I recently stopped by Big Tony's Pizza and ordered an extra-large build-your-own pizza with beef pepperoni, beef sausage, and mushrooms, an order of fries, and the Big Tony's Stromboli. This was my second time having the Stromboli, and I'm happy to report that it's still just as good as I remembered. One thing I really appreciate is that Big Tony's offers beef pepperoni and beef sausage for customers who don't eat pork. The pizza was loaded with toppings, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The Stromboli was fresh, hearty, and packed with flavor. The fries came out hot, crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and seasoned really well. The service was friendly, welcoming, and attentive throughout my visit. The atmosphere was relaxed, comfortable, and a great place to sit down and enjoy a meal with family or friends. Between the delicious food, excellent service, and inviting ambiance, Big Tony's Pizza continues to be a place I'll happily return to. read more

See all

The pizza place we were going to order from was closed, so we decided to give this place a try. The price for a 4 topping extra large pizza was very reasonable. We ordered the regular crust with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and black olives. The toppings were evenly distributed and I was happy to see they use fresh mushrooms instead of canned or brined. The slices were floppy and foldable like NY style. The hubs and I both really enjoyed their pizza and will definitely be ordering from them again. read more

Decided to try, wish I hadn't. Ordered pasta with meatballs. Pasta was decent, but "meatballs" consisted of maybe a half of a meatball that was chopped up into super small pieces. At $13, that wouldn't have been the worst had there not been a pound of cheese on top of it. Literally a pound. Nice staff, horrible food. read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - All cheese on top of a single portion of pasta. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I used dash delivery to get this delicious pizza! I ordered the gluten free pizza with mushrooms, pineapple and ham. All the ingredients were fresh as always and the crust was perfectly done. It comes in a 15" which is plenty for one or two people. Keep in mind if ordering gluten free they do have a disclaimer that it's made in a shared kitchen where gluten is present. I have never had issues during the 5 or so times I have ordered though. read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - Gluten free with mushrooms, pineapple and ham - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Working in town and I googled pizza and looks like I picked the right one. The guys were helpful. I went with the Philly cheese calzone and was glad I did! It was very tasty and chose the smaller portion and it was more than enough. They were moderately busy, but only took about 20 minutes to get my food. read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - Philly Steak and Cheese Calzone was awesome. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This was our first time ordering Big Tony's. We ordered garlic knots, pizza, salad, and eggplant. The kids devoured the garlic knots. The salad was typical and the house dressing was good. The cheese pizza was good- but we would just as easily order from any competitor. The let down of our dinner was the eggplant. The eggplant itself was perfectly breaded but the pasta sauce is not something I would eat again. We threw all of the pasta the eggplant sat on away. read more

Ordered pepperoni lovers 14" for 22.99 on app, if you like your thin crust delivered in a puddle of grease, this is your place. Honestly ate 1 piece and threw away, not a good pizza. read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I do really like big Tony's. I recommend a cheese pizza with extra sauce. I would not recommend the margherita pizza. My jaw got some WORK in. It was incredibly thin and chewy. You know how wild animals look when they rip meat off a bone? Practically the same effort to remove the bite of pizza off the slice. Also, I grabbed a 2 liter of soda it was around four dollars...phew! Edit: look at the quality from two years ago to the pictures today!! read more

See all

Ordered dinner through the website which put delivery through Slice. Delivery was a window of 40-55 minutes. It was delivered after an hour and 24 minutes. After repeated calls to the restaurant they admitted they had no visibility into slice and they had a different delivery window. Slice still missed that window. If you're going to go through a third party for delivery you should never not have control. After contacting the restaurant to challenge the delivery and tip, Raj (the manager) refused any effort to make the situation right. Since he refused to work with us, we refuse to order from Big Tony again. read more

I was really craving some pizza and my #1 choice was closed so I started looking for a new place to check out. Thanks to my friend for telling me about this place she grew up on so that I could try it. Picking up the pizza immediately got me excited as I loved how the brown On the cheese and crispiness of the pepperoni edges. Pepperoni - had a good amount of spice and flavor to it. Gave the pizza a nice zing. Cheese - was not my favorite. Flavor seemed a bit lacking didn't give me that pull part ooze when you bite in and pull the piece back. Even fresh the cheese clumped together and just slid off the pie. Sauce - I think this was my biggest dislike. The amount of spices in there seemed to overtake the flavor. I'm not a fan of a ton of oregano and I feel like that's all I could taste. It was bitter or sweet so the balance of tomato was nice. Knots - I was perplexed to see a variety of color on my knots. The "pale" ones were cooked to my taste. Served with the same tomato sauce that was on the pizza had me off put since again, I felt like the herbs took over. It may have been a mixture of the sauce and the herbs on the bread itself. There was no glisten on the bread so it was a lot drier than I would have liked but still had a decent flavor under the herbs (which were the most prominent). Overall, it fulfilled my craving and I will go back to give it another shot but not one I'll probably run back to. read more

See all

ordered on line, arrived at the restaurant to pickup only to be told they don't accept orders from their website (???). then waited for 25 minutes to have Pizza made. First and last time I ever order from this place..... read more

Stopped by this place today after reading some reviews about it. Chatted with the owner for a little bit. Been in this spot for around 5 years. He is super happy with the neighborhood and his customers. Ordered a medium pepperoni and cheese. Very nice thin crust. Nice and chewy. Sauce was delicious, little sweetness to it. Nice thin layer of cheese on the pie, melted perfectly. Pepperoni was slightly spicy. Super friendly place and great tasting pizza means return trip. read more

See all

First time trying them. Just took a chance on something new. Pizza not so good however the wings are great. meaty and tastie. read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

It was alright. Not bad just alright. We had the steak and cheese calzone. It was bland but looked like a million bucks for sure

First time trying and the pepperoni pizza gave myself and 3 friends food poisoning... not a good look.

This place was pretty good. It was first time ordering from here and I was pleasantly surprised. The variety of pizza was great. They even had an option for almonds on the pizza. read more

See all

I just ordered Big Tony's Pizza Pasta via the yelp delivery feature. Came about a half hour earlier than expected, which was great! I got a cheese pizza with bacon and some bbq wings. Very, very good! The pizza is slightly sweet, but I dig that. The wings were hot and somehow still crispy! So good! Tony- if you're reading this, you have great pizza, my dude! read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - Cheese & bacon One Medium One-Topping Pizza and 10 Boneless Wings - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We had been wanting to try Big Tony's for a while and decided to get takeout to support a local business. The pizza was great and very flavorful. I also liked that they had a sign in their window offering a free meal to anyone with no money. Quick friendly service and great food! read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - people with no money - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

First time trying Big Tony's and it was delicious. Smelled so good I ate a slice in the car. read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I got chicken Alfredo from here and there wasn't even any Alfredo sauce! It was just cheese and noodles with the most disgusting chicken I've ever tasted in my life. A huge waste of money read more

Great food and Tony is great guy, we will be back! Had the Philly calzone and it was delicious!

Ordered last night delicious as always. Tony's deluxe with extra cheese. Deluxe has pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, black olives, onion and green peppers. I left off ground beef. Will order again. Order was on time. Order an cannoli for treat: dessert fresh and not too sweet. Will order pizza again! read more

Big Tony's is my neighborhood pizza shop, but it is so much more. Everything, and I mean everything I have ever had-pizza, pasta, salads, sandwiches are absolutely delicious. The service is friendly, ethical, and fast. I have had to tell myself to not order Tony's because I need to watch my waist. Lol. read more

Pizza was average. New to area and wanted to try something local. I really wanted to like it, but probably won't order it again.

Big Tony sucks a big D. This calzone of sausage, ham and feta was 98% cheese. The least amount of meat possible. One microwavable pizza rolls has more meat than this large calzone. Zero effort in making this product - avoid if possible. read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - All cheese when this was a meat calzone... - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We moved up here 4 months ago from Florida. Prior to that, we lived in Austin Texas. Austin is such a foodie town and I must say his place is outstanding! We each got a sub and shared a small salad. The bread is crunchy and flavorful and the prices are perfect! Wished we found it sooner but is our new favorite local place for a great meal! Highly recommend! read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I felt it was only right to try Big Tony's multiple times before leaving an honest review. Big Tony's Pizza and Calzones are delicious, it is balanced with great flavor, cheese and toppings. Prices are good and I love to support local businesses. Definitely worth a try! read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

big tony's is by far my favorite pizza place! They have the best gluten free pizza & their regular is great as well. I definitely recommend big tony's!!! read more

For their prices, I thought I was going to be blown away...not sooo much! I ordered a calzone and a 6 piece order of wings and it was $20! The calzone was lightly stuffed with toppings to say the least and rather bland. The marinara that came on the side was the only saving grace. The wings were not any better when it came to the flavor department. That department must have shut down and went home, cause it was missing! I should have known something when on a Saturday night before an OSU game, maybe I just avoided the rush. read more

Let me start off by saying that the pizza was amazing. I blog about a pizza weekly, and this is in the top 5 in Columbus. Thin crust, just the right amount of grease, not too dough-y, great sauce to cheese ratio. I also ordered an Italian sub. Hard to mess it up. The loser here was the bread. Not good. read more

Yumm. Excellent pizza. We got mozzarella sticks, one large pepperoni and one large extra cheese. Delivery was on time and the food was delicious. read more

Not ever willing to go back here they delivered to our job and pizza was super sub par. Decided to give em another I would chance with my favorite toppings along with some wings. Blue cheese wasn't in bag for wings, I asked for the wings to be well done extra extra crispy and they were very soggy. Pizza wasn't even that hot and my order was late being made but with all that when I went in multiple times cause food wasn't ready I never saw one of the guys with mask or gloves basically 26 dollars down the drain. Will never return here. read more

3rd time here and finally trying the pizza. My 1st time I ordered the sub lunch special with an italian sub, chips and drink. The sub was excellent! The ingredients were all very good,and the bun set it apart from other subs. It's light but slightly crunchy on the outside. You have to try one! My 2nd visit, I took Tony's advice to try the philly sub. Same great bun and good ingredients as well. Today, I got a pepperoni pizza. Again, excellent! Tasty pepperonies, albiet kind of greasy. The crust was medium thick with the right chewy to crunchy ratio. My wife won't like the strong garlic flavor which will linger on me, but the taste was great! read more

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Our work crew was excited to try a new pizza place in the area, but I don't think we'll be back. The lunch special wooed us - a 12" pizza and soda for less than $8! The dining room is small. The staff is surly and intimidatingly efficient. The food was serviceable at best - it's better than chain pizza, but not as good as premium pizza that are readily available in the area. Given the amount of other restaurants in the area, I wouldn't recommend this spot. read more

Very greasy pizza. It does taste good, but the drippy grease is a little bit of a turn off.

There is many things I love about this place the pizza and subs are great! The Alfredo not much I do not recommend it but stick with the pizza and you will be pleased! read more

Okay listen, first of all the food here is amazing. I have yet to find something I don't like at this establishment. But the people that work there are amazing the customer service is out of this world. I always order delivery late at night and my neighbors have kids so I always ask if the driver can call when they're there so we don't get the dogs involved and kids woken up and EVERY OTHER PIZZA PLACE always kind of sighs and says ok whatever but not Tony's nope, they always say sure no problem and I can actually hear them tell the driver and they're always like yeah no problem! Like seriously. Best pizza place ever. Best service ever. I just love it all. read more

Placed order for specific time because I was 35 mins out. Get confirmation email that order is ready for pickup 25 mins before I requested. Needless to say the food was cold and not that great. Possible could have been better but one food goes cold it's hit or miss read more

I always have them deliver. Great food! Fast! Friendly drivers! I recommend the Italian sub!

Awesome service and food was fantastic! Love supporting this small business! Wonderful Italian food!