Beware: The pizza was so-so, but the price was astounding. The basic price seemed a bit high at $23.70 for a large pepperoni, sausage and black olive, but then, there were the "adders: Carryout Fee ($2.70), Conveninece Fee ($2.49) and Sales tax ($0.17) for a carryout order. So, 23% of the total price was for what? Note: Take-out food in Ohio is not taxed. With the deceptive "apparent price" and unremarkable pizza, I suggest going somewhere else: I certainly will not be coming back. read more

The only actual New York pizza that I have found in the Columbus area. It has the look, taste, and feel or NY pizza. read more

I got takeout two separate times. The service was good, and the pizza was good. I like a little grease on my pizza, but this was a bit too much. No dipping sauces. read more

Always great food and great service! Thin crust NY style is very good. Other menu items like calzones look good too, but I always get the pizza! Highly recommended! read more

Ordered two pies online. Pick up was fast after floating in cartoon character-style on the smell from the parking lot. Employees were very nice but most importantly the pizza crushed. The plain cheese hit my NYC cravings and the guys loved their pepperoni and banana peppers. read more

Been now going here for close to 4 years and yup, still consistently great, right ingredients, right cut, right shape, they know what a slice is, understand sarcasm, I feel like you get the right service and NY pizza shop Ambiance that isn't replicated anywhere else. It's like a united nations safe spot for NY City or Long Island natives.. read more

After hearing so much about how this is the closest thing to NY-style pizza, we finally got around to trying out Brooklyn Pizza. It is definitely the best NY-style pizza place that I have been to in Columbus. The restaurant also has the NYC vibes going with minimalistic pizzeria ambience, no-frills and to-the-point customer service, and delicious, foldable slices (to fold or not to fold - that is up to you). We ended up getting two pies - the cheese and the pesto chicken. The cheese was the clear winner between the two. I will definitely go back here for the cheese pizza, and wish they had other meat topping options such as beef or chicken for non-pork eaters. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Chicken pesto pie. - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Went there today and enjoyed the pizza. Originally from Jersey and trying to find good pizza in Ohio is hard to find. The crust, sauce and cheese was just right. Also affordable and priced great. No complaints here. This is my new pizza spot for sure! read more

I'm not even sure how to word this other than HELL YEAH. I'm from New York and it's impossible to find good NY style pizza and this guy nailed it. He's a Long Island native and he knows exactly what's up. We will be returning for sure. This breathes life back into this New Yorker for sure!! Do it. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Anthony's Brooklyn Pizza is the best New York pizza in Columbus! It is always fresh and hot out of the oven. The sauce is perfect and the toppings are generous. It is the only pizza we eat! read more

The BEST Pizza I've ever had except when I'm in Brooklyn. Seriously the best possible New York style pizza you'll ever have in the state of Ohio. They don't cut pizza square and they don't make it cracker thin. It's New York realistic pizza. read more

This is our go-to New York pizza. We always order two pies for a family of four. We eat it for two days and it keeps well. read more

We're adding a $2.52 "Carryout Fee" now? Insane. I wanted NY pizza, not NY prices. It's incredibly disappointing, because they know how to make a good product, but their pricing strategy leaves a bad taste in my mouth. read more

Pizza was good but the cannolis stole the show!! Best ones we have found in Columbus by far. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

At first I was hesitant to try Brooklyn Pizza with the constant complaints about the owner on social media. But, my experience was actually really pleasant. I am giving Brooklyn Pizza a 4/5 stars because there is always room for improvement. The service is what it is here. It's ran by a family and they focus more on creating a good quality of authentic New York pizza than trying to cater to peoples feelings and emotions. When I went the owner actually talked to me for a few minutes and asked me what my name was. He seemed nice and passionate about his profession. The pizza here is the real deal. It's one of the only authentic NY slices I've had outside of NY. I'm pretty sure the owner is from Brooklyn and brought his recipes with him. They serve pizza by the slice or pies as a whole. I would rate this pizza a 7.4/10. It has some NY flop to it, but the ingredients are fresh and it's reasonably priced. This pizza definitely resembles pizza in Brooklyn however. I wouldn't compare it to Di Faras and Lucali's. But, definitely reminds me of other places throughout Brooklyn. Overall, if you like New York style pizza and live in Columbus this is the place to go. This place is absolutely slept on. Also suggest getting the garlic knots if they're not sold out! read more

By far the best pizza in Columbus and surrounding area. If you like true NY style pizza then this is the place to go.

It is as it says!! Brooklyn pizza! Brooklyn ambiance ( small eat in space) enjoyed it

The pizza was good but the problem is that I have never had to pay a convenience fee and a service fee to pickup a pizza. That fee is not worth my time to drive all the way over there to get a pizza. I can go to places closer to me and pizza just as good without paying these fees. Thanks for the first impression but not coming back to pay the convenience and service fee. read more

Quaint little pizza shop in Powell. The pizza here is decent, much better than others I've had in Ohio. Is it NY pizza though? No the sauce is a little too sweet and it's lacking cheese, the crust is nice and crispy and it is foldable. The price is also decent compared to what you pay for other large not as tasty pies in Columbus. I ordered pickup and it only took them about 20minutes to get it ready, the cashier was super pleasant! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Half pepperoni half 16'' Large Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

Authentic NY style pie here. The white pie was amazing. I thought it edged out the regular cheese pizza. Would return!

Great authentic New York pizza, calzones and Stromboli too! It's great, not a lot of dine in space but carry-out is well done.

Zero Stars if I could! No matter how good something maybe, when your treated like crap that taste last a lot longer. Walked in, and the guy was completely rude--zero understanding of customer service. Hands down the worst experience I've ever had at a pizza place. I will never be back, nor will my family. We'll be praying for that very angry man. God bless. read more

Just not it. Been trying it for years. Ups & downs like regular shops. Last straw was changing the sausage. ARE YOU SERIOUS?! The recipe was perfect. It used to be the best sausage pie. Nah I'm done. read more

Decent pizza but the owner is an ass. Acts like you are doing him a favor by ordering a pie. Never on time they quote either.

Great pizza! Limited indoor seating, but the food is great! Folks taking our order was helpful and kind. We'll be back!

Awesome pizza! Curt customer service. First: The pizza is great - crispy crust, fresh ingredients, hot and ready to go. The cheese is good, the sauce is nice and you can fold the pizza in two like a proper Brooklyn slice. Plus, it's cheap at $3/slice. I really wanted to love this place and give it five stars. Unfortunately, here's an Actual Exchange with this first-time customer: Guy making pizza (not cashier): "Can I help you?" Me, ascertaining what's quick since nothing's on the counter: "Yeah, I've never been here before." Pizza Guy, back to cutting pizza: "We sell pizza." Thanks, Pizza Guy. (For a minute I thought I was in Philly.) The cashier half-smiled in that apologetic sort of manner people use. Hunger kept me from walking out, and I'm glad I didn't. For good cheap pizza, I'll forgo greetings and helpful suggestions and just get my order to go. I'm guessing they prefer it that way. ‍ read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Mushroom slice and sausage slice - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

Only NY style pizza I've been able to find in Ohio. Love it! Basic cheese or the white pizza are my favorites.

Best NY Style Pizza in the Mid-West! I've been looking since I moved here 15 years ago from Boston.

Wanted to try this local ny style pizza place after I heard from a friend. I liked that it appeared like true ny style thin crust pizza. The sauce and cheese were good but overall the pizza was bland. The crust was too tough and chewy. I read on some of the reviews that the owner is rude and I definitely saw that first hand. While I was picking up my pizza, the owner yelled at a pregnant lady in the store who asked for ranch dressing with her pizza. He said, " how many times do I have to tell people we don't have ranch,so stop asking!!" Definitely better pizza options around, so take your business elsewhere. Will probably not get pizza from there again. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

The BEST pizza in Powell - even in Brooklyn! And, super friendly service. Feels like you're in a real pizzeria.

We love pizza. Not all pizza-Good pizza. We are not opposed to driving a few extra miles to get good pizza. We got this last night for the first time. One plain cheese and one white pizza. We will drive for this pizza. This is damn good pizza. I don't care if the people are rude. I care how good the pizza is and this pizza is amazing. read more

Closest to actual nyc pizza you will find in columbus. Really, really good pizza, crisp crust , good ingredients. I have eaten a ton of the iconic places for pizza in nyc and elsewhere and this place is up there with the good ones Hidden gem in columbus read more

This local pizza place is great! It's been on my list to try and i'm happy i went. I came at 12:15, they open at 12, and the place was already full. Everyone was eating by the slice which is perfect we can grab and go! I got a cheese and pepperoni slice and both were amazing. Not too greasy, not soggy underneath. Perfect crisp crust. I will definitely go back for more one day! I also heard the white pizza is a hit! $2.75 for cheese slice and $3.00 for pepperoni slice! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - two slices of pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

The best pizza in Powell IMO. It doesn't taste like pizza from a chain and I appreciate the fact that the ingredients are fresh and tasty. Crust is thin and chewy, which is my favorite. Their Margherita and white pizzas are my favorites, though there are many options. Small dining area, so I usually take out. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Medium Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

It's hard to find NY pizza in Ohio. This pizza is not quite New York but it's still very good. The sauce is sweet. The cheese could be more greasy. Would probably return and recommend. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Half pep half cheese - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

Awesome pizza! If you like the larger thin NY style pizza this is my favorite one in the powell area.

Great NY pizza and calzone.Felt like I was in my hometown joint. This calzone was absolutely wonderful. Ricotta oozed out with perfect smoothness and superb flavor. Now THIS is a calzone. Places claim to make these and call them calzones but this is a must to try. NYers will understand and Ohioans should come on board. Anthony is a great guy. Hard worker and professional as well as expert in his craft. Go ahead.... Ask him to cut pie in squares, I dare you!! Rocky read more

Ah, tasty non chain pizza. It's been a long time since I have ordered their pizza - after A Slice of New York shut down on campus, Borgata kind of replaced my pizza cravings, but I've been eyeballing Brooklyn after my buddy suggested it (he's a picky pizza eater and loves the NY style), and my trips to Ill Mannered always make me eyeball it from across the street. They make delicious NY-style, thin crust (with a little crunch) pizza and CHEESY calzones. Like, super cheezy goodness - I wasn't even seeking a calzone, but my youngest said he wanted to try it! SO calzone and a pizza (1/2 cheese and 1/2 pepperoni) was ordered, and I'm a little irritated I didn't seek them out again sooner. It was fast (like 15 minutes from ordering), it was hot and delicious - my son is ready to try their stromboli next! read more

The best pizza in Powell. Always fresh, quality ingredients. Just a classic slice of cheese, folded, is our favorite!

A you wanna good slice of pie? You've found the right spot. Great pizza and when you walk in it smells like a really good pizzeria. Had the margarita and a pepperoni. Both stellar. Good chew to crust and it holds up for a slice! It's goooooooood! read more