Not what it used to be. The food is now not that great in tandem with price increase make this place a less likely occurrence for me every month. Wings are dry, salad is frosty, pizza is greasy (and not in the good way). Service is mediocre at best. Go take your business elsewhere. read more

Update: I thought I'd give this place a second chance and ordered take-out again. I think this place saves their mess-ups for take-out customers, because once again, I got a JUNK meal. My Brooklyn Famous Stromboli was not nice and tan as in the picture, but rather, was more chocolate colored. I have no idea why this place is so busy. Apparently, the people eating here have never had good Italian pies and other dinner pastries. Brooklyn should sue this place for ruining their good name. AWFUL!!! I ordered a calzone but I am not crazy about ricotta cheese. My wife doesn't like it at all so I got one and she didn't. The calzone can be made with any toppings so why can we not keep the calzone until said time. Then, when I got my calzone it wasn't even closed all the way. It was just kinda flopped over like an omelette. If it's going to look this bad, then why is it so hard to remove ricotta. I think there's probably a better place elsewhere. read more

See all

First time there and ordered 2 Sicilian slices. Bad idea. Looks like it was made 12 hours ago and was cold and tasted like it was made 12 hours ago. Asked to speak to the manager and Mario the cook or owner came out and started arguing that the food is not made fresh but just warmed up and that was that. The. Box the pizza went in would probably taste better. Cheese was already aging on the slice. Fool me once. Lousy customer service matches food. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

Pizza is average and the subs we had tonight were made by someone who didn't know how or just didn't care. Same for the cannolis. They are about two inches long and filled on each end but not in the middle. Is there a ricotta shortage we don't know about now? Try harder! read more

This place is so delicious There pizza is so good I love the Brooklyn bridge and the service is amazing you guys keep this place open forever!! read more

This place is a staple in the area. This is the go to spot for families after baseball or soccer games. Never met the owners but very well run, great pizza and wings. read more

Pizza was assembled with ZERO care. One slice had a glob of black olives, the next slice has a couple. One slice has a sliver of onion. The mushrooms were almost non existent. Ordered Double Italian Sausage and it was difficult like locate the pieces of Sausage. For asking $25+ for a 16" pizza the value and pride making a good product is not there. This could be much better. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

We ordered here for the first time last week when our parents were in town. Food was good but it took a while to get it. We went to get the to go order when it stated online but still ended up having to wait a while for food. I understand with it being covid and a lot of places are short staffed, however while waiting we did notice flys on the food that was sitting out. That was a little off putting to see so I took off a star for that. read more

Great pizza and great service. It's definitely a family favorite. I just wish there was more seating because when it gets busy, you might have to wait for a table, and you're stuck just standing there in the middle of everything. read more

I ordered a pizza today to be picked up at 5:50, we got there right at 5:50. After waiting in line we were told that it wasn't ready and to wait in our car. The pizza would be brought out to you momentarily. 30 minutes later it was finally brought out to our car, they never once apologized for how long it took. This has been our go to pizza place for several years, but it looks like we will be moving to Hawthorne's for now on read more

My family went on a Friday night which is arguably their busiest time but we still had a great experience! The line to order was long but the staff quickly and efficiently helped each customer so we didn't have to wait very long. We were able to immediately find a table and really enjoyed that the staff walks around to fill cups or bring anything you may need. Our food came out relatively quickly and was delicious! My husband and I sometimes prefer different toppings on our pizza so I really appreciate that Brooklyn Pizza does pizza by the slice. We were both able to get what we wanted and didn't have to order 2 different pizzas. This is a very family friendly restaurant because it has a variety of Italian favorites on the menu, the kids menu allows you to customize your pasta option based on your child's current preference and it has lots of tables so it can accommodate groups of all sizes. Our visit ended with one of the manager's, Ashley, coming to check how our experience went and thank us for coming in. I appreciate the management took the time to ensure we had a good experience even when the restaurant was quite busy. We will definitely be back for more! read more

Great meal with the family! Nothing like a big pizza with friends after our boys Tball practice!

Sauce is nothing spectacular. Chicken parm had a different taste to it, almost like it had been frozen. Wasn't really warm. 3 staff people sat at a table when you entered, not one person welcomed you in. It had been awhile since I have been there and more than likely not go back. read more

Brooklyn Pizza has quickly become our "pizza night/ dinner in a pinch" go to! The pizza is authentic to NY pies and the choices are fabulous! Whether it's a pepperoni pizza or a gourmet white pie you just can't go wrong! Love that you can order at the counter and casually wait for your food. read more

Update to my experience. I reached out to the owner Anthony and he apologized for his manager and the experience of the meal. Seems like an owner who really cares about his patrons. I can't say enough good about his reaching out to me and the importance of knowing how much he cares for his business! I also never had issues before this with staff or quality and frequent this place almost weekly for years. I love eating local. Ordered two pieces of cheese pizza slices and paid for four extra toppings each. I just showed the picture to the manager who told me that even though only half the slice had extra cheese and toppings that what did I expect for 45 cents per topping? Also that they have new people working there and that they are told to limit the amount of toppings and put them dead center. The other piece had no meatballs even though we paid for them. Long time customers totally disgusted with her response. Not going back read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - This is cheese pizza slice with 4 extra toppings. - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

Brooklyn Pizza in Wesley Chapel has been our go to when we crave a slice and a salad for many years, but we are now in search of a new one. The crust and toppings are great, but there is almost no sauce on their basic pizza anymore. We have noticed this change over our last five or six visits, so it's not a one time thing. Sorry, but we continue to be disappointed. read more

Regular pizza was good. Gluten-free not so much. I appreciate the effort, but will get a dish next time. Also don't like the yoga pants on the girls. read more

What the hell happened to Brooklyn Pizza!?! It just goes out of business out of nowhere? What did they find a meth lab in the back? Anybody know why they closed? read more

We decided to order a pizza for take out this weekend while we were out running errands. We just went basic with a plain cheese. The pizza was ready to go pretty quickly. For me the pizza is a-ok... but not great. The crust is not the best and it was a bit too greasy for me. This place is preferred over "fast food pizza" like Farley's...but definitely not my favorite pizza. read more

Brooklyn is one of my favorite restaurants in the area. My family and I eat here often I would suggest the Nona pizza for a different taste. The staff are all really nice as well. read more

This pizza was gross and that is something I thought I would never say about pizza. I thought even bad pizza was good pizza because how bad could it be? Well this place answers that question. Crust was so hard and chewy at the same time it hurt my jaw to eat it. Also there was barely any sauce, it was like it had been scrapped off. I would never go back here and wouldn't recommend anyone ever eating here unless you want to hate pizza read more

We order Pizza and Garlic Knots to go quite regularly from Brooklyn Pizza. The food is always good, the owners work there, and are polite even when busy. Highly Recommend! read more

OK pizza - Bad take out experience. Been a take out customer for year plus. Pizza ok best available in the area. Be warned - add at least +10 min to order time is remotely busy. Also if your last name has more than one syllable the girls taking orders will get it wrong so be prepared to give 3 to 4 name variations when you get to the counter. Really need to improve the order and delivery process. read more

This place is OK. Not bad, not great. Pizza comes in only one size - 18 inch, 8 slices which is HUGE. Pizza was cooked alright. Ingredients seemed fresh, though it certainly was not something that woke-up my senses. Atmosphere is a bit run-down and could use some renovating. To be honest, the whole experience was a little disappointing. If the atmosphere is going a little down (not too lively, just a hole in the wall) at least the food could be better. menu choices are limited. Maybe it is the way it is presented (you have to review a menu before ordering even when at the counter). We probably will not be back. read more

Some of the better pizza in the area, but hard to give It anymore than 3 stars because I always have to throw the pizza in the oven when I get home to cook it longer. The appetizers are on point - especially the zucchini fries and the chicken wings. My toddler really loves their meatballs. I tried the square pizza once and it was really good. All around solid food. read more

I have never left a review until now because I was so upset this that I feel I need to share my experience. I have been a loyal customer here since the day that I moved to North Carolina in September 2014. I have been going to this establishment for eight years, pretty much every day. I went there so much that I became friendly with some of the staff and even the owner knew me by my name. The first 6 years, I was so happy. This was as close to real Brooklyn, NY pizza that I had found. I was telling everyone how good this pizza was and telling them that they needed to try it. Then, something changed. Over the past 2 years the quality of the food has declined greatly and is pretty inconsistent. The staff has also been inconsistent, with new people working there every couple of months. I had never had a complaint about the food and I have never returned my food up until this past year. This year I have returned my food two times and the last time the owner had the nerve to tell me that he loses money, every time I come in to his store and told me not to come back. The day that the owner told me not to come back, I had ordered a square slice with extra cheese and when it came out there were 2 thick squares of mozzarella cheese on top of the pizza. They were not melted and just kind of stuck to the top. I tried to return the square and the owner came out and told me he was doing me a favor by adding two thick pieces of mozzarella cheese to my pizza for extra cheese. While he was going off on me, the manager even said "don't mind him, he's in a bad mood". I don't care what type of mood he's in or what's going on with him, you don't talk to a customer like that. After experiencing such disrespect and rudeness, my family and I have decided that we will not be returning to either location. read more

I don't know why I keep coming here .... I ordered ahead of time because you know who wants to wait 30 mins ? I gets side of fries , Brooklyn philly and wings ... I go in and I had to wait an extra 20 min when I called 30 min before because who wants to wait 30 min ? Should I say that again lol ... anyway I finally get my food . Get home and of course why not be disappointed smh philly was soggy and the meat was really sweet .. beard wasn't toasted... by wings were more dry than my phone .. smh over all bad experience and my last experience. Bunch of kids work there also so at times they can be sloooooow or still learning . read more

Ordering a full pie, freshly baked is the right thing to do. Pizza is great and close to NY standard. However, taking by the slice isn't good, or ordering entrees, sandwiches, hero etc has been a repeated fail for us. Eggplant parm hero has been cold, with an almost icy center! Sauce is pretty tasteless, ordered ziti last week and it arrived cold and dry with not nearly enough sauce. I'll stick to the made to order pies! read more

The best pizza in Weddington, great service and always on time. They serve other dishes as well and I've tried many of them. Let's not forget about the wings. Just playing finger licking good. read more

This seems like the hot spot of the town ! I'm visiting my grandchildren they always love to go to Brooklyn pizza parlor. They meet all their neighbors there. Very friendly place ,the servers are friendly, the owner helps out serving the food also. They have the best garlic knots bread that I've ever had . We ordered the garlic knots we ordered a large cheese pizza and we had baked ziti. All the memorabilia is from Brooklyn so it really takes you back home. The only reason that I am giving it a four is because the food comes out little at a time they don't serve it all at one time. read more

See all

Go here once every other month or so. Pizza is fine. New York style obviously. Rice balls are meh...don't know if I'd get again. I like their Hawaiian style because it has caramelized onions, but kids don't really go for it. Have brought a crowd here after soccer and they can accommodate so long as it's not close to 6-7 on a Friday..most crowded then as you'd expect for a pizza place. read more

When we moved down to North Carolina from NY we needed a go to pizza place. We tried a few and didn't think any compared. We met another New Yorker and she told us about Brooklyn Pizza. So we tried it. I feel I'm a pizza snob and this place is the real deal. The pizza tastes great and is the closest to NY pizza. Even the other food from the menu is great, especially the chicken parm. I can't understand why this place doesn't have higher reviews on here. read more

Pizza is usually very good and so are the other items... But they charge $3.50 for a topping on a small 16 inch pizza. Everyone else is like two bucks... Rather obsessive. read more

It's Pizza - not bad, but nothing to call New York about! The service is good, it's easy to bring a large group of kids in and grab a slice of pie, eat, and go. Better than dominos/pizza hut but they don't deliver. Their garlic knots are good, and they have their pepperoni pinwheels that are a tasty appetizer as well. Beer selection is minimal, but they do offer pitchers! Greg Olsen used to come here every Friday night, but since he moved he probably won't be sited anymore. read more

Had the Hawaiian pizza and mozzarella sticks. Coating on the moz sticks was a little to thick but they tasted fine as long as you eat it hot. Hawaiian pizza was fair. To much moisture due to pineapple so it broke down the crust. I probably wouldn't get it again. Ratio of ingredients was spot on. Friendly staff, very attentive. read more

I ordered a calzone and it tasted like it had been setting out all day. It was burnt and hard as a rock. We will not be back. We thought about giving it another try after a few years since our last bad visit: no more. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

I want to love this place, and sometimes I do. Other times not so much. I have come here and left feeling like I have found the mecca of NY style pizza, so good it reminded me of home, and other times I have left regretting even ordering anything. The service is always good, let me start with the positive. The girls that work there always have a smile on their face and are very helpful with any requests. The food on the other hand is so hit or miss, it totally depends on the day as to whether you are going to enjoy your food or not, and I am talking about when you order the same exact thing on different days. There have been times when the pizza was cooked to perfection, with a nice char on the crust, and perfect toppings, and there have been times where the pizza looked like it was just passed through the oven, with a barely edible crust that is pretty much raw. Unfortunately I like consistency with my food, and I'm not willing to spend my hard earned money, knowing I could get home with my pizza and feel like I could have gotten a better one from the frozen food section of the grocery store. read more

I'm not from NY, but I do enjoy NY Style pizza. As most of us are painfully aware, NY style pizza is nearly impossible to come by in this area. However, Brooklyn makes a very good NY Style pizza! They have a great crust, they season their pizzas just right, and they use the perfect amount sauce (and the sauce isn't too sweet!). Pizza can be ordered by the pie or the slice. For those Gluten Free folks...they offer a gluten free personal-sized pie, too. I am also a fan of their garlic knots...delicious pieces of baked dough that is smothered in garlic butter/oil and seasoning. Served with marinara...excellent! I have also had their Calzones and been very pleased and their Oil & Garlic pasta is delicious! I have been to several events that were catered by Brooklyn and have thoroughly enjoyed it! Baked Ziti, Tortellini Alfredo, Chicken Parm....all very good! We have dined-in only a couple of times and the service was very good both times. The place is always very busy and there can be a heft wait for a table on a Friday or Saturday night....especially during little league season. They have nice outdoor seating area as well. Nice little neighborhood spot for very good pizza and pasta. I would also like to recognize them for their support of the community and the local schools. I have seem them step up to assist with many local town and school events and fundraisers. read more

Their customer service is the worse! The restaurant times is posted and online my family walked in a hour before that time, we were told their closing time for that evening was in 30 minutes. They also mention we could not sit in the inside but outside was open if we order entrees that don't require dishes.. Terrible service! read more

We ordered carry out on a Saturday night. Nothing too crazy or complicated: one large cheese pizza and two gluten-free pizzas (cheese and pepperoni). The pizza was fresh and tasty, even after the drive back from the restaurant. The gluten-free option is great for those people who have gluten allergies or are simply trying to cut gluten out of their diets. I tried to take a picture, however before I could, the pizza was in my belly :) read more