We really enjoyed this place. I had the barbecue sandwich and fries and my husband had the one eyed…read moreburger. Both were very tasty. Service was excellent. I'll eat here again.

Pretty grungy place. Old 80s bar. Greasy food and for me, turned out very expensive. Soda tasted…read morepretty bad too. Would not return.

Really appreciated their expansive GF menu. Prices are high…read morebut quality is good. Service is attentive.

Excellent bar great food! So many beers to choose from too. They were so kind and brought my wife…read moreout a celebration dessert on the house for her naturalization celebration.

I'm so sad, man. My wife is a lifelong Virginian who has been to this place many times in the past…read moreand spoken so highly of it every time. We even went together probably almost ten years ago and loved it! So we were in the area tonight and decided, of course, to hit up Boylan Heights for dinner, remembering it as fondly as we did. But I ended up...really disappointed by this visit. First of all, it was super busy, very crowded, and very loud - that's kinda to be expected out of a college sports bar though. The servers were all doing their best, and everybody was really nice! But then I ordered one of their pre-mixed drinks from the bar, and had to end up asking after it about 20 minutes later when it hadn't made it to my table. I was told it got lost in the mix of everything, which I do understand because as I mentioned before, it was busy. So I just said that's cool, I don't need it, I'll just have a root beer instead. 10 minutes later and the server comes to the table with lightly-tinted soda water, very apologetically telling me that's what's coming out and they need to change the bag. I'm autistic and overstimulated at this point so I just say no, water is fine. And that was a little ehh, but the food was absolutely the most disappointing part of this experience. I ordered a burger with bacon and cheese and their curly fries on the side...the fries were barely warm, and not a single element of the burger was seasoned. It was offensively bland, and on top of that, the bacon was floppy. Burger was undercooked as well (menu says they're cooked to medium well, it was about medium rare). I took 2 bites and was totally done. It's really a shame because you can tell the quality of the ingredients is good, but the execution was just kind of embarrassing. Like...salt and pepper the meat at least, please, c'mon. The milkshake was pretty good, though. This place is an institution, but I think it's leaning a little too hard on that reputation and has let the quality of its food slip.

Had a great dinner here with my niece and my sister during college orientation. The space opened…read moretheir doors so there was a lot of fresh air. The weather was perfect for it too. They gave us menus and scantron-like menus to circle in the build-your-own burgers & bowls. That was pretty cool. I chose my chicken sandwich and gave it to the waitress. My sister ordered the boozy milkshake and my niece ordered a regular one. They really liked them! My chicken sandwich was so good! I got the curly fries with it and they were super delish too. My sister got loaded tots which were sooo good. I only with they had pickled jalapeño for them instead of fresh. The fresh were just too much (& I love spice). All in all - solid place to eat!

Went down to see my brother and wanted one of his favorite spots. He said he liked the burgers at…read morethis downtown spot and decided to give it a try. This bar was serving up classic bar food like burgers and wings. They make them good here - no fancy sauce or toppings, but just a good solid burger with fresh ingredients. Pair it with a pitcher of beer to wash it all down! Apps: Wings Entrees: Burgers Sides: Fries

I came here on a Wednesday night around 9:30pm for some dinner with my sister and friend. We got…read morelucky with getting a table because a group just left, you seat yourself. Our waitress was really nice. I did the Baked Goods cocktail and they did the Old Fashioned cocktail, all was really good. For food, I did the BLT with fries, my sister did the hot dog, and my friend did the Nasty biscuit. It was all so good! We even got the 7 layer chocolate cake with vanilla ice cream for dessert which was really rich but good. They had a live band which was cool playing smooth jazz.

Thank you Carl! Great service. He was very attentive. The food was delicious. I would recommend to…read moreanyone. The ambiance was delightful

Lilly H was a phenomenal server. She took the time to get to know us and we got to know her. She…read moremade the restaurant feel like you were eating at a friend's house.

The staff was awesome and great with our kids, the food was amazing, the drinks were great. We got…read morethe Apple Bourbon Chicken with slaw and sweet potato fries which were all great in flavor. The kids shared a coal miner which the barbecue was sweet and the bacon&burger was cooked perfectly. I ordered the Stumble down mac&cheese and it was the perfect amount of pepper jack and cream. We are from FAR away, but would definitely come back!

Restaurant has a lot of history as an establishment that's been around 100 years. Atmosphere is…read moregreat. It seems like a good college bar for drinks. Food wasn't very flavorful including the chicken fingers and French fries. Hamburger was cooked to order but nothing special. Would likely only return for drinks as they had good specials

This is a sad review for me. The last time we will ever dine at this fine establishment. When I…read morefound out it was closing I was extremely upset. This became a place that was a regular rotation for me. From taking visitors from out of town, reuniting with my friends here, spending Sundays watching Bills football, even if they aren't my team, or introducing this place to my partner in crime after our first Fridays after 5 together. It will always hold a special place in my heart. I'll miss the magical Mac & Cheese, the fantastic beer selection, and the vaulted ceilings that made the whole place loud as hell. Love ya South Street.

Came here on Friday July 4th mid day and it was pretty empty. It got busier after 5pm. This place…read morehas a variety of IPAs and draft beers. The fried pickles were salty and hot. Be sure to come check this place out!

The pizza and cheesesteaks are very good! My son loves the wings also. Service is ok not great but…read morethey get the job done for sure. I would recommend without a doubt.

In Charlottesville for work and was craving some wings…read more SERVICE is almost nonexistent Wings came out dry and cold Atmosphere can be a very cool place I had to stand in line and literally beg for my check while actively getting ignored. Honestly should've just walked out without paying. There's no reason I paid for that food. This place is clearly only for the local bar flies. I would never return here again.