I and my family are new to the area and dined there several times now. The service from Heather and Destiny are always great. The owner 7 is awesome and very personable. He even offered to possibly get me some help on my uncle Loren Anderson who was the head basketball coach at Yelm high in about 64. Tbe pizza is amazing heavy filling they don't skimp on the toppings at all. There establishment is also spotless. They also offer cauliflower crust as an alternative. I would highly recommend this place to people in Yelm and surrounding areas. If you havent tried them trust me give it a shot. They also offer take and bake. We have tried other pizza in the area but this is simply the best and also a great price for what you get. They also offer to split ingredients on pizza we get tbe supreme with 4 slices of pepperoni for my daughter. They are very accommodating. GO GO GO YOU WONT BE DISAPPOINTED. read more

Pizza has been delicious every time we've ordered from there. prices could be a bit better, which is why I gave 4 stars. All in all, a great option for locals and visitors. read more

I recommend Bertoglio's to everyone that I can! Followed them from their Eatonville location to the one in Yelm and it's just as fantastic as it was before. Always our choice for pizza! Prices are worth it. We always get the veggie pizza and it is STACKED! read more

The best pizza in town! Big pieces and they do NOT skimp on the toppings! Not too greasy, just all around good pizza.

We've been here several times since moving to the Ashford area. It's nothing fancy, but the food is good and the staff are always friendly and prompt. Anyone who lives around here knows it's hard to find good food; most of it is not only gross, but it also carries a good risk of giving you food poisoning. So, you can imagine how much of a blessing it is to have a place that actually serves edible food. Personally, I'm not a big fan of the fact that they have only one crust. (though, to be fair, this is the case with most small pizza businesses) I have a hard time eating anything other than thin crust, but, despite that, I still manage to enjoy their food. Although my mom is definitely a bigger fan of the pizza than I am. Just bare in mind that if you come here with super high expectations, you WILL be disappointed. This is not a 5-star gourmet restaurant. This is a small business. Expect the kind of food you would be served at a family member's house; simple and sweet, but nothing jaw-droppingly delicious. I have a feeling that most of the people coming here and leaving bad reviews expected some kind of high-end establishment with equally outstanding food. Sorry folks, this is a small town. Get used to it. read more

They turned the open sign off as we approached the door...at 8 o'clock. Closes at nine.

Have to be honest, not impressed, and we've given it at least half a dozen chances in the past couple years. The only pizza place in town. Frozen crust from Cash & Carry, and I believe the sauce and meat products come from there too. My husband and I saw them there buying supplies. So, nope, not fresh ingredients. The veg may be fresh, but the under cooked crust is the real deal breaker here. If you get one and take it home, cook it for much longer than he instructions indicate for a truly cooked pizza. read more

Best pizza place I've seen in Yelm. Staff is super nice and the food was great. Welcome to Yelm!

Delicious vegan pizza! A local asked for vegan pizza, the owner listened, and the local even helped him design the pizzas since the owner is not vegan. Just loved that story. We spent the day hiking at Mt. Rainier and we're ready for a great meal. The first moment my web service turned on coming down from the mountain, I yelped were to eat and saw they have vegan pizza. It's a small, unassuming building. The owner was very friendly and we could tell he took pride in his pizza, using quality ingredients. We ordered 2 pizzas: BBQ vegan chicken with pineapple and vegan cheese, and the second was vegan beef crumbles with black olives, mushrooms, and vegan cheese. Our family of 5 loved them! The BBQ was my favorite. If this place didn't serve vegan pizza, I don't know what we would have ended up eating. So thankful for this place! read more

Way better than PaPa Murphy's or Pizza Hut. You can actually taste all the flavorful ingredients cause each bite is not drowned in sauce or cheese. Cost us a little more but way worth it!! Very filling as well... So count on some left over great cold pizza later. read more

This is thee BEST pizza I have probably ever had in my life. I have never had a pizza where everything about it is up to par and on the same level of excellence!! The pizza sauce is one of a kind, as well as their crust. Our favorite is the Canadian Bacon Pineapple pizzas.. the pineapples are HUGE!! Definitely a summer favorite and our first choice when we want pizza!! So happy they are here! read more

It takes a lot for me to write a negative review but this place has earned one. Today was the third time we've been here, we keep thinking it'll be better next time but this will be our last time. Pizza is good but honestly, it's hard to mess up pizza. It's the customer service that's awful. This place is run by kids who have no idea how to successfully operate a restaurant. There is never any customers inside and for good reason, the service is terribly slow and good luck if you want more than one drink. The servers do the whole, I don't need to write down your order thing and this time forgot a whole pizza. They spend most of their time in the back doing who knows what but it was so bad I went behind the counter and got my own beer. They will not wait on you after taking your order and offered no apology for the missing pizza, no drink refills, going MIA for 20 mins or any of the other mistakes. We were one of two tables inside and this place was falling apart with the minimal amount of customers. We have been looking for a local pizza joint and thought we found it but sadly, won't be back. I hope the owner is aware of this and comments back but I doubt it. read more

Dude...... they serve vegan pizza that rocks!!!!!! Super reasonable price

Ample, thick cut, fresh quality toppings and their sizes are larger than average. The prices are higher though its justified. Always friendly staff as well. Oh I do wish they offered delivery however. read more

Talk about good pizza! Staff is friendly and the whole experience was great. Called in an order, it was ready when we got there & the pizza was great!!!!!!! Will be back!!! read more

I love this place! I have never been to a pizza place where you can choose to have them cook it for you, or take it as a take-and-bake. The pricing is reasonable, and the pizza is great. I like that the pizzas are HUGE, and the ingredients are fresh. I wish they had an area where you could eat inside, but it is just a take-out only business. read more

I love this place. The pizza is great I love a nice thick crust and lots of toppings, that is what I get. I've never been disappointed.

We have enjoyed both the hot and take-n-bake pizza. Both provide a good dinner or lunch with ample size slices. One slice is a full meal! We like their approach to the vegetarian, their vegan version is pretty good too. In the summer its nice to enjoy the pizza in their outdoor eating area. We also order a couple of take-n-bake pies when Saturday is going to be hectic. Its nice to throw one in for dinner. The ingredients taste fresh, especially the tomatoes and onions. A nice thick pizza pie every time! read more

This is one of the best pizza places I've ever been to, and I'm a very picky pizza eater. I LOVE it here.

The business is small, but clean and well kept from what I could see. I have heard good reviews around town about the pizza and mixed reviews about the staff, but decided to give it a try. After looking through the menu the owner approached me and asked what I would like. I asked him what the price would be to build my own 2 topping pizza. He said he didn't know, but pointed out what I wanted was somewhat similar to his Meat Lovers pizza. He exclaimed the price for that was $19.99. Being that I live alone and would ultimately eat 2 or 3 slices and throw the rest out I couldn't really justify the cost in my mind, so I decided to eat somewhere else. I apologized and started heading for the door. As I was walking away the owner asked if I had ever had his pizza. I told him I had not. While the door was closing behind me he said "well that's obvious." I now completely understand the mixed reviews about the staff. Leadership starts from the top. It's unfortunate that he was compelled to take that parting shot. I would have loved to try the pizza when I had family over. read more

Bertoglio's Pizza is very good pizza. The staff are friendly and the prices are good. Big pizzas for the price!