I entered into this establishment because a friend recommended it. They asked if I wanted a sample. Ah, yes please! Then, I fell in love with what I put into my mouth ~ pecan cookie! I bought the tower special for $20, as they said it's all their most popular cookies in it. I can't wait! read more

Best cookies in town .. any town for that matter Parking is on the street so you might have to do a lap or 2 to find something but def worthy of the effort read more

These are different cookies but they are yummy, especially with a hot cup of coffee. Someone likened them to the Pepperidge Farms Chessman cookies and I am not seeing that comparison at all. If I were to compare them to anything they remind more of a Pan de Polvo cookie at least in texture. The cookies are very crumbly when you bite into them so they definitely can get a little messy. I like that the flavors kind of hit you in layers. The original was my favorite. Just simple flavors. You get the brown sugar up front and then you notice the buttery flavor and then the saltiness. Even the crumbly texture adds to the taste sensation of the cookies. We also tried the Almond flavor, which was good but very subtle, and the Coconut Lime. I would say the Coconut Lime was my least favorite because of the tiny bits of coconut in them. I'm just not a fan of the texture of coconut. I didn't think I would like the lime but that was the part I actually did like about the cookie. They are still practicing COVID safety measures even though it's a hit or miss in regard to who is or isn't in the town so it's hard to figure out what safety measures you are supposed to follow from shop to shop. They only let you step a couple feet into the shop and masks are required. There are no tastings at this time due to COVID either. We ordered our cookies off of recommendations from other people. It is a fairly popular shop, enough that tourists and locals alike will send you to visit the store when you ask for recommendations of where to go. I would definitely recommend giving them a try. They do have a four flavor pack but with all our wine tasting I think I killed off the brain cells that had stored how much we paid for the cookies because now I can't remember! I do remember not being surprised at the price so I believe they are pretty much in line with most places that sell specialty cookies. Definitely give them a try! read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

The dude and I saw this place and had to give this place a shot on 01/11/21 as we took a small getaway to Paso Robles. I wish we could enter the store but the lady, owner, worker is stationed at the door. I did peak inside the store as it would have been so cute to explore. The lady wasn't too friendly and my questions weren't too hard. I just asked for recommendations as it was my first time here with the love too. So I didn't know what to expect or anything. I believe the flavors are just using "extracts" so the almond cookies I got didn't have real almond pieces in it just an extract. The other flavors appeared to be the same. The packaging was very cute too! I got a pack for my nieces and I wanted to try them out so I got almond. The experience was quick so this review will be short. The experience wasn't memorable at all but the Almond Extract cookies were delicious the did and I nearly ate all of them! They definitely has a nice buttery almond crunch to it. My nieces didn't like the cookies at all! Which was a bummer as we did enjoy them. I would recommend they are very tasty and hard to put down! read more

See all

Wanted to try this cookies for a while. Finally came here and saw they had a few different flavors. The cashier gave me a sample of the original flavor and thought it was good. Decided to buy a 3-pack of the orinal and a 3-pack of the seasonal cookies. Once, I got back to my hotel I ate one of the original cookies and thought it was too dry and salty. Didnt like it as much as i did with the sample. Unfortunately I would have to pass on coming back here. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

We got to try this place when we were in the paso downtown area and I'm so glad I did! If you are looking for a unique cookie shop for butter cookies this is the spot for you. Our Airbnb gave us some cookies from here and I'm so glad we got to get more! We ended up getting the original flavored cookies and they were delicious. These are small and on the crumbly side but go really well with a coffee. Would recommend to try if in the area! read more

Who can pass up a cookie?? Stopped in Paso Robles to walk around on my way back to the Bay Area and happened upon this cute cookie shop. Their displays were eye-catching and the cookies looked delicious, so I had to go in. I don't think the cookies are baked at this location; didn't smell the aroma of fresh baking anywhere! Regardless, they had a good variety available and several bags of day old cookies at half price! I got two bags (lemon sugar and oatmeal raisin, 6 cookies in each for $9 a bag) and 3 fresh ginger molasses ($3 each cookie). The cookies were all delicious; chewy and flavorful. Good thing they're so far away from me! read more

See all

Changing this review to 5 stars after having a life changing honey cookie from here. I don't think I realized they had cookies besides their little shortbread like nugs. I noticed a chewy looking honey cookie near the register and decided to add it to my order. They were DELICIOUS!! They were so incredibly chewy and filled with the most wonderful flavor. I will be back to get these regular style cookies. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

My best friend and I ended up here because the barbecue place we wanted to try was closed on Monday and this was the second barbecue place we'd gone to that day to discover they were closed. Anger rising! I was being a baby and crying about how we needed to check Yelp for store hours. As we looked for another place, she recognized BBC and had been to here before and swore by their cookies, so she ran in to get a bag to quell my anger. I was on the fence because my friend is a diabetic, so the food she has access to makes me cringe out of fear that her taste buds are reset based on her diet. Using almond flour instead of flour? That means they're almond cookies, right? I'm not that crazy about almond, so I held my nose as I tried it. The fear was replaced with relief. The cookies were kinda cakey, but crispy too. There were little crystals of salt and you could taste the brown butter which I love, and the almond flavor that was subtle enough to complement the flavor without truly being a mere almond cookie. Anger subsided. She got me a pack of eight cookies which were a lot of cookies and lasted me a few days. Glad I got to try them and won't be mad if I get lost again in SLO because it means I'll get Brown Butter Cookies. read more

I have to say I must go on a diet after my short visit to Paso Robles, but holy cow! These cookies! SOOO good! Unfortunately, I only tried one of the many types of cookies they offer. The original cookie is a tiny bit of heaven. A shortbread like cookie that melts in your mouth. The tastes of butter and brown sugar are distinct as is the little bits of salt. Yes, salt. The three flavors blend so perfectly I could not believe it. Against my better judgement, I was full, I ate this cookie! YOLO, life is short, eat dessert first. Well, do not miss out on this spot. The COVID protocols are extremely impressive here as well. They have a plastic screen protector at the front entrance. Underneath is a box where they place your purchase. I wish I would have taken a picture of it. Regardless, Highly recommended cookie store! Cheers and happy eating!! read more

See all

Came here during Covid. They sell their cookies at the door and after you pay you pick it up under the door in a shelf. Contactless. They do not sell individual cookies at the moment just packs of 3, 6 and 12 of a single flavor. This is your not typical cookies, instead of being flat cookies they are shaped in as a mound. I prefer my cookies with crispy edges and chewy in the middle. These cookies were pretty hard but not hard that it hurts when you take a bite. I ordered the original flavor and cinnamon. It was flavorful and I did finish most because I had to share. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

When we went wine tasting our host suggested we try Brown Butter Cookie and I have to say it did not disappoint. They had samples of the classic sea salt cookies, which I am grateful for because I did not even know where to begin. There are quite a lot of options to choose from. I got a pack of six which was great to keep around our Airbnb when we wanted a sweet treat. It was a hit for my husband as well! read more

This is the 2nd location I have visited. The one in Cayucas is the only one that carries peanut butter cookies! I was disappointed. I bought oatmeal raisin instead. They were pretty good and soft. read more

Friendly staff and got a free sample. Bought a three pack of cookies (the cocoa ones). It was a bit pricey for how small the cookies are.

The shortbread cookies were really good. There was a woman passing out samples and that is when I discovered how good the shortbread cookies are. Also, the frozen custard was nice. read more

I really love cookies. I'm like a Cookie Monster of sorts. I especially love shortbread and sweet. However, I did not love Brown Butter. I went out of my way to go here after a friend suggested it on my long drive through California. Everything was double pre packaged for covid, no samples. I went with my gut and got cinnamon and the seasonal bourbon. Bourbon was very strong and burny. Cookies are very crumbly like wet sand. The cinnamon was flavorful as well but something is off. Loved the building they are in, loved the presentation. Won't remember the cookies. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

Cookies are definitely different $8 for 6 little cookie drops something you don't want to get in the habit of.. the taste as soon as you bite the cookies it falls apart in your mouth and melts away it leaves like granules I guess it would be the brown sugar. The flavors you get when it first goes in your mouth it's strong like the coco but then it's not strong you definitely need Althing to wash it down with.. I wish they had a special like buy 3 or 4 bags and get one free.. read more

See all

I'm so happy I happened to find this place while taking a break on my road trip. I absolutely love these cookies! My favorite flavors are the original, cocoa mint, and cocoa, but you can sample any and all the flavors before deciding what you want to buy. They're pretty small (almost bite-sized), but so worth it. They're flavorful and soft and just crumble in your mouth. If you happen to stop by on a Friday at the Paso Robles location, they sell these amazing honey cookies (6 for $7.50). They're chewy throughout with the perfect balance of sweet and salty. If you're in the area and want something sweet, I would definitely recommend checking this place out! read more

Brown Butter Cookie - honey cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

I usually LOVE brown butter cookies, but to be honest these were way way too sweet. I bought a pack of 2 large snickerdoodle cookies and a bag of 3 small brown butter cookies. When I first entered the store, I was offered a small sample of the flat brown butter cookies which I thought were good in a small quantity, but unfortunately as a whole cookie it was really overwhelming. There's also a weird taste to the taste of the sugar. Maybe stevia? Unsure. Also for the price point - it's really expensive and not good. As a constructive criticism, maybe there can be multiple sugar levels read more

I have a new addiction. What started as just another shop we wandered into while exploring picturesque downtown Paso Robles turned into one of the town's highlights. It's just a cookie, right? Well, think again. The spacious and beautiful store located in a historic building across from the park was closed off due to COVID, so that just meant we had to get right down to business. We went with a six pack of their classic cookies and enjoyed them while wandering around. Each hit was heaven. The combination of rich butter, sweetness and a hint of sea salt was divine. The cookies are soft and rich, more like shortbread, but that was totally fine with us. Eat with caution. If they were closer to me I'd get more. I think I'll go see if they ship now! read more

See all

I love this cookie store Not cheap but delicious cookies Every time come to Paso Robles Buy it Not cheap!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Limited selection of sweets and not very good at that. Normally I like shortbreads but the chocolate shortbreads we purchased were not very sweet and also tasteless. read more

I have to give an honest review. Over priced cookies and I will not come back. The gluten-free cookies were not for me. The chocolate chip were okay. The price for 1-day-old cookies is 10 dollars a pack. Regular price 20 dollars? I got charged 30 dollars. The staff is friendly but expensive cookies. I would instead go to Cambria Village and get a brownie with walnuts at Red Moose Cookie Company. read more

See all

Perhaps I stopped by on an off day, but the cookie sample I tried was not good at all. It looked like a raw piece of cookie dough and the texture when bitten into was a crumbly mess. I'm not sure if I ate the same cookies that others purchased or what, but since the staff was busy making cookies, I didn't really get a chance to ask questions or try anything beyond what was initially offered. read more

3.5 stars. As long as you are aware that this is a packaged cookie place, then you can adjust your expectations accordingly. There are no cookies coming fresh and warm out of the oven available for purchase here. Cookies are all at room temperature and packaged. We purchased the 3 pack brown butter sea salt original cookies and a classic sweet and salty sugar cookie. Both cookies were good and they were texturally different. The first cookie had more of a gritty, crumbly texture. The latter was like a regular cookie. They provided cookie samples before purchase. read more

I know the Brown Butter Cookies are delicious in their own right but the Oatmeal Raisin Cookies are what do it for me. All I can say is if that cookie was a woman I'd propose! They are she'd be pregnant that night good read more

Do not be deceived by the name! I LOVE brown butter, especially in cookies but don't think you're getting a homemade variety of delicious cookies. If you like store bought chessman Pepperidge farm cookies buy those instead, they're a lot cheaper & taste better! And they weren't friendly, they acted like they were doing us a favor selling us blah cookies. What a disappointment! read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Original - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

These cookies are pretty tasty! They're pricy though. 1 bag of 3 one flavored cookies for 3.75? So a little over a dollar for a cookie and they are super small. But they still get a 4 because they're super tasty. We got the almond, cocoa, espresso, and cinnamon. My favorite is the almond! Would recommend if you're in downtown Paso. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

We love this place. We travel through this area several times a year and always stop in to buy cookies for ourselves and as gifts for friends. Service is fantastic and the cookies are the best read more

Planned to come here before heading to Field of Lights to pick up some goodies for people and to try ourselves. Really easy to order up front and the staff was super friendly. We bought two 6 packs of the original flavor. Which ended up being $15. Omgoodness. Super pricey tbh especially because the cookies are tiny. Decided to munch on some in the beautiful park. It is the texture of danish butter cookies. You will definitely get some crumbs on your lap from these. A lil too salty for us in the end. Only came here thanks to a travel blog I read up on. It is in a nice area and the park was nice to chill at. I'd rather buy 5 trays of oreos for that price. Very nice young lady in the front though. Very sweet. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Original flavor $7.50 - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

I make sure to stop in anytime we're in Paso! Absolutely delicious and unique cookies. The staff is always very friendly.

The cookies are scrumptious! Easily this would have been five stars except for the rude and condescending staff person. I am a very easy going person and I was just really appalled about how we were treated. I know that staffing is an issue, but we were the only ones in the shop at the time and it was very apparent that they didn't want us to be there. read more

Cute boutique cookie shop in a somewhat foodie downtown retail area. Had lunch in the area, did a little wine tasting and ran into this little gem. I usually don't go out of my way for most desserts/anything sweet, but I am fond of cookies. Well good cookies. Enter Brown Butter Cookies. So when walking by, I literally stopped then scooted back a few steps to their door. I was compelled to go in. Upon entering I was quite smitten. I knew it was super local and super small biz. Even though it wasn't the type of cookie shop that I was anticipating, I knew I wasn't going to leave empty handed. They really only make 3-6 types of cookies here, but in those few, they change the flavors around. Their main cookie here is a shortbread type of cookie. It is more fat disc than flat. It is tiny like 1.5 - 2 bites. It is dryish and pretty crumbly, which is why I have never really been a fan of the shortbread style. Unless it is with tea or coffee then it much more doable. But to their credit here, their shortbread is legit-ly buttery. They will have this style in many flavors from coffee to cinnamon to almond. The cookies here also aren't cheap. It's very boutique in pricing as well. I think I bought 3 bags, 6 cookies/bag and it was a little over $20. But the cookie here that really stole my heart was a flat butter cookie. Honey Cookie as I think it was named. It has a subtle crisp on the bottom which I always love. The interior was crazy chewy, almost meaty but still being pretty thin, which I've never seen. Usually thicker cookies are the chewy ones. I think this is where the honey kicks in. Then the flavor was an intense toffee flavor which I can only assume is from browning butter, hence their name. I love the flavor of browned butter, it intoxicates me. Then they lace the cookie with a scant of sea salt, so it gives off bursts of salted toffee/caramel and really sends this into OMG status. Quite addictive. Unfortunately they don't sell that flatter honey cookie online cuz it is more time sensitive supposedly. Too bad cuz I would order the heck out of it. But probably for the better as I'm sure my waistline is better for it. Boo to sensibility. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Take Home Goods - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

A charming cookie spot that offers you samples! Cookies are buttery, salty, all good!

Melt in your mouth cookies! I've been to the location in Paso and Cayucos, both are lovely. The folks working there are all very friendly a d keep it very clean...super important! The originals are my favorite, but the cocoa and coconut lime are yummy too! Treat yourself or a loves one to some deliciousness read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Original and cocoa..always wrapped nicely. - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

Decided to check out this shop after seeing how cute the shop was from across the street. The woman was helpful and patient when we asked her for recommendations and pricing. She took our order from the front of the store due to COVID restrictions. We chose the seasonal citrus cookies which were okay. They had a citrusy flavor with a kick of cayenne. The ingredients were clearly listed which I appreciate. However the price was pretty high for 6 small cookies. I wish we could have ordered one of each flavor, but there was no option for that. Overall, this was a cute place to check out in Paso Robles, but it was a one time occasion for me personally. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Seasonal citrus cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

Come in and try the cookies. Of course once you sample it, you are hooked. I mean who can resist butter. The cookies literally crumble and melt in your mouth. The best part is they are not too sweet. Also no eggs which is a plus for my vegetarian peeps. Unfortunate the butter exclude the vegan people. They have cookie package in all sizes but also sell individual cookies. Pretty much you are paying 1.25 per cookies - doesn't matter how much you buy. read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

I bought a variety of their cookies but my favorites were the almond and original. The cookies are buttery, crumbly, shortbread goodness that melts in your mouth. Worth a trip if you are in downtown even if a tad pricey! read more

Brown Butter Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Paso Robles, California

My coworker recently brought these back from Paso, and I totally forgot about this gem. The original shortbread cookie is my favorite! It's delicately sweet and buttery, with the perfect crumble. The espresso cookie however, was a little too salty for me. Tip #1: 3 locations! Cayucos, Paso Robles, and San Louis Obispo Tip #2: You can order these cookies online! read more

The cookies are very good! Though the new flavors are not very desirable. I also heard the round shape is changing to a square shape for packaging purposes. And I don't know why they discontinued the almond flavored cookies, that was one of their most popular flavors. I would start listening to your customers, that is why you became successful in the first place. read more