I've been here a few times now and each time is a great experience. The music is fantastic and the bartenders, Elena, Ceci, and Araceli are extraordinary! The food is to die for and each one has it's own flavor, truly recommend this carribbean-styled restaurant with all five stars. read more

See all

Holy cow. Just visited for the first time. Absolutely amazing. We sat at the bar and Elena helped us pick drinks and food that would cover our seafood cravings. I had a passion fruit mixed drink- amazing! For dinner I had the ahi tuna and my husband had a mixed seafood dish with a rich brown sauce. His fish was outrageously big and a steal for the price. I cant remember the name but it came in a stone pot . We will definitely be back. Can't believe we waited so long.! read more

Go. Just go. And enjoy! We went for my birthday with a pretty large group. They absolutely rocked the service! Very patient, attentive, and got the order perfect! We ordered several appetizers, and my fave was the fried fish. For seafood lovers, this place is awesome. And no worries for those who are not, they have plenty of non-seafood choices. The atmosphere is breezy, bright, and tropical. The bar area is fun and inviting too! The only thing that would make this better is if the lyrics had live music. Here's hoping that comes soon!! read more

See all

Loved the chips with the green spicy salsa, the citrusy scrumptuous ceviche and the numerous available spicy salsas. The food was superb, the service was excellent, and the restaurant was clean, and had a design you'd see on the beaches of Mexico - excluding the sand ;) read more

Caribe Marisqueria - Octopus ceviche - ceviche de pulpo - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Long story short, I had some of the best tostadas here. This is located near Fort Harrison State Park, and I pass by it often and I always wanted to check it out. This place was packed when we arrived for early dinner. But wait was only 5 minutes. They decorated the entire place with beach house theme and it is so cute. Colorful. They have a full bar as well. The server notified us that since they are very busy the food is taking a bit longer. I appreciate the heads up. They have so many things on the menu and they are all written in Spanish only (which is a good sign for me). There were many photos as well so it helped me pick what I wanted. I tried "trilogía de mariscos" tostadas. One with shrimp, one with fish and one with octopus. The food took about 25 minutes but at least they told us about it ahead of time, and we had chips and salsa to munch on. My tostadas came with a lot of ceviche. They even had avocado slices. Then I knew why they had good reviews both on Yelp and Google. They were so delicious. Squeezing some lime wedges on them made them even better. Again, the service was slow. It was hard to find our server and it took us 10 minutes to get our check. But all in all, I'm hooked on their tostadas and I cannot wait to go back there already. read more

See all

Freestanding bright blue building with plenty of parking on side of building When entering u can tell it's very clean. Air conditioning is always crisp. waitstaff is always on point. Bar area I consider this restaurant to be one of the freshest, most reasonably priced consistent seafood places in Indianapolis Seafood tower is phenomenal/oysters are fresh large/fried shrimp r fried to perfection margaritas & beer selection I cannot see enough of how fresh & wonderful the food is here read more

Caribe Marisqueria - Just me after a huge meal! - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The service was great and the manager came over and greeted us and thanked us for coming in. The tostadas were epic! Huge portions and very tasty. The house salsa was great. It felt like we were on vacation too! The place was very playful and fun and made you feel like you were on a beach. read more

So tasty and several unique items. It seems like this is one of the more authentic restaurants in Indianapolis. I had to try to Hawaiian Fajitas because I have never seen it on the menu. The staff were very helpful and checked on us several times. I was also pleased with the lovely decor and lively atmosphere. I would go again! read more

See all

We went on a Friday night. The room was very attractive with white chairs and table cloths. I had called ahead because the menu was in Spanish. We could interpret certain words but not all and the manager said we would be provided with an English menu I have to be honest. A lot is being done in Lawrence to improve the Pendleton Pike reputation. I was leery of the location of the restaurant but we had gone to Mama's Korean and it is next door so we gave it a try We were immediately greeted by the manager and given a table to make us feel comfortable. Wonderful flour chips and salsa. We ordered drinks. O my gosh, the mojito I had was wonderful and lasted the whole evening My husband ordered a deep fried fish and I had coconut shrimp. All were wonderful The owner came over and introduced himself and thanked us for coming in. He said he has been working to add diversity in his diners and was pleased we decided to dine with him We enjoyed our meal, felt very safe and very welcomed The whole menu has tons of fresh seafood reasonably priced. We are going back it was that yummy read more

See all

Amazing service, food quality was exceptional, drinks top notch. The inside decore was modern with beach vibes. Cleanest bathrooms ever!

Mi gente!!! Let's start by saying this is a Small mom n pop restaurant, n perhaps one of the best choices we made today! Super clean, friendly staff, that were VERY attentive, our food was to say the least DELICIOUS! We had the fajita trio, comes with a side of rice, beans a small salad n 3 corn tortillas. I'm big on sweets so had to try there homemade flan n WOW! AMAZING read more

Caribe Marisqueria - Location - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Deffinately a must try! If you like Mexican food and seafood, which I love both, then please stop by this little treasure. I thought this was Caribbean place, but it seems more Mexican. But the menu is so loaded there could be Caribbean dishes on there. Enough about that! So far I really enjoyed this play. I got a to go on my first visit but Deffinately want to come back with friends or family and sit down and enjoy the lovely dining area. They have a stage and I believe they have live music on Saturday and Wednesday nights. Definately Spanish speaking staff so brush up on your Espanol. They do have menus in English. I love the decor, now that looks very Caribbean. The lights. The white tables all the space is very beautiful. They do have a bar area as well and lots of tvs all through the restaurant. Looks like a place you could stay a while and have a good time. I had Talapia fish tacos. Comes with 3 big tacos one piece of fried Talia and loaded with onions, Avacado and lettuce and I'm pretty sure cilantro. Comes with a green sauce with a kick and an aoli sauce. Both very good. Can't wait to try more options. Hubby like encheladas and it looks like they have a couple of choices. read more

"Warning: this Mexican seafood restaurant is so good, you may need to buy a new wardrobe. I swear, I've tried every dish on the menu (twice) and each bite is more delicious than the last. The shrimp tacos? Divine. The shrimp tostadas Heavenly. The grilled fish? Ah, just take my money already! And don't even get me started on the guac - I've gained 5 pounds just from scooping it onto tortilla chips. But honestly, it's worth it. My taste buds are doing the cha cha slide and my waistline is paying the price. 5/5 stars, would highly recommend...and also suggest buying stock in stretchy pants. read more

La comida es lo mejor de lo mejor el servicio excelente les recomiendo el pozole y el pescado de hay tienen que ir hay muchas cosas deliciosas si pudiera ir todos los días sería lo mejor read more

The most authentic Mexican restaurant I have ever had the pleasure of eating at in my 18 years of residing in the Indianapolis area. Great atmosphere, excellent service, beautiful decor...my husband and I were both very impressed and will most certainly make the drive from where we live in Greenwood to experience this lovely little place that really makes you feel like you're in Mexico! Highly recommend!! read more

See all

Stumbled upon this restaurant accidentally while driving down Pendleton pike. One of the best Mexican restaurants I've ever been to. Very authentic Mexican dishes - chips are double fried and sooo good- tacos are amazing. Can't recommend it enough! read more

I stopped by a a couple days ago, I was craving coconut shrimp and thought let me try this place out! I'm SOOO glad I did! The food was amazing! I ordered the coconut breaded shrimp!! The staff was friendly and attentive! I would definitely recommend you stop by Caribe! read more

Caribe Marisqueria - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I had lunch there for the first time yesterday and had the Camarones Rancheros, which is listed as a new item. It was great! The shrimp were perfectly cooked in a spicy sauce with tomatoes, peppers, and onions. I loved every bite and, though I'm not a light eater, had enough left over to take home for supper. As another reviewer may have mentioned, the two salsas brought out were very hot, which is fine for me. I'll be back! read more

I love this place. Food is great and live music on the weekends to enjoy with family.

I was literally going to order something but first I had to use the bathroom and I was waiting on my boyfriend to meet me there. I was instantly stop and told I had to order my food first. I had to use it VERY bad so I politely told him. He told me "no" and he was very rude about it. After I came I out the bathroom he once again rudely ask me "where's your order?" I just walked right pass him because that whole encounter ruined it for me. I was already having a really bad day and I just wanted to try something new to cheer me up. Their food look's really good but the way they treat people is disgusting. He also yelled " Fuck you" on my way out so yeah I will not be come back. I don't know if it was because I'm young and black(not to bring race in it but some of the Mexican restaurants are very racist). read more

Awful service. I came here from Miami and I accidentally went to the wrong side for the restroom they cut me off so absolutely don't don't here. read more

What a surprising find on Pendleton PIke. We have passed the restaurant a zillion times but have never stopped. I was encouraged to try it based on Suzanne K.'s review mentioning that the manager was welcoming and they had menus in English. And how extensive the menus are with numerous pages and lots of pictures! (I really like pictures). And the food I saw going by actually looked as appetizing as the pictures. There are so many seafood dishes, it will be hard to choose. My husband got the seafood "broth." Broth is a misnomer. The brought him what amounted to a seafood platter nestled in a savory soup that had the perfect little kick at the end. My husband has a "healthy" appetite and still brought some of his seafood home. I went the very safe route and ordered the shrimp tacos. My plate arrived with very generously filled tacos, salad and beans (I asked for beans instead of the usual rice). I have never had this many shrimp on a taco and there was something wonderfully different about the shells. Service was slow,(I assume they were making his "broth" upon order. It was worth waiting for) but friendly and the music was way too loud, but the restaurant is bright and cheerful and appeared to be clean. We would definitely go back to Caribe and next time I might venture beyond the ever-safe shrimp tacos. read more

I honestly think this is one of the best restaurants on the east side of Indianapolis. It's a seafood, Mexican restaurant, and the seafood is fresh. I mean totally fresh. I just had an appetizer of shrimp and octopus and avocados and oysters that was out of this world. the staff is very friendly. The owner is right here and promises. It's very delicious. read more

Pongan ojo al recibo porque a veces se cobran la propina ellos mismos. Solo fuimos cuatro pero ellos aún le agregaron la propina si mismos. La comida estaba más o menos, pero tienen pésimo servicio. Las meseras no atienden bien a uno y se desaparecen. Cuando fuimos, ni había casi gente. read more

I was driving to another restaurant when the sign caught my eye. The former "Outside In Bar" was now a seafood restaurant. When I walked in I noticed a life music setup. Found that one night a week, Wednesday night, they have Latin music from seven to midnight. The decor was simple and clean. I decided to give it a try and was not disappointed. There was a small bar that could seat about 10 people to the far right. I ordered the breaded shrimp which was a nine on the scale of 10. The wait staff was friendly and attentive. read more

Other best sea food place on the East Side of Indy. They have the best aguachile. They have the best cocunut shrimp. It is so fresh and very popular. read more

Honestly everything was going good until our server i believe was on break, i believe and the place was a disaster all i saw was servers talking and talking i had to walk up to the manager of the place to ask him for a beer. He is honestly so good he took over 3 tables in line 3 minutes because the servers couldn't do the job. He is so outgoing. read more