Gross. I have given this place several chances and it actually keeps getting worse. It would be difficult to discern specifically which is the worst: the actual food, bartenders, service in general or the decor. If you go, please do not expect great service because it just isnt going to happen. Its almost laughable. The food is average at best, and each time I've stopped, something on my plate has been cold. The first time it was the pasta in my mac and cheese. (cold and over cooked), The second, the fries during my leisurely lunch with a co-worker, the third, the gratin that accompanyed my steak, the last, the eggs on my benedict. Why do I keep going back? Its walking distance from my office and Im hoping that even a little bit of the magic of Margaux will pop through flavor wise. I understand that Im looking at a lower pricepoint, but it is still in no way cheap. If you're looking for a good $10-15 lunch, walk down a few blocks and visit Field to Fork and just about any other place for dinner. Its just not good and it makes me sad when I think of what it was vs. what it has become. read more

Black Pig was a restaurant featuring interesting, tasty, comfort food in atypical combinations. The ambiance was nice. The service was great. The price was very reasonable. I had the Korean BBG Egg Roll appetizer and the sword fish special of the day. Both were outstanding. read more

Was excited to try after reading the reviews. Love the feel of the building. The food I ordered was hit or miss. Ordered the lobster soup and had to send it back. It smelled and tasted spoiled also was so salty. Disappointing. The truffle mac and cheese was yummy! The service was slow and the gentleman that waited on me was just not engaging as though he hated his job. Did not feel welcome. I will probably not return. Would not recommend. read more

We had a very difficult time finding a place to eat in Sheboygan near the resort we were staying at. We called around and felt very fortunate to have found Black Pig. We had a party of 8 and they could accommodate a last minute reservation on a Tuesday evening. The interior was spacious and tables were spread out. We started with the white truffle fries which pleased everyone at the table. They had a wide variety of cocktails, beer and wine. I personally enjoyed the Babe's Lemonade and the Blood Orange Cosmo. In addition to the advertised kids menu, they made our youngest customer a butter noodles. For entrees I enjoyed the Thai tacos and others enjoyed the steak sandwich and pork sandwich. Service was good, we all enjoyed our food and collectively decided that we were all glad we ended up there. read more

I've eaten here several times, enough that I don't need to look at the menu. But I do. I keep hoping a praying for a change, something new and different. Usually the wait staff is incredibly kind and professional. Today someone different waited on me. His abrasive style didn't go over well. Late to the table. I never heard if there were specials but by that time I was fairly hangry. So I went with the meatloaf. It was excellent. The waiter should probably read into my tip a bit. read more

Booooo It is a sad day when a creative and talented chef has to dumb down the menu to thrive in the community. Staff was ubber young and not so skilled. Food was full of too much bread, boring sauce and way to many dry fries. The wine was good. I am sad. I am sad Sheboygan could not support the full abilities of the chef/owner. read more

Food was ok. I feel for the price the food should have been better. Staff was great and quick. Personal and talkative staff. Great whiskey and wine list. Food is avg and I expected better. Tomato rissoto was amazing but that's it. Steak and pasta dishes avg at best read more

Black Pig - Flank Steak with Tomato Rissoto - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

We came here for Valentine's Day. The food was perfection! The only thing that kept it from a 5 star was they were a half hour late to get us our reserved table. However, it was Valentine's Day, and they were gracious about it, told us to sit at the bar. (See opposite review for Enoteca Roma). We split mussels, pork orichette pasta, and truffle fries. My husband said they were the best fries he's ever had. The pasta was so succulent. I was spooning up the mussel sauce. The décor is really pretty, unpretentious, offbeat. Good beer selection. read more

First time in Sheboygan and wanted to take the family out for a solid meal. The Black Pig came through. The restaurant is quaint, unassuming but has a bartop and plenty of seating. Everything is very clean and the staff is friendly. Solid craft beer selection. Menu is seasonal and there are nightly specials. The Bacon!!! appetizer was delish and included three types of bacon: black pepper, sweet and Sriracha. All were great. Entrees were solid and kids enjoyed their meals. Every dish is homemade. I had the bacon wrapped meatloaf and my wife had a pork ragut. Again, both very tasty. Not an inexpensive dinner by Sheboygan standards. But worth the money. Finally, my kids are 8, 5 and 3 and felt that the restaurant was family friendly. read more

We were passing through Sheboygan en route to Kohler State Park and stopped in for some lunch. We kept our expectations modest, but were still truly disappointed by the meal. I won't post the picture of the sad $14 "compressed watermelon salad" I ordered. Does compressed mean you are served 5 small cubes of out-of-season soggy watermelon cubes, covered in a creamy dressing and a small tuft of greens on the other side of the plate? Guess so. I was actually super irritated by the presentation, and high price of the meal. We also ordered some fries for our son but they were cold and bland. My husband ordered a salmon salad - which was fine, but also overpriced. I'm always willing to believe that a restaurant is having an 'off day' but there is no excuse for a tiny, overpriced, and *presumptuous* salad in Sheboygan. Would not go back. read more

I only wish the menu was larger! Everything I've had here has been delicious. I have had to go out of my comfort zone with some of it, but it has been worth it! The steak sandwich is amazing! Also, the Cajun Mac and cheese is spectacular! Just enough heat to keep it interesting. read more

Popped in for a late lunch. They were closing at 2:00 pm to get ready for a private Christmas party, so I got the special. A fried Mac & Cheese patty covered with a mild cheese sauce and topped with a mound of bbq pulled pork. I know it sounds weird, but it was delicious. The crisp breading and the rich cheese sauce complimented the Mac & cheese. The pulled pork was tender with a sweet bbq sauce. It was the perfect size for me. Service was very good since the restaurant was basically empty. read more

Awesome Sunday Brunch. It's getting harder to find local places open Sunday... So that's nice. Plus they have an amazing booze selection. That's about it for the positives. Sadly. We figured we'd try a Friday night dinner to sample some of the cocktails. Not that I'm against a Sunday morning scotch, I just prefer it on an evening. At any rate, it was petty slow for a Friday. Took a while to see our waitress. Ordered drinks and an ap. Get drinks order dinner. Then we never see waitress again... Odd. Never got our ap. And other people brought us things. My mac had begun to "skin over" it was sitting so long. Cajun Mac was kinda of bland and lacked any shrimp. Wife loved the pork chop. Drinks are good but pretty weak. And quite expensive. Long story short, maybe skip Friday night. But don't miss Sunday brunch. Good bloodies! Bacon! We'll be back to try a weekend lunch. It could be partly the cities fault too. That part of Sheboygan is shockingly desolate on Friday night... And this coming from a guy that lives in Fredonia. read more

Food was just ok would check elsewhere in the area for similar food choices as I had some other food in the area that was awesome. The fresh catch on Friday was good but ask server for price before ordering as that was triple price of most menu items but tasty. read more

I visited the Black Pig about a week ago while i was in Sheboygan. I've been meaning to write a review. The service was okay. We came during lunch but were given the dinner menu and when we ordered something off the dinner menu we had to reorder. We also wanted mac but since they were out we had to reorder. It would have been nice if the waitress could of just told us right away what they were out of so that we didn't have to waste so much time reordering. It was very frustrating. When we finally got our food. I got a half of the spinach salad and chili fries. The dressing on the salad made the spinach very soggy. I also found the fries to be very salty. The cheese sauce on the fries was very good though. My boyfriend got the special and he liked the sandwich but he could not eat the coleslaw. It was pink. It was a mix between a mayo base and vinegar base dressing. I wished the chief would have just picked one and not mix the two. It tasted really gross. It was really soggy also and the fact that it was pink was really off putting. I would have given 3 stars for food but since we had to reorder so many times. For overall experience I gave this place 2 stars. I did not recommend this place to anyone while I was in Sheboygan. I wished this place lived up to its cool sounding menu. read more

How unbelievable is this place!!! Just an outstanding WOW! 100% chance you'll be wowed by the amazon food and unparalleled food! The chili is amazing by the way. read more

Black Pig - WOW! F-me! These pork egg roles are good! I thought these were super dry and burned, almost sent them back. OMG! Try them!! - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Outstanding food and drink. The bartender knew his trade. The service was fast correct.

Place is great. Came in from out of town. My kid ordered the Cajun corn chowder and I had to finish it. It was terrific. Almost could have been a meal on its own. My wife went with the max and cheese. She loved it. I had the burger and it was delightful. The Bloody Mary is an absolute must. Overall great place. read more

We were headed to the Blue Harbor Resort with the kids for a weekend get away when hunger hit and we needed lunch. We looked up our lunch options and Black Pig came up in the top 5 and we thought we would give it a try. We had a great experience. First, it has great seating so it is child friendly. They also have a children's menu. Mac and Cheese...what kid doesn't love that. We loved our meal. My husband and I both ordered different sandwiches. He ordered the pulled pork and I ordered the short rib. It wasn't a light lunch my any means but it was delicious. The sandwiches are great. The meat was tender, the toppings fresh, and the sauces homemade. It lived up to it's label of comfort food. In hindsight we could have split a sandwich and been satisfied. Not that I didn't eat the whole thing! read more

This place was still relatively new when I tried it, but the word of mouth and Yelp reviews were already fantastic and they did not disappoint. I loved the feel of this place. It was is just slightly more than casual, but you'll be fine in jeans. I got the White Truffle And Black Pepper Bacon Mac and Cheese and could eat it for the rest of my life. If you are a kid a heart like me, try this. But just a warning, it may ruin all other mac and cheese for you. Make sure to check out the walls for what they almost named the big black big statue and pick out your favorite name. read more

Amazing service. I was here with my family and we were harassed by a surrounding table, management handled the situation beautifully. The staff was so kind and made us feel like a part of their family highly recommend. I will definitely being returning for the AMAZING FOOD, DRINKS AND SERVICE read more

Have been back a few times since my initial review. The service has definitely improved. The service yesterday by Halley (I think?) was impeccable. I had my usual steak sandwich, it was good, but has never been as good as that first time! Husband had the New Yorker, which is essentially a rueben without the kraut. Would be really nice to have the option of adding the kraut. The star was the mac and cheese special. It was a parmesan cream sauce with crispy chicken pieces on top. Really yummy and a nice starter to our meal. We shared the small portion as an appetizer. We each also had a beer, and it was nice they served our beers in glasses from the respective breweries. read more

We went to black pig for brunch Sunday , I would said the atmosphere here is unique upscale , we started our day with Bloody Mary and mimosa so both are great! And for our meals we both ordered Rajun Cajun eggs Benedict and eggs our dish was tasty but eggs was over cooked so I have to took 1 star off! Overall the restaurant is very nice and pretty but food should be better than this! read more

See all

We were one of two seated tables in the restaurant and the service was still super slow. Took 12 minutes just to get drinks. Food was bland and undercooked. Menu sounds and looks good, food was terrible. Go to a supper club if you want a well cooked steak for a little less money. read more

Great Restaurant! Service was Great and helpful, knowledgeable, and enthusiastic! Menu was exciting and inspiring for a combination that was delicious! read more

Interesting, different, and tasty. The black pig in Sheboygan is one of my go-to spots for others visiting the area. The duck-fried fries are extremely tasty and the plates are quite tasty. I haven't encountered an order here that I didn't enjoy. Some played may be on he pricey side, but once you take a bite, it doesn't seem so bad. They have two TVs at the bar, so if you're just coming in for a drink (they even have a sazerac!) and some finger food, it's definitely worth the time. However, I'd recommend trying some dishes from the menu. read more

See all

The four of us had four different dishes for lunch: Pork Tacos, Korean BBQ Tacos, Braised Calamari, Hummus, and a special Denver Omelette. The Denver omelette and the Korean BBQ Tacos got the best reviews in our group. The Braised Calamari was passable. The hummus had an interesting seasoning added which was a nice departure. Our server was appropriate, but seemed nervous. I asked for a latte--they don't serve espresso. I asked for a coffee with some kind of non dairy creamer--they don't have that. Kind of odd that they would offer gluten free options and some vegan options, would serve "vegetable fries" meaning fries cooked in non animal fat, but not have some soy or almond milk. I can't see myself returning here. read more

If you want a million choices of whiskey, whisky, Scotch and bourbons this is the place. Located in a vintage building, the decor is warm and classic. The extensive booze list has something for everyone. They have several flights, that you can try a bit of everything at reasonable prices. The wine list is not nearly as large, but has some quality wines at affordable prices. Those flights are also as great way to try something different. And don't get me started on the beers. It takes a knowledgeable staff to answer my questions and make superb suggestions. Will come again when in the neighborhood. read more

What a wonderful experience! We had no idea of the high quality culinary delights and fine service we would find here. Highly recommend! Friendly staff and nice drink selections. read more

Wife and I went to the Black Pig for lunch. Atmosphere is 5, service is 4, food is 3. Cool decor with tin ceiling and pig-centric vibe. Service was attentive and functional. Taco construction made them hard to eat without a knife and fork. Chunks of iceberg falling out. Shredding the lettuce would help. Pork was good. Wife's burger had jalapeño cheese which was too hot for her to finish. Not for us. read more

Great atmosphere. Good service. Excellent burger with bacon truffle fries. Food was hot and prepared to order. A bit on the pricey side. I would like to go back for some of the other menu items with a little more cash in my pocket. read more

This was our "go to" place since we moved to Sheboygan. Unfortunately we went there tonight for my wife's birthday dinner, and after a 15 minute wait at the table for the waiter to take our order we discussed going somewhere else. Should have! I had the flat iron steak and my wife had the black cod with mushroom risotto. The steak was tough and the cod was soft and soggy. Told the waiter and he really didn't seem to care. Disappointed! read more

I knew what I was going for. I had looked over the menu online, saw truffle oil and bacon mac & cheese, and my expectations were set. I went with a co-worker, and to offset the indulgence, we got a salad to start. We split a large portion of the grilled broccoli salad. It was excellent. I like a place that knows how to put together a salad. Then came the entree. I can't remember if I got the small or large portion (I think I ordered the small), but in any case, it was a lot of food. A lot of delicious, everything I wanted it to be mac & cheese. We ate at the bar, so the infused liquors called to us and we got a couple of mojiotos of different flavors. Both were very good. The bartender was busy, so we didn't get constant service, nor did we need it. We were very happy with the food and drinks. I will definitely be returning. UPDATE: Went back with the husband. This is a five-star place. We ordered different foods. Everything was awesome. My husband got the duck, chili fries, and I got a different mac & cheese--wow. Everything was awesome. And my husband liked it that he left full. =) read more

This building is so nice! Great atmosphere here. However, the air conditioner was a little strong on March 29th when the temperature is in the 30s outside. As for food, my family has a few suggestions: the New Yorker, the big butt pork sandwich, and the chili fries were fantastic! However, the pineapple pork flatbread was less than great- the flatbread itself was like a big stale cracker. The coleslaw was bland, no zip. The wait staff was extremely awesome, very on top of things, friendly, and helpful! My step mom even got a free piece of cake for her birthday! We all are definitely coming back again, just trying different food :) read more

CAJUN MAC AND CHEESE. Truffle fries. BACON everywhere. Granted truffle and bacon are pretty much the best anytime, anyhow, anywhere, BUT the Black Pig still gets major kudos for understanding that and utilizing both to their fullest. We're not longer living in Sheboygan, but when we go back for a visit I know some mac'n'cheese is calling my name.... read more

We came here as a big group. I will start with the positive aspects. Service was good, quick and efficient. They gave us a nice table in the back that suited us well. Everyone was friendly. Now as far as the food, it left much to be desired. I'll start with the kids meal. We ordered the mini burger. Now I understand wanting them to be cooked decently, but these were literally burnt beyond burnt. Now they did fix them, and the second round was better. We also ordered the fried garlic chicken, which was mediocre at best. The Korean pork sandwich was the worst of all the items, which for a pork restaurant, we expected more. The sandwich was ice cold on a stale bun and had a sad rendition of slaw on it. It was really not good at all, and three of us ordered it, and all agreed that it was not worth writing home about. For the prices, this joint definitely leaves much to be desired. read more

As a vegetarian, I find it strange that they honor pigs on the wall with quotes about their intelligence, etc., while serving pigs up in every way possible. That said, I'm happy they offer so many quality vegetarian options, including a vegetable mac and cheese, vegetarian French fries (I hope they are truly fried in vegetable oil of some kind), a vegetarian panini, etc. Also, the atmosphere is warm and the service is friendly and efficient. read more

Thursday is taco night at the black Pig, most definitely the scrumptious item on the menu read more

I would not of guessed that such a gem of a restaurant would be located in a small town such as Sheboygan. The area is undergoing a real Renaissance.. The service and quality of food was comparable to new American/Gastropub type restaurants found in the Bay Area of California. The spinach salad, specialty bacon, and the Mac and cheese were off the hook delicious. read more

I travel....a lot. This is one of the best places I've ever eaten at!! Duck tacos, duck fries, Cajun Mac!! Just do it. You will thank me.