My husband and I had reservations at Blue Fish Grill on May 5 for our 23rd wedding anniversary. We were seated within 10 minutes of our reservation time. We ordered our meal and when my meal came out it was cold. I advised the waiter of this, and he stated he would go and heat it up. He returned to our table within 10 minutes and the meal was still cold. We had been there about an hour and not once were we asked if we would like our beverages refilled. We asked for the check and advised by the waiter that he would give us a really good deal on my meal. I advised him that I would not pay for the meal since I did not eat it. We paid the bill at the front register and we were trying to advise the woman of our experience and she brushed off anything we had to say, so we paid the bill(minus my meal) and left. It was a very disappointing meal and service that we received. read more

I still absolutely love this place. They have a new location and I love it so much more than the other place, why? Well I hated that other parking lot and this one is so much easier to get in and out of. I know that sounds like an absurd comment but really it is so much better! The inside is really clean and nice, I love the lamp jars, I notice the little details. It doesn't seem to have any more seating than it used to. It is more open and looks much nicer. I did not see any outside seating, but this also could be due to the new location and it not being super warm yet. There is a bigger waiting area in the front. Food is just as good as ever. The menu changed a little bit. I was nervous when I didn't see the Calamari Po-Boy on there because I also turn that into tacos. If you love calamari then I would definitely suggest that. NOT the one with avocado, the one with coleslaw and tartar sauce. It's heavenly. The french fries are still amazing and I love getting extra seasoning for it. The owner is super nice and friendly, always remembers my boyfriend and the waitress even remembered us. Great people and great food. read more

Blue Fish Grill - the new sign at BFG! - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

This place is a solid seafood restaurant. I got the Mahi Mahi with the mole sauce and it's one of the better seafood dishes I've had in a while. It's a bit pricy but I'd say the food is worth it read more

Great Tokyo Tacos! Been going here for years and is one of my favorite places. The acoustics aren't t the greatest, too loud when restaurant is full. read more

Great on every aspect. We are healthy foodies; the menu is full of delicious healthy food options.

Amazing little fish shack I wish I lived closer to! Delicious, very fresh fish at amazing prices. A mix of classic "fish shack" fare, like fried clams, and Innovative seafood fusions (the Tokyo tacos, with seared Ahi tuna were to die for). For the summer I would suggest you wait for an outside table. We didn't, and the inside is not air conditioned, or properly vented. Still, that is pretty much the only flaw. We split an order of Tokyo tacos and fried clam strips for our apps. I had the swordfish special and my fiance had the Calamari Po-Boy. Everything was cooked to perfection. The seared Ahi in the tacos was so amazingly fresh, I couldn't believe I was in Flemington. They had sold out of the Mahi-Mahi and the other fish special by the time we got there, and it was only 7:30 or so on a Saturday, so be warned. The place was pretty packed, but our server, Courtney, was amazing. Despite the fact that she was managing two large parties, we never felt either neglected or rushed. She fully explained all the menu options, answered our questions, and chit chatted about the food and her favorites. BYOB helps keep the cost down, on food that is already amazingly cheap--especially for the quality. Be warned though, expect to be given disposable plastic cups for your wine! read more

Blue Fish Grill - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Really good food, great music, and a good location. We had to wait an hour for a table but we walked around and it was worth the wait. The key lime pie was amazing read more

Had takeout last night. Was delicious. I ordered two meals as was pet sitting in town for my son. The hostess was lovely, friendly and inviting. Even with the storm that blew through, me and the dog had a lovely evening. Thank you. Needed a reprieve from Mother Nature last night! Your food hit the spot. y evening read more

We love this place!! The food is delicious and the service is great. We organized a party of 30 not too long ago and the staff was amazingly well prepared. The kitchen was able to get all 30 dishes out basically all at once, and our waitress was wonderful. The manager did a great job organizing the event. My favorite dish here is the Latin Mahi Bowl, but the specials are always good too. read more

Blue Fish Grill - Latin Mahi bowl after I ate a few bites :) - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Love BFG! The Tokyo tacos, fries, ahi tuna nachos, and specials are always great. We like to sit outside in nice weather & love that it is BYOB. The servers are always very nice and accommodating too. One of my favorite places in Flemington! read more

Nice, quaint restaurant with indoor and outdoor seating available. Food and service were good. Highlight for our group of 10, was the calamari, soup, salads, chicken, burger and home made sauces (blue cheese/pickle and ranch dressing). Accessible parking. Restaurant located right off a main street. read more

See all

Always a great meal we love the tuna nachos! Definitely a great spot in town to grab something to eat.

Just moved to town and I love this place! Curbside pick up is super simple and ordering online now has made it so much easier. My husband has a severe peanut and tree nut allergy, so they even have a section where you can add a note for each item ordered, which is super helpful for that. Food is tasty and menu has a lot of options. Looking forward to ordering again! read more

Went to Blue Fish Grill for lunch. I've been there a number of times...both at their original location and the "new" one. The original BFG was a favorite. It was very casual and served really nice seafood at a very reasonable price. After the relocation / expansion there has been far greater variability to both food quality and service. On this visit, I found the menu changed again and all the mains are now served ala carte with all side dishes as options. Clearly designed as a move to increase revenue, I was a bit disappointed to see this most recent change. However, I ordered the shrimp tacos and they were quite good. I noticed that the tacos themselves now come 3 to an order vs. 2 on the prior menu...although they are a bit smaller...so net net...no change. Service was ok. The waiter was on the informal side...so that style comes down to personal preference. On food alone I would rate BFG a 4...but service and historical inconsistency merits a 3...I'll re-evaluate my rating on my next visit. read more

Blue Fish Grill - Shrimp tacos - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

We stopped in here for a quick lunch today, before heading out for a few wine tastings. Sat outside, kept it simple, we each ordered tacos. (1) Tokyo Taco - ahi tuna, and baja - beer battered mahi-mahi. Was the perfect size for a light lunch, no alcohol, unless you want to purchase a bottle of wine from one of the local NJ vineyards. Our tacos were excellent. Weather was perfect for a day outside, side note that i will add is that depending on which way the wind is blowing, we did get wafts of garbage. we were at the end of the dining area and this could be the only place that happens. Didn't linger but we did experience a few times. Server was very knowledgeable of the menu and specials and was very courteous. My only complaint was that water was not brought or offered, and once my seltzer was finished, he didn't ask to refill or check on our status of beverages. Not a big deal, had a bottle of water in my handbag. Would def come back for lunch or dinner, its a great spot. read more

Blue Fish Grill - Tokyo Taco - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all

The food is always fresh and amazing! We have gotten many things on the menu and everything has been incredible.

The food is great, but disposable plates/silverware/cups ... seriously ?! We had heard about this place for quite a while, with many friends suggesting we try it. We finally did. Blue Fish is definitely a no-frills casual experience. We went on a Friday evening for dinner and it was busy. Lots of people, ranging from families to older couples, filled both the restaurant and the outdoor seating areas. We had a bit of a wait, but after agreeing to take one of the tall 'two-top' bar room style tables it didn't take long to get seated. I had the pulled pork sandwich, which was good albeit a little dry. It came with french fries (spiced; excellent!) and coleslaw (good). I also had a blackbean soup as an appetizer. The service was prompt, though not especially so or especially professional or attentive. The wait staff was primarily composed of high school and slightly older young people. My only complaint was the manner in which everything was served. I received my sandwich in a plastic basket and paper tray (which was fine) but my soup and coleslaw came in disposable styrofoam bowls! Our drinks were also served in disposable cups and my wife's meal (tuna steak) was served on a disposable plate! I find this completely unacceptable, from the perspective of 'green' to appearance to enjoyment of my meal. Everything about the concept is not justifiable in my opinion. For this reason alone, though I liked the food, I would think twice about eating here again... read more

Blue Fish Grill - pulled pork sandwich, spiced fries and coleslaw. - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all

Food was excellent and service was great. Indoor seating was a little loud but overall a great atmosphere. Will be back.

Karim strikes again! Our favorite waiter, with flair, energy, and a welcoming engagement to his customers, delivered another Blue Fish Grill delight last night. It was a perfect evening for outdoor dining and the hosts made sure our reservation saw us sitting at a prime outdoor table. The restaurant's Ahi Tuna Tacos started off the savory fare, followed by each us selecting from between the two special entrees. We keep forgetting how much we love this place when we dine here: perhaps it's the subconscious ensuring that every experience is special. Never the less, it's a treat to share how well the Blue Fish Grill and its staff offer a delicious experience. read more

We happened upon this restaurant as a suggestion from a local and we were pleasantly surprised. What a great find! Small restaurant with nice amount of outdoor seating. We ate a nice Sunday lunch here. Our server was excellent and we followed his suggestions. One brisket sandwich with fries and the ahi tuna tacos. Both selections were great, just what we wanted. The fries were excellent too...however, the seasoning is a bit strange, salt, pepper and sugar. Can't wait to try another food option and maybe byob. read more

Love the food here! Fish tacos were amazing....my daughter loved the Caesar dressing on her kale salad so much she was literally licking the container it came it lol read more

We have had several lunches here. The food is very good and the service is prompt and fun. The reason for 4 stars and not 5 are the flies inside the restaurant that were annoying when we had lunch there this past summer. It was the only time it happened, but one that's difficult to forget. On the plus side, it they have clam chowder on the menu, get several quarts to take home. A true winner! read more

Never had a bad meal here! Love all the options and super friendly and warm staff ! Ambiance wise , no clustered seating and when the weather is nice , the outdoor patio is refreshing ! read more

A fantastic dining experience. It's all outdoor seating right now so bring your coat. But don't worry, the fabulous food will grab your attention. A fusion extravaganza where each mouthful is an explosion of flavors. And the service is exceptional. It was apparent that many of the diners were regulars as the waitstaff not only knew them but also their favorite foods. We'll be back again!! read more

Blue Fish Grill was our go-to takeout place during the pandemic. They do a really nice job packaging takeout food so that it's still good once you get it home and I really appreciate that they take that extra care. The salmon with soy ginger sauce and rice salad is my go-to favorite, but do not sleep on the specials here! I still dream about the barbacoa over cheesy grits I had there once read more

Food was delicious and came out fast! Really recommend asking the servers what they like to eat/ what the chefs favorite dishes are. Will be coming back next time we are in the area. read more

Wow how things have changed. Frozen burger patty $14.50 ice tea $1.50 with tip $20. No thanks, won't be back. read more

See all

Just a true gem. Highly recommend their Spicy Tuna Nachos and Tokyo Tacos which are out of this world! Never had a bad meal here. Cheers!

I love it here, every time we come I like the food more. The ahi tuna nachos are always perfect, we tried the shrimp ceviche today and it was good. I had the ahi tuna bowl for the 1st time and I really liked it. read more

Blue Fish Grill - Ahi Tuna Bowl - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

We love this place. It was one of the first spots my wife and I went on a date when we moved to Flemington and we still come back several times a year after we moved away. The food is seasonal, well made and consistently delicious. What keeps us coming back is the excellent service we get from the team who works at this place. If you're in flemington and hungry, eat here read more

Years after my bad experience I wanted to give them another try. I made reservations online, which really weren't needed for a Sunday afternoon. Our waiter was really nice and efficient. I really like how they have their lunch menu set up, in regards to the section with picking a grilled item, a side, and a sauce. I think its great they let you order from the brunch or lunch menu on the weekend. I was surprised at the starkness of the inside, there were only 4 tables when I was there and it was loud. It could use some decorations. However my fish was flavorful and fresh. I think this is a great spot to add to my revolving restaurant list. I am definitely glad I came back. read more

Not ashamed to say i come here about once a week. The food is amazing no matter what you order and for the prices you really cant beat it. My go to is the tokyo tacos, the ahi tuna always comes out perfectly. Also, the nachos, whether its the pork or tuna, are incredible. I could literally order them as my meal. Highly recommend! They also always have specials which is awesome for the regulars who like to switch things up. On top of all the amazing food, the staff is great. Really professional, personable, friendly people who know the menu and can answer any questions on the spot. read more

Amazing food, friendly, fast service in a casual atmosphere. They do a great job with accommodating food allergies, are always adding new menu options, and prices are very reasonable for the portion sizes. BYOB is an added bonus. A true Flemington gem. read more

Stopped by Blue Fish Grill after visiting Old York Cellars as recommended by one of their employees & I am SO glad my roommate & I did. She ordered Fish & I ordered Steak & they were SO delicious. I dream of the food!! read more

Just had another great evening at BFG! My sister and BIL were visiting from out of state and we brought them here for dinner. Everything was fantastic and they loved it. Staff is friendly and efficient. Not rushed but we were also not left waiting. A perfect evening out! read more

Fantastic food. Peaceful atmosphere. BYOB! Try those outrageous nachos! Be back soon!

Always consistently excellent. Really appreciate the servers especially Kareem. A regular hometown 'go-to' with my fav grilled salmon with wasabi aioli and mashed potatoes. Sweet !! read more

Love love love this place!!! I've been here many times & I've never had a bad experience. EXCELLENT fresh & tasty food, great service, nice atmosphere & decently priced. Also it's either BYOB or you can buy a bottle from Old York Cellars! I get cravings for their tuna roll that is usually a special but they'll make it for you if you ask! read more

Blue Fish Grill - Tuna roll! Usually is a special but they will always make it if you ask!!! - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

My favorite go to restaurant as I only eat fish. Love anything mahi mahi with their wood smoked grill. Great portions, friendly staff, and great prices. read more

This is one of my favorite restaurants in town. Love the BFG!! The food is always delicious. Every SINGLE time, it's consistently excellent...never disappointed. It's BYOB, small cozy space, nice atmosphere, fresh ingredients. Service is great, we usually have Karim as our waiter (very knowledgeable about every dish and he's the absolute best!) see photos below of some dishes we had here. read more

See all