Benny Mazzetto's is such a great spot in Summerville. I love hanging out in the back bar, especially on Sunday nights when they have live music. The vibe is very chill, relaxed, and just good energy all around. Everyone who works there is really nice, and it always feels welcoming. It's a fun place whether you're stopping in solo or meeting up with a group. Always a good time and definitely one of my go-to spots. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

A solid slice of local pizza, and probably the most generous sized slices I've ever had the pleasure of taking a bite out of than this one. The new York slice was crisp but foldable, and even with just pepperoni it still gave just the warm evening bite that I hoped it would. Glad we got recommended this pace, when we return for another visit I can bet we will end up here sometime. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - The big box! - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

See all

This place is great and for the reviews and ratings it is showing on here should be higher. We had this pizza at the downtown location and we see that it's awesome they have one here in north Summerville area which is perfect. They have the biggest tastiest slices of pizza in town. This place reminds me of the greatest pizza joints in the city of up north. So if you are looking for that New York slice that's huge, this is the place. It's a must try. They also have a hidden cool bar in the back with more dining space. I will try out the bar next time. If you have a hungry crowd at home to feed, this is your perfect spot to fill those tummys. read more

Benny's is always our go to after our Wine Tasting Wednesday get together! It's such a vibe inside Benny's! And for the size slices you get, well worth the money! Service I always great, the bartender is always such a sweetheart! He's so kind! read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Pepperoni slice! Hand for size! - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

See all

I was very hungry after a few cocktails up the road and my friend recommended grabbing a slice from Benny's. The slices are huge and definitely enough for one person. I got the maple bacon and it was sweet and savory. I really liked the garlic sauce that they offered too! The garlic bread was nice and cheesy! I'm will say it is quite hot in there with the ovens being out but worth a try! The service was quick and friendly! read more

See all

Giant pizza slices, sweet employees, great service, clean restaurant, live music, wow!! I love this little pizza place. Perfect crispy cheesy New York style slices. read more

See all

Probably won't be back. Did not like the flavor of the sauce on the cheese pizza and the chicken bacon ranch was just meh. I feel like this is better as a late night spot after a few drinks. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Slice of cheese - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

I learned that "large" is a relative term, and it worked out well for us. I ordered a large pepperoni and sausage pizza, delivered via Uber Eats. The driver said he'd never seen a pizza this large. Neither had I! I had a surprise visit from my two young adult sons, who are in the military and fit. They consume a ton of calories to support their rigorous activities - which is why I ordered a large pizza. Benny's large was perfectly sized, and as importantly, great pizza. It was the highlight of their visit, and a memorable night for us all. I'd conclude that Benny's is good pizza. It can also be an epic memory if you order a large. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

See all

Absolutely loved our experience here. My kiddos and I decided it was time to try out this huge pizza we had been hearing all these fun things about how great the pizza is. We loved the pizza it was huge and honestly for the size of each slice you can't beat the price! The service was great, there was a festival going on and they were swamped but that didn't affect their service. The restaurant was fun and inviting. You have to try one of their slices of pie. read more

See all

The pizza was hot and fresh and the service was fast and friendly. I'll definitely be back! read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

I was in Summerville and the kids had been wanting pizza, so it made sense for me to swing by Benny Mazzatto's. I have seen them on DoorDash running about $70 fora pizza, but my pickup order placed through their site was only $48. That's still a LOT for a pizza, but keep in mind that one of their pizzas is about 2x the total area of a normal 18" pizza so it's right in line on value for a relatively expensive local pizza shop. The pizza tries to be a New York Style pizza and (speaking as a native New Yorker who still goes there for work on a regular basis... so I am familiar with the pizzas there) it mostly pulls it off. I have had better NYC style pizzas in SC, but this was solid. I think if they made it 18" it probably would hit closer to the mark. The pizza was ready within a minute of the expected time, which is a miracle and made me happy. Folks at the counter were friendly. There were some interesting looking desserts I wanted to check out too, but my hands were full and I wasn't sure if ice cream would make it to my house in North Charleston without melting. Overall this was a good pizza and I wish that I lived close enough for this to be a regular pickup. I deducted the star mostly because it wasn't a top flight NYC pizza, and somewhat because I would like an 18" option. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Literally filled the trunk of my Camaro ‍ - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

If you are in the mood for pizza & beer this is the place for you. You can get pizza by the slice or as a full pie. If you're not super hungry 1 slice should be plenty. If you're really hungry 1 slice will be enough. A single slice covers 2 full plates! These slices are massive! The staff are incredibly friendly & helpful. The restaurant & bar have a very comfortable feel; like a local hometown bar should be. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Good Times Brocken Bow Irish Stout - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

See all

I love coming here for a quick bite. The pizza slices are huge! They have classic pizza, pepperoni, and a few extras. I love their drink selections! They have all kinds of hard to find sodas which I love trying. This is a typical pizza place vibe with an open kitchen and big ovens. Lots of seating up front but there's a whole bar area in the back. The service is friendly but to the point. You won't get smiles and friendly conversation, but you get great service. read more

See all

i've been coming to benny's for years and never have a bad time. we usually sit in the back where the bar is and they always have nice staff and good service! i constantly recommend it to my friends when they come into town looking for good pizza! read more

I've visited and online ordered on several occasions. Today I ordered 2 slices of pizza. Very disappointed. Both slices were BURNT. Called restaurant. Apology was given. Asked was there anything they could. I said no. I would not order again. Impossible that server did not know slices were burnt. Can't do business with them. read more

Great pizza. As close to New York style as you can get in South Carolina. Great prices too.

My family has tried Benny's two times now and both times they have been happy with the pizza. They thought the sausage and pepperoni pizza was better than the garlic and mushroom pizza with sausage added because they felt there were too many mushrooms on the pizza... it's a 28 inch pizza. The box is HUGE! We have to transport it in the trunk of our car. It barely gets out of the door of the restaurant. It's very fun walking out trying to hold the pizza but we enjoy it. (I'm not being sarcastic. We actually get a kick out of it.) These large pizzas cost us $40ish each but we feel it was well worth it. The only downside is there is not any vegan option, so I have to just watch everyone else enjoy it. read more

See all

First impression: Needed some Za and beer and this place hit the spot. Cool spot right in the heart of S'ville. Vibe: Wanted to watch a little football and there was a perfect bar in the back. If you want to order some quick pizza upfront or drink and hang in the back, it's a good place for it. Food and bev: I've had their pizza at other locations and I like it. It's big slice, big pie vibes. Won't be the best pizza you've ever had but it's very good. They have their own pale ale that was also really good. Service: Wasn't too busy and the bartender was very good, gave me a free koozie! Overall: Great spot for za and beer, no complaints! read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Free koozie from Benny's! - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

Strange pizza place ! Has a certain college vibe! Indy rock playing! Kid at the counter! Confusing menu! Order before you sit ! $40 for a gigantic pizza. We didn't know ! Pizzas by the slice was way to much food ! No service to speak of! examen des cols bleus:x read more

See all

Ordered 2 slices of cheese pizza. Had it delivered through DoorDash and came pretty fast. However, the pizza was extremely dry! The crust was really hard and had a burnt taste. The pizza tastes as if it was setting in the warmer all day. I really wanted to like this place but this was definitely a bummer! read more

Benny Mazzetto's is a New York-style pizzeria that opened in Summerville, South Carolina in December 2020. It is actually part of a larger chain of pizzerias that all feature the given name "Benny". The chain was founded by Virginia Tech classmates Chris Brown and Zach Toth in 2011. They had an idea to start a local pizza spot that wasn't a cookie-cutter chain like so many others. They decided to make their pizza a combination of thin New York-style with the Jumbo Slice concept found in Washington, D.C. The fictional namesake of the pizzeria was Benedito "Benny": an Italian immigrant raised in Brooklyn who worked under countless Italian chefs before relocating to a small town on the Eastern Shore of Virginia. The first pizzeria opened in Blacksburg, Virginia under the name Benny Marzano's. Today there are nearly 30 different locations (mainly in the southeast). Each new location that opens features a different surname which reflects the town it is within (i.e. Benny Ravello's, Benny Palmetto's, Benny Rinaldi's, etc.) While the pizza is the same from store to store, each location features décor that reflects its whereabouts. My family and I visited Benny Mazzetto's while we were on an East Coast Road Trip. We were visiting our cousins who live in Summerville (right outside of Charleston). On our first day in town, they brought us to the pizzeria for dinner. It is conveniently located in the historic downtown area. The surname "Mazzetto" means 'bouquet' in Italian and is a reference to Summerville's annual Flowertown Festival. Our cousins told us that Benny's was well-known for their signature 28" pies. We decided to order a pepperoni pie. This thing was HUGE! Each slice was bigger than my head, but it sure was tasty! Despite the size, it was reasonably priced. We all enjoyed some slices while we played some games at an axe-throwing facility across the street. It just so happens that our son is also named Benny (and he loved the pizza). The chain should start a new location named after him: Benny Lupoli's! read more

See all

When you hear about a pizza that's so big you struggle to put it into the car, you have to try it! We tried it, that's about all. It's a fun concept but the pizza is relatively flavorless. We got the Philly. Everyone ate and there was more than enough but the sauce and crust could use some work in the flavor department. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Big box - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

See all

I ordered a 28 inch pie yesterday, half cheese & pepperoni for me & 8 other people yesterday and today all 8 of us are now either throwing up or it's coming out the other end cause of the pizza. We called the pizza place so they were aware of it and the manager was just giving us BS answers to try and save his ass. I requested a refund and am not getting one. So please be aware that if you order from here just watch how you are feeling hours afterwards!! I've ordered from here before and had 0 problems but this one got all of us. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - 28 inch half cheese & pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

Amazing pizza and good service! Prices are fair and did not have to wait long at all for our food. Place is unique and comfortable. HUGE slices. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

We landed on this pizza shop because my husband saw the "giant" pizza (I think 28"?) and had to try it for game day. It was gigantic! The sauce has a little sweetness to it, which I really liked and surprisingly the crust held up even in the middle of the pie despite its size. Cheese and crust were okay, but this is something I would get again for a game day get together or party because it's just so fun to have for a gathering. Next time we will try some of the traditional menu items and see how they are! read more

See all

Great pizza, perfect size for a small party. Have bought the whole pie a couple of times and it's always delicious.

We love this pizza place!! A slice will fill you for 2 days...they are huge!!!! Or you can get a whole pizza....super fun to get it out the door! Nothing fancy about this place, several different slices of pizzas, some cheese bread, beer and soda! I love the variety of soda and sparkling waters....the only place to have my favorite, Fresca. Walk in order your pizza slice and have a seat. My favorite is the garlic mushroom. Located in the beautiful Summerville square right next to a local brewery. Stop by, grab a slice, eat in inside or during nice weather grab a spot in the square. Enjoy!! read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Garlic mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

See all

Decided to treat my daughter to a HUGE PIZZA for her birthday. She loved it! It smelled a little questionable in there and we had to sit by dirty mop water, but overall it was a good experience. Probably going to opt for takeout next time. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

So the smell is delicious when you enter the restaurant but everything is individually provided. No fountain drinks or sweet tea and the water is only bottled. Definitely a big profit margin for canned soda and bottled water,$1.00 each. The slices are limited but they have a rotating slice for the month which is a positive. Also be prepared to buy an entire cheese bread for $18, nothing small but it also wasn't as cheesy as we hoped. The slices were good and the atmosphere was ok but we would skip the place the next time. Good luck with the place . read more

See all

This pizza was huge. If you have a lot of people to feed order here. I only did one slice and it felt like I ate 3 Pizza Hut slices. The pizza was good and worth the money. The wait for it to cook was longggg but I was like it's to big to be done in 20mins. So I guess there's no complaint for that. Next time I won't order when I'm hungry so that I won't think about the wait time. I ordered 19 Feb 2021. Normally there is leftover pizza when you wake up. But when I opened the box in the morning to snag a slice the box was empty. The whole house enjoyed it! read more

See all

Decided to stop by today with a couple of girl friends the minute we walked in we were told we needed to order and then look at drinks I politely informed the lady at the front we weren't ready since we hadn't even been in the restaurant 30 seconds. After we looked at the pizza choices for a few seconds longer we order our pizza and drinks without knowing what drinks they had because we were being forced by the cashier to order immediately. We sat down and after a few minutes our pizzas were done but unfortunately completely burnt from the bottom of our pizzas being black to the cheese on top being crispy and black. The price isn't worth the food or attitude. read more

what?! this pizza is amazing. we had slices of the bacon, chicken, ranch and the pepperoni. my husband says this is the only pizza he wants to eat from here on out. the service was great: they were friendly and quick. the atmosphere is relaxed and clean. there's a cozy little bar at the back. we've already been back and it was just as good as the first trip. highly recommend! one slice will fill you up! on our 2nd trip we ordered a whole pizza and it was just as good re-heated. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - chicken, bacon, ranch slice - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

See all

Food is great and service is exceptional. Alway made to feel welcome by Patrick and the crew.

The Taproom in back is a hidden gem! My kinda spot. Great little break from the average dive bar. Highly recommend!

Novelty is cool, large slices and HUGE pizza pies. We went in after having a few beers at Frothy next door and picked up a slice for our son who opted to stay home. The kids running the counter were less than friendly, I guess more neutral than anything, pizza slice was huge but fairly bland. I give three stars because of the novelty and it would be good for a get-together. read more

I've had positive experiences here in the past but today was by far the worst. Employees dressed like they just got out of bed, poor customer service, and employees not using gloves and wiping hands on their clothes instead of properly washing them. No one who works here acts like they want to work or even seem to care if you come in. It's against DHEC to not wear gloves when preparing food, so that's a huge red flag. Makes us not want to eat this food read more

Wow! Good pepperoni pizza in only one size; MASSIVE! 28 inches is, as we all know, slightly over two feet. But you don't realize what that means until it's delivered in a box 29" x 29" and barely fits through the door without tilting it. Disappointed they had Vanilla Coke advertised (Uber Eats) but didn't actually carry it and I had to call them to ask because UE said Bennys was sold out of pepperoni?! Apart from that, we were pleased. BTW- you can get ONE piece per ziplock gallon bag; if you fold or roll it over. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - Doesn't fit on a dinner plate! - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

See all

A true New York style pizza. Huge slices, it only takes one to fill you up. I had the Garlic and Mushroom and it was delicious.

Looks like a great local place to enjoy some fantastic pizza. Unfortunately we couldn't patronize Benny's as we are both vegan. I know it sounds counter intuitive to have vegan pizza but with the growing vegan community many pizza houses are catching up to this market share. We hope that Benny's will begin to carry a vegan option or two (cheeses and protein) so that we can support a local eatery. Cheers! read more

The pizza was pretty good! It was thin but cheesy and the toppings were great! We ordered through DoorDash and it didn't take long at all. read more

Benny Mazzetto’s - 28" Pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Summerville, South Carolina

See all