Brooklyn and it's two cousins take #2 for best pizza in Charlotte behind Due Amici in the University Area. Brooklyn South is in Wesley Chapel in a bustling shopping center with CFA, Target, and some various other stores. When you enter, you walk to the counter and place your oder. They have a huge subway map on the floor which is super cool. Last time I was there, I got 2 slices of cheese and a water. They give you your drink right at the counter and you take a street sign back to your table so they know where to bring your food. I sat down at a booth, but the booth itself still had pizza crumbs on it. Ew. The table was clean but I guess they just missed the booth. The food came out fairly quickly and it was HOT. Unbelievably hot but also so delicious. Crispy crust that could be folded, a nice amount of cheese--not too much--and great tomato sauce. It's really very good pizza. Service is friendly and efficient--no complaints here. Brooklyn South could just be the best pizza in south Charlotte! read more

Too Expensive! My husband paid $40 for one pizza and a spaghetti entree, no garlic bread, just a piece of bread thrown in the bag and not even wrapped up! The pizza was WAY too greasy, but I'm giving 2 stars, because after getting the grease off with a paper towel, the pizza made a nice breakfast and the taste was pretty good. Spaghetti came with one meatball, had very little sauce and was just okay. read more

When I picked up my pizza and garlic knots order from Brooklyn Pizza on May 8, 2020, I was shocked to find that none of the staff had on masks, and the staff were not even pretending to practice social distancing at all. I had to go into the store to pay and was not allowed to pay over the phone. The store had a marked path (with arrows) on the floor from the door to the register, but the only other customer in the store went the wrong way and passed within a foot of me. I will be not be back. I will spend my money at restaurants that care about keeping their employees and customers safe by wearing masks. read more

I ordered at 6:07pm was told it'd be ready within an hour. I called back at 6:29PM was told my order would be ready within twenty minutes. It's now 7:28pm and my food is still not ready. I am waiting outside in the parking lot for my order and don't recommend this place whatsoever. I am noticing tons of people inside of their restaurant and outside of their restaurant are complaining and are still waiting for their orders as well. I recommend going to Lorenzo's Pizzería: 16721 Orchard Stone Run Unit 100 Charlotte, NC 28277 United States You get way better customer service and way better pizza at Lorenzo's and won't have to go through this entire ordeal. By the time my twenty wings get to me they'll be cold and by the time my pizza gets to me it'll be cold as well. Go elsewhere people, i run a business and I believe customer service is number one. How is it that Pizza Hut, dominoes, and papa johns who have tons of customers know how to handle their customers waiting time read more

Im very picky when it comes to pizza, most pizza doesn't do it for me. this place though, is so good. I highly recommend it. They are family owned. Every thing I have had has been awesome. I mainly get a large pie with pepperoni... the crust is tasty I could eat it with some marinara and be quite happy. their lasagna is huge enough for 2 or 3 people and is excellent. the arancini is huge and fried to perfection. they have great salad. I'm partial to the greek salad. my next trip i will get more garlic knots and try their subs. they have a pretty huge menu. You need to come here. The staff is very attentive. the managers are visible and check on customers. Me and My family and friends have been very happy and highly recommend this place. read more

When they first opened, I loved their linguini with clam sauce. However, through the years, it has become horrible. It just isn't what they used to serve when they first opened, the clam sauce is just yucky now. Their pizza's still seem pretty good, and their Antipasto salad was, and possibly still is, wonderful - even though I haven't had it in a while. Guess I'll go back to that salad, since my days of having their linguini and clam sauce are finished. I gave it numerous chances, but it just never measured up to what it had been when they opened their doors. read more

Amazing customer service. Love bringing my family here to enjoy a night out. Staff loves engaging in conversations with customers. Pizza is amazing!!! read more

Really good food always consistent and arguably the closet thing to real NY style pizza in the area. The entrees are always good and the chicken cutlet dangerous is always a5god choice. And their sweet tea by Java Jeff is the best on a hot day! read more

I am so beyond disappointed. This is a consistent problem. Go to pick up my food, wait, wait some more, wait more. No one asks what I'm waiting for. They apparently gave my order to someone else. I watched what the throng of customers after me left with. One was told, yours isn't ready, we'll bring it out to you. I had to walk up and ask about my order after 15 minutes and was asked what I had ordered. Oh sorry it's gone. Then get an attitude from the cashier. I will not be back. Even Pizza Hut is not this incompetent or rude to their customers. read more

Very rarely do I rate 5 stars...this is well deserved. ALWAYS impressed with this place! We have VERY high expectations when it comes to NY style pizza and have NEVER been disappointed. Like wings? Do yourself a favor and try the sweet chile wings...WOW! Literally have never been disappointed with anything on the menu! read more

Lemme just say that this pizza is more pricy than most, however when we got our hands on it, we couldn't help but notice its weight!! This thing was loaded with the toppings we ordered! Not to mention delicious! We're not super frequent here, but the few times we have ordered its been great. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Loaded with toppings!! - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

Good pizza if your looking for an easy dinner and don't want to resort to "fast food" pizza like dominos. And probably is your best option if you live in the area. If your picking up pizza to go, be sure to park in the lot that is closest to weddington road and they have a side door for people who are picking up to go orders. I have ordered from here over a dozen times and I have always had a timely and yummy experience. The Hawaiian Pie is good. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Casual dining inside - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

This is some bomb pizza! We're in town from Oregon - here visiting childhood friends ( Stephanie divine ) and Anthony ( the owner) hooked us up with some delish pie! Some of the best pizza I've ever had! This style of pizza is my favorite- wish we had it in Oregon ! The sauce is to die for! read more

I have been craving eggplant parm lately so when we said we were going to a NY style pizza place I figured score...uh not so fast. While it was indeed eggplant it was served so oddly, 3 flat, round frozen pieces of eggplant spread out over ziti, instead of stacked in layers. I have a cold so I was told it wasn't that bad, but all I know is the cheese shouldn't make up for the lack of yummy eggplant flavor. The sauce I knew was gonna be bad as soon as they set my plate down, it was that bright red sauce that doesn't look authentic and is overly sweet and needs to be seasoned like crazy. It was also served with a piece of blah, cold bread. The rest of the fam got an antipasto salad and pizza, so I pushed my plate aside and ate the pizza. It was good, not great, have had much better in Charlotte. It was served straight from the oven and so the cheese slid right off theslice when you picked it up because it was piping hot. Overall it was fine, you order at the counter and they deliver to your table. Refills were offered, plates were cleared at a decent pace. Its not my new fave but I'd go again and skip the eggplant and stick to pizza. read more

Very overrated and overpriced. Crust taste like it came from a can, vegetables taste stale and old, and meats have no flavor. Ordered a bbq chicken and the bbq sauce tasted like it came from a generic jar. Onions were not warm so I have to assume the cooks forgot before making the pizza and threw them on top afterwards. Chicken had no seasoning and flavor. Obviously not a true bbq chicken because it looked like the cooks cut up some Chicken and threw it on as an after thought. Wasted $18. Little Caesars is better. Oh and don't expect your food in a timely fashion. Even on a slow night it will take the kitchen 30 mins read more

Usually a very good experience. Tonight was absolutely awful. My order was completely screwed up. Our hungry kids waited 45 minutes for a pizza that we told we did not order. Was told that I didn't order them. The alleged manager was smug and didn't care that they ruined our night. Maybe ownership should be present during these high volume nights. read more

I come to Brooklyn Pizza once or twice a month and my usual order is two slices of pizza with mushrooms. The pizza is pretty good and very reasonable in price. The service is always great. I decided to try something different yesterday and went with angel hair and meatballs. When I placed the order, I told them to go light on the sauce. A few minutes later, my order came. I saw a fairly large plate of pasta with two decently sized meatballs. A good amount of steam was coming off of the pasta. So far, so good. When I looked closer, I saw that there was a ton of sauce on the pasta....not what I wanted. The meatballs looked a bit strange. I may be wrong, but they did not look homemade (they were near perfect replicas of each other on the outside), and the inside of them looked very processed-looking. Neither the sauce (which was a-plenty) nor the meatballs had much taste to them and I poured on a ton of grated cheese and crushed pepper to doctor the dish up a bit. Moreover, the meatballs were both cold. I told the server and she brought me over another meatball. You guessed it- it was a clone of the other two and it also was cold. Next time I go, I will stick with the pizza and avoid the pasta. read more

I wouldn't rave over this place, but it is very solid and consistent when it comes to pizza and lasagna. The hot wings are surprisingly good, not on the level of Mooseheads or DBs, but good classic flavor. The pizza is your classic ny style cheese type, but they do have other options of crust. The pin wheels are very tasty! Not the cheapest option around, but you will have a good experience. read more

if i could give 0 out of 5 stars, i would!! this has honestly been the worst customer service ever!!! the employees messed up the order, were rude beyond measure too!! tried to make us pay for the food that they forgot!! they also tried to say my mom was cursing at 16 yr olds, lol!!! the ruined my moms birthday! never coming back. read more

Pizza is OK but the rings are good. When we first moved In the area, we would eat here a lot. Overall staff is cool.

Rude staff. Our waitress rolled her eyes when my son asked for a refill of his sweet tea. This is not the first time an employee has treated us poorly here. read more

Brooklyn pizza used to have the best Nonna Pizza around with stewed tomato's on top. I ordered one tonight and they don't put the tomatoes on top anymore. Now they just put pizza sauce. So disappointing. The pizza used to be a masterpiece but now it looks like it was made at Cici's. I will not be going back. Such a shame. Maybe they franchised out too quickly. read more

This place has seriously gone down hill - horrible last several times I have been. A staff who doesn't care and more concerned with chit chatting with each other, kitchen staff lazy (order 3 slices of meat lovers - got two and the third was clearly an old slice of pepperoni with some sausage thrown on top and barely reheated). Pizza dried out and hard as a rock - sauce flavorless - complained and kitchen just sent same piece back with no correction or even an apology. Burnt mozzarella sticks - we just won't be back as I am not going to waste money on their crappy food again. read more

The pizza is alright, but the prices are WAY too high. Today, however, I ordered the eggplant parm hero and the eggplant was bitter, mushy, and undercooked. I complained and got another one for free, but it was just as undercooked as the first one. I gave them a second chance and they blew it. I won't be ordering from here again. read more

EwWwW! this is the worst pizza place I have ever been to. Every time I eat here I get explosive deadly diarrhea. Also everyone who works here is from New York and are ruining the universe. All of the employees are rude not to mention the horrible cookies they have. Once I purchased these shell cookies that were half covered in chocolate and they tasted the way my diarrhea smelt which was NOT good. yours truly, Raccoon read more

Great pizza and friendly service! The pies are really huge, so leftovers were taken home and were equally delicious! I gave it four stars because it's a bit pricey. Also, it was very cold in the restaurant, maybe because they had just opened. Either way, I will definitely return to this great place! read more

The place looks cool inside but I was not impressed with the food at all. I understand making cheese pies beforehand but every piece of dough I had was stale tasting; including the garlic knots. I'll come back one more time to try their pastas but I can get a better pie from a smaller place near home. read more

Brooklynn's pizza is pretty good. The pies are sizable and decently tasty. On my last visit, the service was outstanding. A table was promptly cleaned for us to sit at (despite being slammed on a Friday night) and an employee by the name of Jack went out of his way to get us refills, sauces, and extra plates without us even asking him. If all pizza places had employees like this guy, I would be more willing to eat out at pizza joints rather than ordering delivery. All-in-all, this places pizzas are a bit too pricey to justify me going here regularly, but they are fair considering the portions you get. read more

I've been here three times before and it was ok, but this time was pretty bad. We ordered 2 plain slices, antipasto salad, fried calamari & 2 drinks. The guy at the counter said something about picking up the drinks at the end of the counter, but forgot to pour them so we got them after the meal came - no big deal. The food though was bad. Maybe we just ordered the wrong thing? I'm attaching pics of the burnt calamari (how can they serve it like that? Clearly they forgot about it in the fryer - or refried an old order) and the antipasto. The sauce for the calamari is a jalapeño sauce that's also not thick enough, and I still prefer a good marinara instead. The antipasto dressing was like colored water. Flavorless w/ the same viscosity as water. It ran right to the bottom of the plate. The meat that's minced and put on top of the lettuce turns out to be not a lot and annoying to eat. It would've been better with a spoon for meat cut up that much. IMHO, they do that to make it look like you're getting more than you are - more surface area. So, I'm out $25, but I learned to never go to Brooklyn pizza again. At least, not until I see consistently good reviews from others. I'll give it a second star bc my son liked his slices, although I tried his pizza & I definitely prefer Tony's or Lorenzo's. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Minced meat on top of antipasto with watery dressing. Terrible. - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

See all

We order take out almost weekly. My son loves the gluten-free pizza. We are a fan of the garlic knots and Nonna's pizza. Ladies taking orders and delivering pizza have always been nice and friendly. Also love their lunch specials! read more

There was amazing customer service and my food wasn't cold and it tasted like it was right out of the oven.

This place is amazing! I've never had better pizza in my life! Staff was attentive and friendly and overall the restaurant had a very nice atmosphere. Definitely will be back, recommend it to everyone! read more

Not sure what kind of "New York Pizzeria" serves calzones without any cheese other than a small spoonful of ricotta, but we found one. Additionally, overcooked and I literally cut my gums repetitively on the crust. Won't be back. read more

Cheese rice ball was really good, a little on the salty side but nice & big! The plain Sicilian pizza was a little cold but tasty. The staff is very friendly and attentive! read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Cheese rice ball - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

See all

So the cheese pizza is good. That is their redeeming factor. Oh the cheese tortellini was pretty good too but with extra parm cheese and red pepper flakes. The "vodka" sauce is nothing more than bland marinara and a splash of cream. Their Caesar salad is like store bought Kraft dressing but worse. The Greek salad was decent. And sorry to the people who didn't end up with half their order because it was given to us instead, your calzone wasn't great either. Anyway the water is probably the best thing on the menu. ‍ read more

Wow! How can I explain how bad the food was?? Bought 2 calzones and some pasta for take out. Calzone #1 was a pepperoni and ham. #2 was a mushroom garlic & bacon. Besides being cold, the calzone breading was hard as possible. The only soft spot was the golf ball sized center. This small spot also happened to be the only part of the thing that had filling, which was a 1 inch stack of super salty pepperoni surrounded by some ham shreds. This was then surrounded by a small pasting of ricotta. The pasta was supposed to be garlic and oil covered but it was devoid of garlic & very bland. I've been to Brooklyn and I've had pizza there. This place is not worthy of the name. read more

Absolutely disgusting customer service at this establishment. I witnessed the manager harass a large group over them not wanting to buy single sodas as the restaurants fountain soda machine was not allowed to be used. Absolutely pathetic display of customer service. Avoid at all costs. Pizza is bland but customer service was apalling. read more

We started with an appetizer of mozzarella sticks. Very good. Delicious lasagna! More than enough food and we enjoyed our leftovers. We also had a ham and cheese calzone. Yummy. And the tomato sauce is delicious. We really liked the sauce- yummy! Service was great and they were super friendly. We will be back to try the pizza! read more

My favorite pizza in the Waxhaw/Weddington area. Sometimes inconsistent, but overall great!

The atmosphere is very casual, buy they do make some great pizza.