This is our local go to for Italian over the other options in our immediate vicinity. We've eaten here enough to give a well rounded rating. It's a solid choice if you don't want to travel far from here. Skip the garlic bread, it's nothing special and after trying a few times, it's consistently not great (tough and dry, we usually just pick the cheese off it). Their rolls are ok, but only if they are fresh. They can make a dish spicy which scores points with me since most places don't do this at all. So if spicy is your thing, this is your spot! Some of their options can have an overabundance of oil, just be aware. I usually order pink sauce, Alfredo, vodka, or a cheese tortellini. I rotate around these options, all are good. Their meatballs have never been dry, also a plus. Their pizza is good, I haven't been disappointed but only tried a feItalian. Their tiramisu is some of the best I've had, it's served almost pudding style but it is fantastic. Ultimately, a solid local choice for italian. Not the best out there but you won't be disappointed! read more

Rigitoni Vodka Pasta is awesome. I dine here every week. Family Favorite. Dylan is very attentive to our table.. read more

It's a vibe in here.... very nicely decorated. Awesome lunch specials, tasty food. BYOB read more

Cafe Sicilia - Italian Near Me - Arlington, Texas

See all

First time here and i don't know why this is the first time I'm trying this place. I got take out but I went inside to get the food. Love the atmosphere and staff, and my food was ready when they said it would be. I got the chicken parm which was good. Came back and got a slice of pepperoni pizza. So good. Also they have free delivery after 5, big plus! read more

Cafe Sicilia - Chicken Parmesan comes with bread and salad - Italian Near Me - Arlington, Texas

It's hard for me to give a 5/5 review... but this place deserves it. I've lived here my whole life and finally found this gem. I got 3 appetizers to try calamari, mozzarella sticks and spinach artichoke dip. I'm gonna be honest didn't like the calamari, Sonic mozz sticks are better but the Dip.... that's to DIE for. Seriously amazing. As i got the appetizers it's BYOB so of course my table brought like 5 bottles of wine and they were nice enough to give us buckets with ice to put it in. As a meal i got the vodka sauce seafood pasta... and well. This meal was maybe $15 and at any other restaurant would have been $30+. For the price. Amazing. Also the bread is so good, I'm not a bread person like to me olive gardens bread is nasty but this bread i actually really liked. Will be back soon, i promise. HIGHLY RECOMMEND Also the host was so nice, even nicer than our waiter. He needs to be a server ASAP read more

Cafe Sicilia - Vodka sauce seafood pasta 10/10 - Italian Near Me - Arlington, Texas

Our waitress, Giselle, was excellent, and the place was so lovely and romantic . She put my wife and I at ease and never made us feel hurried. The cuisine! Amazing ! I am eagerly awaiting my next visit. Everything on that menu appeals to me. read more

I'm not getting my money back so I'm gonna COMPLAIN. One good thing; The red sauce is amazing. I got a take out order. Save your money. There was a film of oil or butter on pretty much every meal we got. The rolls were stale. The fried mushrooms...why not cut them up and make it more delicate? It's like a blob of batter. One of the meals had white wine sauce, even that was covered in an oily mess. White wine reduction sauce is supposed to be light and delicate, not hard to make. It was not olive oil, olive oil is expensive, I doubt they drown their food in it. Grossed out honestly. Ugh. read more

Great food and ambience Would love to go back. We went for our anniversary one year a while back.

Food was ok, nothing that sets it apart from any other Italian restaurant. Service was great!

Cafe Sicilia''s decor will hit you one of two ways : kitschy sentimental neighborhood Italian restaurant or simply "not Olive Garden" gaudy. I like indoor fountains and fake vines and a certain amount of kitsch and we enjoy the older look here. What you do need to support the look is good food and crisp service. We've used Groupons twice here and I would recommend them so you can save a little if you want to check them out. Cafe Sicilia does have $7.50 Lunch Specials every day from 11 - 3 pm with your choice of soup or salad, rolls and soda or iced tea. There are a host of items to choose from and I chose the meat Lasagna and my spouse the Eggplant Parmigiana. We both had the tossed salad. Last time we ordered entrees from the menu and found the portions to be huge and they matched the prices. This time the lunch portions were perfect, the crispy cold lettuce with housemade dressings and their housemade garlic knot yeast rolls were just right for us. The Lasagna is good old fashioned restaurant style with a quite a bit of cheese and not so much meat. Tasty and it satisfied a lasagna yen. The Eggplant Parmigiana was good according to my husband with firm flavorful eggplant and sauce with wide pasta noodles and again, quite a bit of cheese. The casserole dishes could seriously burn you or your children, though. They are that hot and they stay hot. Just a word of caution. Last time we had a crackerjack waitress. Every step perfection and we tipped 20%. Today this young woman was sweet and compliant; but needs to improve. No straws with our water and then only a straw for me when I asked for one and she zoomed off. I laughed and told my husband he just wasn't quick enough. I realized into our entrees that we didn't have our drinks. We got those to go. I had wanted mine in a to go cup anyway; but not after my meal. Be sure and ask the price of the desserts if you decide you want one. Our lemon raspberry cheesecake torte was more than a lunch special! We had that to go. The food was good. The service could have been better. I like listening to the tinkling water fountain. We would go for the lunch specials, again, definitely. read more

Cafe Sicilia - Lemon raspberry cheesecake torte (graham cracker crust) $7.99 after we got it home (it fell over) - Italian Near Me - Arlington, Texas

See all

Came here for lunch had seafood pasta so rich and creamy Great service Staff friendly and attentive Ofelia and Donna was Great read more

Very disappointed with this establishment!!! My niece is in town visiting. We went out for dinner on Friday night 4/9/21 Her beverage came with a lovely side of ROACH!!!! Never will go back! read more

This is a small, family owned diner with great quality service and food. I love that it's a BYOB place, allowing us to bring in our favorite beverages to enjoy with the great Italian food. I've been here a few times but on 10/12/19, I chose to celebrate my birthday here- little did I know I would be proposed to at this dinner. When I walked in, the tables had birthday table clothes and mini centerpieces- I thought a family member did this but the staff actually had this ready along with my reservation! After dinner was winding down, I was proposed to and the staff was super sweet allowing us to stay a little after closing time to take pictures. I loved the service and environment of this place before, but now it'll always hol a special place for us read more

Cafe Sicilia - Italian Near Me - Arlington, Texas

This place is the best Italian food. If your looking for a great place to have a good meal, you will definitely enjoy this one!!!'

Two words: Nutella cheesecake. Is it bad that I licked the plate clean? It's not on the regular menu, but the server said they usually have some around. read more

See all

This place serves up really decent Italian-American food, and I like that you can bring your own bottle of wine. My favorite dish is the tortellini with Canadian bacon in it. My husband loves the lasagna. We both love dipping the delicious homemade bread into the house dressing that comes with the salads. I've also enjoyed the other menu items I've tried, and even my grandmother is a big fan of the angel hair pasta with bolognese. read more

Mom and pop type of place. Love the cozy/casual ambiance and decor. They almost always have offers on Groupon. I have seen this place on Groupon so much, I decided to give it a try. They are BYOB, so don't forget your wine!! After ordering they bring bread. The bread is in the shape of a cinnamon roll. The rolls were warm, buttery, and tasted fresh. I ordered eggplant Florentine. This was my first time trying eggplant Florentine so I didn't know what to expect. It is similar to eggplant Parmesan (my personal fav italian dish), but the eggplant is rolled up and stuffed with spinach. The dish is covered with marinara sauce and cheese. It was good, but I would not order it again. Next time, I will stick with trying their eggplant Parmesan! They have decent prices and good service. read more

See all

This is a great restaurant. Food is good and service is great. It is also BYOB and inexpensive.

Have been to the one in Bedford & didn't even know they had a location off Matlock. So excited as this will be our Italian spot when on this side of town. Great service & food amazing. What's better is it's BYOB. read more

Cafe Sicilia - Leonardo Fettuccine - Canadian bacon elevates this dish. - Italian Near Me - Arlington, Texas

Beautiful atmosphere, friendly staff, the food is wonderful highly recommend this place

My Fiancé and I ate here about 3 months ago. I love the BYOB concept. We had a beautiful white wine with our meal. The food was fresh and flavorful. The pasta tasted like it was made fresh, it was light and thin. The Seafood Fettuccine was amazing. I am definitely going to be back just for that and the bread! read more

Love the pizza and all the desserts!! The service is amazing! It's such a welcoming environment!

Great food, we started with some cheese sticks, just average but the marinara sauce was good not the out of the jar stuff so I knew the was going to be hand made not the generic Italian we get from all the "Joe's" places around town. I got the chicken rollatini it was a chicken breast will fresh mozzarella rolled up and pan fried served over pasta in a pick sauce, it also had veggies, it was really great. The rolls looked like The generic rolls that you get in most Italian places but they actually had flavor to them, we had to get extra they were so good. My wife had the past with all the seafood in the house in it, she chose the Alfredo sauce and she really enjoyed it. We will definitely be back, great food, service and atmosphere. read more

Cafe Sicilia - Cool decor inside - Italian Near Me - Arlington, Texas

The food is really good. Especially the bread at lunch time. Everything was hot and fresh. They have like 15 items for $8 and under during lunch and it comes with soup or salad. Highly recommend! read more

Cafe Sicilia - Lunch cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Arlington, Texas

Second time here. Giving it another shot since La Gondola was booked. Wife ordered the tortellini but asked to take bacon out because of vegetarian. We order the artichoke dip as an appetizer. It came with bacon even though it's not on the menu. Online menu,yes; in person menu, no. Pasta came out waaay overcooked. Very mushy. Chicken was overcooked; dry and rubbery. We were sat toward the back. Table was so close to a cabinet that the staff insisted on having us move our chairs forward every time they walked by instead of going around. Table needs to be moved if walking through this area is such a must. read more

Love their Chicken Florentine....it's been a special in the past. But they will make it upon request, as it's not listed on the menu.

This was my first time here with one of my best friends. Juan, our server was one of the best servers I've had in a while!! Very great service and he checked on us from time to time, thanks Juan! Very great spirited guy. Oh and my friend and I tried the cannoli, may i say, very good! The best cannoli I've had so far, I've had it b4 elsewhere but it was gross but the food and everything here was amazing! Thanks again y'all! I'll def be coming back esp w my family/more friends. read more

I have been here 5 times and each time has been awesome! Today was no different! I feel welcome each and every time. I bought to-do food for the family once and my daughter ate from my mom's plate of chicken Masala and today this was the place she chose for her birthday dinner. She's like, I want that meal you got that time you brought us something. I love this place so I was like, word! This is absolutely my go to for Italian. Check'em out! You'll like'em too! read more

Cafe Sicilia - Cannolli birthday surprise! Awesome! - Italian Near Me - Arlington, Texas

See all

This place DOES NOT disappoint! This is a great place for wanting Italian Food, every dish we have had has been amazing. Large quantities to say the least. Dining in, you will have to get a to-go box. The manicotti is fantastic, again generous portions. This is a bring your own wine or drink place, but its all about the food at Cafe Sicilia, a hidden gem that may not be hidden too much longer. A must go on our family's restaurant list. Do yourself a favor stop by for some delicious and authentic Italian food. The staff is extremely friendly and accommodating. read more

The Michelangelo was DELICIOUS! I ordered togo and was greeted at the front immediately. My food was brought out immediately with no wait. I highly recommend eating here. The inside is extremely cute as well! read more

Cafe Sicilia - Michelangelo - Italian Near Me - Arlington, Texas

So my husband and I recently moved to the area and a friend told us to give this place a try. WOW!!! So good! We came for the first time on Wednesday and it was so good that we came back on Saturday! Twice in one week! First night we got the mozzarella sticks, seafood fettuccine & my husband built his own pasta with spaghetti Alfredo and chicken. The mozzarella sticks were ok but we probably won't order those again....THE PASTAS THO?!?!!! Wow!! Everything was beyond expectation. Hot, flavorful and filling. Saturday we got the spinach artichoke dip, tortellini Michelangelo and chicken rollatini. Again...food was amazing beyond expectation so at this point I knew I had to write a review. The spinach dip was exceptional....i don't know if I've ever had better in my 30 years of life. The pastas were really good but we decided that our Wednesday night pastas were our favorites so far. We can't wait to come back and bring visiting family and friends!!! Highly recommend!!! read more

Food and service is great! The atmosphere is very clean and friendly. I would recommend going!

It was our first time visiting this restaurant. From the moment you enter the atmosphere is cozy, the mural they have is beautiful, you go on a trip and you feel in Italy. Customer service is excellent, very attentive and respectful. The food is exquisite, the portions of the plates are perfect. They have a variety menu, meats, pastas, sauces. To satisfy different palates. It is a highly recommended restaurant. Definitely we will return. read more

See all

Everyone was nice & the food was really good! We will definitely come back. We're very happy to have found a good Italian restaurant close by! read more

OMG THE BEST ITALIAN PLACE EVERRRRRRR!!!!!!! I wish I discovered this gem a lot sooner!! When you walk in you instantly feel like you're in a whole different place. (Restroom needs a little work, but other than that everything is great.) You can tell they put in a lot of thought into all of the detail and decor. It also makes you feel right at home and welcomed. Everyone is so nice and the environment is just fantastic. You can really tell the owner cares about their customers. Our server was a bit slow though she seemed distracted/occupied with something else (a boy). But I won't let her ruin the rating I give for the restaurant. Plenty of food to choose from. I had the fettuccine Alfredo with chicken and it is so creamy, rich and flavorful. Portion is great for the price. Really taste like homemade food from grandma's. My husband got the stromboli, it was def stuffed with lots of good stuff in it. Best one we have had in a very very long time. Calamari was crispy and delicious. MoIzzarella sticks weren't unique, but they weren't terrible. Glad it didn't taste like grease either! Get the pizza !!! Got the pepperoni pizza and I was not disappointed. The crust was crispy on the outside and soft in the inside. I was in pizza heaven ! On Sundays they have new specials that run for a week. I had a spinach dip special, the bacon is a little over powering the other flavors but if you love bacon, it'll be good! Im overally satisfied and I can't wait to come back to continue to try all of their other items on the menu! And I will def recommend all of my loved ones! Highly recommend this to all of you. read more

Best fettuccine Alfredo!!!! The complimentary bread and butter is the delicious! The chicken parmigiana is my 2nd option! And love that's it's byob! Nice family atmosphere! read more

This is a really nice Italian cafe. The food was fantastic. I had the small supreme pizza (big enough for 2). It had a delicious crust and plenty of good toppings. My wife had the chicken rollatini. It was also very good. My granddaughter had the gluten free chicken Alfredo. She said it was delicious. Free fresh baked bread was served before the meal (also yummy). We split a cannoli for dessert. The prices were reasonable as well. It's in a little strip mall. Well worth finding. read more

The food is great, friendly faces each time we visit. Cutest Italian restaurant. We bring our wine and enjoy the most delicious Italian food. read more

I'm sorry, but I don't understand the hype about this place and I'm all for small businesses as I have a business. and I understand reviews are the biggest focal point of a business and so I just want to say this place was beautiful inside the staff were super friendly and helpful. But the food appeared to be good but as soon as we got home, maybe not even 10 minutes later my daughter was throwing up. My mother was sick to her stomach and later me and my son were sick of the same symptoms. I had to miss work and what makes it worse as I called to give feedback and all they said was we never had anybody have food poisoning from here of course you're gonna say that because you have to protect your image why would you tell a customer the truth. And I was waiting for some type of hay we can offer you a partial refund or maybe some type of other resolution we did not just spin $50 there it was $100+ It's not about the money. It's about the principal of it you as a business are responsible of resolving issues, especially if people have fallen severely sick from your food I will never recommend this place or ever step foot in it. read more

The food was ok and can't say it was great. The rolls were warm but really hard around the edges. The manicotti was ok but not great. The tomato sauce wasn't anything really special. We ordered an appetizer of fried mushrooms which weren't served until after our meal came. Kind of weird. The drinks tasted off. Maybe the water? Anyway we ate, were full but I can't say we'll be back. :-/ read more