"I was very hungover, and honestly still a little drunk, when I went to breakfast here. They do not skimp on they're breakfast servings, three egg omelet, two pieces of toast, and lots o'potatoes! Completely cured my hungover and it was nice and quiet too which was dope cause I had a killer headache. Would def eat there again! A cute baby was there too, which was delightful. I love kids, I want one, oh god, I'm so alone. Five out of five stars! " read more

Too hot to cook tonight, and tired of the usual suspects. We've always wanted to go when visiting Peddler's Village, but it never worked out. We called, Caleb answered and we had reservations for 2 in no time! Caleb confirmed it was a BYO and we were all set. The menu has a wide variety, it's unusual to find one where every item was one I wanted to try. We had the beet salad, lobster rolls, sustainable salmon, and the crab cakes. Each was memorable. Can't wait to return for dinner, or brunch to try everything else on the menu. I see that Monday is locals 3 courses prix-fixe $24, Tuesday's is burger night time to build your own. We'll definitely be back, and often to try the rest of the menu. PS. The decor was bright and relaxing, the staff attentive and friendly, Thanks to Kelly for making our evening relaxing! read more

Our favorite breakfast/lunch place closed. We found Caleb's American Kitchen thanks to our favorite server Cheryl. Now we can't imagine going anywhere else. Everything is fresh farm to table delicious food. There are always amazing specials. We've tried almost everything and its always wonderful and delicious! ( and healthy)!! read more

We do take out all the time now but intend to start going back to the restaurant once we are vaccinated. Great food always.

Was in town with my mother. This place came recommended. Excellent service. I love that it is BYOB. We shared the HALLOUMI & HUMMUS salad. It was good but tiny. The menu highlights a couple of ingredients that were basically garnish. Not good value for the money. The entrees, on the other hand, were larger portions than I expected. My mother thoroughly enjoyed the SUSTAINABLE ATLANTIC SALMON. I ordered the BEEF FILET MEDALLIONS. The beef was perfectly cooked, the decadent potato croquettes werr delicious and they veggies were cooked perfectly - bot too raw, not overcooked. We were unfortunately too full for dessert. Our waiter was excellent, funny and gave great service. The place was crowded and noisy. read more

Staff was wonderful. Worst breakfast I ever had. I ordered one of their morning specials. It was supposed to be an egg skillet with sausage, cheese, roasted tomato purée. The eggs were raw in the middle (not under cooked). The tomato purée was Heinz ketchup. (Trust me, I know the difference). It really was the worse thing I have ever been served. read more

Great food and the wait staff are very pleasant. I e eaten there many times for lunch and looking forward to trying it for dinner.

Came here with two of my friends for breakfast and all I can say was that my "All American" (2 Blueberry Pancakes, Eggs and crest Beacon) was fresh and fabulous! The pancakes were light not a heavy batter with fresh blueberries inside - plus the best part was that it was served with real maple syrup, not the thick supermarket brand syrup. The Beacon was also delicious! not the Oscar Myer brand. The decor was clean and fresh with grey / white color walls with plenty of seating inside. Plus the prices $$ for breakfast were just right. However, my friend did tell me that their dinner prices were just a little too high $$$ and that she would rather eat somewhere else in town for that money. The staff could not be any nicer and the service was quick. ***Note: there was plenty of parking out front, and we did not have a problem finding a spot. But, I did hear that on Sunday's after church lets out the place is a madhouse and there could be a long wait. All and all, I will be coming back here for breakfast... YUM! YUM! read more

A suggestion based on experience - don't complain about the food. Not to your waitress or manager ger.

I love that their food is locally sourced. Food is very good and reasonably priced. BYOB. I had the duck and my husband had the seasonal monkfish. We were both very impressed. read more

Beef brisket and blonde sundae was phenomenal.New England chowder had a pleasant light cream with crab. Warm bread was a welcome touch with "Italian butter" -aka Olive oil with sea salt and rosemary. read more

Delicious food and atmosphere! I ordered the all American breakfast and it was simply delectable. Will be back soon!

We are in love with Caleb's! Wow, wow and wow! The food is always amazing and the staff are lovely as is the atmosphere. It is also a lovely touch that Caleb comes out and checks in and says hello to all, making you feel like a part of the family. It is our go-to place and we send all of our friends too!! read more

Fantastic dining experience with the lady! BYOB- don't forget it! The crabcakes were fire! Tough time deciding between all the wonderful salads! Make sure to say hi to Caleb himself on your way out! read more

Food is always excellent, service is good and atmosphere is lovely. I go here often for breakfast since they serve it until noon daily and later on weekends. Owner is great-he accommodated us last minute on a last minute parents night out. Food is always delicious and appealing. read more

Excellent Excellent Excellent. American tavern classics. Higher end per plate ($$$) but well worth the cost for quality. Service was extremely amicable. Call for reservations. read more

I've been here for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The food is always good and they have a bunch of vegetarian options. The pumpkin pancakes with maple butter are awesome! This is my "go to" breakfast spot. I always ask to be seated in Amanda's section, she is always sweet, friendly and quick (even first thing in the morning). PS. You will never see the bottom of your coffee cup at Caleb's unless you ask them to stop bringing it :) read more

Usually love calebs, had eggs benedict. the spinach was too spinachy, too bitter, a little salt and fat take away bitterness fyi. Too much ham, i prefer Canadian bacon. I was surprised by the potatoes, greasy, not a fan, wish theyd offered me fruit. read more

This is a fabulous spot for breakfast and lunch! With plenty of options on the menu from crabcakes Benedict, to creme brulee French toast, I have not been disappointed with anything I have eaten! The server was excellent the facilities clean and freshly decorated. I highly recommend this establishment for a great start to your day! Bravo, Caleb!! read more

Love this place -- especially for breakfast and lunch. The crime brûlée French toast is out of this world. Their salads are always delicious. read more

We went during restaurant week in the spring. We had great service food was exceptional and I liked to the trio of desserts. The decor is modern minimalist. Will try to go back in the summer read more

Valentine's 2021. Each course was better than the last. Absolutely sublime. A sophisticated, creative, and delightful experience. The service was friendly, attentive, without being annoying, and genuinely warm. One of the best meals I've had in a long time. read more

Disappointing Valentine's dinner at Caleb's. We eat here regularly and so expected to enjoy the same quality of food and service we normally enjoy at Caleb's. The service and hospitality, as usual, was exceptional. The food, however, was not up to normal standards. Both of my lobster tails were undercooked - still quite translucent and rubbery with cold crabmeat stuffing on top and served with cold risotto and vegetables. Our dessert was missing several of the elements that were supposed to be included. We did not feel comfortable bringing any of this to the attention of our server because the couple at the table next to us was so close that they repeatedly interjected themselves into our private conversation. Our server was great-- attentive and personable. Overall this meal was not anything near what we have come to expect from a meal at Caleb's. read more

We went for brunch and everything was fresh and delicious! Their blueberry pancakes were wonderful! And when you're waiter asks if you want crispy bacon, you can't beat it! Can't wait to go back and try their dinner menu! read more

Great place for breakfast. We have had pancakes-wonderful, eggs-great, the potato frittata - ok. The bread is outstanding, one reason not to order the pancakes! read more

This is a local favorite of ours. There is always locally sourced food on the menu with many choices for all palates. The service is great and they are also community minded. read more

Outstanding spinach salad with Golden and red beets . I asked to substitute salmon for chicken . One of the best tasting , freshest salads I've ever ordered for lunch . Beets were prepared naturally and out of this world ! read more

Just moved to the neighborhood. Wife and I went to Caleb's for lunch. I had the frittata-a but dry but not bad, she had a salad which was far too overdressed. Iced tea was old and stale. However the service was excellent. Will probably go back once more to see if we caught them on an off day. read more

We went to Caleb's last night and loved it. We are vegan and the tofu dish and the beet dish were fabulous. We can't wait to go back. The couple we were with had a chicken dish and the barramundi. They loved both dishes. EXCELLENT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Mostly disappointed. Ambiance - close seating and loud. Food - barramundi was a bit dry and over done but the veggies etc helped a bunch. Really liked crisp lobster rolls appetizer. My partner had the miso glazed salmon and reported, correctly, that her salmon is better. The tuna poke was a first time so hard to rate. I drank almost the whole liter of water bc my food was too dry. Owner/chef walked around giving out free shots of raspberry white chocolate - but not us. Prices too high. However good food is priceless so if it were superb, then twice the cost would have been acceptable. We will not go back. We are not going back. read more

We had an excellent breakfast to celebrate Mom's birthday. The wait staff was excellent and really made us feel like everyone was celebrating this event! There are many breakfast choices in the area, but Caleb's ranks at the top read more

Great food. Prices reasonable. Great decor. Server was good. They take reservations. We had the breakfast menu. I got the blueberry pancakes. Amazing. read more

We've been here three times. Once for dinner with friends, twice for breakfast. Dinner was excruciatingly loud, the meal was ok, but not very inspired. Breakfast has been a hit for my wife once, a miss the second time. Both of my breakfast experiences have been the same - room temp meal accompanied by potatoes that have been sitting on the flat top way too long. The wait staff spend more time in the kitchen talking to each other than they spend doing their jobs. I'm sorry to be so direct - but our waiter never checked on us after serving our meals... not an offer of more coffee nor an inquiry into how our meal was... after finishing our meal - and 10 minutes of looking at our dishes - we had to get up and ask for our check... and still nobody asked how our meal was. $25 for breakfast for two is fine but one should expect basic service. It will be a long time before we give it another chance. That being said - your experience may vary - hopefully it will be a better experience than ours. read more

Outstanding food. It's byob. I had the salmon and it was delicious. My husband had seared scallops that were delicious as well. Caleb was on site and treating guests. Also offered a complimentary shot of grapefruit liqueur. read more

Best restaurant in town!! I got the noble pig which was incredible. My mom got the avocado toast which she absolutely loved. Will be back soon! read more

Caleb's American Kitchen - The Noble Pig sandwich with onion ring on top and homemade potato chips...amazing!!! - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

I have never had a bad meal here!! Caleb's breakfast is my favorite in town. The local's night 3 course pre-fixe for $28 is an AMAZING value!!! I highly recommend! read more

Caleb's is almost there. Food was very good but not great. Just needs some additional small touches. Adding a wasabi sauce to the tuna dish for example. Simple salt and pepper seasoning. The food is a great value for the quality and quantity. I will be back. read more

Tried out Caleb's while staying down the street at the Golden Plough Inn because of the Yelp writeups. We were not disappointed. Food was good. We had the flatiron steak and the swordfish and both were well prepared and presented and the portions were just right. read more

I come here often with my family when in the area because we think it's one of the best brunch spots around. Today we came and were not disappointed. It is was a little crowded but they did a good job of handling it and provided good service. I ordered the breakfast quesadillas, my father got the veggie Rueben, my grandfather got the three egg omelet, my sisters got short stacks of pancakes, and my mother got the Creme Brûlée French toast. Our food took about twenty minutes, a normal wait time. When it came it was very good. The breakfast quesadilla was stuffed with scrambled eggs, peppers, beans, etc. On the side was some avocado salsa. It was delicious and very flavourful. The creme brûlée French toast was also good, with thick slices of creamy french toast thinly covered in creamy sauce. The veggie Rueben was good too, with potatoes, imitation beef (which was amazing considering some i've had) and all the classic elements of a good Rueben. My grandfather claimed the three egg omelet was good too and well cooked with the perfect amount of spice. My sisters both seemed satisfied with their pancakes and quickly devoured them. The drinks were good too. I got raspberry tea and they provided lots of hot water which I liked. (I've been to places where they barely provide enough water for a full cup of tea.) Caleb's is a delicious breakfast spot in a nice location. read more

I hosted a brunch of 25 people at Caleb's and everything was great! The set up was perfect; there were two large tables in the sun room, very pretty. The food portions were large and delicious. The waitresses were very nice and on top of everything. read more

Caleb's American Kitchen - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania