The fried catfish and shrimp are good. Decent portion size friendly staff. They prepare the food as quick as they can.

Okay so I'm so excited to make this review I had a wonderful experience today in which was my first time at Brothers Seafood. It's located not too far from the big mall, after doing some shopping I was referred by a man named Derrick that the food here is phenomenal. It's a neighborhood favorite so happy for the referral because me and my princess enjoyed. Food: 3 Shrimp, 3 Fish, Fries 11$ special you can't be that it was so fresh and soooo yummy. You gotta make sure you add the dipping sauces...mambo sauce, sweet chili sauce...so yummy, hot sauce & tartar sauce. Perfection Crab Mac- 14$ it wasn't what I expected taste wise as I'm pretty picky when it comes to Mac and cheese...the portion size and not being able to taste the crab meat but got a lot of boil sauce flavor. The price makes it pretty steep...I wouldn't get it again but might just not be my cup of tea. What really captivated me was the service it was phenomenal...felt like family and all love. So much love was spread that good convos spread regarding androids vs iPhones a lot of laughs. #Teamiphone... the same women who started the convo helped bring my food over felt so much love and even payed for my meal. I was beyond grateful for the love, ambiance & the amazing workers Leo & Omar. They know how to serve good food and good hospitality I would definitely come back here hands down...can't wait to try other things from the menu like the salmon bites , the drinks as well as other specials Thank you for the experience Blessings, Zen read more

See all

Wow! My bf found this place on Ubereat's and we were not disappointed. I didn't even wanna stop eating and I was already full lol. I can't wait to order from here or even dine in! I def. want to try their other dishes. This restaurant needs their recognition. Only thing I didn't like was when I called and asked if they had garlic butter sauce.. I was told to put it in the notes of the Uber eats order and it will be given to me. So thankfully they didn't forget to give me ranch dressing(even though I asked for blue cheese) so I could dip my seafood and wings in them! read more

See all

Two stars because I can taste Old Bay and arrival on time. I'm not a fan of tardiness myself. One thing I'm a fan of, getting what I pay for. $3 for a side of macaroni and cheese that look like someone gave me the rest of their lunch. Fish arrived warm and broken up. I guess if you're a caveman this would be alright but I work hard for my money and this is wrong. I wouldn't recommend this at all. Like I'm very upset that I've spent money on flavorless food. Don't want your restaurant? I love to cook! read more

Brothers Seafood - Fish (Whiting) - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

See all

This used to be great now it's just incredibly greasy fish that looks like it was fried to perfection, but actually it's a big ol grease bomb. They used to have turkey wings which were great but I assume that's too much work. A decently deliciously fried fish is tough to come by in the area. I did enjoy the streamed veggies but I didn't trek here for the broccoli. read more

3 stars??? How in the world? Anyway, I'm giving 5 stars, one extra for the audacious 3 stars overall rating! I can ALWAYS count on Brothers for well seasoned fried seafood (haven't tried the broiled or boiled options) I usually get the flounder & chips... sometimes when I'm feeling extra greedy I'll add on fried shrimp as well. I don't eat fried food often, and sometimes after eating it from other places I instantly feel like my arteries are clogged and the guilt sets in. Not when I eat Brothers. Not saying their fried offerings are healthier, but it sure doesn't taste as heavy or salty, so that's a PLUS. Add some of their homemade made tartar, ketchup, and hot sauce...baby lemme tell you something: Best GUILTY PLEASURE for the month. The owner/chef is super cool & accommodating, and easy on the eyes too. Oh, forgot to mention they're reasonably priced, very reasonable. It's dark inside, very hole in the wall style, but please don't be fooled. The place is CLEAN and the food is fresh...and that's on what? Mary had a lil lamb lol. read more

MY GO-TO fish spot whenever I am in the Bronx! Fresh, well-seasoned, large portions for great prices. The sauces are not to be slept on as well. The mambo sauce is my favorite on fish, shrimp, clams, fries lol. read more

I frequently go here for lunch because it is right across the street from my job and has great lunch options for only six bucks! Steamed seafood options are the main food options here but they also have started to offer turkey wings (smoked and jerked) which I have not yet tried. I always get the steamed baby shrimp with mixed vegatables and I have tried the steamed salmon but was not a fan. They use frozen salmon which I am not a fan of. I have also tried the fried whiting which has greatly improved since I first had it at this restaurant. I cant say its the best seafood Ive had but it is the best in this neighborhood and everything Ive seen them serve is fresh. 3/2/13 - Finally tried the jerk turkey wings today and was so glad I did. They were a bit on the spicy side but very good and they even came with two sides for a total of $6.50. Great lunch deal. read more

Brothers Seafood - Menu - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

This is not my first ordering from Brothers Seafood on Walton Ave but it certainly will be my last! Your menu should state, Catfish Nuggets. The sweet potato fries are burnt and why does my broccoli look like the corona virus? The half chicken wingettes, really? Pandemic or not when you get an order for $50 your food presentation needs to be better than this and you should at least give a freaking soda! I'm Done and FINISHED!!! UH UH!!!!!!!!! Your pictures do not reflect what I received. Is Old Bay the only spice you have? This is what happens when you patronize the Brothers! This shit was WHACK! So back to my kitchen I go. I was tired of cooking and hadn't ordered from here in a while. Y'all fell the fuck off, all the way! What happened to you? ‍‍‍‍‍‍‍ read more

See all

I ordered food from this restaurant from Uber eats, the food was delicious.. I had the fried lobster tails with the 5 chicken wings and French fries. Everything was delicious read more

If I could give it zero stars I would.. I am a pescatarian and love flavorful shellfish and this is definitely not good. Just taste like oldbay potatoes corn and broccoli taste like it was blanched in water and thrown in plate ‍ read more

Brothers Seafood - 2. Baby Shrimp with Steamed Vegetables Specia - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

See all

Delivery from here is always slow and I can overlook that because the delivery guy is always courteous and apologetic. As for the food, I was given a rotten corn on the cob! It was brown on one side and placed in the tray with the rotten side down so it wasn't noticeable until I picked it up to eat it. Not only did they serve me rotten food but they tried to hide it! Never again will I order from here! read more

Brothers Seafood - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

I ordered on 4/17/20, the ordered was delivered to my job and this is what I received......i wouldn't even feed this to my worse enemy. Now what your looking at is the catfish and four piece shrinp..... you guys should never ever serve something like this to any customer. I dont understand how you cut shrimp in two, and instead of catfish I got fried pieces of batter basically read more

Brothers Seafood - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

This place really came through for a fight night party we hosted on May 2nd. We ordered 60 pieces of fried whiting and it was delish! The fish was still crispy by the time we drove it home. The trick, the placed bread throughout the pan. Who knew? Nice trick. The fish was a hit and we told our guests to visit as soon as they could. Definitely a diamond in the rough. read more

Brothers Seafood - New menu - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

See all

Honestly i didn't expect the food to be all that but trust me when he handed me my plate I was like . I got the fried combo with fish, shrimp, and fries , can't forget the sauce. I would've posted a pic but that plate got demolished real quick!!!! Prices aren't bad also read more

Good but cud be better fast delivery Nd order but missed one item on a 60 $ order gotta do better business

I have ate fish at plenty fish and shrimp but by far ... AWESOMEI LOVE THEY FOOD . I don't what they put in it . But its is absolutely gold . You can smell the season outside. The fish and shrimp are huge Pleasant to be in and eat . Nice and cool ....I am going back to BROOKLYN . Make 1 hour to get this fish & shrimp read more

Brothers Seafood - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

I ordered the whiting (which was actually ling) Yes I know my seafood while fried hard it wasn't seasoned well and smelled off. The crab cakes were bland and tasted a little off too. First and the last time I'll order. read more

I work across the street from Brother's Seafood and have been eating the food here since they opened and have never been disappointed when trying something that I haven't had from them yet and today was no different. I had crab cakes with collard greens and seafood rice.....everything was perfectly seasoned making it a delicious meal and it didn't take long for my meal to be made. The place is clean and the staff is friendly. Keep up the good work . read more

Absolutely love the seafood here. I used to come here as a kid all the time and get two orders for myself.. every time. The restaurant is definitely not much to look at. Its a hole-in-the-wall local joint. But i think I've always liked that about it. Gives it a kind of charm. Long story short; Great food. Fresh selection. Super decent pricing. I can't complain. read more

I so wanted to like this place. I've been passing by for a few years now, and decided to give them a try. This is my first time placing an order and I used the Eat 24 app. They botched the order, but I'm willing to give them another chance. Items were missing from my order. The restaurant says they added "extra" shrimp and fish to the items that were delivered, since some items weren't available. Ummmm...no you didn't. The 14 piece shrimp order still only had 14 pieces of shrimp. Same for the 5 piece shrimp and fish order. $13 is too much money to overlook for items not delivered. Thankfully the fish and shrimp were not overly salty. The problem is, they were bland, no flavor at all. I'm going to give this place another shot, but I'll go in next time as opposed to ordering through a delivery app. Maybe the flavor of the food missed the mark because it was almost time for them to close. read more

I'm not a fan of package wrap seafood not good to me the place is Kool n they have other things to choose read more

Brothers Seafood - Salmon shrimp n veggies heavy seasoned with Idk but he said it oldbay - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

See all

My first order they didn't so well , I ordered by uber eats ... tonight I decided to give them another chance with the salmon and shrimps with veggies. It was amazing . It was a good amount of food . On my first order they gave me half of my fish filet but now they gave me the right amount of salmon and shrimps . Thank you I will order again soon . read more

Brothers Seafood - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

This hidden gem gets five stars because the food is great and service is also great. Your treated very good and the employees are very friendly. I was told about this place two weeks ago and I must say I visit it at least 3 times a week. I've had the steam salmon with vegetables and also whiting fish with fries and they both great. They do deliver which is good. If you want to eat good seafood at a LOW PRICE head to brothers. read more

See all

Super delicious. First time ordering for this restaurant. Food was prepared perfectly accompanied with tasty sauces. I recommend!

I was in the mood for seafood and craving some steamed salmon so I went on Door Dash and found this place. They had a 4.4 star review and so I ordered 3 whiting fried fish with chips platters for my kids and steamed salmon with veggie for myself. I placed the order at 5:49 PM today 5/8/20 with an ETA of 7:14 PM. The delivery came on time but when I opened my food I noticed the salmon(if in fact that's what it was because it sure didn't taste like it) had some white slimy stuff on it. To wait nearly 2 hours for this was unacceptable. My kids food was good but mine was awful :-( I don't think I'll be ordering again. read more

The best fresh seafood in the area. Good Hood eats. You name it they have it. Get the whiting and chips! read more

Brothers Seafood - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Their food is good. Some things are salty Turkey wings delicious. The guy answering the phone is just full of game. Tried ordering but Yelp wouldnt allow me to. I called he said they were not doing deliveries because the delivery guy just left to go home.. I said okay. He then asked where I lived because he could send the guy to me on his way home and hed five him the money then next day. Just weird. Not rude at all.. just weird. Anyway. My 1st order was messed up they forgot something took over an hour to send the delivery guy back.. the 2nd time I attempted to ider the above story happened. Decent food but not for me. read more

Great little lunch spot! Had steamed salmon with veggies, and potatoes! It was out of this world good, and you can't beat the price!! I will definitely be returning soon! read more

They are the little restaurant every neighborhood needs. The fried whiting are my favorite, with some tarter sauce and hot sauce yum!!! Good customer service as well. We don't want to see places like this go away, so show some local support. Thanks for the good energy and great food Brother's Seafood. - Your friendly neighbors *No I'm not a paid actor read more

Ordered for the first time via GrubHub and even with delivery the food was delicious. My husband, daughter and I all ordered something different and each meal was equally good (we ordered a variety of shrimp, salmon, crab and veggies). We will definitely order from there again and I cannot wait to visit in person. read more

This is the second time I've ordered from this place, in hopes, that the second time would've been better... WRONG! Please DO NOT EVER EAT HERE!!! The Mac and cheese is very bland! Literally no cheese through the macaroni. I did give one star for the yams.. they were the only good thing, the 1st time.... however good yams don't make up for HAIR IN THE FOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Actual hair fried into the shrimp (picture attached)! I am literally appalled! Disgusted and I literally will never in my life eat here again. read more

Brothers Seafood - Hair fried in the shrimp. - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Every single time I order through uber eats they call me less than two minutes later telling me that they don't have what I ordered and that they can give me an alternative . If this was the case then they should make it unavailable to order . I gave 3 stars because when they made the first mistake the food was actually delicious and put me in a coma . read more

Absolutely disgusting and bland the yams tasted very old and the mac and cheese definitely lacked cheese and flavor the shrimp was okay because it naturally has its on flavor but overall terrible read more

Brothers Seafood - Seafood Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

I ordered the catfish and fries. Only complaint is that the coating on the fish was more salty than I like and the fries were not crispy and a little oily. I also had the steamed shrimp and vegetables, again more salty than I like and the vegetables was steamed to much and were soft but, the mix of vegetables created a good flavor. The portions were ok for the price. read more

Fast delivery good food and fair servings! Steamed salmon is a little over seasoned but still yummy. Also, I do wish the collards were cut up (I'm a food snob ), but it still goes down yummy. NONETHELESS, with the more than reasonable prices they offer you can't really complain about the little things. I Recommend this establishment to seafood lovers. read more

Absolute worst Mac & cheese! Tasted minty! Creamy instead of cheesy! Cat fish wasn't fresh, must of been frozen fish strips!!!! Yams? Smh & I'm pregnant & was starving so I'm extra disappointed!!! read more

For starters the can of ginger ale was dirty. It was caked all around the rim with what appeared to be ink or motor oil. Even after rinsing & scrubbing there was still leftover residue. The rice & peas that I got was so dry & stale. I literally spit it out as soon as I put it in my mouth. I mean I don't know how you can screw up RICE of all things. I got a turkey leg which had a bizarre & unappetizing grayish/pink tint to it. Just tasted kinda sour & funny. The collard greens were just bitter & sad looking. It's always very apparent to me when a business takes pride in what they do. It's very clear how far they missed the mark. Avoid this place like the plague. read more

Food is great and the customer service is great deff. somewhere you would order to go from though. I also like the juices they make very good. I recommend this place to eat. read more

This food is soooo good that I live at least 30 minutes away and I tried to order via UberEats and for some reason it wouldn't work so Instead I got dressed, called a Uber (in a snow storm) and went to go get the food. My husband and I ordered from here about 4 years ago and have been saying that we have to go back again. We had it today again for the 1st time in over 4 years and I must say that I was VERY VERY VERY SATISFIED! The food was DELICIOUSSS! The seasoning on the shrimp and the catfish was AMAZING! If I had to critique one thing it would be that the fries were more oily than crispy. But everything else was AMAZING! Even the tartar sauce was A1! Next time I have to try the steamed seafood and vegetables. read more