Best cheesesteaks around great staff and wonderful Sicilian pizza. I order the same thing every time I go there and it's always fresh..

Got served a cockroach on my sandwich today. When I showed it to them, they said since I took one bite, which I immediately spit it, they didn't owe me a refund or an apology. Unbelievable. read more

Food and service are incredible. The quality has been consistent for many years. I remember enjoying the pizza from Brother's back in the 80's. The pizza is still amazing. read more

The pizza is so delicious with the perfect crust and high quality cheese and pepperoni. They even delivered 7 pies to my son's Nottingham tennis team at Veterans park and on time too. If you pay cash it's also a little cheaper and the friendly Pasquale delivered all the pizza with a smile. read more

ordered meatball parmesan dinner with penne. dinner came with only two meatballs and not parmesan. meal prep took twice as long as was promised. read more

Trying to order pizzas in the area of places I haven't tried before. Decided on this this past Friday. Price is reasonable for a plain pizza. But it was probably the most oiliest pizza I've ever had. The flavor itself was good. But I just couldn't get over the greasiness. read more

The pizza I have found in New Jersey by far Delicious many choices There rolls and subs also excellent read more

Absolute best pizza in central Jersey... maybe even in the state. They sauce has gotta be some secret recipe. I have never tasted anything like it and I am a picky eater. Speaking of picky eater I hate crust but there crust is so golden and crispy. One of the only pizza crusts I will eat. But all the food here is amazing. I also love the Buffalo chicken cheesesteak, eggplant parmigiana, and lasagna. But everything here is delicious. read more

Brothers on Whitehorse has been our go-to pizzeria for years. Actually, my wife grew up here and has been going to Brothers for over 40 years. Me, closer to 20 years. Anyhow, the past year has gotten consistently worse for this establishment. I used to rave about their pizza steak, willing to put it up against any Philly-made cheesesteak out there. Unfortunately, tonight's visit will be our last. $55 for four mediocre sandwiches and soggy fries is just plain disappointing. I hope these guys hop on Yelp and read their reviews so that they can make the necessary corrections and get back to the high quality they were once known for. read more

Pizza is good but the rudeness is not acceptable. I ordered a pizza and was told 20 mins wait. Got there after 25 mins since I hate waiting and was told a few more minutes. Many people came and went - inquired again and was told a few more minutes. I waited a few, asked again, and at this point I will admit had some attitude as its been 45 mins, more than DOUBLE the original amount of time. When pizza was finally done (waited another five minutes) the owner proceeded to yell at me, telling me that they aren't fast food and if I wanted that I can go elsewhere. Well sir you got your wish! read more

I will never go to this place. Once I asked for the center swuare and the moron that took care of me refused and when I said I liked it without the crust he took a burnt part of the Sicilian pie and cut off the crusts. I left. The only reason I went is because someone said they were connected to Brothers on Route 33 where the pizza is better and the service is always outstanding. read more

I returned today for my pizza fix after trying the Italian Hot Dog last week. Here's the breakdown: 1. The crust held firm on both slices, making for crisp points and easy first bites. 2. The underside was nicely singed with black spots, but not so much as to acquire a burnt taste. Definitely, the strongest element of the pie. Very cracker-like. 3. The surfaces of the slices were a bit oily, allowing for a steady drip onto the paper plates on which they were served. 4. The sauce was on the salty side, perhaps from reheating, but not the mildly sweet basil/crushed hot pepper tone I prefer. 5. At $5. for two slices and a small drink, the price was certainly right. I have paid a few bucks more for the same amount at places that don't compare in quality or taste. Conclusion: Not the best pizza in town, but not the worst. Somewhere in the middle of the range for the multitude of pizza shops in Hamilton. When I think pizza, this is not the first place I will think of, but neither will it be the last. When convenience is a factor, it will come out ahead due to proximity to my office. read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

Best pizza place in town hands down. Cheesestakes and buffalo pizza are something else

My parents have enjoyed the pizza from Brother's since moving to Hamilton last year. My mom likes the Brothers special sandwich so this time we ordered that plus the "boneless buffalo chicken". On the phone, the guy said "the boneless wings?"; sure, that's what I assumed they would be anyway. The sandwich was pretty good, we both ate a half and they stuffed it pretty well with the meat, peppers and onions. The chicken, however, was basically chicken fingers smothered in the saltiest, tangiest buffalo sauce I've ever had; not wings, but breaded chicken tenders. On the container it even says "BBW", which I would think means boneless buffalo wings. Since it was breaded, it was disgustingly soggy. We ended up throwing it out because it was inedible. Tl;dr pizza good, special sandwich good, boneless chicken BAD read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Boneless buffalo chicken - aka what they claim to be boneless wings... - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

Ordered a pepperoni half Sicilian it looks like they took the Sicilian off their slice counter and added pepperoni to it very sloppy I would recommend this place to have the best Sicilian unfortunately this time around things were not good not sure why you would risk losing customers over that read more

Good food and service Philly cheesesteak pizza is full of steak and not greasy also their pasta dishes are very filling

Sad again that our order was made wrong again. I spoke to the person on the phone and when we got our order it was wrong. Honestly, there are so many places to go to get Italian food. I called to talk about the mistaken order and was told that they were too busy. Guess what. You won't be too busy for long if you keep screwing up people's orders. Just saying.. read more

I stood there for about five minutes waiting for my order. In that time, the gentleman behind the counter wiped his nose with his hand about ten times. I saw him handling multiple orders and evens few pizza slices, but I never saw him wash his hands. Do with that information what you will, but I have no desire to ever eat food from a place that is so blatantly unsanitary. read more

The service here is extremely poor from m the people at the counter. I have never eaten in so I am not commenting on the waiters and waitresses. read more

I've been going to Brothers for close to thirty years as my childhood home is directly around the corner. We would order Brothers every Friday night from the time I was born til I left for school in the fall of 2002. I would return for summers until I left for Pittsburgh in the fall of 2006. Sometime between leaving for Pittsburgh in 2006, and returning home in 2009, I believe it changed. Not only did they change the awful dining room but I swear they changed the quality of the cheese. It is much greasier than it used to be and it no longer sits well with me. Go with a whole pie for best results as it is especially obvious in the reheated pizza served by the slice. It is still well loved in the area, but I know I am not alone in my opinion and I prefer Nino's on Chambers Street in Trenton, Vitos on Route 33 in Hamilton, Corleone's on Olden Avenue, or of course, Delorenzos. Sorry to be a traitor, but it is what it is. It is no longer the best place in town.. was it ever or was it a case of location bias? I have my answer. Go make up your own mind.... read more

Worst pizza I ever ordered from there, medium garlic pizza is soggy, falling apart and crust sticking to the paper. Very disappointed...

Ok not to be confused with the 1 million other Brother's Pizza places around. This is probably one of the best pizza places ever, and I've been going to this place for about 25 years now. Consistently the best pizza in town, especially when bought by the slice. Their cheesesteak pizza, sicilian, broccoli, and sausage are all great once you get sick of the plain (if that ever happens). Also the prices are not bad at all when compared to other local pizza shops. Did I mention the cheesesteaks and chicken cheesesteaks? Those are off the hook and affordable as welll. unnnhhhhhhhhhh! enjoy read more

So, I am from New York originally and therefore a pizza snob...I have lived in the area for over 8 years and I don't go anywhere else to get pizza. It is always fresh and consistant. Their sauce is amazing, perfect amount of cheese and toppings. The staff is friendly and fast. It is busy as can be on Friday nights so call ahead to place your order and on game day prepare to wait a bit. They don't deliver but I live close enough to not care...I almost didn't post this because I don't want to it to get so busy that I can't get my food!! lol But I am in a sharing mood so you're lucky!! Best pizza hands down in Hamilton even better than the other location on Route 33. read more

Everything was going great this fine Saturday night; after a long day of hiking with my 7 year old, I decided it might be time to try a new place for pizza. Although I normally opt for UNO's Pizzeria for its quality food, today I thought "screw it, I'll try something new." My late mother always told me to expand my horizons and always be willing to roll the dice in life. Initially, my first thought was to read some reviews of this establishment. All looked well - I decided to place an order for a buffalo wings and a pizza with spinach and mushrooms (trying to keep my son healthy!). When I say I have NEVER had pizza so disgustingly bad in my life, gosh darn it I mean it. The pizza looked like someone dumped a hot cup of water on it, punched it repeatedly, and then undercooked it to the point that that cheese didn't even connect to the pie. It's almost like the cheese was a separate entity from the pizza itself. Whoever made this pizza - shame on you! Whoever let this monstrosity leave the doors of that god-forsaken restaurant - I hope you never find peace. You have made my family go hungry tonight since all the businesses are closed due to COVID-19, and you have lost a customer forever. I will only consider eating here again...when Hell freezes over. read more

See all

This is the mothership of all that is good and sacred in this world. If you like NY style pizza, please look no further than this particular pizzeria. I don't care if this means you must travel for hours in order to taste the excellence. But seriously, this is my favorite pizza place, and I am passionate about this particular style of pizza. It's a low key environment, and the pizza is modestly priced. Literally perfect for lunch or a casual dinner. read more

I've tried all the pizza places in town and the combination of crunchy crust, delicious sauce and quality cheese makes this shop the best. My son has dairy allergies and can't have cheese so they make him a cheese-less pizza with crust, sauce and olive oil. My son loves it and I eat it as well. My wife isn't as big a pizza fan as I am and she loves the grilled chicken sub they make. Very fresh and tasty. The people that work there are friendly and very accommodating. Although I never eat in, it seems like a great place to grab a quick bite. If you're looking for quality food and freshness, I recommend Brothers on Whitehorse. read more

Consistently amazing. Friendly service. Never once got sick from their food. Get the Sicilian pie well done with pepperoni. Only your arteries will be sorry. read more

I hate bad pizza....I've been to just about every pizza place in hamilton (there are a lot) but I have to say Brothers was a disappointment. We got a margarita pizza, which was very soggy and had no basil. Pretty tasteless overall. The chicken parm sandwich had barely any sauce and buffalo chicken fingers were bland with hardly any buffalo sauce. The plain pizza looked pretty good so maybe they are better with regular pizza than specialty pizzas but with so many other options in the area we won't be going back. read more

If I could give this three and a half stars I would. The pizza was really delicious. It was kind of weird that I ordered bald black olives and half plain and I only received WHOLE olives on two and a half slices. While the whole olives were awkward to me since I've only ever seen sliced olives, I did enjoy the difference. The crust was good. The cheese was good and the sauce was really good. The pizza itself deserves 4 stars. What's holding this back was is the soggy cheese less oily cheese fries I received. The mozzarella was almost completely melted down to the bottom and the entire bottom of the pan was greasy. They sealed the lid without venting it so the fried turned to all mush. I won't be ordering fries again but I will definitely be ordering the pizza. This location only offers pick up which is fine with me because it's not in a bad location. I will be ordering pizza from here again the next time I'm hungry for it. read more

See all

I like this place but check your food before you leave. I ordered a italian hoagie and when I got home I noticed I got a ham sandwich instead. Same thing with my pie I asked for mushrooms and peppers and got mushrooms, pepperoni and sausage but no peppers. Two meats on one pie is not my thing... I'm a a one meat type of guy ya know. read more

What can I say? It's my favorite pizza in the area without all of the hype. When you look into their eyes, you will see the abyss, but they make a hell of a pizza. read more

Worth stopping in!! I had a training down in Hamilton and ended up at Brothers by chance. My colleague & I both enjoyed the food. Simple pizza place with pretty adequate seating and dining area. It was pretty packed for lunch time, so that makes me think the pizza is pretty damn good. Neither of us got pizza though, I ordered the Grilled chicken Salad which i thought was really good. the chicken was moist and flavorful, they had peppercinis in the salad, a favorite of mine! I was pretty impressed by a simple chicken salad. I wouldve loved to try the pizza...but maybe another time! read more

Pizza is great. The employee who took my order needs to speak up. Couldn't understand him. Otherwise atmosphere and food are pretty good.

We order from this location at least once a month. They have quality pizza. You can't go wrong with their plain slice.

Ordered two pies, a white with 1/2 broccoli and a pepperoni pizza. It was very tasty pie . Little pricey but the pie is good so I'm ok with that. Only wished they delivered! read more

We love Brother's brooklyn pie, but when we ordered a bunch of cheesteaks and pies for a party, picked them up, the order was wrong. Asked for onions on the side, but discovered that every steak sandwich had onions on it when we got them home. When we called, we were told to bring them back if we wanted new cheese steaks. That seemed ridiculous to me. As if we were lying about the onions and they wanted proof they were on there only to toss them in the trash?? Went back and got new sandwiches so they made it right but wasted a lot of our time away from our guests making two trips. Will give them another try maybe in the future, maybe not. There are many other pizza places with similar menus in Hamilton. read more

This place has the best sicilian pizza ever. No question about it. Try the pepperoni, they use the authentic chunky kind. They are making some improvements to the outside, hopefully the inside gets some tLC too.! read more

With the 300 other Brothers Pizza around this town and state THIS one is simply the best. They have the best pizza and I have tried them all. They also make a great calzone and cheese steak. read more

This is the only Brothers Pizza in Hamilton that you should be going to. Great pie, and food. My favorite part is that they will make you just about anything you like. I happen to be a fan of chicken cheese steaks on garlic bread and they make it awesome here! I'm a big fan and I highly recommend this spot! read more

They make the best Cheesesteak Pizza. Been going to this place for years.