I enjoyed my dining experience at Cafe Alaia. The service was lovely and the food was tasty. This restaurant is nice and quaint. Perfect for a date night or catch up with a friend. I'm giving three stars because while the food was tasty, the price points are high and portions are small. read more

See all

Got here at 6 pm on Tuesday night with only one other table occupied. When we left at 7:30 the place was jammed and they were also eating at the bar. My grandson and his fiancée ordered wine and I was in the mood for Johnny Walker Red and soda. For an appetizer we shared stuffed eggplant. It doesn't sound appetizing. It has a big long Italian name.If you try it you will be blown away. For my entree I wanted to try the Rigatoni special which included onions in a thick ragu. I always like to try pasta dishes without red sauce. I was very glad that I chose the special. It was over the top. My grandson ordered chicken rollatine which was also a special. When the manager came around to ask how everything was , I raved about the Rigatoni special and told him I never had pasta with onions. We were too full to order dessert so just finished off with cappuccino. Sal E. New Rochelle read more

See all

I already posted a long and specific glowing review of this marvelous restaurant!! Great food, service and ambiance! read more

See all

Still the #1 Pasta place in the village of Scarsdale. I tried their tortelloni (tortellini but bigger) special which was amazing. 10/10 Their calamari is also very good. 8/10. The service is exceptional. They make you feel welcome. The ambiance is elegant. They have free wifi. read more

See all

I love Cafe Alaia. We discovered several years ago after taking a walk along the Bronx River and cutting back to downtown Scarsdale on the street. Have gone many times, always very satisfied with food and service. The owner, from Naples area if not mistaken, takes great pride in providing a great experience - from the food specials to the wine. Definitely make a reservation for weekends as the place is busy but all the employees work hard at making your experience one to remember. You will not regret it. read more

A great dinner spot with a romantic and formal ambiance. The food was delicious. The service was great and everyone was so attentive. Tried the eggplant soufflé, the grilled octopus, the butternut squash salad (special), and the lamb. The eggplant soufflé was so soft and airy. Had the flavors of a hearty lasagna but it felt so much lighter. The octopus was perfectly cooked. It was tender and it paired well with the sauces it came with. The squash salad was a warm salad. The taste was somewhat as expected, but still a solid dish. Not sure if it was worth the price of a special. The lamb was fantastic. It was cooked well and the sauce provided a great depth of flavor. I really like the use of the mint in the sauce. It was a wonderful dining experience. I would've given 5 stars but for a bite in the salad that had a really dried piece of basil (?) that I couldn't chew. I thought it was plastic at first. Still, highly recommend! I will likely be back to try some of the other dishes! read more

See all

Terrific food. Great ambiance. Beautiful restaurant. Eggplant burrata was soft and succulent. Lamb was one of the best I've had. Our waiter Fabrizio was fun, knowledgeable and very efficient. Will be back for sure. read more

This restaurant came highly recommended from someone who I trust. Unfortunately I was underwhelmed with my first visit here two weeks ago. The ambiance is wonderful. The waiter seamed friendly and nice, but he never returned to ask if everything was okay, nor if we needed anything. The eggplant appetizer is odd but intriguing. The fried calamari appetizer is the best I've had - light, tasty, tender, & crispy. The pasta with shredded lamb was the worst pasta dish I've ever had. Lamb was salty and lackluster, wide flat curly edged pasta was boring. It's something how a server can unfortunately make such an impact on a dining experience. Had he asked how everything was and had I had the opportunity to tell him how displeased I was with the Lamb Pasta dish, the entire experience could have turned out completely different. Due to my nephew (the one who loves this place and has frequented this place, I'll definitely give it a second chance the next time I'm back in town. read more

Cafe Alaia - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

We had the best meal at Cafe Alaia. The food, ambiance and service were terrific. Everything was tasty and fresh. Our server Ignatzio (hope I spelled it correctly) was friendly and accommodating. I wish I lived closer, I would go often. read more

See all

I returned to Cafe Alaia for a birthday dinner with my wife. At one point we just sat and marveled at the incredible competence of the team that runs this establishment. From arrival- an offer to wait at the bar or sit at the table, to decor- the lighting and music is just right, the decor is modern, clean and pleasing, the bathroom is spacious and immaculate. The service is available but not overwhelming. The food was great- Fresh bread, meatballs, a fresh eggplant salad, home made tortelloni alfredo with ham & peas, and broccoli rabe. A tasty dirty martini and a super Tuscan were our drinks. My wife mentioned it being my birthday and a complimentary biscotti, whipped cream and candle were served. I have read previous reviews that the owner is a polarizing figure to some customers..... If the result of his hyper focus is this incredible restaurant then I tell the owner to keep doing what you are doing because there are not many really special restaurants in Westchester- but this is one of them! read more

What a lovely place! Service was wonderful and food was delicious. The homemade pasta was so well done. I started with a salad of warm beets, melty goat cheese and roasted almonds- it was so yummy. My husband had a pasta with lamb ragu for his appetizer (although that would've been a meal for me!). For entrees I had the spaghetti with seafood and he got more lamb. Everything was cooked well and tasted delicious. We'll be back! read more

See all

Delicious food. Very good service. Thoroughly enjoyable. Pricey but worth it for a nice night out. read more

Glad I made the trip when I was staying in town. Seat at the bar on a Monday night. Food lived up to the solid reviews they have received. Will definitely go back when I am in town since the rest of the menu looked amazing. read more

Cafe Alaia - Crispy artichoke and arugula salad - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

See all

Met my son and his gf here for dinner. Super Chic chill vibe here like NYC. They bring out the best tomato jam and bread ti table it's so dam good Started with zucchini flowers stuffed with crab meat. Nice concept but was kinda cold and not crispy. We ordered Mushroom crostini for table and it was amazing nice crusty bread with sautéed mushrooms. Also ordered eggplant soufflé topped with burrata . It was really original and very good . I ordered pappardelle lamb ragu and shaved pecorino. It was truly amazing. Creamy and pasta was homemade and cooked to perfection. Wife ordered the homemade ravioli stuffed with pumpkin and squash with a butter sauce. She loves it something different My son ordered the sea bass special. He said it good flavor but fish was a bit dry Place is a bit noisy and crowded but def a good vibe and food is amazing Parking on the street. Can be tough. Def will be returning read more

See all

I love Cafe Alaia! I stopped by for dinner. I was planning on going to another nearby restaurant, but it was a holiday weekend. And, I ended up here. I was pleasantly surprised. Because it was a holiday, the restaurant was very quiet. But, the service and food was amazing! I had salad, bread and pasta. Everything I had was very fresh; I'd definitely come back here again to try more of their options. They have outdoor seating during the summer months. The inside of the restaurant is very cozy and had a relaxed vibe. This is a great spot to try for great Italian food! I'd highly recommend stopping by. read more

My wife and I had the pleasure of having dinner here this past Thursday. Cafe Alaia is arguably one of the best restaurants in all of Westchester. I had their seafood pasta and a delicious bottle of the servers recommended wine and I was in total bliss. The service, decor and sumptuous cuisine is an outstanding experience that everyone should experience. This is the type of establishment that you can close your eyes and choose any meal on the menu that your fingers land on. I also loved how the chef went around every table and greeted the guests. It doesn't get any better than this . I'll be back here real soon read more

See all

Happened to be in the neighborhood and decided to try Café Alaia for the first time. We were hungry, and ordered the homemade Pappardelle with the lamb Ragu and the pasta with clam sauce. The bread that they put on the table was so crunchy and delicious, with a wonderful tomato based tapenade. Loved that! My pasta with the lamb Ragu was rich and delicious. The pasta was perfectly cooked Al dente and was covered in a tangy lamb flavored sauce. Very filling. My friend thoroughly enjoyed the spaghetti with clam sauce. The sauce the pasta was in was garlicky delicious and almost drinkable! We used the crusty bread to soak it up. The plating was very well done. Our waitress was very friendly and nice and Overall, it was a wonderful experience read more

See all

Nestled in the charming village of Scarsdale, New York, lies a culinary gem that delights the senses with both its atmosphere and cuisine. From the moment you step through the door, you are greeted by Fabio, the restaurant's gracious and charismatic host, who ensures that each guest feels like family. His warm smile and attention to detail set the tone for an unforgettable dining experience. The restaurant itself is an elegant blend of contemporary and classic design, creating a cozy yet sophisticated ambiance perfect for any occasion. Soft lighting, tasteful décor, and intimate seating invite you to relax and savor the evening. As for the menu, it's a true celebration of fine Italian dining. Every dish is crafted with care, offering a perfect balance of flavors and presentation. From the impeccably fresh seafood to the handmade pastas and succulent meat dishes, each bite is a testament to the chef's dedication to quality and creativity. The wine list, expertly curated, provides the perfect pairing to enhance every course. I went back with my friends and we were pleased to have found a e new great selection of Bourbon and Rye. Most of the restaurants do not offer so much variety. Very well done!! What truly elevates this restaurant beyond the exceptional food and beautiful setting, however, is Fabio's personal touch. His passion for hospitality shines through in every interaction, ensuring that no detail is overlooked. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a regular, Fabio makes you feel as though you've been invited into his home. For a dining experience that seamlessly combines gourmet cuisine, a refined atmosphere, and the warmest of welcomes, this Scarsdale establishment is simply a must-visit. Fabio's presence is the cherry on top of an already extraordinary evening. Good Job Cafe Alaia!! read more

Good surrounding and delicious food Highly recommended Hope to try other things next time read more

See all

Delicious food and drinks. Intimidate atmosphere with amazing service. One of our favorite places to go

Always have an excellent experience here. The gentleman who I suspect to be the manager always gives my father in law his favorite table near the front when we dine with family and friends. Their service is impeccable and the food is always stellar. Scarsdale has been needing a new 5 star restaurant for a while, and this is it! My favorite new place in 2024. read more

It's no secret Alaia has been making some waves on Garth Rd in Scarsdale for a few years now. And on a relaxing, post-New Year's day, decided to bring home a few bites. Café Alaia hits a rustic-industrial look with two socially-distanced dining areas with the bar dividing them. Menu is straightforward and settled on Fried Calamari and 'Crispy Artichoke' Salad (as menu states). Owner? was pleasant and mentioned the 10 minute wait. Cool. After $38, all I wanted to do at home was pause for a moment and dive into my heaping plate of Fried Calamari and Crispy Artichoke salad. Let me expand: First- Alaia's $18 batch, is nothing else but rings. The things is....I like heads on my calamari. Although tasty, I will also mention the crisp, flaky breading, provided a nice complement to the Calamari and made for a wonderful and pleasing crunch. And second, $16 'Crispy Artichokes' in my salad were the marinated type ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. I expected a higher-end calamari and salad dish because of Alaia's exclusive location and hefty price tag. Instead, all I got were just fried calamari rings I could've easily gotten from around the way or a chain spot. Who knows... maybe other items are prepped better than this. read more

See all

Met some friends for dinner on a Thursday evening! Was lucky to grab a spot right in front! They say parking is tough, but it's definitely worth the wait for a spot! Walked in and we were immediately greeted. They served us some really great sun dried tomatoes purée for the bread! We started with drinks, of course! Then we had meatballs, the eggplant soufflés! Omg that was amazing! We then shared the parpardell with the lamb ragu! We ha a rainbow beet salad. And the side order of the best potato chips!!! Everything was cooked perfectly! Drinks were great! Service was excellent! Great spot! Gio was our server. And he was great! The owner checked in to make sure everything was good, and it was! read more

See all

A friend told me about a restaurant in Westchester that has the best Bolognese. She never mentioned it's also listed in the Michelin Guide's New York restaurants to visit. I live on Long Island but I'm vacationing in the Hudson Valley. For my birthday I would like to dine at Café Alaia. Our waiter shows us to our table. He's very knowledgeable on wines and the menu specials. We started with some Italian Wines. My red was silky smooth, its an Italian Wine recommended by our waiter. He mentioned the restaurant specialty is Stuffed Zucchini flowers. This is a mediterranean dish, there are Turkish and Greek versions but my favorite is the Cafe Alaia Italian version. My wife and I were floored over the delicate preparation of this dish. We also ordered the Polpo alla Griglia, a marinated grilled octopus over potato & green bean salad. Another starter that was deelish! I decided to split Tagliatelle alla Bolognese into two bowls and order a large Branzino. The homemade tagliatelle is tossed with beef ragu. Not too creamy, this was a rustic dish that was made perfectly. I wish I had Cafe Alaia close to my home, this was an outrageous dish that I would devour weekly. While we're dining, the owner Vincenzo comes into the dining room. He's looking like Ninja in his black chefs coat. He walks over and asks how is everything? We give a thumbs up, this was just a perfect ending to our day. I understand Cafe Alaia is moving to a larger location. From the amazing food to excellent wine selection, Cafe Alaia is a restaurant destination to discover. read more

See all

Overrated and overly expensive. It was expensive before but now the prices are even more expensive than a mediocre Manhattan restaurant. For example, 4 mini meatballs for an appetizer costs $28 and a tortellini soup is $24. The biggest ripoff in Scarsdale. So dissatisfied and disappointed by this place. Used to be decent but not after another round of prices increasing. read more

Our waiter was wonderful. That being said, the food was sparse and very expensive and not very good at all. A bowl of soup with a few tortellini's was $24.00! My octopus appetizer was so salty it was inedible!! The mussels tasted fishy and the eggplant appetizer couldn't satisfy a two year old's appetite. I guess growing up in an Italian family, I know what great Italian food tastes like and Cafe Alaia doesn't deliver!! Obviously we will not be back!! Too many places around for much less $$$ and much better food. :((( read more

I love love love this place. Stopped by for coffees and a snack and not only was the food amazing but the wait staff was the nicest staff I've met. We'll be back soon read more

Cafe Alaia - Cappuccino - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

See all

Excellent food, decor and service! Very impressed with Cafe Alaia. Truly terrific experience!! My only gripe: This place isn't cheap, in fact it's quite expensive comparatively. I'll be back next time I want to splurge for a great meal. read more

This spot never disappoints! It's so fresh and so clean. The staff is amazing ! We were served by Geovanni (Geo) Saturday night - and even with a packed big energy restaurant- he was super attentive to us. We got the filet mignon and the salmon. Wow. Just wow. So flavorful and cooked exactly as you requested. Mine came with shaved potatoes and the seasoning was next level. It's a lovely delicious spot for any celebration or just a sweet casual meet up. read more

See all

This restaurant is the best of the best. Great food and service. Fabio and Giovanni are amazing. read more

Food was tasteless and way over priced Even the waiter felt bad! Don't bother waste of $ read more

So had dinner last night after a fews days stopping in Scarsdale a new addition is the new manager Fabio from moscatos He runs a real good show Food was awesome as well as the drinks Service right on Few things. Took some time to get our cocktails and the food comes out real fast Very noisy as well Dont order all your door at one time read more

No problem with the food or service. I ordered artichoke salad to start. Four nice tasty artichokes on a bed of radicchio and arugula not swimming in dressing. Dressing was a nice background the way it should be. Partner ordered fried calamari w zucchini. Arrived hot and also very good, calamari tender zucchini still crunchy and minimal batter on both. He had snapper cooked in parchment paper. I tasted it flavored well not dried out. And he enjoyed it. I had rigatoni w tomatoes. Pasta perfectly al dente. He ordered pans cots desert and liked it. The problem comes with the drinks. I had 2 Negroni. Normally I am asked if I have a preferred gin wasn't last night so I assumed it was bar gin which would have been fine. When I got the bill it was 42$ for them! And the bill said Hendricks gin. I didn't ask for that and as I said I wasn't asked for a preference. This is an outrageous scam on the restaurant's part and I am going to contact them about it. This could be a fine place for a regular nothing fancy Sunday dinner but if this is how they conduct business they have seen the last of me. read more

Delicious food, great staff and amazing atmosphere! Attention to detail is Lovley Very cozy, clean and beautiful. Finding parking is tough at certain times but not impossible. Great music and interesting wine list! read more

See all

Early dinner with no reservations...and it was really very busy. Good service and good food. Started with the octopus. It was tender and the size was ok. Nice accompaniments but definitely needed the lemon to draw out the taste. Beet salad was great. Frisée and a little goat cheese. Could have used a little more dressing and certainly more cheese. Chicken liver was a pate with wilted onion. The bread it was served on got the sauce from the livers but the crust was very hard. Pappardelle Pasta with lamb ragu was terrific. Not too oily. Nice balance and richness. The Pappardelle was perfectly cooked and the portion size average. Very tasty. A special dish was the Swordfish with saffron lemon sauce and broccoli rabe with roasted potatoes. Excellent cut of fish cooked moist on a generous bed of br. Sauce was tangy and accompanied the fish well. I recommend this place. read more

I went back here over the weekend and it did not impress as much as it did previously. The staff was great but the food & portions left much to be desired. We ordered the rigatoni, ravioli, and shrimp with beans. The rigatoni was good and pretty tasty. The ravioli was a special for the day so I decided to try it. When I got the plate, there were no joke 6 or 7 raviolis on my plate. It was gorgeous to look at but after eating my meal I needed one and a half bread baskets to fill me up. The flavors weren't anything super special, if anything it was a tad over cooked. Definitely not worth it for 6 pieces of ravioli. The shrimp was good, again a small dish but pretty filling! The beans were delicious but we wished there was more flavor in the meal. Overall, will probably come back but only for a handful of specific dishes. read more

See all

The place was a nice upbeat vibe from the time I walked in. Sat in a table by the door it was a little cold as people came in and out. The staff was very nice and service was great. There was eight of us and all the appetizers they were great fried calamari was delicious. The shrimp and the bean dish was good but the shrimp was very small. Fresh mozzarella was also very good but all portions were small. Main course was great had a pasta dish. The sauce was amazing and the portion was good also had stuffed raviolis that were delicious. Everyone enjoyed their main course. The restaurant was great but not cheap. Overall, I would recommend this place is a great place to eat . read more

This is the fourth time I've eaten here. I've ordered different things each time and have not yet had a good meal. Last night I started with the caprese , which oddly was served with cherry tomatoes. There were two pieces of a larger tomato but were completely unripe. The entree I chose was Milanese. The chicken was dry and unseasoned . A few pieces of arugula were served on top. The chicken was so tasteless I didn't even take the leftovers home. I would love to know how this restaurant is so crowded with inferior food . At 100 dollars a person without alcohol , I think it's outrageous. Not too much to pay for delicious food but this is not it! read more

Out for dinner and despite the parking difficulties in this part of Scarsdale, we managed to snag a spot. I would describe the vibe as NYC Chic with a warehousey look and a decent sized bar. We ordered a round of drinks which were delivered promptly and then a few more minutes to decide between menu items or specials and away we go. Between 4 people, we got 3 different appetizers and 3 different entrees...no we didn't skimp on the ordering, it was simply a matter of duplication. I got to try 2 appetizers and all 3 entrees and I after pondering for a couple of days now, I wish I could have given the coveted 5th star but I felt like the food was just a bit bland for my (and most of my companions) tastes. Service is awesome, the best I've had in years and unlike anything else around. I think if I return, I will sit at the bar, order some drinks and some nibbles and call it a day! read more

Authentic Italian restaurant with impeccably cooked pasta; every dish is delicious! The desserts, especially the tiramisu, stand out, a rarity in restaurants in the suburbs. read more