Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen

    3.9 (52 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 8:00 pm
    Updated over 3 months ago

    Order Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen Takeout or Delivery

    Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen Photos

    Business Info

    CAPLINGER'S FRESH CATCH SEAFOOD KITCHEN ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Casual
    Dogs allowed

    You might also consider

    More like Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen

    Recommended Reviews - Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    A seafood place with a breaded tenderloin
    Richard P.

    If you've ever driven down Pendleton Pike and done a double-take when you passed by what looks like another Caplinger's location, it is actually a Caplinger's location. Officially known as "Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen," this spot semi-resembles its sister locations - the original spot on Shadeland Avenue and the Whitestown location. In case it's not obvious from the name, Caplinger's specializes in seafood - dinners, sandwiches, etc. Unlike the sister locations, Caplinger's is not a sit-down joint. They offer carry-out or delivery. I placed my order this evening via GrubHub, a rather dastardly way of having dinner given the upping of the price but a nice option for someone recovering from surgery and wanting a decent meal. Also unlike the other locations, this location obviously doesn't have any retail options. Essentially, as has been pointed out, it's rather like a food truck but in this case it's in a set location. You pull into the parking lot and order at the window. You wait for your food. They do have a loudspeaker, so you can wait in your car if desired. As they prepare the food fresh, the wait can be 20 minutes or so. For some odd reason, mostly because I have a friend who blogs about tenderloin, I opted to go away from their seafood options and order their hand-breaded tenderloin. It comes with the usual toppings, though they were delivered on the side. They also have a variety of side options - I chose an order of waffle fries. The entire meal came in at just over $12 for the base meal, but by the time you add in delivery and tip you definitely go higher. While I'm rating the meal a 4-star, I'll add a slight disclaimer that I doubt I would actually order it again. The Caplinger's specialty is seafood and this meal wasn't really good enough to make me deviate again. It was fun to try, but just a touch disappointing. The sandwich is huge - it's on the thinner side, but not too thin. It definitely has a meaty taste to it with some strong seasoning. I would almost say a bit too strong. I'd almost gone for their hush puppies, which I'd tried at the Shadeland location, but opted for the fries. Again, I'd probably go for hash browns next time. The waffle fries weren't much more than warm by the time they arrived, though the serving size was plentiful. If I could, I'd probably go 3.5. However, I'm going up primarily because service is always solid at Caplinger's and this is a side item outside their specialty. It's a solid value for the price. It is noted that they have sandwiches, dinners, sides, desserts, and drinks. I did not see drinks on the GrubHub menu, though I doubt that I'd have ordered a drink anyway. The only two sandwiches that are not fish/seafood related - chicken and tenderloin. Among the dinners, the only things not fish/seafood are chicken. They do also have frog legs and alligator tail. Since I just had my leg amputated, I didn't have the heart to eat frog legs. I'm kind of being serious. Anyway, I'm going with a 4-star rating while acknowledging that upon a future visit I'll likely stick to their seafood menu specialties. If you're in the area and looking for something to take home, it's a terrific option but definitely not a destination spot. I should note that there's a wheelchair ramp that goes up to the order window - it's a touch steep, but its presence is appreciated.

    Fish and Shrimp combo with Buffalo Fries and Candied Yams
    Meg E.

    I came by this week to pick up dinner. It's typically busy here with a line and I was able to come at a rare non-busy time (score!). The gentleman at the counter was patient with me as I asked questions about the menu (I had only been to their other location once years ago). He explained that the fish they are known for (basa) was brought to the area by the Caplinger's and very delicious. I decided to try this with the fish & shrimp combo. I got the fish fried and the shrimp grilled (they give you a variety of seasonings to choose from). I ordered buffalo fries and candied yams as my sides. My wait wasn't very long and it looks like everything is made to order so I didn't mind waiting (only about 5 min). As I waited, a lot of people poured it. It's obvious that this location is booming and I'm happy for them! Support local businesses!! When I got home with my order, I quickly realized I had no hush puppies, sad day. I dug in to eat and was not overly impressed with the small shrimp. They were underwhelming. The fish though- that was the best darn fish I had ever had in my entire life. I would give that fish 100 stars if I could! The buffalo fries were okay, a little softer than I prefer fries, and the yams were pretty good. I tried to call about the hush puppies but the line was busy (likely with orders). I messaged them on yelp and the owner got back to me within a couple of minutes. He was very kind and apologetic. I was not upset, mistakes happen, I just wanted my hush puppies on my next order, which he guaranteed to help make happen. Overall, this is a great place that deserves continued support. If you aren't into seafood, or have someone in your party who isn't, they had other options, such as chicken and pork sandwiches. Otherwise, you better try that basa - you'll be SO glad you did!

    Menu
    Dale D.

    I had heard many times about this restaurant and have to admit I was skeptical about ordering from what looked like a shack on the side of the road. I am glad I decided to try it. I ordered the catfish dinner and it was really good. Came with plenty of food and sides. I will definitely be ordering there again and want to try the main location now. If you are on that side of town, I highly recommend you give Caplinger's a try! Keep up the great work and the good food.

    Menu
    Libby B.

    So I was trying to decide what to have for dinner on the way home when I suddenly remembered that I'd be going by Caplinger's! I see it often, but for some reason, I could never remember it was there! Well, I finally did. This is more like a food truck setup. You order at the window, and then you wait probably 20 minutes or so for your food, depending on how many orders are in front of you. You can actually wait in your car with the window down if you want. They announce your name over a loudspeaker. I realized they didn't ask my name, but just used the one on the card I paid with. With cash, I imagine they ask! I got the catfish dinner which was a serious amount of food! Two large filets, 2 sides (slaw & mac 'n cheese), and 2 hush puppies. The mac 'n cheese was amazing and well seasoned! The catfish was perfectly crispy and great by itself but also tasty with the tartar sauce or hot sauce. You can eat there if you want as there are picnic tables, but it's not the most scenic/restful place to do so since it's next to Pendleton Pike and currently next to an active construction site (for Belle Tire). I'm a happy camper, and I'm sure this will solidify my memory that although this location is unassuming, it's still amazing seafood! No more forgetfully driving by this one!

    Caplinger's Fresh Fish Market on PendletonPike
    Bobbi J.

    This one is outdoors, a get it and go place, but the same deliciousness as the one on N. Shadeland. Maybe they will add picnic tables in the future? That would be a great idea in my opinion. Also, Greenwood needs one!!

    Ocean Perch Dinner
    Dione B.

    The perch is amazing. Seasoned, crispy, and the white meat is so soft! Waffle fries better than chick fil a! Just hurry up and place a order!!!

    Is that worth $13?

    The fish is decent. But def not worth the price. I've tried this place 4x. Each time they've been hella rude and always make it so hard to order. I will say, someone besides the cashier always try to help me. Today is the day they lost me though. I paid $13 for barely a filet of catfish. I feel like I'm getting robbed everytime. This is not worth the money. And the sides are very mid. And I mean veryyyyy mid. Not only that they tricked me and had me thinking they'd fix my order. I waited an extra 10 mins for literally no reason at all. Highly do not recommend.

    a sandwich in a plastic container

    See all

    7 years ago

    Awesome shrimp cocktail! Variety of seafood possibilities. Definitely worth the drive if you don't live near the location.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    I can eat caplinger's special dinner everyday if I had to. I lovvveeeee Caplingers!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jan B.
    0
    10
    6

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Bob B.
    0
    23
    2

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Love the guys here! Food is always great and fast! My family's favorite place for Friday night Fish and Chips!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen

    Is there another phone number for this location? This one does not go through.

    Not that I could find.

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    Juicy Seafood Indy - Castleton

    Juicy Seafood Indy - Castleton

    3.8(146 reviews)
    5.7 mi
    $$

    I really enjoy coming to Juicy Seafood in Castleton. One of my favorite things about this place is…read morethat it's not loud, so you can actually enjoy your meal and have a conversation without shouting. The booths aren't the most comfortable, but the overall atmosphere is relaxed and pleasant. The $5 Coronas are a great deal, and my go-to order is the Juicy Special. It has a little kick to it, so if you're sensitive to spice, keep that in mind--but I think the flavor is worth it. I especially loved the lobster, sausage, black mussels, and frog legs. Everything was flavorful, and the seafood was delicious. There are some good deals on the menu if you're looking to keep the cost down. However, if you're dining with your partner and both of you order lobster or other premium seafood, plan on spending around $100 or more. For me, it's worth it for a nice seafood dinner. Don't worry if cracking the seafood seems intimidating--they provide scissors and seafood tools at the table to make it much easier. And don't forget to put on the plastic gloves and apron before you dig in, because things can definitely get messy! If you're looking for a casual spot with a relaxed atmosphere where you can enjoy great seafood and actually have a conversation, Juicy Seafood in Castleton is definitely worth a visit.

    I visited yesterday as part of a large group (8 adults, 2 kids) for a birthday dinner. We were…read moreseated promptly and had a very sweet server. It took some time for us all to order and start getting our drinks. However, the food started coming out pretty quickly. I ordered the Plant Power with cajun seasoning at the medium spice level with a side of boiled eggs. It was so delicious! It came out piping hot and covered in seasoning. The plant power comes with a generous amount of corn, boiled potatoes, and broccoli. The boiled eggs were overcooked, though, and they were too hot to eat for awhile, though. They burned my fingers! I loved the flavor and didn't think it was spicy at all, though. I was worried that the veggie plate would be underwhelming in comparison to the seafood boils that everyone else ordered but I think I actually enjoyed it the most lol Since they knew we were celebrating my boyfriend's birthday, they gave a gift card for $15 off his next visit. They also have a neon lit birthday sign and our server lead us in singing the Birthday song -- if you don't like that kind of attention, don't tell them lol

    Photos
    Juicy Seafood Indy - Castleton
    Juicy Seafood Indy - Castleton - Black & Red for Two

    Black & Red for Two

    Juicy Seafood Indy - Castleton - The mold in the drink

    See all

    The mold in the drink

    Watami Sushi All You Can Eat - Chicken Cutlet and Fried Dumplings

    Watami Sushi All You Can Eat

    3.8(301 reviews)
    1.3 mi
    $$

    I love all 3 Watami here in Indy but the one on Pendleton Pike is my favorite…read more The Lady who is host is so gracious and lovely and always makes you feel welcome. I love their seaweed salad and green tea ice cream. The other locations don't always have these two items. They have a great selection of various kinds of sushi as well as many other Japanese specialties. Their Tempura is some of the best I've ever had anywhere. I recently had a girls night out here with two good friends who are dealing with a-lot of hardship and this beautiful delicious meal Lifted our spirits and satisfied all craves! Anytime I come here alone or with friends it's a wonderful experience. Also you get a lot of quality food artfully presented for very reasonable price.

    Watami has one superpower--One unique selling point that it does well. And honestly, it's really…read morethe only thing it does well. But this singular power is strong enough to cause me to stop in from time to time. So you have to ask yourself... what kind of sushi eater are you? If you or anyone in your party is a sushi aficionado (read: sushi snob) then Watami is not for you. The food is good, and the Godzilla roll is probably one of the best cooked sushi rolls I've ever had. So the food, itself, is appetizing and worth a visit. But if you are looking for an elegant evening of dining, a trendy sushi bar, or even just decent service... keep looking. Watami is not for you. On the other hand, if you simply want to eat an ungodly amount of udon noodles, vegetable tempura, sashimi, and sushi rolls with no shame, that's where Watami shines. Their super power? All you can eat sushi. A tablet is stationed at each table with the menu, and you can order until your little heart (and stomach) is content. I ate so much fish on Saturday night, they probably should have tested me for mercury poisoning. I miss the days when they simply had a laminated menu and you made marks with a dry erase marker. This meant your server was visiting your table frequently. Now that the menu is on a tablet, they only need to bring you the food. However, drinks aren't on the tablet. My friend couldn't order a glass of plum wine until our meal was almost complete. Pro tip: if you go in a large group like I did the other night, I would suggest clicking the "send" button at the top after each order. We passed around the tablet and everything came out on 1-2 large platters. If you know everyone in your party, it makes for a fun family style meal. But if you are with new friends or order something specific, I would place your order, first, and then pass the tablet.

    Photos
    Watami Sushi All You Can Eat - US31 Roll and Gozilla Roll

    US31 Roll and Gozilla Roll

    Watami Sushi All You Can Eat - IPad you order on for all you can eat!

    IPad you order on for all you can eat!

    Watami Sushi All You Can Eat - Sushi

    See all

    Sushi

    Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen - seafood - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...