We had a last minute change of plans and were so happy to get a reservation for brunch after church…read moreon Easter Sunday and to finally check this place out. Thought we were going to be outside on the enclosed patio and knew it was going to be raining so we were thrilled to be seated inside by the fireplace instead. Price fixe was $65 pp so a bit steep but the bottomless drink options definitely helped. We enjoyed everything we ate and the service, restroom cleanliness and atmosphere were all on point. Will def return!

2 words: osso buco! If I had to base my review on this dish and the service I would give five out…read moreof five stars based on service and quality, however... Came here with my parents for their birthdays and was blown away by a single bite that I had of my dad's dish! It's a special and it's incredible! I was not overly impressed by the flatbread I got, I've had far better for cheaper than other places that are not Italian. My mom got the meatball and it was decent Went back on Father's Day and it was a decent meal. We all wanted to order the osso buco, but sadly it wasn't a special :( My parents got the fish special in two different styles.. The fish was fresh and delicious, but the proportions in the size of fish varied greatly. My dad got a small piece of fish at my mom received a larger one. I feel like if you're presenting the same dish consistency is king.. I don't even remember what I ordered. I believe it was an ok burger, hat's how unmemorable the dish was. My parents love the food but I was not blown away on either occasion for the $300-400 bills I paid. The ambience is not high-end, but I like that. I like when I go into a restaurant and I feel like I'm walking into somebody's home. The servers/service was great both times and Jamie on the front end is fantastic and makes you feel like family!

Awhile back, I left a pretty bad review for this place. Since then, they've changed owners, and…read moremade some much needed cosmetic changes to the storefront as well (not that it matters that much, but who wants to buy food from a place that looks like a dump?) Anyway.... I was hesitant to give em another shot, but after hearing about new ownership, fair is fair. And I didn't think my previous review would be "fair" to them. So I made my obligatory "3 visit" rule (I try out a place 3x times before writing a bad review; after all, everyone is entitled to have a bad day, right?). So.... I'm happy to report NOW that the place was clean, the staff were pleasant and friendly, and the pizza was GREAT. Lots of choices (I'm a by the slice kinda guy), all tasted fresh, and frankly, it's pretty damn good. With that: 5 stars, and a hearty recommendation! Enjoy!

Ordered the Northfork veggie pizza and the broccoli was missing which was a total bummer,…read moreespecially since I was charged for the broccoli. Overall, there weren't that many veggies except for olives and olives are actually considered a fruit. Ha! Oh well. We will try the other pizza place down the street next time. You win some and you lose some.

Great food, servers, and wait time. Family and I were stuffed. Thank you for a wonderful…read moreexperience!!

First time visit after living on Long Island for 52 years. I've driven by this hole in the wall at…read moreleast once a week and never decided to stop until today. Hospitality, quaint little hole in the wall, specials galore. Not an overwhelming menu, but the food is overwhelming. On point, delicious, well prepared, and fresh. Highly recommend. Don't wait 52 years like I did. Bring the family come solo, have a drink which was made perfectly, and enjoy the appetizers, and a fantastic food.

Some of the best pizza New York has to offer. Real service in a classic pizza shop ambiance. This…read moreis the pizza shoppe you think of when you think pizza in NYC. We ordered an entire cheese pie, kept it simple. Talk about an authentic crust, with high quality cheese and Italian tomato sauce. These guys know how do pizza! Every slice has the best cheese pull you can imagine. Their pepperoni is amazing, so is their grandma pie. But since I don't get authentic NY pizza in California, the simplicity of a delicious cheese pie is so satisfying and comforting. Every time I land, this is the first place I go. I can't wait to get back!

This hidden gem is worth it. Food always fresh. Great italian meals and shareable portions.read more

I got a pizza from this place on Sunday and it was some of the best pizza I've ever tasted, the…read moreemployees were very nice, there was a nice kid named Anderson and he helped me pick out what I wanted, I was unsure and he helped me, it was amazing, the place was also very nice like the furniture and lights felt like I was in a high end restaurant, nice spot and nice people as well, 10/10 would recommend.

Place looks run down and tell me why the pizza had zero taste at all I was basically just eating…read morecardboard but the crust and slice was crunch but the taste was just horrid absolutely no taste at all

I am so impressed with Giovanni's Sal was absolutely…read morefantastic Unfortunately, I lost my mom on March 20 had the week and had the funeral and went there after the funeral I brought about 20 people with me family and friends and when I made the reservations, he did not hesitate to try to accommodate us and I just couldn't make any more decisions and he made absolutely perfect decisions. The beginning was the bread which was fantastic. Plus a Caesar salad salad. The Penny à la vodka was absolutely amazing and everyone's food whether it be the chicken franchise the chicken Parm or the eggplant Parm plus desserts was absolutely outrageous. He made a god-awful day much easier for me that I did not have to make any more decisions the food is fantastic and Sal is number one in my book.

Great food, friendly service, and a beautiful ambiance is how I rate Giovanni's. I got my pizza to…read morego, and it was absolutely delicious. Every bite was heavenly. This is my first time here, and I was impressed with the quality of the pizza. The crust itself had the perfect texture, and the sauce and cheese were flavorful. I got their classic cheese pizza so I could taste all of the goodness in it without having too many toppings. I'm glad I did. Giovanni's is a Top 10 Pizza Shoo on Long Island on my pizza scale. I can't wait to come back and try their Grandma pizza pie!

Only came in here because I dropped my uhual off next door. It's a notch higher than a NYC dollar…read moreslice. Absolutely subpar pizza.

this place has the most delicious food. Everything is fresh. Everything taste wonderful. The people…read moreare so nice. The owner is fantastic. She is a sweetheart. they catered my mom's 92nd birthday. The food was spectacular. People did not stop raving about everything. I'm so glad I went with this place. They are definitely top notch in catering and an every day Italian food so much.

Went for breakfast this morning l Store closed went out of…read morebusiness rip swan will miss best egg sandwich and best roast beef around been going there since 1980

I woke up this morning craving a breakfast sandwich and come to find out they are permanently…read moreclosed. This is sad to hear. It was my go to spot the owner was always pleasant to me and sandwiches were always good.

Anyone can impress for one dinner but when the second visit is better than the first you know…read moreyou've found a special spot. Chef Mike and team provide exceptional food and service with a personal touch usually reserved only for socialites in Manhattan. For our second dinner visit we doubled our party to 8 and dug a little deeper into the menu. Cocktails and Wine were nicely crafted and presented with skill. For starters we chose orders of Fried Calamari w/tomato sauce, fresh Potato Pancakes w/applesauce and the big pretzel. While you would expect perfect potato pancakes at a German inspired restaurant the quality of the Calamari might surprise. Perfect batter and cook with a tasty sauce. The table varied up the mains which upped the challenge for the kitchen but all dishes were served perfectly prepared and together. 4 chose the signature Sauerbraten with fresh red cabbage. The meat was fork tender and perfectly sauced. The Twin Grilled Pork Chops, Tomahawk for 2 and Roast Lamb followed and equally impressed. Of note was the char on the pork which contrasts well with the sauce. Personal note; I tend to be very skeptical ordering lamb but had faith in Chef Mike. Might have been the best Roast Rack of Lamb I've ever eaten! The flavor on the crust was bold, meat temperature was a perfect mid-rare and the sauce had a surprise sweetness that balanced the plate. For dessert three fresh Apple Strudel w/strawberries and vanilla ice cream brought it all home. Note: last visit we made note of the dining room decor and in fairness I should do the same. Great Job brightening up the room and setting beautiful white table covers w/valentine red runners. The room looked crisp and inviting. Pine Grove Inn is a bit off the regular path in Patchogue but absolutely worth a little drive. I'm looking forward to seeing this restaurant full on our next visit even if we have to fill it with our friends.

This place has been here forever or so it seems. I remember going here many, many years ago but…read morehaven't been back until last week & I have to say I very pleasantly surprised. I was there with a group for lunch followed by bingo. We paid one price which included a drink, either alcoholic or not, a lunch entree and coffee & cake. The bartender was very friendly and made really good sangria and I'm not usually a fan but his was not too sweet. There was bread on the table which was refilled on request. The wait staff made sure there was also two pitchers of water which I appreciate. I got the fried trio which consisted of 2 baked clams, 2 nice sized shrimp and pile of calamari. All three were nice and crisp and tasty. One of the other people at my table got the chicken Caesar salad which was huge and they enjoyed it very much. From what I could tell everyone enjoyed their meals. The staff was friendly & professional I will certainly go back at another time to try some of the regular menu items and I would recommend it for lunch or dinner