I recently discovered Captain Cookie through Too Good to Go and ordered a mystery bag to share with my coworkers. I was not sure what to expect, but I love a good surprise and my coworkers love a good sweet treat, so it felt like a win win. When I arrived, my mystery bag ended up being all chocolate chip cookies, so that is the only flavor I have tried so far. BUT when I put them in our breakroom around 9 in the morning, they were completely gone by 11:30. So it is safe to say they were a hit. Delicious and definitely not likely to last long if you are sharing with others. I am looking forward to coming back and trying more flavors. The store had a steady stream of customers, but the service was quick and smooth. One heads up: parking is a little tricky, so expect to walk a bit from where you park to the store. Not a big deal, but good to know in advance! read more

We went after meeting up friends for Oktoberfest next door. Location is great - they have indoor and outdoor seating and service is quick. We got one cookie-wich to share. It was on the pricier side but more than enough for two people to share. The cookies are delicious and the ice cream is great too. They give you two scoops of ice cream in the smallest size which we got and was big enough for us so it's great to try out more flavors read more

Captain Cookie & the Milkman - Arlington - Two scoops of ice cream (cookie dough and chocolate) with peanut butter cookie on top and double chocolate chip cookie on bottom - Bakeries Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

My family was staying in the vicinity and stumbled upon Captain Cookie and decided we would visit. We arrived around 10:15 PM on a Saturday night. There was no line and only one worker. Three of us got the duo which is a cookie and scoop of ice cream. My wife got milk and cookies. Ice cream was ok and the cookies were ok. It's an interesting little shop in Arlington with a good concept. Ice cream and cookies are good, not exceptional. It's worth a visit if you're nearby but no need to go out of the way to visit. read more

Captain Cookie & the Milkman - Arlington - Double Chocolate Chip Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Great service by Laronda (i hope i didn't butcher that spelling if she sees this!). Got a relaxing few minutes in a chill atmosphere while the kiddo enjoyed a delicious treat after a long day. Will be back. Thanks!! read more

They have cookies, ice cream and ice cream sandwiches! The cool thing about this place is that you can choose 2 different cookies and 2 different kinds of ice cream for 1 ice cream sandwich for $7. All their cookies are great, I love the snickerdoodle and strawberry ice cream. There isn't much room inside, 3 tables that maybe fit 6 - 8 people. This is more of a grab and go spot. read more

Captain Cookie & the Milkman - Arlington - Bakeries Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Who doesn't love a good baked cookie? Unfortunately i have to rate this shop a 3/5 the service was great the cashier was pretty nice and informative on the cookie options and helped select the bundle price for a better option. The best cookie was the Ranger - corn flakes, chocolate chip & oats pretty good cookie but honestly the rest of the cookies were a little dry and lacked true flavor that would be memorable for a return read more

See all

After catching a movie nearby, I looked around for a place to eat and saw this shop near the restaurant I was headed to. I'm a sucker for a good cookie so stopping in was a no brainer. The shop was small and cute. There wasn't seating inside from what i can recall but there is seating available outside. The gentleman behind the counter was great. He was friendly and helpful. The cookies were reasonably priced but the ice cream scoops and edible cookie dough were a bit pricey for what you get. I tried the chocolate chip and snickerdoodle cookies. Both were good but not mind blowing. The edible cookie dough was good but the texture reminded me of play doh. They have a few other classic cookie flavors available to try so I would go back when I want a sweet treat in Arlington. read more

See all

I really enjoyed the interior of the store despite its size, it still offered enough space for seating and for you to view their edible dough and ice cream. They had a small case in which they kept the cookies, however the cookies didn't really taste like anything outside of what you could make at home. BUT, I really want to try their edible dough jars that they have and possibly their ice cream, so I would come back and try them again :-) Give them a shot! We tried them before going to see the new Spiderverse movie at AMC because we had sometime to kill. We also picked up BOGO drinks from Starbucks since it's basically next door. They also have other food options around as well with a big parking lot next to the AMC that's free on the weekends. read more

Captain Cookie & the Milkman - Arlington - Funfetti cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Captain Cookie has always been a "hit" in the Courthouse area with their food truck so thank goodness we no longer have to track your food truck on IG just to enjoy your cookies :) But this evening I walked in to get a 1/2 dozen and walked out with a Baker's Dozen. Their cookies are absolutely delicious! And where else can you enjoy milk and cookies or ice cream and cookies. The perfect treat(s) for everyone to enjoy. read more

See all

My friends and I decided to try this one day and we were not super impressed. We had heard amazing reviews but didn't really get the hype! The place itself is super cute and the employees are very friendly, which is always amazing. In terms of the food, I got an ice cream sandwich with a double chocolate cookie and peanut butter cookie with cookies & creme ice cream and the ice cream was really good but the cookies were mediocre. They were honestly really crunchy, and I prefer my cookies on the softer side - maybe if they had been heated up? Overall, if you like crunchy cookies - I highly recommend, or if you're just looking for some ice cream. There are about 8 or so ice cream flavors to choose from and a variety of cookie flavors to choose from as well! There is not a lot of indoor seating, but there are some tables outside the building. read more

See all

THIS WAS SO DELICIOUS. there was no line and the lady working was so sweet! first time there and very cute vibe, will be back read more

Captain Cookie & the Milkman - Arlington - Ice Cream Sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

I came in here for a quick snack during a work from home day. Service was quick, staff was nice, price of cookies is $2 which wasn't bad. Cookies were very subpar- the peanut butter cookie was super dry and lacked flavor. Funfetti cookie was better but neither cookie was any better than a grocery store bought cookie. I'd like to come back to try come cookies with ice cream next time. read more

Very cute addition to the courthouse area. We've only gotten the half dozen cookies and all have been delicious. We warmed up the chocolate chip cookie and ate it with vanilla ice cream at home which was super. Staff is friendly and assists you in making decision when all the yummy cookies are in front of you. read more

See all

Who doesn't love fresh cookies and ice cream?? Captain Cookie did the dessert at our wedding but being in Baltimore I don't get to enjoy their treats very often. I was in the area so stopped in at their Arlington location for a ice cream cookie sandwich. I love that you can customize your sandwich - pick your top cookie, bottom cookie and ice cream flavor. My sandwich was delicious! It's expensive but you get quite a lot, though the ratio of ice cream to cookie is a bit off (you get way more ice cream) so you have to eat with a spoon. I just wish my cookies were warm (they might have been warmed up a touch but they need to go longer to be more gooey), they started to get hard midway through. They also had a case of edible cookie doughs in a variety of flavors which all looked tasty too! It's a small shop but it seems like most get it to go and eat outside in the courtyard area. read more

The customer service terrible no greeting when coming in and the cashier seem to have an attitude. Maybe they had a long day but that's no excuse. And my cookie was cold read more

Well...I ate one on the car ride home. Lol...Ummm, the cookies are just okay. I was looking forward to trying this place, so after enjoying a movie at AMC Courthouse, I decided to walk over and finally give Captain Cookies and the Milkman a try. I was so hoping they would give me that Wow moment, but it didn't. It's a bummer!! read more

Captain Cookie & the Milkman - Arlington - Chocolate Chip Cookie Ginger Molasses Cookie Double Chocolate Chip Cookie 1/2 Dozen Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Got an ice cream sandwich! It was sinfully good (though I wouldn't recommend looking at the calories) the staff were so friendly as well and let me sample a flavor I was unsure about. read more

Friendly service, reasonable prices, great portions! Thank you Marco for serving us this tonight! read more

Super disappointed. Insanely overpriced!!!! 8x the price and worse quality than Giant but the exact same cheap packaging and presentation. Do not waste your time here. Unless you're high out of your mind. The reason for 2 versus 1 star is these will be an entertaining JOKE that my family will remember for years to come. And also it will be good for our health since we will not be eating anymore. The staff were also very friendly. read more

Captain Cookie & the Milkman - Arlington - Bakeries Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

I love this place! The best combo is the chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich with salted caramel ice cream. Most cookies are pretty good but the double chocolate stands above the rest. The refrigerated cookie doughs last forever and are a nice treat. A spoonful a night is a pretty adequate dessert. read more

Took the family here for a treat after seeing a show. The cookies were fine, the ice cream was fine. A little on the pricey side.

Ordered a classic ice cream sandwich with a chocolate chip cookie, a sprinkles cookie and cookies n cream ice cream. Both cookies were delicious and freshly baked. The ice cream was thick and reminded me of Wisconsin ice cream. Would definitely go back when I have my next dessert craving. read more

Captain Cookie & the Milkman - Arlington - Ice Cream Sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Nice little shop with fresh baked cookies and cool and creamy ice cream. I love it that the spoons change color when cold. read more

Captain Cookie & the Milkman - Arlington - Salted Caramel scoop and chocolate scoop - Bakeries Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

I was craving cookies and happened to stumble upon Captain Cookie. I got the peanut butter, snickerdoodle, and chocolate chip cookies. They were really soft, had good flavor, and were pretty big/thick! The people working there were really friendly too. All in all, a good stop for your cookie cravings. read more

Ordered 50 cookies a few days before an event for a set time. Did not show up on time. Called the store and kept getting a voicemail. Finally got a person and was told the manager would call me. Never did. Cookies showed up after the event was over. Don't order from here if you need reliable delivery. read more

I'll be completely honest after trying this place for the first time I wasn't impressed. I ordered 2 cookies and a scoop of vanilla ice cream. The cookies were very small for the price and just tasted very artificial. The ice cream as well. Today I tried to give them another chance and ordered an Oreo milkshake (I was craving one so bad and the closest milkshake would require me tot take the metro). I always see this place empty and now I know why. This is probably the worst shake I've ever had in my life. I don't know what kind of base was used but the shake tasted horrible. Also it was very watery and there was no flavor from the Oreos. That $8 shake went right in the trash. I'm sad to say that this was my last time at captain cookie. read more

Excellent ice cream and cookies. Cookies are chewy... perfect texture. Ice cream is fresh and creamy. read more

Captain Cookie & the Milkman - Arlington - Salted caramel and mint chip - Bakeries Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

What a great place! Delicious cookies, great staff, and the location is nice and cozy! 100% recommended

I picked up a Too Good To Go order here. I got a generous selection of delicious cookies. The service was great and it wasn't too crowded.

The monster cookie dough tasted like vomit. And I don't mean that in a joking way. It tasted like stomach vile. Maybe it's off or rancid? Absolutely appalling. The service was good though. No complaints with the employees. read more

The ice cream cookie sandwich was yummy and the staff was so friendly and welcoming. We will definitely be back!

I'd only ever been to the DC location and was elated when my boyfriend and I were the leaving the movie theatre and stumbled on this location. Per usual, the ice cream and cookies did not disappoint. My boyfriend doesn't particularly have a sweet tooth but he even couldn't resist the ice cream sandwiches. What made this visit even better was the exceptional service we received from Laquisha and Atistose. They were amazingggg and real troopers considering how hot it was in there. These ladies still managed to keep a great disposition and smile from ear to ear. The temperature in there was really the only reason I did not give a five star rating. read more

Would be a perfect 5 star for the cookie and great customer service I received! But it was super hot inside. Uncomfortably hot but the ice cream and the cookies arw great! read more

The staff was very friendly! They gave great suggestions. The cookies were yummy! My office enjoyed them! The pecan Sandy should be a menu keeper!! One person swore I baked the pecan Sandies at home . I couldn't take the credit. They were very delicious. The chocolate chip were great! One person grabbed more cookies because they were so good. read more

Over priced & over baked! These are the blandest, tasteless, driest cookies Ive bought! If you want to spend your money on cookies definitely try Moltn if you like cookies with flavor! read more