This is a lovely restaurant with old world charm. I can only describe the ambiance as a place that used to be nice 15 years ago, and is still nice but could use a décor update. It's reliably good and is one of those places I like to return to every so often for a specific meal. The bread is good, and the provoleta appetizer is pretty good, too. We always order the osso bucco that is served with saffron risotto. This dish is served with the bone, so if you like bone marrow then this could be a real treat for you. I'm not a bone marrow person at all, so I don't appreciate it as much as someone who would really enjoy it. read more

See all

Always a consistent place for great food and service. The location is quaint but has ample seating. The severs are wonderful and have been there for a long time. They are always so courteous. The food is authentic and flavorful. Never a let down coming to this place. A little gem in Coral Gables. I highly recommend. read more

See all

Best place in town to order genuine Italian food. Been ordering for almost 15 years from here. It's our go to hangover and Friday night food. Just so good. You will never go wrong with any platter read more

Amazing food, great wine selection always, and the best hospitality! Just the best restaurant in The Gables to make you feel welcome. read more

See all

This cozy restaurant is a great alternative for work lunch Their specials are ample enough to please a crowd My favorite is the house lasagna a flavorful portion soaked in tomato sauce filled with savory bolognese, good enough to leave you with a smile House wine os available as well as the Italian espresso to finish your lunch and continue your work day at ease. If needed parking at rear is a commodity at the area. Nice staff ready available to serve your requests. read more

See all

Other than the fact that a server named Lorenzo Pozzoli was unbearably ugly, the food was horrible too. On the bright side, it was an absolutely atrocious experience! read more

I celebrated my birthday here in August 2025 and it was the perfect choice. The food was absolutely amazing, and the menu is very extensive with plenty of options to choose from. I ordered a pizza and it was really, really good, one of the best I've had in Miami. The service was excellent, very attentive, and made us feel welcome the entire evening. Overall, this place is a hidden gem and I highly recommend it. Whether it's for a special occasion or just a casual meal, Caffé Italia is definitely worth a visit. read more

We heard good things, were excited to try it. We went on a weeknight, they happened to have a large party which was celebrating and was extremely loud, to the point us and other diners moved as far away as possible immediately after sitting. The party was yelling and cheering, something you do at hall not in the dining room of a restaurant, unfortunately no manager was there to ask them to quiet down. The dining room is nicely decorated but everyone was cold and wearing their jackets as the AC was much too high on an unusually cool night. The meat sauce tased more like a chili sauce than an Italian Bolognese, our portions were small. The bread was good. The server seemed upset when he offered cocktails and appetizers and we said no thank you. Maybe it was just an off night as all places have them. read more

Caffe Italia - a black and white photo of a family in a wine cellar - Pizza Near Me - Coral Gables, Florida

Met with friends to have some Italian food. The place is quite elevated inside, and although it sits on a corner, there is ample space to park near. Today the venue was not packed and that was good because I could see this restaurant super busy. The decor was appropriate, and the service was excellent. Very much so that all pre ordering was done rather quickly. The food was phenomenal in taste. Temperature was adequate, and the portions appropriately. The only reason for not a 5 star was because one plate of food had to be returned for more cooking, and the refills had to be asked for constantly. Nevertheless, kudos to the staff for making us feel VIP, the entire time. They even have a wine cellar to make selections in wine. Other than that, I highly recommend this place for a good encounter with a special someone or meeting up with friends. Prices were very accommodating. read more

Caffe Italia - Spaghetti with meat-sauce - Pizza Near Me - Coral Gables, Florida

See all

We loved this little gem, and it used to be our favorite spot for pasta. When we visited in November 2024, we were disappointed with the food but assumed it was just a bad day in the kitchen. Today, we went back, excited after some time, only to confirm that the food quality has changed. We always order the same pasta dishes; Carbonara and Pescatore--and this is now the second time we have left without wanting to come back. However, we won't be returning. Our family and friends have shared the same experience, and we are very disappointed. The customer service is average, no connection with the server and does not justify the automatic service charge. read more

This place must be under new management or something. Came back for the first time in a long time, we waited over an hour and a half for the food. We ordered a Sangria and had to send it back because the wine tasted bitter as if it was very old and rotten. When our food finally arrived, some dishes cold, and the chicken parm was absolutely disgusting. The chicken tastes like freezer chicken that has been sitting in a fridge for days. The Service was also not great, no one told us if there was something wrong with the kitchen or anything until we asked an hour and a half later. We ended up leaving without eating any food. Will never be coming back unfortunately. read more

I have traveled through Europe and I can confidently say this place has the best pasta I've ever had. Moreover, every single item we ordered tonight was phenomenal. Anyone visiting should make it a point to visit this location! read more

Caffe Italia - Baked Tortellini Pink Sauce - Pizza Near Me - Coral Gables, Florida

See all

Just so people are aware there's a 18% gratitude included. I went during lunch time and it was pretty empty and quiet which was nice. I ordered the fettuccine Alfredo with chicken and my grandmother ordered the spaghetti marinara. We both loved our dishes, the pasta wasn't overcooked, and the sauce had the perfect amount of spice and flavor. read more

The restaurant looks small from the outside but it's comfortable and roomy and you don't feel crowded. The loaf of bread they brought to the table was right out of the oven and it was quite warm, tender and delicious. Olive oil was provided for dipping as well as butter. The portions were quite large and we all had leftovers. The food was very good from the lasagne to the eggplant Parmesan to my cannelloni. We had a large salad that we shared and their homemade house dressing was fantastic. The prices are quite reasonable. I don't know about parking as we walked from a nearby office building. Definitely plan on returning. Our waitress was very attentive but not obtrusive. read more

This place has been here for years. It's a staple. Always excellent service and the food is fresh and amazing. It's like stepping back in time to a family neighborhood restaurant! read more

Excellent service! Our 40th birthday celebration for 36 guests was awesome and affordable. They worked with us on a fixed menu that incorporated our selections. Their wine selection is unrivaled for a family restaurant. We are picky and have to tell you we have yet to have a bad bottle of wine at Caffe Italia. You can trust Caffe Italia to meet your celebratory needs. Kudos and Thanks YOU! read more

Cafe Italia is located right next to my job and our management has ordered several time lunch from there. Here you will find a menu full of typical Italian cuisine plus thin crust pizza. This past Thursday our team ordered two orders of pizza one with pepperoni and the other just cheese. The pizzas were delicious thin crust with the right amount of cheese and red sauce. The crust was nice and chewy. read more

Caffe Italia - Pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Coral Gables, Florida

Came to celebrate moms birthday and was not disappointed! I have to say, I had the most delicious meat sauce I have ever had in my life! Delicious! But, every single item was amazing. The calamari, alfredo pasta, everything! The restaurant looks completely different from the outside than it does on the inside. On the outside it looks like a little hole in the wall. On the inside, it is absolutely beautiful. It's kind of old-school classic vibe. The service was OK. It wasn't bad at all. But what impresses hands-down is the amazing food! I am so tempted to go back and order more meat sauce today. That's how good it was. read more

Excellent food. The staff was very attentive. Very large menu. Tiramisu was especially good! read more

I finally got a chance to try Caffe Italia, and I was blown away. The staff was welcoming and attentive, inside was beautifully decorated. Our waitress Gisela was spectacular, very friendly and knowledgeable. The Burrata was delicious, and the meat lovers pizza was excellent as well. I definitely will come back and try some of the pasta dishes next time. Grazie mille! read more

See all

I've worked as a waitress at proper italian restaurants for many years and I can tell you, hand on my heart, that this is not it. We had the antipasto, a started supposed to consist of bite-size quality cheese, cured meats, vegetables, and bread. What we got was cheap sandwich ham, 1 slice of soggy parma, and gross salami. I am pretty sure it was all bought at Costco (I'm not exaggerating at all) - and we paid $14 for it ! There were some basic olives, some cheap tasteless tomatoes with one mozzarella slice and another piece of cheap sandwich topping in the form of a thin slice of provolone I'm pretty sure. If an actual Italian came by he would be just as much in shock as I was! I couldn't even eat most of the meal because I was actually pretty grossed out by it. The pasta meal was at least somewhat eatable - but the pasta was really soggy (breaking rule #1 of Italian pasta) and they had just soaked it in a bunch of cheap pasta sauce and topped it with chunks of mozzarella. I'm sad to say I could have done better myself, and I'm not a very advanced chef (again, I'm really not exaggerating). It tasted like one of those prepaid meals you get from the freezer isles. I was super disappointed :( The place is nice and cozy, so if you are mainly there for the atmosphere then go! But I would never, to anyone, recommend the place for it's food. read more

They make freshly baked bread that comes out hot, especially when they're busy. We went during peak hours so didn't expect the efficient service we got. The server, bread and water were a team and backed each other up so well. The fettuccine Alfredo is so fresh and full of flavor, and the chicken Marsala was equally good. Will come again. So romantic when you walk in it does feel like you get transported to a little restaurant in Italy. read more

Caffe Italia - Boneless Chicken Marsala Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Coral Gables, Florida

See all

We've been here a few times over the past couple months and love their food. I get the veal Marsala which is so tender and juicy with pasta and lots of mushrooms and gravy. Wife gets the creamy Alfredo with large shrimp. Also delicious. Servings are large enough we'll have for dinner tonight too. The loaf of hot bread is home made and delicious. And the house Chardonnay is pretty good too. Lunch specials look good so I want to try that next!!!! Go, you won't be disappointed. Some free parking if you go early. read more

Caffe Italia - Veal Marsala - Pizza Near Me - Coral Gables, Florida

My husband and I had the pleasure of going for dinner one day and fell in love with a place. We reserved for a birthday a few days after and it was great. The food is incredible. Great quality, services was amazing. And the ambiance very friendly. Highly recommend. read more

We attended an amazing wine dinner last Wednesday at Caffe Italia. We were a group of 10 and the service was spectacular. In the past years, our group has attended many wine dinners in the So Florida area. I believe last week's dinner was one of the BEST wine dinners we have ever attended. All the wines were amazing, but the food presentation and quality by chef Jackie Pozzoli was one for the record books. I felt like we were being served at a Michelin star restaurant. We all highly recommend it. Special thanks to owner Hugo for his warm hospitality. read more

Take out order. Staff is very friendly. The chicken parmigiana sub sandwich is good but it needs another bread more like a French baguette and not a soft bun or at least put that on the panini toaster because this soft bun makes no sense. Their food is always good tho. read more

See all

Great food and excellent service. We usually order take out, however the place is cozy and inviting. There's also space for family gatherings. Been coming here for 20 years and have never been disappointed. read more

Went there recently and the food and service were outstanding . You will have a great experience. read more

Caffe Italia - Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken and Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Coral Gables, Florida

This place is amazing. I was missing out for a long time. This place means a lot to a few of my close friends and after being there I can totally understand why. Great wine selection, friendly staff especially the owners, and the food is impeccable. I truly recommend this place. read more

Delicious! Absolutely delicious!! We enjoyed a spectacular dinner here last night. The service was quick and gracious. Our glasses never went empty, and everything we ordered was wonderful. We started off with the Mozzarella Marinara and some garlic rolls. We then had Penne with Pink Sauce, the Fiocci, Veal Parmesan and another Veal dish. If you are looking for a cozy place in Coral Gables for a lovely dinner, look no further than Café Italia! read more

Caffe Italia - Penne with Pink Sauce baked with Melted Mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Coral Gables, Florida

I had the opportunity to have a dinner with family at Caffé Italia in Coral Gables over the holiday break. It's an intimate and classic Italian restaurant serving old-school Italian favorites, pastas, pizza, salad's, seafood etc. At any Italian restaurant there's plenty for vegetarians to eat, so I knew I wasn't going to go hungry. I tend to prefer more refined, slightly less classic Italian food, but every now and then you need a good basic Italian meal just to keep you going. The staff was very accommodating to our party - not only am I a vegetarian, but we had a gluten-free diner and three kids with different preferences. No one left hungry. They served us super good Italian bread. It was very light with a perfect crust on the outside. It was everything you could've wanted out of Italian bread. (Served warm!) We started with a large cheese pizza as an appetizer for the table. One of the kids in the party wanted it well done, which kind of ruined it for me who doesn't like a burnt pizza. I definitely felt it was overcooked, and for my taste there was nowhere near enough tomato sauce on it. I'd be happy to try it again in the future, not well done so I could get the appropriately chewy crust, and not overly burned cheese, and I would definitely request more sauce I ordered the veggie lasagna, which I thought would be a marinara based lasagna with vegetables in it, but it turned out to be a cream-based lasagna, with broccoli mushrooms and spinach. It was hearty, and tasted pretty good, though the noodles were a little bit over done. I thought they should've been a little al-dente. It certainly was an impressive looking dish with a bit of marinara sauce around the edges. Nothing not authentic about it. All of the dishes that came out to everyone had very generous portions and for the most part people people enjoyed their meals, though one of the teenagers did comment that they didn't think their pasta pasta dish was all that great. I should also mention I had the house chianti wine. Generally I am a Cabernet drinking person but being in an Italian restaurant it's nice to drink an Italian wine. House wines can often be on the lower end in terms of taste and drinkability, but I found this to be surprisingly smooth and just the right amount of sweet for a wine. read more

See all

It has been ages since I have dined in person however this restaurant is very consistent. There is a reason it has been there so long. The pastas are good but the pizza is DELICIOUS. The margarita is great, so is any other concoction. There is a lot of competition in the area but this place is top 5. read more

My husband and I just had dinner there and it was phenomenal. We found a 2018 Hall Cabernet Sauvignon on the menu, which was exquisite. The sea bass in a creamy pesto asparagus sauce was incredible. The tiramisu was the fluffiest, and spongiest that I have ever eaten. Our servers, Oscar and Gisele were so attentive. This restaurant has a wine list that is huge and the music playlist includes Frank Sinatra, Dean Martin, Andrea Bocelli and Michael Buble. We loved everything about our dining experience. read more

I came here today for the first time and I'm blown away. The garlic breads, pizza and other appetizers were just insane of how great it taste. The food is authentic Italian style and the service is superb. I would highly recommend this restaurant and will definitely come back again. I'm a fan from this point going forward. read more

The inside filled with wine bottles and cozy tables. Nice private area and service was good. Portions are generous. Osso Bucco was delicious, however the tomato sauce on my pasta was a bit unsavory, to my taste. Cannoli was amazing. read more

Caffe Italia - Eggplant parmigiana and spaghetti - Pizza Near Me - Coral Gables, Florida

See all

We have enjoyed this Restaurant and have attended for many years but have never posted a review and thought that I should do it now since we were there last Wednesday. The food from the salads to the pastas to the pizzas ,empanadas have always been delicious. Really good food like homemade, nice wine and reasonable prices. Great for a date night and really all the time. This is why it has existed for so long. Great service like you don't get anymore in certain places in Miami. We have recommended this Restaurant to many and they have always enjoyed it and now can't stay away! Including my son in law, ha! Try it! read more

I had not been to Cafe Italia in a few years and boy am I glad I went on Friday for lunch with my son. The service outstanding and the food magnificent! The bruschetta is perfectly seasoned and the tomatoes were firm capers make it ultra special. I had the veal parmigiana with pasta special and enjoyed every bite plus I had some leftovers for dinner. I'll be back real soon. read more

Amazing place with delicious food in the heart of Coral Gables. This place is so close to perfection, the taste has not changed in the 15 years that I have frecuentes this place. Las time I visited was 5 years ago and yesterday was as pleasant as the first time! The flavor is the same, the service is great, variety of foods a d wine selection is sublime! If you are a wine lover you must visit the wine cellar, you will go nuts in there! Baths are modern and very clean. As far as C19 bio security, precautions are taken (no Temperature check), cleaning between customers, social distancing and sanitizer is offered. The coffee is out if this world and dessert is so good. The pizza is deliciously tasty with a wide selection. An item to highlight are the mini-garlic buns... O-Em-Ge! This is a MUST! Price wise: PERFECT! Over all after all these years, I am still in love with this place: excellent food, location, romantic ambience, parking available, wide selection of wines, private, amazing coffee, good desserts and A1 customer service! You need to go, will become one of your favorite spots in a heartbeat! Congrats to owners, manager and staff for keeping high quality standards!! Great work guys! read more

Caffe Italia - Wine wall... a dream! - Pizza Near Me - Coral Gables, Florida

See all

Great food, great service, reasonable prices! It's been around for quite some time but I just discovered it and I'm certain it'll now be on our regular Italian rotation!! read more

Ended up here for Mother's Day with the family. Small, cozy place with fast and courteous service. Food was tasty and yummy. We ordered a thin crust five cheese pizza to share. Could have been a little less cooked, as some edges were a bit burned but it was still good. Spaghetti and meatballs portion could have been a bit more generous. Meatballs were huge but tasteful. Lasagna was a decent size and perfectly layered. A bit too much sauce, thankfully it was around the actual pasta and not on it. The chicken Alfredo was yummy. Creamy, tasty and a huge portion. Garlic bread was homemade but the garlic was overpowering, even the smell of it. The taste was so strong it didn't go away after eating salad and main meal. All in all we were satisfied and out of there in an hour because of the great and prompt service. I see us going back to try other items on the menu. read more