We came here for a cake tasting and Molly was an absolute charm! Very pleasant and personable, the problem was their cake wasn't good. We tried about 10-12 and only 1 tasted ok. Big disappointment. Presentation was good, they have iPad minis with a gallery of their cakes, and they looked beautiful but we wanted a cake that taste good too :-/ have our cake and eat it :-P read more

I stopped by while in town for business and it was one of the best red velvet cupcakes I have ever had!!! It was super moist, the icing was phenomenal, and I actually appreciated the size - it wasn't too big but it was certainly enough. Next time I am in town I plan on going back and trying more of a variety. GO GET SOME CUPCAKES! read more

Service was friendly. Cupcakes : Cake part ok. Frosting was horrible. Tasted like straight butter. This is the third time I have been in. THIS IS MY LAST TIME!!!! YUCK!!! read more

I always go here to get cupcakes on birthdays for friends, family, and coworkers. Everyone loves a Cake Fetish cupcake! Try the Half-baked, their best selling cookie dough filled cupcake. On Saturdays they have my favorite--Carrot Cake. Everyday they have different specialty cupcakes, always delicious. The only reason they don't get 5 stars is because there are no vegan options (ie: no eggs or milk). read more

The best cakes and cupcakes in town, hands down! Quality you can truly taste. Bill and Kendall are absolutely amazing to work with. I highly recommend Cake Fetish. read more

When you go in on a Tuesday to put in a cupcake order for the following Saturday and they tell you they are no longer taking orders for Saturday, I wonder if they realize they are a business. I could understand if I only gave them a 24 hour notice or even a 48 hour notice but I gave them 5 days. Odd. I walked out and won't ever go back. Cupcakes are cupcakes and there are other bakeries. read more

As a cupcake fiend, I love the idea of a cupcakery and was extremely excited when my boyfriend took me here for a little anniversary cupcake. Cupcakes are my thing, I love baking with a passion and can appreciate a good cupcake. I really really wanted to love Cake Fetish, but I was disappointed on a number of levels. The variety wasn't amazing and the cupcakes were on the small side. While $2.50 is a fair price for a medium sized cupcake, these looked almost smaller than the average size you'd make at home. I'm surprised they don't have a basic vanilla cupcake every day! He got the Peanut Butter Cup cupcake and I got the Velvet Elvis. We both found that both cupcakes were dry and hard to eat even with a fork, since they rip apart and collapse. The buttercream was ok, better than store bought but nothing close to a good, thick buttercream one could whip up in any home kitchen. The tables were sticky and dirty, which was unfortunate since I really did love the design and look of the little shop. The man running the shop was very nice and friendly and the drink selection for $1 was good. Overall, Cake Fetish to me was mediocre at its best and definitely not somewhere I'd suggest to anyone again. You could find the same kind of quality at your local Smiths. read more

Nice bakery. The cupcakes are okay but sometimes a bit on the dry side.

Really enjoyed the orange dream cupcakes about 3 years ago. Looking forward to the chance to get back in and try it again.

Good cupcakes but nasty attitudes of those who work there! We spent about $500 and they couldn't even bring themselves to say Hello when we arrived or Thank You when we picked up our order. We'll take our business somewhere else next time! read more

I was in the area today and decided to stop in to pick up a few cupcakes. I had samples of them last month and they were so good. My goodness, if you want a good cupcake, this is the place to go. They are excellent and the people are friendly that work there. read more

I am getting married this summer and called Cake Fetish to set up an appointment for a cake tasting. I was told that I just needed to let them know the flavors that I wanted to try and then I could just come a pick them up. So, I showed up to pick up my order and was immediately informed that "this is not the way we do things" and that I was supposed to make an appointment. I informed the woman that I was told to just come in and pick them up. She then told me that I must have misunderstood and they "are not in business to give away free cupcakes"! I could not believe this. You know what Cake Fetish, it turns out you did just give away free cupcakes, because I will not be returning to your store. Good job, you just lost an entire wedding order because you don't know how to treat a customer. I will be telling everyone I know to steer clear of Cake Fetish. read more

I love this place! I stopped in yesterday for the min assorted cupcakes on my way home from work. They make the best little desserts and everyone is always super friendly! The key lime pie cupcakes are my absolute favorite!!! read more

Can't say enough good things about this place! Reasonably priced, great and friendly service, and their to -go packaging is very cute! You won't be disappointed. read more

Here is what I have to say about Cake Fetish: This is a small business that is actively working to make innovative strives, not only in their cupcakes, but in their services offered. Try having a talk with the owner sometime to prove that. She is willing to listen, take opinion and fix a problem. Sure, other users have had issues with their customer service, but don't be fooled that they are not working to improve that. If anything, my grandmother takes my 5-year-old niece in there every Friday and even she recognizes that they put attention into making her smile. Beyond just the fact that she's being handed a grenade of sugar, but that they encourage her to be open to decisions and feedback. And believe it, she gives it. And yeah, they're a small business trying to make a big impact. What's you're other option? Walmart? Where I can guarantee no one will offer you custom service on your choice for a mediocre product. All I'm saying is give it another chance. Don't just support improving local business. Encourage it. read more

Did we eat the same cupcakes? Holy crap these cupcakes are phenomenal! I haven't had better anywhere. Nowhere in california are cupcakes this good. So moist, flavors so balanced, not overly sweet. Frosting not overdone. It's heaven. I had the mint chocolate chip, the vanilla, some chocolate thing with strawberry, and the lime flavor. They were all incredible. I don't even like vanilla but theirs is fantastic. I've had sprinkles, kara's cupcakes in SF, sift cupcake in SF, tons of places in san diego. Really, this place is the best. I can't wait to go back. I could pretty much eat a dozen of these in one sitting. read more

Nice cupcake selection, but found them to be too dry and too dense. Apparently the red velvet cupcakes run out first. On Louisiana and Menaul. read more

My family used to love this place and we waited yearly- but things have changed . The frosting on the "Pucker-Up", for example, is now like paste with no lemon flavor at all; the "cheesecake" frosting on the"What's Up Doc" is not tangy cream-cheese but taste like a creation of Duncan Hines. The other toppings that used to be whipped cream now taste like Cool Whip. All, in all, of the dozen cup cakes of various flavors we bought, not a single one was gourmet or lived up to even its description. read more

From Seattle and this was the second cupcake place we visited while I was in town. It was the better of the two. Bought a dozen fresh and a dozen mini day olds. The day olds were fresher than the first places current day. Couldn't pick a favorite, but red velvet, lemon, and some chocolate dipped cupcake kept me happy for 12 days. read more

I have heard of the Cake Fetish for a long time I had the cupcakes today, one of my co-workers brought them in for a meeting and needless to say they were devoured by everyone..................SO GOOD! I have got to get some for the next gathering that I have I know they will be a hit! Can hardly wait to see what all there is in the store! read more

I came in last week to place an order for a birthday cake and received five star customer service! I was told that they bake their cupcakes and cakes FRESH which I love. Everyone at the party loved the cake and commented on how the icing wasn't too sweet. Definitely give this place a try! read more

I got a dozen for my sons 13th bday after reading great reviews. i ordered them special, so they were supposedly fresh and they were bland, flavorless, and DRY! I HATED THEM! ALL 12 of them were bad. Even my kids hated them! And kids will eat just about any cupcake! I sliced a small piece off all 12 and they all were terrible. My kids each ate one and that was it. You know it's bad when a kid won't eat a cupcake. I am offended they sold me this crap and I am embarrased I served it to my son on his 13th birthday. If they have any sense at all, they will stop baking this way and give refunds to people like me. Hqnds down, any grocery store has moister, more delicious cupcakes than this 1.75 per cupcake place! read more

Hi I had a huge birthday party and ordered a cake and four dozen cupcakes on the side. Although it was an amazing experience that they were nice and well ready when we arrived to pick up our order.. our cake looked amazing! so. .. good customer service .. amazing presentation. . hmmm the taste was overwhelming... WERE RETURNING CUSTOMERS! We had ordered.. Zen for the cake a little dry but the taste was wonderful and I was please above all else! Birthday cupcake was good a little simple if ur not adventurous. cherry cordinal a big hit everyone jumped on it! OMG half baked is now my husbands favorite! He can't stop talking about it. And ta da* the cookies n cream soo delicious. My favorite and my reason I'm a returning customer.. so fairly a good attitude and a watery mouth take your taste buds to amazing bliss.. in cupcake land.. please consider bad AND good but our day was fantastic! Thanks cupcake fetish!!! read more

Super friendly staff and new owners! I love what they've done with the decor and improvement in flavors and moistness of the actual cake. These cupcakes are so well done! Their assortment of seasonal flavors, in addition to their regular flavors, keep me coming back for more! I wholeheartedly recommend them! They are Soo good! read more

I have gone into Cake Fetish a few times before for a single cupcake as a treat for a pregnant friend and always had a good experience. $2.50-$3.00 per cupcake is quite expensive, but they are tasty. I recently had my daughters birthday and she wanted a "TinTin" cake. I called Cake Fetish and emailed them pictures. We first wanted the "Half-Baked" but we called 5 minutes after we ordered and changed our order, deciding on a cake resembling their "Chocoholic" cupcake. I was told that the middle layer would have their ganache and then it would also be drizzled on the sides. The lady I spoke with said that she would somehow need to freeze the cake to do that layer of ganche. I was even charged an extra $3.00 for the extra ganache. Well, on my daughters birthday I picked up the cake and it looked amazing! That night, however, we were quite disappointed. There was no layer of ganache in the middle. The cake was not very chocolaty. The frosting was sparse. I brought a piece of her cake into the store the following week. The older gentleman who works there looked at the cake and my receipt. He kept telling me that the $3.00 extra charge was for the drizzle of ganache on the sides, because "ganache is expensive". That was not true, but if so I NEVER would have ordered it in the first place. A tiny drizzle of ganache for an extra $3.00? No one has called me. He did offer me a cupcake as I was walking out the door. I gave it to my daughter since it was her $40.00 birthday cake that was a disappointment. We REALLY wish we had gone for the Half-Baked instead. I do feel we should have been reimbursed a bit more. It costs them almost nothing to give out a cupcake. That cake was EXPENSIVE, especially during this time for my family. I don't think I will ever be ordering a cake with them again. read more

Just picked up my daughter's birthday cake. I requested a customized birthday cake with a "The Little Mermaid" theme. I brought in little figurines in to be used and asked them to create the cake around the figurines. They showed all sorts of interest and even said their cake designer was all excited about the cake. I ordered the largest cake they make to allow them more room to be creative etc. Paid 130$. What we got was a giant plain blue cake with the plastic figurines I provided stuck into the top off the cake. Nothing else. Not a single design, not a sea-shell or starfish or anything that would have required an actual cake designer. My wife is now decorating the cake herself because she is so horrified by it. read more

My experience at Cake Fetish was by far the best experience I've had in a bakery, I was helped by a sweet girl Cassidy, she was VERY helpful and was able to answer all of my questions about ingredients of both the cake and frosting.. I will definitely return and reccomend it!!! Thank you for a great experience Cassidy!! ;-) read more

The cupcakes themselves are delicious. They have tons of options and they are all elaborately made. The presentation is what disappoints-for to go, they give you your cupcakes in a plastic container, same as what you would get at Walmart. For real? This is a gourmet bakery, not Smith's! I would totally go back as cupcakes are great, but come on Cake Fetish...let's work on containers that are not cheap and ghetto. Smallcakes has printed CARDBOARD BOXES. Do the same. read more

If I could give zero stars I would. This place puts out a living social deal and then acts upset when you want to use it. Hello? If you don't want us to use your coupon then DONT PUT IT OUT!! I called to order my cupcakes,as stated on the coupon, and I could tell instantly that the staff member was aggravated that I was using the coupon. I was rudely informed that I needed to call EXACTLY 48 hours or more before I could pick up the cupcakes . I ordered them to be picked up 5 days later. When I arrived I was given a dozen of plain vanilla cupcakes. Normally they have sprinkles which my daughter loves. When I asked about them I was rudely told those were not included with the coupon and if I wanted them I would have to pay 0.25 cents. Obviously 25 cents is not much but the principal is what counts. I have spent lots of money on cupcakes here in the past but the one time I use a coupon I am treated rudely? I will NEVER come here again and I would not waste my time if I was any of you. Rude service for mediocre cupcakes. read more

My teenaged son is an aspiring baker, he and I are in Albuquerque on a quest to try as many bakeries as we can. The name Cake Fetish is adorable and was very appealing to us and we were excited to go there. We arrived at 4:45 on a Saturday and the friend we were with suggested we get the box of 12 tiny bite sized cakes so we could each sample several flavors, we thought that was brilliant and it's exactly what we did. I walked over to where there were napkins, grabbed a couple and we started to walk to a table and we were informed that since it was now 4:50 and they close at 5:00 we were not allowed to sit there. The girl was very unfriendly (its cupcakes, maybe you should smile a bit!) and not apologetic at all when she pretty much asked us to leave. It was VERY hot that day and we came in separate cars and didn't want to sit in the car while we tried the cakes, so we stood in front of the shop and consumed them all the while watching several customers go in and out. The business was still very much open when we were done because we managed to each eat 4 bite sized cakes in about 5 minutes TOPS. The cakes were pretty good, I felt they were a little on the oily side and the one with coffee tasted artificial to me, but in all, I'd give the cupcakes 3 out of 5 and the service a 1. We travel to Albuquerque fairly often and honestly I see no reason to return to Cake Fetish. read more

ok, cupcakes are so not my thing- they're beautiful, but often disappoint by being too dry/sweet. but even i like the cupcakes here. i walked in 10 min before closing time (they have different hours for different seasons on saturdays- i think i said that right), and there were 2 more flavors left: "Scutterbotch- Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream dunked in melted butterscotch" and "Chocolate Cream Pie- Chocolate Bavarian filled chocolate cake topped with chocolate whipped cream & rolled in graham cracker crumbs". Did you catch the part about being dunked in melted butterscotch!?! I bought one of each and took them home to share with my roommate. We both loved them and I wished I didn't have to share. I'm not big on frosting in general, but the cake part was good enough to win over a cake-hater like me. Plus, they had cream fillings, which is a big plus for me. The woman after me in line had called ahead to reserve her Choc Bavarian cupcake, which was smart b/c she got the last one. Custom order cakes start at 6" for $30. read more

I used to love coming here, until today. I ordered special cupcakes with an edible picture of a soccer ball. When I got there this morning they informed me they had issues with there printer and it was going to be a few extra minutes. I was OK with that, I understand things happen. Fifteen minutes letter we got to the soccer park and I noticed 4 cupcakes where melting and looked horrible, the other 8 looked fine. I figured maybe they through on the printed edibles on and they where still warm or something. I called and was told that they need to be refrigerated and they would melt in the sun. Well today is overcast and in the 60's. If that was the case then wouldn't they all melt? I was shocked after spending $42.00 they did not offer some sort of compensation. Oh and by the way, I left 3 cupcakes in the car for 2 hours and they did not melt, they looked great. I am shocked they did not admit it could be there error since they had a "printing" issue. I am sad they could not handle this different. I will make sure to inform anyone and everyone I can. Back to ABC cake I go! read more

We had a good experience starting with our tasting and consultation. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. And the cake was incredible tasting at the ceremony. When the cake was delivered the person who delivered had no idea about putting the styrofoam square under the tablecloth which we were told to do when we had our consultation. Not a huge problem, we went ahead and did that. I had emailed pics of the topper to the bakery before the delivery so that they would know what was needed to secure it. After the cake was delivered and the guy left, the topper fell off the cake. It bounced off the layers and landed (luckily) on the table or it would have broken. We were able to fix it ourselves and secure it to what was originally in the cake to hold it. When I called in to request a copy of our receipt, the person I talked to listened, but I haven't heard back from anyone, so don't know if the information was passed on to the appropriate person. I would appreciate knowing if the information was received. read more

I ordered a wedding cake from these people. HUGE MISTAKE. Although they did show up on time for delivery and have free consultation, the rest was not good at all. When we went cake tasting they didn't have all the flavors they offered out for us to taste. Okay I suppose I can GUESS what pineapple cake tasted like but it would have been nice to have their other options. After discussing with them what I wanted our cake to look like in detail (it wasnt too hard, there was even a cake inside at that time on display looking exactly like it!) Well a few days before the wedding they tell me that they can't get the frosting "drape" to work on this type of cake (when they had specifically told me MONTHS before that it would be just fine) Well we'd already paid for the cake so she said she could try to find some material instead of frosting and for the inconveinience we could probably get it discounted. Well let's just say I never heard about that offer again. So finally ON MY WEDDING DAY I see this UGLY monstrosity of cake. The frosting was almost yellow and NOT white like we asked. The flowers they used weren't the ones I was shown, but they were white so it looked disgusting against the frosting. Also the cake was stiff and very hard to cut. I was VERY dissappointed. Why would you send out an ugly cake? read more