!! Light crispy crust NO flop! Perfect seasoning and cooked to perfection. Wanted to eat the whole pizza but had it wrapped so that we could have coffee and gelato for dessert. Do yourself a favor and the next time you are looking for a cute, friendly place to have a great meal try Bear Mountain Pizza...I know I will be back sooner than later. read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - Sexy Pizza - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

See all

This place was amazing. Loved i!!! Pass it a million times and never stoped till today. The food and the pizza was so good. Thank you sister for the great lunch and dinner!!! read more

Solid pizza, great prices and quick service. Smelled great inside as well with the giant oven. Quick place for food near West Point.

Stopped in after bear mountain hike for a couple quick slices. A+ Buffalo chicken and "sexy slice" aka margarita were both top notch. We're from NYC and eat good pizza all the time -- this place held its own for sure! Quality and fresh! read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - Sexy Pizza Slice - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

BEST Pizza in the area. Everytime we visit the area, we stop there to eat. I can't wait until they finish the remodeling and open the bar, it is going to be 10 times better . read more

Very pleasantly surprised - like many other reviewers we stopped here after a hike in Harriman. Tortilla soup was delicious. Good garden salad, garlic knots and Stromboli. I'll be back the next time I go for a hike in the area. Service was kind too read more

See all

Orders: - Large Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza: The cheese peel was immaculate! - Garlic Knots with Mozzarella: So flavorful and buttery. - Wings: the spicy-sting had me begging for more. Top Tier Service. Got some dessert, on the house. Smiles and friendly demeanor of all staff made this cozy place so inviting. 10/10 would recommend! read more

I pick up others every so often since the indoor dining opened back up and no more food truck. So the service I was mixed on, since guy making pizzas had to text to get someone to man the counter which was bit embarrassing I would say. So I placed my order and it was ready in time. The grandma pizza was delicious, I see why most of my deliveries are for that type of pizza, just right amount of fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce with a small amount of fresh basil. The crust was thin and not doughy. Penne bolognese, the pasta was al Dante, plenty of meat, but wish had more sauce since the pasta was but naked without. Otherwise a pretty good meal I portioned into two for a later lunch. Garlic knots were alright, not swimming in garlic oil, which my heartburn thanks me for haha. But still great knots, better than some side salad, or bread loaf. Don't get many chances to try here, but on a visit I have try the sexy pizza, when I get more time and Cash. Glad to be customer here for once rather than a driver. read more

See all

We stopped by after a trip to the zoo because the kids were craving pizza. The owner greeted us warmly and we ordered a regular cheese pizza, half with pepperoni. The pizza was thin crust, hot, and just wonderful. I love a crust that doesn't bend and isn't burnt. This fit the bill. The owner also brought us zeppoles. They were good and the kids loved them. If we ever are in the area, we would definitely return! read more

Spectacular crisp crust pizza (highly recommend the sexy pie!). Fresh french fries, all food made to order. Well topped burger. Draft Peroni and Sam Seasonal tasted good after a long day of hiking Bear Mountain. read more

So good! We walked in expecting a sit down pizza joint, and quickly found out it's a classic pizza style. I.e., you walk up to the counter and order either slices or order whatever you'd like. The gentlemen behind the counter were SO friendly and charismatic. We ordered a small pizza and pinwheel. Both were phenomenal. Based on our experience, I would venture to say they use fresh mozzarella, which makes a better pizza (and is what drove me to review this). Overall, it was a great experience with great food read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - View into counter - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

Pizza is ok only problem is if youre going there for a slice or 2 they usually have old leftover pizza that they reheat. I had a chicken bacon ranch slice and the chicken was rubbery like it had been left over from the day before read more

This was our first visit to the area, and we're so glad we found your place. We absolutely loved your "Grandma's Pizza"! The old-school pizza shop vibe was great too! If we're ever back in the area, we'll definitely stop by again! read more

I ordered food through an app for delivery. I ordered, pizza, garlic knots and a slice of tiramisu. Pizza was okay. Crust wasn't cooked well. Garlic knots, okay but not marinara sauce included as the it said on the description. Then I ordered tiramisu. They never notified me anything was wrong. They sent me lemon cake. I called and they said they sent me cheesecake. It's not even cheesecake. All I got was an apology. So that's the reason for my poor review. read more

This area of upstate New York, surrounding West Point Military Academy, is a food desert. Your only options include a McDonalds, a Chinese restaurant with a 1 star average on Yelp, and a few pizza joints. Bear Mountain is one of them, and probably your best bet. Their menu offers an impressive range of classic and unique pizza slices and pies, plus house made pastas, salads, desserts, and more. One large pizza, 2 slices, a salad, and cannoli, came to $75 via DoorDash. Our order took 1 hour and 30 minutes to be delivered, despite the restaurant being 3 miles from our hotel. Do not get a salad from here. About 50% of the greens in my House Salad were rotting, and thus inedible. The Eggplant Rollatini slice was, well, confusing. Did the thin, flimsy pieces of breading contain eggplant? It did not seem so. Why was there a giant gob of mozzarella in one isolated area? The ricotta on this slice was good, but nothing else was. The best item in our order was the Grandma slice: an expertly executed square of crisp, olive oil scented crust, topped with flavorful marinara. Our large pie, which we got with pepperoni and olives, was passable. It was not on par with NYC pizza, but had a solid crust and above average ingredients. The Cannoli was tasty as well; it had hints of cinnamon and fruit that I was not expecting. read more

See all

I have ordered several times here before and the pizza has been amazing. Love the sauce and the dough is perfectly crisp. This place is a total gem. I have had pizza all over NYC and just recently at A Sally's in New Haven and Delucias in NJ and Bear mountain beats those two places hands down. read more

Me Wife sis and mom visited West Point. After a long day of walking we decided to come in here for some dinner. Best decision to come here. Everyone's dinner was delicious! Bruschetta was freshly made and tasty. Chicken Parm Hero was amazing ! will def come again if I'm the area ! read more

Excellent pizza and not one would expect outside of NYC and Long Island. Definitely competes with the likes of Grimaldi's and Umberto's. We got the grandma's pie which I recommend, and a calzone. The calzone BTW is the size of a football. They have their own brand of sodas, which had good flavors. We came here thinking it was more of a sit-down restaurant, but that was our mistake. Except for the lack of AC, we did not mind it though. You order at the counter and a server will bring you the food. There are chickens (and in early August a chick) roaming the property, which delighted my kids. The folks are very friendly. Parking is a little confusing because there is an inn there, but basically grab any spot that doesn't impede traffic or block anyone. read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - Their own soda brand - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

See all

Great Place! Great Food ! Great Service! everything on the menu is delicious. I used their catering and the food was delivered on time and hot . it's the only place to get great pizza , also the gelato was great, you have to try the honey & walnut gelato! read more

We've tried different pizzerias since moving to the Cornwall area, and haven't found anything tasty. Until now. Bear Mountain Pizza was a very nice surprise. It's unassuming, especially since The Old Oak Inn sign is more prevalent. But don't be fooled. We had the grandma pie and it was delicious! The sauce is spot on. Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil put on at the right time. Thin, crispy crust. Thank God my husband passes by on his way home from work! read more

Was kind of taken back by the pie we ordered delivered yesterday Really not that great Arrived , barely warm Overcooked and although your homemade Ingredients are good of quality, the pie just lacked taste . Picture of overcooked pie below read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

The hot honey grandma pizza along with the sexy pizza are amazing! The service was kind and nice. This is by far my favorite pizza place 10/10! read more

Decent pizza, tried multiple flavors - sexy (margherita), chicken bacon ranch, meatball, and onion. The marg was my favorite, chicken bacon ranch was tasty but a bit heavy to eat more than one slice, meatball tasted like store bought meatballs to me, and onion wasn't bad albeit a little boring. The crust wasn't the crispiest, but not bad. Prices are a bit expensive here. When ordering online, the pickup times are outrageous but it doesn't take nearly as long as they say. This made it hard to gauge when to leave to pick it up. They actually called telling us it was ready before we had left to go get it. read more

Highly recommend Grandma Pie!! Amazing thin crust! Fresh homemade sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh Basil, perfection!! Perfectly cooked in a brick oven. Best pizza I've ever had hands down! read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - Grandma Pizza - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

Stumbled upon this place and it did not disappoint!! Excellent Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken! The cookies and cream gelato was fantastic as well! Awesome building as well! read more

Really hit the spot on cold winter nights. Pizza was great, as were the cheese steak sandwiches. Came back a night later to order pasta and wings. Staff is friendly. Not a whole lot of food choices in the area, but this place seemingly has it all. read more

This is located in the Old Oak Inn on route 9W, We had just finished shopping at Woodbury common's and we were just looking for an area that had Restaurants with outdoor seating options. The waitress was very nice. This turned out to be a pleasant surprise because the pizza ended up being really great. There were 4 of us and we shared the following dishes. They have a big variety of pizza, pasta and salad options. We got the supreme pizza that had Peppers, onions, black olives, mushrooms, sausage & pepperoni. For about $25. The pizza was very big and the toppings were plentiful with lots of cheese. We began with a Caprese Salad with Tomato, mozzarella and a balsamic glaze. The tomatoes and mozzarella were very good and fresh. For about $13. We also have these pepperoni bites which were very good as well. We ended the meal with some nice home made gelato/ice cream The only downside is that they don't have their liquor license so I couldn't have a drink with my dinner but I don't know if they were BYOB which would've been good because then I would have picked up a bottle of wine to drink. Overall if I'm ever in that area again I will definitely go back. read more

See all

We had gone to Hudson highlands for the long weekend of Presidents' Day. We were looking for a quick lunch spot when we came across Bear mountains and pizza cafe It is a cute little cafe where you can make your own pizza slices or pick one from their display. It was surprising to find such amazing pizza in the middle of no where: I got a customized slice with chicken, bbq and ranch sauce (was so good), must try! And my partner got the Grandma slice which was delicious too! read more

See all

I love this palace! We always get calamari (very crunchy, Hawaiian pizza(the Dow is perfect!) and chicken parm. sandwiches, love their heans walking around and nice out door tables read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - Outdoor tables - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

See all

The pizzas were incredible! My boys are pizza connoisseurs and they were impressed and noted the sauce especially. Highly recommend! read more

Really Really Good! Everything made fresh to order. Location is also convenient right near the highway (and pretty much the only place in town as far as we could see). We were headed to Storm King Art Center, and this is THE Perfect stop on the way back or towards. The crust on the pizza is so delicate and crispy. Overall the textures are very rich - lots of cheese and herbs. I personally love the commitment to amazing quality, the service is also a PERFECT 10! I really encourage you to stop here if possible. Very special attention to detail. Vegan friendly, the cauliflower crust is one the BEST EVER. OVERALL -- nothing less than DELICIOUS! read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - Sexy pizza - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York

See all

Good food and service it's little small when I when but I think they have close the dinner area. But everything was really good

Hit right after a big hike. Service was quick and the pizza was tasty. Can't wait to go back and try the gelato one day, it looked phenomenal! read more

Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Highland Falls, New York