Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Blue Buffalo Pizzeria

    3.2 (6 reviews)
    Closed 12:00 pm - 9:00 PM
    Updated 1 week ago

    Blue Buffalo Pizzeria Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like Blue Buffalo Pizzeria

    Recommended Reviews - Blue Buffalo Pizzeria

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 months ago

    there was some weirdo working there that kicked my kids out of the bounce house. if it's up why can't they use it.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    BEST PIZZA IN ISLAND PARK, we love it and their sandwiches - absolute perfection!!!! Highly recommended!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Brock B.
    6
    88
    116

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    Ask the Community - Blue Buffalo Pizzeria

    Anglers Riverfront Restaurant - Trout

    Anglers Riverfront Restaurant

    4.7(42 reviews)
    0.5 mi

    Amazing restaurant including a beautiful outdoor seating area. Wonderful service! Everyone in our…read moreparty enjoyed their meal. There is also a happy hour featuring select cocktails, etc. Our whole group left very full, the portions are no joke! Highly recommend!

    Really nice ambiance, like an upscale cabin, overlooking the river where you can see people fly…read morefishing. The restaurant is on a gravel lane off the main road and is nice to walk around. They have outdoor dining where dogs are allowed as well as indoor dining with a bar. As of May 2026 when we went, the menu online was not the menu we received when we dined in, so I attached a photo but keep in mind it can change. The service here was great, it was out waitress Brooke's first night and she was wonderful. The manager and staff overall were fantastic and the food came out at a good pace, not too long or short a wait. For starters we ordered the grilled peach burrata salad, elk and bison chili, crispy brussel sprouts and chicken wings with huckleberry bbq sauce. Each of these were very tasty and we would eat them all again. I would argue the appetizers were better than the entrees. The wings were slightly under par compared to the other dishes, but that is just because they needed more huckleberry flavor (very light). For entrees we ordered the pan seared trout and the grilled ribeye. Both were massive portions, the trout came with wild rice and asparagus, the steak came with goat cheese mashed potatoes and brussel sprouts. The trout was served as two big filets (found a few small bones, but no big deal) and was cooked well, but one filet needed more seasoning and was a little fishy tasting. The rice was a bit boring and dry, but the asparagus were superb. The ribeye was cooked nicely and tasted even better with the chipotle lime butter it came with. The mashed potatoes were great and did taste of goat cheese and the brussel sprouts were delicious, very similar to the appetizer preparation. Similar to the trout, the portion of steak was large, but a good portion of it was gristle and fat (about 30-40%). Overall a nice meal with huge serving sizes. Had we known how big the entrees would be, we may have shared one or ordered less appetizers. Great service with a pleasant ambiance.

    Photos
    Anglers Riverfront Restaurant
    Anglers Riverfront Restaurant
    Anglers Riverfront Restaurant - Don't make me re peach myself cocktail

    See all

    Don't make me re peach myself cocktail

    Lakeside Lodge - Chicken club

    Lakeside Lodge

    3.8(91 reviews)
    5.0 mi
    $$

    Dylan was amazing! Every food item and drink was perfect. He was very pleasant. Service was nice…read moreand fast and he helped get us under patio when it started raining.

    There aren't a whole lot of dining options this far out in the boonies, so finding the Lakeside…read moreLodge, only 15 minutes away from our rental cabin, was a blessing. Their operating hours...not so much: by the time we realized we were hungry, we had to book it over there to grab a table before things started to wind down (their closing time was 8:00pm, which makes the Lakeside Lodge a lunch place, in my opinion). True to its name, the lodge has gorgeous views of the water, and a welcoming, rustic aesthetic. We didn't order anything fancy or particularly adventurous: a bison burger for myself, and some surf-and-turf sturf for me wurf (sorry, the Swedish Chef in me took over there for a moment!). Everything was good, if not particularly remarkable, but it certainly did the job. Expect hearty, homestyle cooking, not haute cuisine, and your expectations will surely be met to your satisfaction. Service was present, attentive and friendly, and if it weren't for that passive sense of anxiety that comes with being the last served table in a closing restaurant (not their fault; that's my own hang-up), I would have felt more at-ease. I wish we'd had more time to check out the restaurant and the resort, but I guess that'll have to wait for a return trip, sometime in the future.

    Photos
    Lakeside Lodge
    Lakeside Lodge - Bbq chicken wings

    Bbq chicken wings

    Lakeside Lodge - Sunset view over Island Park Reservoir

    See all

    Sunset view over Island Park Reservoir

    The Buffalo Bar - Huckleberry lemonade and side garden salad

    The Buffalo Bar

    4.1(1k reviews)
    24.5 mi
    $$

    A welcome late- dinner respite after a long delay leaving Yellowstone. We ate outside on the patio-…read morethere's plenty of indoor and outdoor seating, so even though it's crowded, it can accommodate a lot of people. The cinnamon pretzels are the best pretzels we've ever had- wow!! They're soft, coated in cinnamon sugar, and accompanied by the most delectable icing. I'd return just to get these for dessert. The buff bites were also excellent- I got the huckleberry BBQ sauce, it hit the spot, and definitely was enough for a meal. My husband got the country fried buffalo steak with mashed potatoes and also loved it. It's standard bar/grill food, something for everyone, but be sure to get the pretzels!

    Buffalo bar was pretty good. It's a bit removed from the main drag but I had the west-Mex Buffalo…read moreburger and my wife had an order of wings (naked) and sweet potato fries. The burger was GREAT! Beware the roasted jalapeño as it definitely has a good kick, but I took bites of mine along with the burger and it was great. The wife's wings for being naked and not sauced were well seasoned and a good size for the price, recommend a side of fries or SP fries for only $3. Service was quick, we sat in less than 5 minutes with no reservation. Atmosphere was exactly what you would expect for a bar with sports and video poker, overall 8.5/10 after a long day, they need to keep their menus updated when they remove seasonal beers for a 9/10 or rounded 5 stars.

    Photos
    The Buffalo Bar
    The Buffalo Bar - BBQ Chicken Salad

    BBQ Chicken Salad

    The Buffalo Bar - Chicken wings with. Garlic buffalo and huckleberry bbq sauce

    See all

    Chicken wings with. Garlic buffalo and huckleberry bbq sauce

    Madison Crossing Lounge - Elk Ossobuco. Fall off the bone. Be sure get the marrow from the bone and put it on the elk. Paired wine went well with it. 5/5.

    Madison Crossing Lounge

    4.1(773 reviews)
    24.6 mi
    $$

    Excellent food and service! We came here for our "nice" dinner during our Yellowstone trip. Their…read moremenu looked very inviting! They don't take reservations and their is a long wait for dinner (great place, busy place!). I woukd suggest getting on the waitlist and then go shopping. They have an excellent waitlist system that you can see where you are and how long you have waited. Our wait was about 90 minutes as we were told. We came back when we were close to.the top. They share the building with other businesses and a nice lobby area to wait in. For cocktails, both husband and son ordered Old Fashions 1910! Made perfectly! They really enjoyed their drinks! I ordered the Flat Iron Steak and a House Salad. The steak.came with a chimichurri sauce, asparagus, and potatoes au-gratin. The steak was a pergect size, 8 oz. The star was the potatoes au-gratin! My husband ordered the Bison Meatloaf. Something you can't get just anywhere. Came with asparagus abashed potatoes. Generous size and he ate every bite! Excellent choice! My son ordered the Chicken Prosciutto Pasta. Perfect portion! Prosciutto was fried up crispy! He enjoyed his selection. We were too full dessert but could not pass on their Blueberry Bread Pudding. We took it to go along with Huckleberry ice cream and enjoyed the next day! Our server was Haeley and she was excellent. Although we had a carafe of water on our table, ahe made sure to refill.our waters. She checked on us often. In addition, the woman. Working reception was amazing. Juggling all the people on the waitlist. So many cing in.and hearing the long wait. She was patient and very friendly.

    This was the best meal we had on our entire west trip. The elk rack was amazing, I can't remember a…read moresteak that good in years. My Fiance got the trout but subbed mashed potatoes for the rice, and blew her away also. For dessert, the blueberry bread pudding with huckleberry ice cream is an amazing combo. We tried to go here 2 days in a row around 8:30pm, they close at 9. One night was too busy so we went elsewhere but we got lucky the 2nd night and found seats at the bar. The bartender was super nice and helpful with picking out the best stuff. Our drinks were also great. Huge selection of whiskeys and looks like every liquor. The building the place is in is pretty cool too, check out the brewery that's nearby. And also pickup bear spray for rent near the front door.

    Photos
    Madison Crossing Lounge - Inside bar area

    Inside bar area

    Madison Crossing Lounge - Trout cakes. Excellent. Lots of Trout and less filler. Lots of flavor. Not greasy or oily either. 5/5.

    Trout cakes. Excellent. Lots of Trout and less filler. Lots of flavor. Not greasy or oily either. 5/5.

    Madison Crossing Lounge - Bison burger

    See all

    Bison burger

    Blue Buffalo Pizzeria - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...