*under new management!* Stopped in for a Yelp event and will DEFINITELY come back for a 'regular' meal haha. The owner Rudy told us his whole story about how he opened a restaurant in February 2020 that closed 5 weeks later due to COVID, and what a financial and emotional hardship that was. Now, he is the new owner of Blue Taco in a "it's meant to be" kismet story that brought him full circle. Rudy's cocktails are super - he is trying to win Best Cocktail in Westchester this year. The signature drink "Mariachi" was made him habanero-infused tequila (Rudy does it himself!), passion fruit, lime juice and chia seeds. It is inspired by his grandmother, who passed from COVID. The drink definitely had a kick - usually when I order a spicy drink it's not spicy enough but this one was PERFECT. The passion fruit balanced it nicely. I also ordered the Avocado Lady. It was served in a beautiful coupe glass. You can have it with gin, tequila, or mezcal (I opted mezcal), with avocado, agave, and orange liquor. It was so refreshing and would go perfectly with a spicy meal. For our special YELP event, Rudy had tequilas and mezcals out for us to taste - this was super generous (and probably costly to him!) and fun. Since we were here for an event, it was trays of appetizer foods, buffet-style. We had 2 types of quesadillas (cheese only, and chicken), beef empanadas, chicken taquitos, tortilla chips, and jalapeno poppers. Everything was cooked SO well and was so delicious. Rudy informed us he has chefs in the kitchen (not cooks), one of which used to work at Tres Amigos in Mahopac. Rudy's inspiring story about his family and his vision for Blue Taco was so special to hear. I wish him and the staff the best of luck and will be back for sure to try some more of their entrees and cocktails. read more

See all

What a great Yelp Event!! The food was super good and service was spot on! My Birria tacos were to die for. The fish tacos were excellent... and the ceviche was, not as good as mine, but excellent! The Yelp Event food was good too.... And it was fun to be able serve ourselves.... (Pictures pre-event) read more

See all

Retuned here with family after attending a Yelp event here Food was Good Bartender was talented and likeable (He also is part owner) Food tasted fresh and we left satisfied. Quiet day it was when we were there. Will go back for more drinks and delicious food read more

See all

This place is in a cute little strip mall. Easy parking. The dining area is separate from the Bar area and spacious. Service was fast, attentive and super friendly. Parking was easy-breezy. This establishment is clean, well organized and the menu rocks. We had a great time a great meal and look forward to returning. read more

Blue Taco - Mural in the dining room is gorgeous - Tacos Near Me - Mahopac, New York

This place just gets better and better and tonight yelpers showed up in mass to show their love. A fun time was had by all stop by and enjoy the music, food and the people here it's magical. read more

See all

Our first visit here was great! The service was quick and so friendly! Loved the atmosphere! The food and drinks were wonderful, and the prices were so reasonable. The restaurant is very spacious and has a friendly crowd. We ordered nachos and an enchilada and a burrito. Everything was fresh and tasty! The rice and beans were delicious, and the churros with the fudge sauce were sooooo good! We plan to go back when we're in the area to try more dishes! read more

Blue Taco - Delish - Tacos Near Me - Mahopac, New York

After hearing great things about the Blue Taco, we finally decided it was worth a visit and they did not disappoint!! I had 3 tacos ( pork, chicken, and steak) Absolutely Delicious! So fresh, served with fresh cilantro and a radish garnish. I had a yummy white sangria which was a perfect pairing. The decor is simple yet charming displaying a few pieces of custom artwork. Our server was actually an owner named Freddy, who treated us like family from the second we walked in. My wife and I shared a delicious dessert and I finished with a perfect Mexican Coffee. Sorry Taco Dive Bar (Peekskill waterfront), there's a new taco contender in town! There is no shortage of great restaurants in that area of Rt.6, but if you are a taco lover, I do not think you will regret a visit into the Blue Taco!ENJOY! read more

Blue Taco - Tacos Near Me - Mahopac, New York

Stopped by on a Saturday afternoon. There was only one other table there- not busy. We ordered margaritas- pretty good. We got the chips and salsa, I loved the salsa, it was very tasty! The appetizer we got was the fiesta app, I think it came with calamari, elote, fries and wings. We were not crazy about the wings, they were not warm, the French fries were soggy and not cooked fully. The calamari was alright, and elote was ok. Nothing outrageous. For our entree we had to remind the server that we didn't order yet. We finally got our food and it was pretty good. Carne asada and Texans fajita. I will probably be back, but now I know not to order that sampler app! Not complaining but for a full summary of the lunch- The bill was about $90 for an app, two drinks and two entrées. read more

Blue Taco - Carne Asada - Tacos Near Me - Mahopac, New York

See all

order enchilada mole, and was freaking delicious, not too spicy able to enjoy the taste of the food. Bartender and waitress was really nice, my wife and I enjoyed it much, definitely be coming back! read more

Blue Taco - Beautiful mural in the restaurant. - Tacos Near Me - Mahopac, New York

Please do yourself a favor and have dinner at the Blue Taco. The food is delicious. The wait staff are friendly, helpful and knowledgeable. Our waiter made some wonderful suggestions since it was our first time there but it was not our last time that's for sure. read more

I have been to this place twice so far and both times I enjoyed it. It looks small from the outside but don't let it fool you as it is very big inside and is divided by a glass/wood wall that separates the bar area from the dining area - the bar area has a few tables. It is very clean and spacious. I have enjoyed the food (burritos, steak tacos, combination plate), drinks (pina coladas) and desserts (tres leches, churros, flan). The food is very good albeit it once or twice it didn't come out as hot as I would have liked it but I ate it all the same. And once or twice we had to go to the bar to get drink refills as they didn't realize we needed refills at our table but it was ok. All in all I can't figure out why this place isn't packed more often but I will definitely be back! read more

The food came out quick and was delicious. Service with a smile, even though the owner had a late night at the restaurant. Very hospitable.

Absolutely delicious food and drinks! Has a great vibe too at the bar to hang out and music. Super welcoming and their Sangria is delicious! Can't wait to go back and check out the DJ! read more

Went to meet old high school friend and fellow gear head for drinks and dinner. Neither disappointed. Great mezcal. My buddy returned with his family a few days later. I'll be heading back as well. read more

First time coming based on a recommendation. Loved the appetizer. Burrito lacked the same luster in seasoning as appetizer. Margarita didn't hit well with me either but it was a classic next time I'll try something different. I highly recommend. Came in at 9pm on a Saturday and definitely will be back. read more

Blue Taco - Margarita- Classic - Tacos Near Me - Mahopac, New York

This place has great food. My supreme burrito and my wife's taco's were delicious. So great to have a go-to mexican place in Mahopac.

Strange vibe, karaoke On Fri night but very few people there. Only one other family dining and a weird quiet atmosphere in the dining area. Drinks were warm bordering on hot and had to ask for extra ice. Food was mediocre at best, chips were stale. Service was slow and inattentive. Disappointing read more

Came in for lunch. Brand new restaurant in Mahopac with very reasonable prices. The food was delicious. The Margarita was perfect. The calamari has a little kick in the seasoning. The shrimp tacos were perfectly cooked, seasoned, and just delicious. And the sevice is excellent- family owned and they take a lot of pride in their restaurant. Definitely warm and welcoming, making you feel like part of fhe family. Definitely plan to come back to try more on the menu! read more

See all

Came for the first time The Blue Tacos are great The appetizer was not Got the nacho platter mediocre Tacos great Ask for blue or you get beige President Beer awesome Steve read more

Birria Tacos are incredible. We had a party catered. Delicious flavors! Nice decor inside and friendly service.

Walked in after getting PT next door , got a real hunch to come in thank goodness I did because their food IS one if not THE best Spanish restaurants in MAHOPAC . They've been open only 6 months and this place deserves its recognition. I ordered something small , steak nachos & rice w beans and honestly it was slamming , really good quality . I wish them the best and wish you guys to come give them a try . read more

Blue Taco - Steak nachos & rice w beans . AMAZING 5 out of 5 , thanks to the waiter Fabio presentation and well cooked . I loved it !! - Tacos Near Me - Mahopac, New York

This was the Best Mexican food I have ever had . So fresh and homemade . Best tortilla soup ever ! Excellent staff and awesome ambience

I took my wife out to dinner and wanted to try this new restaurant. I'm all for supporting local business in my town . However my experience will not allow me to come back. My wife ordered the chimichangas , very bland and dissatisfied with the quality of the food. I ordered a chicken and steak fajita, aside from the food having no flavor they only gave me 2 fajita wraps , then of course I had to pay extra for more wraps. But the worst part was I didn't receive any condiments with my fajitas , no cheese, sour cream , or guacamole.. when I asked they charged me extra for it . Made no sense, that's like charging me for ketchup on a hot dog . This restaurant is far from authentic and not worth wasting your money read more

Honestly a great place to eat. The food was really good, the service was amazing, and ambiance was very comfortable and welcoming. read more

Amazing taco spot. We love the shrimp tacos and regular tacos. Even for take out the portions are very generous. Highly reccommend.

this place is very sub par. it wasn't completely terrible but i don't think it deserves 4 or 5 stars. i stopped by on a thursday after noon around 4-5pm. the place was completely empty. the cheese dip was definitely not homemade, tasted very fake, like from a grocery store jar. i ordered the sierra margarita, tasted terrible at first, then the bartender said he forgot to add the lime juice, tasted better after! the salsa was decent. didn't wanna order more food so just got some rice & beans. they were fine. didn't wanna give them 2 stars but don't deserve the 4 star medium in my opinion. staff was nice & relaxed since no people were there besides me. they also didn't give me any silverware, napkins, or water. read more

See all

We're hoping they were having a bad night because we really wanted to like this place. Unfortunately, we were sadly disappointed with the food last night (Wednesday). The steak was tough in the burrito and the fajitas, the beans were undercooked, the rice tasted off like a stale taste (is that even possible) and everything lacked flavor. Very bland. On a positive note, the young ladies who waited on us were very pleasant. They were the reason for the one star :( read more

Wow, what an incredible experience! The food is amazing and the drinks are incredible. We will def be coming back. We enjoyed a platter, tacos, and fajita. Def check it out. read more

Blue Taco - Sierra margarita is incredible! Made with cilantro, basil, mint. Yum! - Tacos Near Me - Mahopac, New York

See all

First time here to check out the tacos and was not disappointed. Good beer selection and the shrimp and the pulled beef tacos were great. More chips with salsa would be appreciated. I'll be back when in the area read more

Great service, yummy drinks & super fresh food... cannot recommend enough! Chorizo tacos and al pastor tacos were perfect...

Will never go back! Received horrible service for 2. Ordered our drinks (one of 2 tables) , got those and finished them, didn't see waitress again for an hour! A table of 4 came in after us, got their drinks, entrees and we were still waiting! I finally told waitress who didn't seem to care, we paid for our drinks and left. 1. NO apology 2. Could have at the very least, given us the drinks on the house! We gave you a chance, not like the place was packed! Worst service ever! read more

Hands down best birria tacos I've ever had. Empanadas we're also great. Nice staff and super clean inside

The Nachos supreme were amazing and the burrito was the best I've ever had. Music was great, safe was very polite, and it was very clean. If you like good Mexican food and good vibes i recommend coming here. 10 out of 10 read more

Went there today with my family. The food was delicious and fresh. We had the guacamole appetizer, corn appetizer. For lunch we all had tacos ( shrimp and beef were my favorite however we also had the chicken, al pastor pork, Burria and fish. All were fresh and delicious. Where are you hot sauce lovers you must ask for the housemaid hot sauce delicious. Both my husband and I had the Mojitos super fresh tasty good prices my son had their lemonade fresh and delicious. Overall good prices good atmosphere very nice very clean staff was very friendly and accommodating and we highly recommend. read more

Honestly the worst tacos ive ever had i wish them luck. I really hope they were just having a bad day

Great food! Great service! Great atmosphere. Couldn't ask for more. Highly recommend. Go check it out.

Service was terrible. I ended up walking out after 1hr and a half of waiting for food. The bar tender kept apologizing but produced no results, yet we kept seeing people behind us continue to get food. Drinks were decent. Service was atrocious. I will never come here again. read more

Food was very tasty , I had the Birria tacos and my girlfriend had the steak tacos they were very good we sat at the bar were we had amazing margaritas with Tajin rim and some chips and salsa while they were preparing the tacos .they bar tenders were very friendly and attentive , and always smiling we felt like home we will be back soon. read more

Amazing food! Excellent service and friendly environment. Rudy was very attentive, kind and friendly. I would definitely recommend.

We've been ordering Blue Taco for take out and have been really enjoying it. Birria tacos aren't easy to find, so we're happy to see them on the menu. Everything that we've ordered has been good and ready to pick up on time. It's been great having this option close to home read more