I've made a few bad decisions in life and eating at Bob's Clam Shack in Kittery Maine was one of them.
I'm from northern New Jersey and planned my family's trip to Boothbay Harbor, Maine on August 29, 2012 for a wedding via Kittery, Maine because I had watched Guy Fieri's Diner's Drive-ins and Dives segment on Bob's Clam Shack and wanted to stop there for lunch before heading to Boothbay. I guess I would consider this place under the category of "Dive", it was pretty bad as far as my family was concerned. My wife and I were looking forward to eating the fried whole belly clams which we've had before in Connecticut and other places in Bar Harbor, Maine. This is not the place to go for that. They weren't the least bit crispy or tasty and almost looked as though they were clam strips cause they were so small. My wife ordered the Whole Clam basket and I got the medium Whole Clam side order which was definitely the wrong choice at $27.95, while my daughter ordered the Calamari basket. Nothing was crispy or crunchy at all. Sorry, there was one thing that was crunchy, it was the Oyster crackers before putting them into the medium Clam Chowder and medium Lobster Stew that we also ordered. Again it was the wrong thing to get, both were terrible especially the Lobster Stew which tasted like the Lobster had been cooked to death and sitting there for a while. My daughter loves Clam Chowder and said this was the worst she's ever had (she said canned chowder tasted better). She always finishes her chowder wherever she orders it but this time left about 90% of it. The same was true for my wife's Lobster stew. We ordered everything that Guy Fieri had on his program. I guess they must have made his order special for TV or his taste buds weren't working that day.
I guess the only real food critic can only be yourself, you can't rely on internet reviews and you certainly can't rely on what you see and hear on TV. This place really sucked to put it mildly, and now regret wasting our time going there. And did I tell you that this experience cost me around $90.00, that's without any drinks (we had our own in a cooler) or tip (wasn't required). Absolutely not a place for any budget minded family looking for good food at a reasonable price.
I should have drove directly to Boothbay Harbor where you can get pretty much the same selections only a whole lot better, and definitely a whole lot cheaper. I found a place called Kaler's in Boothbay Harbor where we had dinner, which we thought was excellent. We had a twin 1 lb. lobster dinner, an enormous Fisherman's platter that was fried to perfection (came with whole belly clams, haddock, Maine shrimp, calamari and scallops), 1 1/2 lbs. of Native steamed clams, onion rings, Buffalo chicken dinner, a bowl of New England clam chowder and sodas, all at a cost of only $78.00 including tip. We went back the next day for lunch with 6 other people and they all loved it, we all pretty much ordered the same things again with the addition of 2 Lobster rolls which were overflowing with tender morsels of lobster and mayo on a lettuce leaf on a toasted roll, and it was excellent again.
If not for Guy Fieri's review, I could have had lunch at Kaler's that day also instead of the over priced terrible meal at Bob's Clam Hut.
And don't let the crowd at Bob's fool you, most people who were there probably got suckered into going because of Guy Fieri's review on this "Dive" of a joint.
If you have the time, go to Kaler's in Boothbay Harbor, Maine which is about 2 hours northeast of Bob's Clam Hut. I guarantee you won't regret the trip. The cost savings will probably even pay for your fuel cost. If Kaler's was closer to northern New Jersey, I'd probably be there weekly, this place is great.
KL of Northern New Jersey
Dissatisfied customer of Bob's Clam Hut in Kittery, Maine and Guy Fieri's review of the joint
Totally Satisfied customer of Kaler's in Boothbay Harbor, Maine read more