The pizza has everything anyone could want in the sauce, toppings and the cheese. Once cooked not greasy as other places are. The flavor and the thickness of the crust is excellent. But...the crust needs to be crisper, in my opinion. Had an issue with the buffalo wings being undercooked in the past, so, I have yet to retry them. read more

This place isn't what it used to be. I will not be ordering any more pizza from them. I've wasted the last three orders just flushing money down the drain. read more

See all

Never going back again, wth is this ? Especially top dollar for a local place? Literally any frozen pizza and wings is better read more

Varsity Pizza and Wings - Bro wth is this ? Cold ass, Pizza Hut pizza ? And some burnt dry wings - Pizza Near Me - Roy, Washington

See all

Honestly the best pizza spot in the yelm area I think it's pretty good spot to go to. Little on the pricy side but worth it over what's around read more

Good wings, pizza and beer!! Great very local place to try! Looks very supportive of local schools and teams which I LOVE!!

Friendly staff, military discount, quick service!!! A cute local spot and the only place we could find some good and tasty wings in this area :) read more

See all

We've been here several times and always have great service and great food. If we lived closer we'd come back more often! The staff was friendly and helpful with my questions. We ordered pizza for a get together and everyone loved it (Garlic Chicken pizza is my favorite and got rave reviews). Thank you Varsity for consistently great food and service! read more

I just moved to the area and was excited to find a pizza place nearby with gluten free options. Not only do they have the option, but it doesn't appear that they charge extra for it like most places do. They were friendly and quick and the pizza was delicious. Will definitely be my go-to pizza place. read more

Very disappointed. We drove all the way out for dinner on a Thursday night from Orting, after work. This is a place we have wanted to try for years. It took us about 45 minutes with the road construction to get there. Pulled into the parking lot at 7:40, ready to relax and unwind. We had no idea they closed at 8pm! My husband opened the door to walk inside the restaurant and we were told from the counter that they would only serve us take-out, as they were closing. No greeting of hello or anything. Back in the car we went, through construction, hungry and upset. Decided Farellis pizza would be a much better option. read more

I ordered a meat pizza and it was so not worth the $26. It was super dry, was super crusty on seeds in the dough and the toppings kept falling off. Not to mention the meats were really greasy, like greasier than usual. Don't order from varsity. They suck. The only thing they get right is the drinks only because someone else made them. Overpriced and disgusting. Even frozen pizza like digiorno would be a better pick for Friday night. They should just be glad that I am not able to rate it 0 stars, because that's what it truly deserves. read more

The food is very good, but unfortunately the cost is also very high. We rarely get it because of how much it costs.

One of my family's go to pizza place here in Roy, WA. They have their original off Mountain Hwy, and in both places, the pizza has always been a hit. This time I ordered a half&half pizza with BBQ chicken/Varisty together! A great addition was the Varisty sticks which as by far our favorite pizza dessert! Fluffy sticks of dough, covered in cinnamon sugar, served with a warm side of creamy cream cheese frosting as a dip! Try this place out too if you love pizza! read more

See all

Omg why is this place not up north where I live , the best pizza we came down to McKenna to buy a truck , cheaper taxes the dealer told us about this spot and he was not wrong the crust was perfect and the sauce full of flavor so good , definitely gonna visit every time we come south read more

Normally we enjoy their food as middle of the pack pizza and good grinders. I will revise my review to 4 stars if a manager addresses it. Made an order online tonight. Arrived at scheduled time. They had clearly not yet started the order. I was told it would be a few minutes. No apology at all. I'm not a total jerk, I understand places get busy, but if your "few minutes" is actually over 20 minutes I expect, at a minimum -a mumbled sorry. More appropriate would have been a more accurate estimate of time for the order and an offer of a free soda or cookie for the wait. read more

With delivery pizza we all know what to expect... a fair pizza. It's not the best but it's not the worst either. For the price during happy hour you cannot find a better deal. My husband loves pizza and it was our first time trying so we ordered a few $5 8in. Pizzas: basic cheese- well cooked and good amount of sauce/cheese, Taco Pizza- great toppings (the favorite!), Hawaiian Pizza- fine and chicken bacon ranch- fine. I also ordered the $5 garden salad which was simple but came with ample dressing of my choice (the ranch tasted fine). Based on quality and regular pricing I would not order this pizza. Based on quality and happy hour pricing I would suggest this pizza to anyone! I also appreciate that they deliver because many places (including Dominos) do not deliver to my home. read more

I have been stopping in at the McKenna varsity, at least 3 times a week, and getting a italian grinder for the lunch special, I always get onions , jalapinos, black olives on it for 10.01 including drink. Today the gal in there tried to charge me 11.50 plus tax, when i questioned her about it she said it was the price, and i didnt have to get the extras, Shes right i dont have to get anything in there, or cross there door step, not the first time ive had problems there, but it will be my last read more

I've given this pizza place multiple tries. Their food is disgusting, super greasy and at times inedible. They also frequently get the order wrong or forget things. To top it off they're over priced. I would not recommend eating here ever. read more

Varsity Pizza and Wings - Meatball appetizer - Pizza Near Me - Roy, Washington

Expensive but always great speedy service & good pizza! We usually do carry out. McKenna & Eatonville locations has plenty of room for dining in. Had a school field trip at McKenna location for a bunch of elementary students and they handled it like pros! read more

I was driving through Roy and seen a sign that said New York style pizza. I decided I had to try it, the employees were very kind! Once I got home and tried the pizza I knew this would be my new favorite pizza spot whenever I am in the area next time. The ingredients tasted fresh and the cheese and flavor was delicious! I would highly recommend! read more

I'm sorry to give them a low rating because my first visits were initially pretty good a year or two ago, but the last two pizzas I've ordered to go from the McKenna location were both over-baked and the cheese was leathery and unpleasant. A pizza like this should never go out to a customer. The second time it happened, I had a couple of pieces simply b/c it was at least fresh, but threw away the rest of a large pizza. I should have called to complain, but of course I didn't, but they do need to know. Do not box up a crappy pizza and send it out. It is NOT OK. read more

Best Pizza I have had in a looong time! Second time at this location. Last Summer in July we brought our adult kids and grandchild. We ordered two pizzas for dine in. Honestly, we would not have even known, but they said they made one of our two pizzas wrong, gave it to us along with the two we ordered. Who doesn't want three pizza's for the price of two? Aside from that it was a great to sit and enjoy our pizza fresh and hot in their casual dinning area on wooden tables. We had plenty for at least one more meal which was certainly an added bonus with three people visiting our home. My second more recent visit was spontaneous take out. We had just picked up our repaired car from Caliber who shares the parking lot and needed to make a quick stop at Walmart. So I called in our order of a large pepperoni pizza which was $22.00. Some times its best to keep it simple. Did our shopping at Walmart quickly returning to pick up our pizza which was indeed ready. Took it home reheated it to get it crisped back up after sitting in the box for 30 ish minutes. Even under those circumstances this pizza had so much flavor, nice thin crust, YUM! We visited around 4:30 on Tuesday 4/19/22. read more

I am in love with this place! Delivery times are a little high, but they're the best pizza/wings place in town! Just make sure to call earlier than you want your food. read more

Varsity Pizza and Wings - Cranberry Heat wings w/ extra sauce - Pizza Near Me - Roy, Washington

Greasy pizza and rude management. I'll spend my green down the road at the completion, thanks...

I wish I could leave no stars. I called on the way home from a 14 hour day at work; have to be in bed at 8:30 to get up at 4am. Pizza is delivered in about an hour at 7:43. I told the girl on the phone THREE TIMES!! No mushrooms on the combination, that I'm allergic to them. They've screwed up twice in the past and added mushrooms anyway. I called in as my pizza was loaded full of mushrooms. The girl on the phone promises that she'll put a replacement in the oven and get it right over as soon as the driver comes back. The manager then has the audacity to call me back 15 minutes later and says "we checked the cameras; there were no mushrooms on your pizza" (?!). Basically called me a liar and said the driver went home already (store closed at 8, so they didn't want to deal with it). $47 plus tip for this treatment?! NEVER AGAIN. Go into Yelm to la Giatanna or Bertoglios. Varsity is overpriced for what you get anyway when they DONT screw your order up and accuse you of fraud. read more

Varsity Pizza and Wings - Stay Away - Pizza Near Me - Roy, Washington

McKenna location, After working 13 hour day on the weekend, we went there to get a quick meal that wasn't so quick, after an hour and a half wait, they realized we hadn't received our pizza yet, came to check on us and asked, you haven't got your pizza yet. Clearly no, so they brought us a salad, which we thought would be free compensation for waiting. When they finally brought our pizza out it was a small pizza and we had ordered a large, they then realize they had completely lost our our order. Really, how does that happen??? Needless to say we got a refund, left and will never go back. Owner blamed the system. Good customer service would have said come again and let us make it right. Nope they were to busy for us. Two hours for a pizza is to long!!!!! read more

Honestly their pizza is pretty good--we've had some issues with a topping being wrong in the 5+ times we've ordered. That aside, I had to stop coming here because the staff stopped wearing masks a few months ago and still don't. I can't support a business that doesn't follow safety standards of the time (height of Omicron in December) and I'm not really sure what their work comp would have to say about it either. Doesn't make me comfortable with eating the food. read more

I truly hate to rate a local small business with a poor score, but feedback is important. Service was great, so this rating is solely based on my preferences and personal opinion of their pizza. The Pizza had no taste, at all, and the dry crust overpowers the very thin layer of toppings. It was possibly the worst (non frozen pizza) I have ever had in my 50 year old life .Again, it's just my opinion (based on my tastes), I think everyone should at least try to see if it meets their expectations. It was the first visit and it will be the last one for sure. read more

Poor customer service would be a putting it nicely. Whoever was working yesterday when I arrived for lunch was in an argument with a customer. My favorite part was when the female employee stated loudly. WE DONT CARE ABOUT CUSTOMER service. Some people in my party got up and just left. I do believe there was a time this was moderately acceptable pizza for those desperate souls who have never tasted a real pie. Just drive past. read more

I spent many years developing franchise owners throughout the West Coast for various pizza chains so I understand many ins and outs of the business. However I've been looking for a place like this for a long time. The staff was great. The Restaurant was relaxing enough to just chill and catch a ball game. The Pizza was great but needs a little bit attention to detail The dough is hand tossed so your pizza appearance will be variable from one to the next. The execution has been spot on so far. A tip for you reviewers when getting a pizza is making sure they aren't using old dough. If you ever get a pizza with a doughy crust edge that looks transparent or doesn't seem to tear properly send it back!!! . This place again so far seems to be good about that. My only suggestion when it comes to making the pizza is it needs to be cooked about a minute longer when its heavily topped item like a combo. The ingredients look all to be fresh and tasted amazing. Seriously that truly makes a difference and this place has it 100% right. My only gripe- the manager or owner needs review sanitation. If you staff with one or two people who handle money/phone orders/ customer etc. and they cross train to make food they need to wash their hands or wear gloves when making the pizza's- wings etc. I'm a realest, but it has to be done. This wasn't being done on both of our visits . . Overall we loved it and will be back again and again. Would have rated 5 stars but the food handling thing...... read more

Varsity Pizza and Wings - Fresh ingredients, cut and boxed well. Taste was fantastic! - Pizza Near Me - Roy, Washington

Pizza is good, prices are pretty high, had a delivery and pizza was smashed as driver took a corner at 90! Called and asked for a different pizza with the smushed pizza untouched. All I was offered was me to drive there and get a refund and keep the smushed pizza.... *mckenna location* read more

This place sucks. Period. Frozen pizza from Walmart is waaaaaaaaaaay better quality. read more

Don't ask for delivery after 6pm. Had to call 3 times to get someone on the phone and once they finally took me off hold after 3 attempts I wanted to place an order for delivery. They replied, "it's a two hour wait." At which I replied, "That is fine." At which point they replied, "Well we can't deliver that late." ..........why would you inform your customers that it's a two hour wait and then immediately respond with that. Regardless, this is only one of many instances where there services have been rendered terrible. Good luck getting them to actually find your home. On one occasion they were so lost that they had to call us three times to find the correct address. 3 TIMES! -The pizza is so sub par that a simple Pizza Hut would have less grease, and would more than likely not look like some kid kicked it all the way to my door. -The wings are always cold, and let me state that we live a total of 3 miles from this location. - The worst offensive is their salads, dry and tasteless. I have never gone into this establishment due to the fact if I am going out there are far better places in Yelm to grab a nice dinner. I can safely say that this is the last time I will order from this sad pizza parlor located in my town. read more

I love varsity pizza it's on the higher price scale for pizza you could always get cheap pizza but if you want good pizza varsity pizza is the place awesome that you can get your growler full of cider or beer filled when you pick up your pizza we live in walking distance and I love varsity!!! read more

Varsity has good pizza but they are too expensive. The inside of the restaurant is fairly small. They do not deliver very far from the store. read more

Just walked in 50 mins before they close to buy a pizza for dinner. The lady cleaning made it clear that they're closing in less than an hour and there is a party of 10 coming in. We told them we only wanted to order pizza and again she made it clear that there is a party of 10 coming in. We turned around and walked out and as we were walking out she said, "We can fit you guys in." It was obvious that she didn't want a party of 10 and our family in there. We have a movie to catch at 8:20 so we would have been out of there before they closed, as long as they could have gotten our pizza made. Guess they didn't want our money. read more

This varsity has been going downhill for a few months now. We use to order every weekend up until recent. We gave them another try today and they couldnt get our order right again! We picked up as they couldn't deliver for some reason at the time... We ordered 2 pizzas one pan and one deep dish. We were given the excuse that the deep dish pan wasn't cleaned properly and had to wait another 30min. No big deal! Get the deep dish pizza and it is the smallest medium pizza we had ever seen. We won't be ordering from Varsity ever again. read more

Varsity Pizza and Wings - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Roy, Washington

Was treated poorly by a blonde employee on 6/18/2019. It was about an hour before closing time. She asked us if we were a party of 10 that called in and we said no, she repeatedly let my family know that they didn't have enough room, even though there were about 2 tables taken in the whole restaurant. She also let us know that it was almost time to close and they were short staffed. She made us feel very unwelcome and made us feel as if we were inconveniencing her coming in an hour before closing. We went to Pizza Hut and spent our money. Don't waste your time trying to eat here and I hope the owners know their employees are turning away business and don't seem to want to work. read more

Last few times we have ordered its been 30-45 minutes late past the time quoted. Good pizza but super disappointed in the level of customer service. We call and get put on hold. When asking where our order is, they say they cant find us or its minutes away when in fact we wait another 30+ minutes. 3 pizzas for 60+ dollars, i would expect better. read more

Love their pizza! They even make personal pizzas. Just enough for 1 person. Everyone is very nice and service is great.

Excellent Pizza! And very friendly and helpful employees! This location is their 2nd location, so looks like the are expanding some,Very pleased with the quality of food here! read more

Varsity Pizza and Wings - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Roy, Washington

See all