Oh my goodness did I have a difficult time finding this place. My date and I were literally circling the block again and again looking for the 191 building, and JUST when we were about to give up, we looked up and saw the tiny letters of a building arranged in the words "Cafe Gazelle" Success!!! However, when we opened the door and stumbled inside, confusion immediately struck me; were we in someone's house? Right before I was about to die of embarrassment, the wonderful aroma of Italian food wafted through my nostrils and into my soul. At that moment, I didn't care where I was or whose house I so rudely stepped into, I was staying for dinner.
This place looks and smells like grandma's kitchen, that is, if your grandmother is indeed Italian. There are a total of 8 tables in this tiny restaurant, all but one of which are 2-person tables, so yea, bring your special someone here, not your drinking buddies.
We started off with a bruschetta appetizer, delicious! Juicy tomatoes topped with basil, drizzled with olive oil, and complemented very nicely alongside some cannellini beans, ah heaven. By the way, this is the type of place that emphasizes quality rather than quantity (our bruschetta came with only 4 pieces but they were too good to pass up).
For my entree, I chose the Siciliani which was sort of a penne pasta with tomato sauce served with roasted eggplants and mushrooms. But first, I had my choice of a soup or salad. I ALWAYS go with soup so the server brought over a bowl of their minestrone. Honestly, I think it was one of the best tasting minestrone soups I've ever had. It looked really watery at first but each sip was completely full bodied. Such a comforting dish, especially on a windy night like tonight.
After my glass of wine, my piece of bread (that they bring to your table at the beginning of the meal), the bruschetta appetizer, and my bowl of minestorne, I was feeling pretty darn full when my entree pasta came. I think I got through less than half of it. Don't get me wrong, just like everything else I had eaten that meal, it was delicious, but I was just so full.
And of course, dessert. I'm usually against ordering dessert, but of all the things, my date was craving bread pudding. Well, lo and behold, the server came over with a PLATTER of dessert (that is so unfair by the way!) and placed it on our table. He then proceeded to present each one to us (there were at least 6 on the platter) in such a sultry voice. This is how it went:
Server: "here's our selection of dessert, we have a chocolate hazelnut bread pudding, a new york -"
My date: "YEA THAT ONE"
So beware! Be prepared to spare no tummy room whatsoever!
Even though the food was delicious, what really won me over was the incredibly cozy atmosphere. It's so authentic, so real, and definitely something everyone who loves Italian food should try. 5 stars! read more