The food is amazing, service can be a bit slow, and ambiance is slightly less than amazing, I got eaten up by mosquitoes on the patio and the indoor area was very loud. However the food kept us going back! Overall my favorite restaurant on the island read more

I went here with my sister and parents, and we had a good time! The food was a little different than what I expected, but very unique and delicious in its own way. I definitely recommend the Asian/Korean-style wings. Also, the people there are really nice, and they were always patient and kind. read more

Was a wonderful meal and our server was delightful. We hope to return soon and enjoy another time.

I had a great time at Caribbean fish market there was great service and excellent food and drinks. I had ordered the stuffed Caribbean lobster and it was great. But I would like to mention Liz and keke were great waitresses and the rest of the staff were very friendly. read more

One of my favorite places here. Sea bass was amazing and the view was stunning. Try to make it there before 6:30p so you can enjoy the view.

We stayed at the resort where this place is located. Nice atmosphere, service was a bit lax..took awhile to get drinks and refills, on to the food- it was very good but the disappointing thing was they always were out of the sides the entree came with and they did not tell you until you got the dish. Over good but a bit pricey...to me a bit overly priced. Local caught lobster was $75 for three halves. read more

I had the seafood medley/pot and enjoyed it but that was 1 of 4. My son had crab stuffed grouper and the crab was like something from a grocery store. My son and wife had a fish plate which was a 5 out of 10. The ambiance was awesome, staff was great and prices were ok. Worth stop but not as good as we were expecting. read more

Amazing lobster, grouper and penne pasta. Ambiance was beach elegant. Great place to dine!

A gobble gobble day getaway consisted of an impromptu dinner at Carribean Fish Market. After waiting on the beach for an hour, we finally got a table. Tip: When in USVI, ask for the bottled stuff, since even the filtered H20 taste a little off. For our table of four, we each ordered different apps. My choice of she-crab bisque could've been due to gender specificity, like crab bisque "for her" as opposed to crab bisque "for him". After looking it up, apparently the female crabs taste a lot richer because of their roe. I'm all about tastiness and it was dipped, sopped, and licked off with every bit of the bread bowl it came in. The portions were enough for two people to share. I wanted to try the local catch and went with the wahoo with choice of a mango ginger chutney sauce and side of potatoes. It was a HUGE piece of fish. I never had wahoo before, but I thought as a fish it was dryer and tougher, despite great preparation. The boy's grilled lobster was overcooked. Maybe we didn't order the "right" things that night as one of our dining companions loved her Yellowfin Tuna with goat cheese gnocchi. Given that they were probably short staffed for the holiday, they forgot our order of mussels and we felt neglected by our server up until the check arrived. We were expecting more out of our fish market experience. Given that there were plenty of dining options to try it didn't warrant a repeat visit for the duration of our trip. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - grilled lobster tail - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

I'm really not sure how this place doesn't have all 5 star reviews. The service and food are amazing and so is the view. Don't let the negative people leaving reviews keep you away. This is a must stop when in St Thomas. read more

We are staying next door at the Ritz. It was a quick walk over here so we thought we'd try it out. We had the she crab bisque, which was incredible. Sweet from the crab with just a touch of spice and finished with a touch of sherry. Amazing! My wife had the Ceviche which I believe had mahi mahi, scallops and wahoo. It was equally as good...again a nice touch of spice. For dinner we both had lobster but with two different preparations. My wife had a broiled tail and I had a version that seemed like a Caribbean version of Lobster Thermidor. Finished with Panko crumbs and the top portion was shrimp stuffed. It was amazing. We're so happy we came here. We will be back! PS.... I had the flourless chocolate cake for dessert. Nobody should ever put flour in chocolate cake ever again! Lol. Loved it! read more

See all

Food was the best I'd had on the island . Beware of the mosquitoes attacking you if you decide on the romantic beach dining experience. The hostess was Great . She brought my husband and I a drink while we waited for our special table setup . But honestly it wasn't worth the additional money we paid . read more

Outstanding kind attentive service, beautiful location, menu was fantastic and food was awesome. Location is off the beaten path slightly from red hook and we couldn't get a cab for over an hour until a staff member helped us get one. Overall great! read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Caribbean baked stuffed lobster - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

Good concepts but not great execution. A bit pricey for what we got. The flavors described in our meals sounded magical. The hot pot just needed more seasonings. Nice ambiance and very good service. We got there at 500 without reservation and had no problem getting a table read more

So, I let them know we were celebrating our 25th Anniversary and wanted to surprise my wife with a romantic dinner. I spoke with Jessica at the resort and she said not to worry about anything, she would take care of everything! Well, when I walked my wife to the restuarant, saying she was surprised, is an understatement! They had put a beautiful table out on the beach, set up with candles, beautiful sea shells and even name cards with our name and Happy Anniversary on them. I explained the basics of what I wanted, as far as the food was concerned, and they did not disappoint! We were given a glass of complimentary champagne, then brought fresh bread with their special butter, slightly sweet, with a dash of sugar and cinnamon, and a dash of salt! Excellent. After that, we were served a beautiful salad of mixed greens, cucumber, cherry tomatoes and a raspberry vinaigrette dressing. The main course came and it was situated beautifully, with a filet steak, with homemade mashed potatoes, and freshly made cooked vegetables. The waiter was designated to only our table to ensure we received the best service possible. Our Waiter, Josh, was wonderful!!! Not enough can be said about this restaurant! Try it, and enjoy! read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Our beautifully placed table on the beach! - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Beautiful night. Great atmosphere Lobster special was wonderful. Service was great. Celebrated my birthday with coconut cake!!!

After a long day relaxing at Magens Bay, my girlfriend and I decided to go back to Caribbean Fish Market for dinner. We went there last year after hurricane Dorian and really enjoyed it. I forgot to review last year so I better do one. Seems like when we go to Caribbean Fish market, there is always something going on. First a hurricane and now COVID 19. Lucky I guess. Now for the review. I really enjoy the Caribbean Fish market. The food, the service, and the location is great. It's a fun place! I was not super hungry so I decided to have their blackened shrimp wedge. It hit the spot!! Really enjoyed it! My girlfriend was hungrier. She started with the watermelon arugula salad which she said was outstanding. For her main course, she had the apple stuffed pork chop which she thoroughly enjoyed. I had a bite and it was very good. Our server was a delight!! Very attentive and fun! TheCaribbean fish market is a fun and relaxing restaurant. Quality food! If you are looking for a more upscale restaurant... try the old Stone Farmhouse. If you want to have good restaurant with a nice vibe... then Caribbean Fish Market is the place. Will be back... hopefully under normal conditions!! read more

See all

The food was excellent and the service was super quick , even for a Saturday night. Nice vibe & location

Amazing food and service! We had the Ambassador as our server and he was so friendly and the service was great. The stuffed lobster, grouper, and the ahi tuna nachos were to die for! Definitely recommend to anyone looking for a higher end seafood restaurant. read more

Outstanding fresh seafood. I took our server's recommendation for the fresh local wahoo. It was cooked perfectly. We also shared several appetizers. Great service and great food. read more

Wow! Great place! Very interesting that it didn't not come up in the top 20 fish restaurants. Great service , great atmosphere and great food! read more

The best place we've eaten in the USVI's! If you like gourmet dishes made to show of the flavors of really fresh fish, then this is your place. Don't expect deep fried, heavily battered food! The steamed mussels and wahoo were scrumptious! It was easy to find a nice wine for pairing from their extensive list. We've already made reservations to come back!! read more

The ambience is waaaay better than the actual food itself. The view would be very pretty at sunset. The apps were disappointing (I would not recommend the general tso's cauliflower or the ahi tuna nachos). The shrimp wedge salad was decent. The homemade ice cream is really good. I'd come for happy hour, or coffee and dessert. read more

Avoid. Service was horrendous and food was meh. We were a large group celebrating a birthday. Multiple dishes ordered - the appetizers were good. The entrees were mediocre. Fish over cooked and too salty (specifically the sea bass). Mediocre food and bad service on top of out of this world prices. Server was difficult to find when needed something, took forever for things like a water refill, water was warm, she didn't seem interested (or happy)- maybe because she knew she got the 20% tip for large groups anyways. Only the location was good..... but not worth it at all. Go somewhere else to celebrate. read more

Plain and simple, probably the best place near red hook to find fresh seafood. Lots of the locals recommended it, and I think I'd have to agree with them. The food is great, servers were just attentive enough to not be annoying, and the atmosphere is gorgeous as it's right next to the beach. It's about a $10-15 ride from ride hook with a taxi, and the food can be a little more pricy than some places around St.Thomas but it tends to be more quality. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Pound and a half of lobster. - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

My waiter, the Ambassador, was soooo funny and helpful!! I had the Seafood Paella and it was great. Seafood Hotpot was very spicy but good, and the Brussels sprouts were gas. read more

Best meal we had on any island in the USVI! Food was Great! The service was even better! Must try a KeyLime dessert cocktail! The best I've ever had!!! read more

This was our opportunity to splurge. The calamari was fantastic. The stuffed lobster was just ok considering it was $75. The grouper was also very small portion. The crab stuffing had many pieces of shell. Three of us ate for $220 with only one alcoholic mixed drink. The restaurant was very formal but casual dress was ok. A random black cat walking in and out of the dinning area made the long wait more pleasant. read more

See all

Dear Caribbean Fish Market, I had great expectations, but alas.... Just three stars for now. The main course left much to be desired. The fish (corvina) was bland, my husband's mahi mahi special was even worse. Hey, it's mahi mahi, what did we expect? And yet... The potatoes were equally bland. And for the fish market, they had only three choices of fish. The best thing was their own butter (with hints of garlic and honey). Lobster bisque was pretty good, and the desert - tiramisu - was really fine. It seems like this place needs to change its name from Fish Market to anything but. Fish is not its forte. Maybe in my case it was deceived expectations: mediocre fish dish when you are expecting something really special. But everything else is fine - even the service was not bad. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Corvina fish with haricot vert and potato fingerlings - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Definitely wouldn't be imma first pick again. We ate there for the convince of it being right at the resort we stayed. Overall, it was just extreme expensive for what you get. The conch fritters was our app only get 5 they were okay I would try the other options next time. Had the grouper which was good but each entree we had was very small portion and way over priced! However, the thing I would go back for it the chocolate cake and house made vanilla ice cream. The ice cream was one of the best I've ever had. I know it hard to imagine a anything but perfect from ice cream but this ice cream is top tier. So dessert and the environment was great it being right on the beach. I'd say overall it was just okay. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - View from our table - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

Y'all this is a MUST!!! My fam and I LOVE this place. I can't say enough good things about it. Best service on the island and best food and drinks! Luke & John are the best!! :) we love yall!! read more

Excellent food excellent service. Sitting outside was perfect we will go again easy access easy parking

Ok wow! Best seafood I've had in awhile. This was my boyfriend and I's first dinner on the island and we were both very impressed. We had the cauliflower app, my boyfriend had the salmon, I ordered the seafood hot pot and we finished with rum cake and the waffle ice cream desserts. I'm not sure why this place isn't highly rated, but the food and ambiance were both amazing! Highly recommend! read more

Reserved for our anniversary on a Sunday night. We arrived early and were seated even though there was a line and the place was packed. There are sort of four separate vibes/seating areas. By the bathroom there's a dance club like feel, the bar area has high tops for dining, the other side of the bar is an outside covered patio for dining which is where we were seated and the main room is largest and brightest also with an attached covered patio. Overall very festive, read not too romantic. There was a private party under the trees with hired music playing also. The food was very good, arrived hot. We had the Korean wings that were super spicy and it didn't say so on the menu, only 'sweet and tangy' and the pear and Brie flatbread was great comfort food. We had the pork chop which was tender and flavorful and the sesame crusted tuna that was the size of a sushi roll and placed in a small bowl over soba noodles. The prices were very disappointing. My tuna was a special but in no way warranted it's cost. Kiki our server was the epitome of kindness and warmth. She deserves high accolades! The kitchen was apparently over loaded and she graciously visited us frequently to explain. This was much appreciated as it had nothing to do with her but she owned it and we felt her sincerity. As it was becoming late we passed on dessert. Enjoy all. read more

The food was not worth the price. The menu had basic American restaurant items on it despite the name of the restaurant. Service was good. Ambiance was good, but neither of those were worth the price for the food that we got. The fish was flavorless and some dishes were dry. And just the appetizer of five chicken wings was 18 dollars. The salmon dish was good. The pasta was okay. The mahi was dry and lacked flavor. read more

It was a good experience. We walked in on a Monday around 8:30 with no reservation. It was quiet. Our server and all the waitstaff were absolutely wonderful. The filet was fantastic, as was the lobster tail. The mussels appetizer was very good! But the Brussels sprouts and cauliflower were pretty average. The drinks were fantastic also! read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Lobster tail - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

I was pretty disappointed with my experience here. I ordered the surf and turf and the steak part was delicious and well cooked but the lobster was completely overdone, dry and chewy. The food was definitely overpriced for the quality. My boyfriend ordered the seafood hot pot which was also delicious in terms of the seafood, however the rice was undercooked and hard. Giving this place 2 stars because an over cooked lobster tail at a seafood place next to the ocean for $85 kind of ruins the meal. read more

We read some good reviews on this restaurant so decided to give it a try. What are good: To be fair, the environment is top notch: it is literally by the beach so you will have the great view. When it gets dark they will light the torches around the restaurant which makes it really a nice atmosphere. The servers are nice and attentive. They will explain the menu and food clearly to you. What are not so good: with the price, you would expect the food to be better. We ordered two entrée and two kids meals and the check came out to be over $120, but food is mediocre. My wife ordered the salmon, and I ordered the daily special of wahoo fish. Both turned out to be so so. Plus it took them 45 mins to bring them to the table from the moment we ordered. We noticed it wasn't just us, the other tables around us were also delayed. Clearly the kitchen of that night wasn't properly managed. Also our server told us about the daily special of raw oysters and we ordered. Not until he bought us our entrée did he tell us "oh forgot to tell you we sold out oysters tonight". Bammer. In conclusion, I hope it was one off night for them. The view and atmosphere is indeed good. If you are looking for a romantic setting to woo someone, sure this is the place; however if you're just trying to have some quality seafood then stay away from this place. read more

Entirely disappointed. First, there was no answer to several attempts by telephone to reserve a table for our party of nine... but since I had my heart set on this restaurant, we decided to just go and hope for the best. When we arrived, there were plenty of seats and tables available, so I don't know why no one could be bothered to answer the phone... Anyway, as others have noted, the atmosphere was lovely. We also felt that the food was decent enough, but our server was so off-putting that I'll never go back. I don't recall his name, but the air of arrogance which infused his whole approach made me question whether his ego would allow for him to care much about our wants or needs. At one point, the owner(?) stopped by, who seemed hospitable enough, but by then I was over it. Long story short, at the price point of this establishment, I expected gracious, considerate service but that was not what we got and it brought the whole experience down. read more

This was the best dinner we had on the island. Everything was delicious. I had the hotpot and my husband had the stuffed lobster. I also ordered sangria, which is not on the menu, and they were able to mix up a very tasty drink. The manager was very friendly and his conversation was entertaining. Highly recommend. read more