Food was not good at all and super expensive. The only thing that was good was the tamarind calamari. 20% surcharge added with no warning beforehand. Would not recommend. I would say if you are looking for food with flavor, look somewhere else. read more

If you are looking for the best overall dinner/ date night spot, look no further. Hands down Caribbean Fish Market has the best food, service and drinks. We had their signature dish, the stuff lobster... and wow! It lived up to the hype! The plate was huge, big enough for 2. I also had the watermelon salad, mussels and oysters. For desert we tried the ginger Creme brûlée and at first I was skeptical because of the ginger, I thought it would be overpowering but it was well done! The top was crispy and the crème was soft and creamy. The ginger complemented the flavor and was not pungent at all. We wish we could've had time to come back to this spot before we left since it was so memorable. We will definitely be back to this gem! read more

See all

I can't... I just can't. You can't charge prices like this and then overcook lobster. And there weren't any other dishes to properly counter the bad, extremely pricey overcooked lobster. I just can't recommend this place. read more

See all

ROUND 2 of trying this place and we were not disappointed. This was my annual visit home and brought some friends with me and all they wanted before they left was stuffed lobster. Well- we called, made reservations and talked to the manager to ensure they knew we were coming for the lobster because last time we were there they ran out. Our server was fantastic. She was she attentive to the group and made us all feel so comfortable with our choices. The food was delicious and we were all stuff to the brim. Expect to pay a hefty price but I always say"'you pay for what you get ". Few things I must make note of that is of no fault of the restaurant but they are located on the beach and as soon as it gets dark be prepared to be eat by the mosquitoes. We dined good and so did they, lol. However the ambience of sitting out and being able to see the beach was fantastic. Would recommend to anyone looking for a great meal and not worried about price. read more

See all

The atmosphere is perfection. Right on the water, waves crashing, it couldn't be a better backdrop. The food... super lacking. We had the cauliflower starter, it was definitely good. We didn't finish but, we took the rest to go. The tomahawk, oh boy. It was bad. Burnt! Burnt! Burnt! I'm pretty sure they turned that amazing piece of delicious cow into shoe leather. Unfortunately, it wasn't what we were expecting. I do need to emphasis, we are not complainers. We do not ask for a free meal... EVER! But, this was bad. The manager never came out, they did not come speak with us. They offered at 10% discount, which we graciously accepted. Did that. Over the loss of the meat that we actually sent back? Absolutely not! Would we ever come back, no. We would definitely try a new place. Unfortunately, this place did NOT meet the mark. read more

I was really excited to eat here we waited til the second to last night to eat here and I'm glad because I get to have a better dinner elsewhere tonight..I got the butter lobster and it was way overcooked so chewyand so salty. My friend got the Caribbean lobster and hers was cooked perfect I was super bummed I didn't get that one instead...my other friend got the paella and the mussels were chewy and the rice was undercooked which made her dish inedible the waiter never asked y her while dish wasn't eaten or why she didn't want a box which I found odd..my husband got the wahoo and it was bland and meh so don't let the beautiful plating confuse the lack of luster in the food it was an expensive not good experience.. read more

See all

Many options. And all delicious too. Parking available. Service is quick and friendly. Ambiance is calm , no views , but it's still nice. read more

See all

Went & had an excellent meal to bring in my 40th b-day. Started w/ the Shrimp Cocktail which was excellent, had a light seasoning on the shrimp, a bowl of celery salad & a really good dipping sauce. Also had the Calamari which was good, although there was no dipping sauce & the battered calamari & peppers had a slight sweet taste, which caught me off guard, not bad though. Her main course was Crab Cake wrapped Grouper w/ this amazing sauce & these tiny red peppers we weren't familiar w/ but they were bomb. I had the Surf & Turf Filet Mignon, Lobster Tail & a really good sauce, with Mashed Potatoes sat atop a bed of Shredded Brussels Sprouts. Every bite was perfect. Who knows if I ever make it back to this island, but if I do, I'll be back read more

See all

We had just checked in the to the hotel and were starving. It was a Sunday and Sangria's was closed so deciding where to eat was a no brainer. It looked quite full when we entered but they have a lounge area in the back that was really nice and we were the first ones to be seated in that area. The ambience It was dinner time, sun was set and the lounge area reminded me Miami. It was chic yet cozy. They have a pink neon sign as well that everyone was getting their photo ops by. 5/5 The Prices Everything was definitely overpriced and this is in comparison to Boston and NYC prices. It's kind of expected given that the island imports majority of their goods. 3/5 The Food The calamari was good, not the best I've had but I like the tamarind sauce gave it a new twist that I liked. 3/5 The Grilled Salmon filet was cooked to perfection. It was charred on the outside but still moist on the inside. I was skeptical of the quinoa tabouleh since I'm not a fan of tabouleh but it was more quinoa than tabouleh. For some reason I don't remember the flavour of the sauce but I know everything went well with each other. This is a very light meal which I what I wanted and it left me satisfied not stuff so stuffed. 5/5 The shrimp penne pasta. I just took a taste of this from my husband. This was really good. It was a large serving too that he couldn't finish it and it came with large shrimps and they were generous with it too, most restaurants I go to you get about 4 shrimp max. 5/5 Spicy Brussel Sprouts. Not much to say here. They were good. Spicy lol 5/5 I was also impressed how quickly the food came out seeing how busy the restaurant was. We can't forget our server/ bartender, Rico. He was was friendly and helpful with narrowing down our menu choices as well as what/where to see on the islands. read more

See all

Went to CFH with friends for a birthday celebration. I've been there before and it didn't disappoint. This visit was even better and thanks to Jared who was our server it was fantastic. We started with appetizers which consisted of eggplant Fritz, which had a balsamic and some thing drizzle, wings, and a pear and Bree pizza. In addition, we had the lamb chops, which were amazing also. We shared the appetizers and everyone was impressed. For entrées we had salmon, whole snapper and stuffed lobster. The polenta is always a must for men. Everyone was happy with their dish. I had t stuffed lobster, which was OK but in the future I'll probably stick with the Caribbean lobster. Drinks weren't too bad and overall I'd look forward to visiting CFH again. read more

See all

A lovely restaurant tucked away behind the Elysian Beach Resort with it's own little strip of beach. The location is quite unique with seating outside and inside. Romantic ambiance, good food, very good service, this place will be a sure hit during your visit to St. Thomas. I came here on a weekend night with my wife, my buddy, and his fiance. We were pretty excited to try one of the better reviewed and rated restaurants on the island. Our table ordered the Drunken Mussels. The mussels were a little small, but the flavor was wonderful. The garlic and white wine, mixed with a sprinkling of spinach, served with slices of baguette, was delicious. We also ordered the following entrees: USVI Wahoo: The Wahoo was seasoned and cooked well. Seafood Hot Pot: My friend ate this dish up happily. Nothing was left over from his insatiable appetite of this dish. Shrimp Penne Pasta: Also cooked very well. The Penne was al dente and the ingredients worked well together. I did think that the sauce may have been a bit heavy in richness, but perhaps it was the design of this dish, which works. There was also a lot going on in this dish. Apple Bacon Stuffed Pork Chop: The dish I had ordered, and enjoyed the most. It was cooked very well. Juicy, flavorful, and stuffed with bacon. Resting over a pillowy bed of mashed potatoes, this was my favorite dish of the night. While the food was excellent, what you order is what you get, in the sense that there really isn't much else to what you order. For example, the pork chop is just the pork chop. Yes, there is mashed potato and some red cabbage on top, but the dish looked fairly empty and lacking. Maybe it was because of how the food was plated, which rendered it to be... just a pork chop. The same goes for the Wahoo. My other disappointment was that the beer we ordered (Virgin Island) was brought out in their 12oz bottles. For some reason, I was really expecting local draft beer. So when bottles were brought out, I was quite disappointed. With all that said, this place is definitely a place to keep on your list for when visiting St. Thomas. read more

See all

Just wanted to note, we came back to Caribbean Fish Market because we loved it so much. This time made early reservations with a toddler in tow. The restaurant has high chairs and is very kid friendly. We had the general tso cauliflower, calamari, stuffed lobster and pork chop. All came out fabulous and just as delicious as we remembered. For dessert we had both coconut cake and red velvet cake. This is by far our absolute favorite restaurant on the island hands down. This one is not to be missed. read more

The customer service here is AMAZING! They really know how to make their guests feel special. Our waiter would continuously call us "family", which I thought was too cute! He was a really persuasive guy and convinced us to get the daily specials. Super friendly. He had a way with words. The restaurant is really nice and has a lovely view of Cowpet Bay in Elysian. They are a part of a popular restaurant group in St. Thomas that also owns Agave, Sunset Grille, Raw, and Pesce! + Prime Rib: Tender and flavorful! It comes with scalloped potatos and asparagas. They only have this on Wednesdays. + Surf & Turf: The lobster and steak were both a bit overcooked, but flavored well. + Tamarind Calamari: Really yummy combination! They both really compliment each other. Eat this fast though. If you let the tamarind glaze sit too long, the tanginess overpowers the calamari. + Sunkissed Señorita: This drink has a REALLY strong tequila taste... Maybe due to low quality tequila? I could hardly taste the strawberry. + Catch of the Day (Tuna): Pretty good! I feel like the flavor of the tuna did not pair well with the risotto, but it was still a satisfying meal. read more

See all

This whole red snapper with a soy miso glaze did not disappoint. It was fresh and delicious and an amazing last dinner on my trip to St. Thomas VI. Caribbean fish market is a lovely restaurant with a chill vibe. They provide attentive service that makes you want to return. Come for drinks and food as you enjoy an amazing g Caribbean sunset view. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - whole red snapper with a soy miso glaze - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

We were celebrating an anniversary, a graduation and a birthday! The ambiance was lovely, beachfront. Our server was professional. There were four of us we all loved our food. We had lamb lollipops, marinated cucumbers, prawns, sea bass, lobster(special of the day) and a steak and dessert. We would definitely visit again! read more

Loved everything about it. The location is steller. Loved the food. We've been there 3 or 4 times. The service was great.

Food was excellent, the service was good, kept drinks full with a party of 15 no complaints from any of us. We sat outside at big table the server was very nice and we all enjoyed our time there. read more

Fabulous food! Ate there numerous times, best prime rib ever, yummy Wahoo. They just need to train their hostesses to be more friendly. Noah, Jennifer, Malachi were all great. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Sign in Caribbean Market. - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

Great place to celebrate our anniversary or anything else! The place was romantic and worthy of a nice evening! Food was good. Service was as well! read more

See all

We just ate at the Caribbean Fish Market which is in the resort just outside the Ritz. Two of us had the Curry Monk Fish and two of us had the Sea Bass. The Curry was perfectly spicy for me and very delicious. But be aware if you are not a spicy person. My wife said her Sea Bass meal was one of the best meals she has had in a long time. Recommend trying this restaurant. Service was also great. read more

I was looking so forward to eating here. We had 6pm reservations. Our order was taken at 7:00. We were served at 8:30 our main course , before our salad. I asked for my salad first. They took back the main course and when it was brought back to the table it had been reheated. At $56 per plate, I want my food cooked fresh. Sent the food back and finally got served at 9:30. No one ever checked on us. The server apologized when he brought the bill stating they were short staffed. The whole red snapper was delicious as was the watermelon arugula salad. The Chilean Sea Bass did not have any flavor. Ordinary at best. Cheesecake was amazing! We have reservations for Saturday, hopefully things will be better. The ambiance was delightful. read more

The food here was so good it was insane. We came here three times, once for brunch and twice for dinner and everything was great. The ambiance, the presentation, the view...everything except for the service. I ordered brunch at the bar and the bartender was a complete jerk. I asked him to add something to the order and he got upset and said, "the guys in the back are gunna give me sh*t" then threw a glass or water at the bar in my direction. It was pretty wild. I'll attach his picture to the review. Otherwise, amazing service and food read more

See all

Bunch was absolutely good and peaceful! Island vibes for the food and service. The mimosas are strong and are the best! Let's just say happy hour is your friend!! read more

See all

Was not impressed at this restaurant or location. I have the feeling the tuna in the nachos was not fresh even though I asked- it was simply not the color it should be! My boyfriend was sick all night! Mussels had good flavor Ice tea is not bottomless refills Caribbean lobster dish was $75-90 dollars....over priced for the quality! Go anywhere else! Also the view was blocked by construction. Overall just trust me and go elsewhere. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Pei mussels - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Dearest gentle reader, The food here is absolutely divine, precisely the Caribbean stuffed lobster filled with shrimp stuffing and a side of hot melted butter- mouth watering indeed. The atmosphere most settling .At last the flavors were exquisite so as the service. read more

This was definitely my favorite place to eat on the island. We had a late reservation and we ended up sitting outside- the weather was perfect from the ocean breeze. The ambiance was a modern beach vibe- one of the nicer places on the island for sure. Our food was amazing! My cocktails were good and strong, just how I like it. They have a bar area which plays music - great vibes and our service was wonderful. I wished we would have gone back again. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Spicy brussle sprouts, tamarind calamari & CFM crab cakes - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Made reservations for Christmas Eve because we were staying nearby and wanted to walk instead of drive. The menu looked good--catch of the day, lobster, filet mignon. The restaurant itself was nice but not amazing. It's right on the beach so that's its real ambiance. The food was 75% good. That is to say we had four meals and three were mostly tasty (stuffed lobster, grilled salmon, and grouper) although the side dishes of mashed potatoes and 3 asparagus spears with the lobster were a bit lackluster. Not bad, just fairly standard. The fourth entree was the pork chop which was tough and under seasoned with lackluster sides. My son was so disappointed in this dish. We didn't bother with dessert. The service could've been more attentive (no drink refills offered; no knife arrived with the pork chop and we had to wait on that and then remind them to bring it while we stared at our food a while). The restaurant didn't appear understaffed or overbooked. On the plus side the service was friendly and the vibe was pleasant and with its beach front and walkable location it's just what we were looking for. But when we pay $300 for dinner I like the entrees to be 100% tasty especially on Christmas Eve! read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Pork chop with mashed potatoes - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Woman the front wouldn't look up - surprise- no one in St Thomas is friendly. Told her I had a reservation. She said she couldn't find it. I showed it to her on my phone but she wouldn't look up so who knows if she saw it. She sat us down didn't say a word. Waited 30 min for any kind of service , I went back to her. She sent a nice woman over who apologized and said she would take our order until our server was ready. He never showed. She ended up taking care of us. She said towards the end of our dinner he finally asked her if we needed to be taken care of - 2 hours later. She said he was out of it. Food is not worth the gassed up prices. read more

Tried this place 3 times, breakfast/brunch, Lunch/happy hour and dinner and all three times it disappointed. I get it, it's in front of the beach, can't beat the view if you get a good table. Other than that, the food is in my opinion really really bad, small tiny portions for certain dishes and crazy over priced. The staff is really rude, they try to rush you, reach over and you and the only time they would check in with you faster is when they are collecting their tip. Not worth it at all, unfortunately this place and sangria were the only food places in the resort. Wish I would've had this warning before coming. read more

Eating in the Caribbean in my opinion is best when you can enjoy the view and the food. This place provides that opportunity! We have been here a few times. Our latest visit was June 28, 2020. This is great place in the east end of at Thomas with a wonderful view of the water. The wahoo was delicious! The staff was cheerful and attentive! There is covered patio dining as well as seating available on the sand. We sat under the covered patio which was fortuitous since the ever present tropical rains came. read more

Located in the Elysian resort, we had high hopes that it would be good considering it is one of the 2 options available at the resort. We went once and will not return for dinner. We might try brunch. Our server was amazing and he is the reason it is getting 3 stars instead of 2- he was awesome and brought some "life" and light to our evening! (IYKYK) Everything else left us wanting more. We were seated outdoors and it was a lovely evening. The restaurant could use some renovations, however. A little attention could go a long way but the Elysian resort is tired at large and you can tell they aren't trying too hard at this establishment. We got bread and butter to start and it was pretty bad. It's hard to mess up bread but it was managed- it was really quite flavorless. We got the Paella to share because we weren't terribly hungry and it was just meh. The seafood in it was just okay- nothing special. The rice was the same. The entire dish tasted like saffron and all seafood was fairly mushy/slightly overcooked... which was unfortunate. The red peppers were the only thing that tasted a little different and they were an odd addition in my opinion. It could have used something else to brighten the dish up a bit and the lobster (or all of the seafood, if they can't keep it from overcooking) cooked separately, and maybe served with drawn butter would have been a nice touch! The drinks were fine, nothing special, and we decided to pass on dessert because nothing sounded fantastic. There are plenty of other restaurants in Red Hook, sadly I cannot recommend this one. read more

Beautiful visit to St Thomas stayed at the Wyndham Elysian Beach - ate at their signature restaurant several times. Had the Soft Shell Crab BLT, the Chicken and Waffle Sandwich and a Red Snapper special that was very very tasty. Also tried the Lobster Special, Watermelon and Arugula Salad and Brussels Sprouts. Billy was the Bartender/Server on one occasion and he was FANTASTIC. I don't know what they're paying him but it can't be enough. Excellent food and great service by Billy! The ONLY suggestion for the staff is: Timing is important. On two occasions the mains came out with the appetizers at the same time. That caused the food to not be as hot when you got to it. That needs to be addressed but apart from that - well done. read more

See all

It's safe to say that I do NOT recommend dining here. A party of 7 ended up being $500 for dinner and appetizers. The lemon chicken was supposed to be a half chicken, but it was so small a normal fourth would have been bigger. They must have had baby chicks. The broccoli wasn't cooked and was flavorless. The rice was flavorless. The Brussel sprouts were the worst I've ever tried. The fries tasted like cardboard and were NOT edible. The server we had was nice and so was the water view, but that's all. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Half chicken with rice and broccoli. - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

Absolutely delicious food. Best fish I've had on the island. Great cocktails, great service, and great views. We also had the orange cheesecake and it was incredible; subtle, light, and fresh. You can tell the chefs here love their job. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Crab encrusted grouper - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

This was an exceptional dining experience and will was the perfect meal to celebrate my wife's birthday! After making reservations via Open Table I went on CFM's Instagram page and saw that they offered a beachfront setup and thought this would be a perfect way to elevate our date. The look on her face as we walked up and when she realized the set up was for us was truly priceless. The decor was amazing and our waitress Liz was outstanding and made sure we needed for nothing. Her recommendations were spot on and I was so glad that we listened to her. The Crab Cakes, Sea Bass, & Caribbean Stuffed Lobster were all sensational and was the perfect amount of food for us (was stuffed after the Coconut Cake). We really enjoyed our romantic evening at CFM and would highly recommend to anyone looking to make a truly memorable evening with their special someone. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Beachfront setup available upon request - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

If you're looking for a beautiful atmosphere right on the beach, then this is for you. We overall really enjoyed our drinks and food, with the one complaint that one of our two lobsters was a bit dry; I would probably return and try something else. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Stuffed Lobster - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

Dinner was great. The Ambassador was our server. I had the stuffed lobster, wedge salad shared with my wife, she had the Wahoo fish. It was all very good. Drinks were a little mehhh, but they were super busy and "The Ambassador" was doing a great job! Overall a bit pricy, but it was an upscale restaurant and expected. read more

See all

Server: Rena Rose Dishes Tried: Crab Cakes, Crab Crusted Grouper, Shrimp Wedge Salad, Watermelon and Arugula Salad, Coconut Shrimp Overall, our dining experience at Caribbean Fish Market was fantastic, thanks in large part to Rena Rose's attentive and friendly service. I highly recommend this restaurant for its delicious seafood and top-notch service. read more

My kids wanted the regular lobster tail which was 52 bucks. The waiter upgraded them to the stuffed lobster tail without the stuffing $120 each! I feel robbed literally. Not the way to treat your customers and be honest, professional and classy. Be better. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - robbed - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

We were a party of 6. Our waitress tried to overcharge us by $210 on the bill by adding entries that were never ordered. While we quietly discussing it, she was watching us and immediately ran over to "proactively tell us she is aware of the mistake". It wasn't a mistake , it was malicious. Management needs to be aware. read more