I recently moved to Columbus from NYC and I can genuinely say that Brooklyn Pizza is the best pizza in town. The crust is thin and crunchy and the ingredients are fresh and delicious. Even the salads are great! I have very high standards for pizza because it's one of my favorite foods to eat. As a born and raised New Yorker and Italian you can trust my judgement on this one. If you are looking for quality pizza say no to the chains and try Brooklyn Pizza. read more

I would love to try this pizza but they never answer during the business hours. I called at 8:15 tonight and nothing. I tried last Saturday and they were out of supplies, per their automated message, and the week before, again no answer. I know I could drop by but with a busy family with young kids, I'd love to be able to order it first. I'll try again, I guess, as I just moved from Chicago and am dying to find some good pizza. It has just been frustrating so far. I guess a 2 is fair but from what I've read it sounds like a 4-5. Please just answer. read more

Brooklyn Pizza deserves a better fate than to be stuck back on Grace Drive in Powell, where good restaurant ideas go to die. That being said, it is worth the drive to sample their excellent NY-style pies. The crust is perfect, crisp on the bottom but not cracker-like and chewy on top. The tomato sauce is tangy, not biting, and is perfect with just enough cheese to pull apart when you bite in. We had the Margherita pizza and, for once, there was interest in the pesto and enough garlic to actually taste. The meatballs were homemade and great on the meatball pizza. The owner, John, seems nice, from Long Island, and eager to please. All in all, this is worth the trip any time. read more

Closest thing to New York pizza, in all its foldable greasy glory, you will find in central ohio IMHO. The sauce is balanced with just the right amount of spices, the crust is as you would expect from a New York pizza. The toppings are fresh and plentiful. Give it a try if you have not had it. If for whatever reason you are not impressed (I have always been) this is one place that is worth a second shot. read more

Pretty good pizza. Located just north of the center of Powell. I ordered a large, made to order pizza. Their large pizza's are 16 inches, (larger than many of the more common pizza places). Ingredients were very fresh tasting. Loved it with garlic. Very competitively priced. They don't offer delivery. They have a couple tables inside, but their main focus would be takeout. They are only open until 9 PM, including the weekends. Their menu offers a few subs, a couple calzones and a Stromboli. read more

So hard to find good pizza (East Coast Style) I need them to open a parlor closer to my home. I will drive the 20 min. to eat there,it's that good. read more

Brooklyn Pizza is really good. Plenty of melty cheese, good sauce, fresh crunchy and slightly doughy NY style crust. I had Brooklyn Pizza again today and got my personal favorite: tomato and meatball. It was great, which is par for every other visit I've had here. Get the pizza to eat in if you want to scold your mouth on hot delicious pizza. If you literally can not stand the filth that is the standard for Central Ohio pizza (hear Donatos), then you will probably really like Brooklyn Pizza. If you want crappy pizza go somewhere else down the street. read more

Fantastic pizza. Best in Ohio. Im from Long Island and so happy to get a little taste of home at Brooklyn Pizza. Owner Tony is great! Kudos! read more

If you are looking for a a spot that reminds you of NY style pizza in Central Ohio, this is the place to go. I'm originally a New Yorker & have been looking for some genuine NY style & taste and by far Brooklyn Pizza takes the prize. Thank you Brooklyn Pizza! read more

We ate here for the first time on Sunday and it is a darn good pie. I'm from Ohio, so I don't pretend to "know" New York style pizza. However, this is the closest to what I've had while visiting NYC. Ownership is awesome and the new location shines like a diamond. read more

This is New York-style pizza like Sbarro is New York-style pizza. The quality of the crust and cheese just isn't there.

Absolutely wonderful pizza. The crust has the right amount of crunch and chew; the sauce, perfect. Glad to see East Coast pie in Columbus. Oh yeah, the meatballs rock too. read more

What happened to Brooklyn Pizza in Powell? We have always been willing to pay more at Brooklyn Pizza than the chain pizza locations in the area. We have experienced recently, that the sauce and amount of toppings have continued to decrease in last several months. The last pizza we ordered was unbelievable. a significant reduction in sauce and toppings. The quality and quantity is why we became a regular customer and now why we are leaving. read more

Called to place an order and voicemail suggested calling back in a half hour? Always love their pizza, but for any business to say, "sorry we're too busy to take an order" is beyond belief!!! Lost my business! read more

Great slice of new York style pizza. Excellent crust. My favorite in the area. Small walk in with a handful off tables. Friendly staff. read more

The best pizza I've found near Columbus. Worth the 30 minute drive just to get some real deal NYC-style pizza.

Love the fact you can get pizza by the slice and quick too. Thin crispy crust, just how I like my pizza. Too bad I found this place my last few days in the city! If u live in the Powell area or close I recommend it. read more

NOW THIS IS PIZZA!!!! EAST COAST STYLE BABY!!! This pizza is EXCELLENT! My wife is from the East coast, and it conpares to it. Not for the "squares".This pizza is right on point! Worth the drive across town. Will be back! read more

These guys get it. Pizza is good. Attention to personal business goals is commendable.

Brooklyn Pizza is pizza is truly genuine New York City pizza. I'm so happy I found this place. I had a large pepperoni pizza and every bite reminded me of the amazing pizza that I had on my last trip to the to the big apple. I highly recommend for those that love real New York City pizza, or for those who want to experience some amazing pizza. read more

Im a fan. Nice chewy crust, like real pizza. Small joint great for takeout. The white pizza (never thought id say this) is almost TOO rich. Red sauce ones are spot on. I've never had pizza actually in the city of NY, but I'm guessing this is pretty close. read more

Best New York style pizza in Cincinnati. My husband and I drive 15 miles for a slice.

Tried Brooklyn based on reviews, bad idea. Cashier could only find half of our order, went to ask for help which ended in 3 employees insulting each other's heritage. With our full order received we headed home. Upon opening the box the pizza was smashed to the side (not by us) and two Strombolis were smashed into one container. There was nothing special about the pizza, cheese had a lot of filler, toppings didn't taste fresh, you get the idea. Will drive to Antonio's in Westerville or some of the better Powell options going forward. Disappointed... read more

OMG!!! This is the absolute best pizza in all of Ohio!! A true New York style right here in downtown Powell!! If you haven't had this pizza you HAVE to give it a try!! read more

About the closest you are going to get to NY/East Coast style pizza in Columbus!

They didn't close, they just moved across the street. My wife is from New Jersey and this is her favorite pizza place because it's the closest to the New York style she grew up with. read more

We were looking for good pizza as we passed through town an this place won. Awesome crust and flavors it got my three year olds seal of approval an they have awesome customer service. read more

If you want REAL NJ/NY style pie go to Brooklyn Pizza. The name says it all. And they cut the pizza in SLICES! None of that little square stuff (whats up with that)? read more

I had high hopes for this place considering the high star rating and other good reviews. However, me and my husband were both very disappointed. We ordered a pepperoni roll and a medium cheese pizza. The pepperoni roll was fine, not bad, but nothing to write home about. Lacking in some of the cheesy goodness I was hoping for. The pizza was in fact New York style. Thin crust, with some crisp/chew. The issue we had was with the overall flavor. Not much flavor at all. We had ordered an extra side of sauce for dipping bc we like things "saucy" but we didn't really like the sauce. It was very watery, and again no flavor. Pretty much, after I was done eating... I just wanted to go get some more pizza bc this did not hit the spot. read more

Best pizza west of New York. Anthony makes fabulous calzones too. I love the salad with Italian seasoning and artichokes.

This is the best pizza in Powell. My daughter has a dairy allergy and these guys made a pizza with cheese I brought in. Great service and outstanding pizza. read more

Not impressed with this pizza..... Being in the pizza business, I can tell you that all a brooklyn pizza is is a small doughball stretched out to a large..... Ingredients weren't very good on this one. read more

If you are looking for NY pizza you will not find it here.. Tasteless crust, sweet sauce and poor quality cheese.. Employee's are rude. As a native New Yorker from Brooklyn my search for edible pizza in Ohio continues..... read more

Authentic Brooklyn style pizzas in Powell. Cheese and Pepperoni pizzas are really well made. It is primarily a takeaway joint. Friendly staff. The menu is not very exhaustive but their offerings are all very tasty. The service is prompt and the pizzas are delicious. read more

We were extemely disappointed in Brooklyn Pizza, after reading some of the reviews it had gotten. We tried the Margherita and the Brooklyn Deluxe. The Margherita was supposed to have fresh basil on it, but instead had something, I would surmise, was pesto. It didn't look to bad, but it was very, very bland and the crust was as tough as shoe leather. The Deluxe had so many black olives on it, that you couldn't see what the other toppings were. I mean they were literally piled on top of our pie. If this is what "ggod" New York pizza is all about, you can have it. I've tried "east coast style" pizza in a lot of places, even New York city and have never found one I like better than some of our local pizza joints! Kids will eat anything that even looks like a pizza, my kids didn't even like it! In my humble opinion stick with the standbys, Tommy's, Rubino's, Massey's or Plank's on Parsons. You WILL NOT be disappointed! read more

This is our favorite pizza in Columbus. As a former resident of NY, I can say this is authentic NY style pizza with amazing chewy crust. Great service and friendly owner. You must try it. read more

Exceptionally good New York style pizza. Great crust and quality ingredients. Owner is very nice and personable, and the pizza came out perfectly cooked. Also tried their bianca pizza and it was incredible. definitely coming back to this place often. read more

Very good pizza, especially for Powell and central OH in general. Nice owner, does everthing by hand, from NY and used to work in a pizzeria with his father. Pizza is NY style and, as far as pizza goes, is very good. The calzone really shines, it is absolutely delicious and as good any I've had anywhere. If you live in the Powell area, definitely worth trying. read more

Great pizza friendly service. Local fair. As close as you will get to NY pizza in Ohio

Pizza is good and part of our regular rotation. The problem with this shop is that they don't always answer the phone on Friday/Saturday. So be prepared with a back-up option. There are many other pizza joint in Powell with better customer service. read more