Ok the ambience in this place is really nice. If you're looking for a place on the island to get dressed up and go for dinner then this could be your place. The food was really mediocre for the prices. The dinner entree menus are pretty uneventful so we ordered a variety of appetizers. Some of them were good like the wings and brussel sprouts but the rest of the options left us figuring out what we could add to it to help improve the basic flavor. We added lemon and salt and still weren't impressed. Maybe you'll have better luck when you but don't set your expectations too high. Get dressed up and take pics though for a fancier night out in St. Thomas. read more

See all

We chose Caribbean Fish Market for a special 50th Birthday dinner while on vacation in St. Thomas. It did not disappoint! I had the Crab-Crusted Grouper and it was absolutely amazing. My husband enjoyed his Tuna on Thai noodles. Our entire group of 8 enjoyed their meals. The server and staff went above and beyond to make this a wonderful celebration of the Birthday Boy! We will definitely return on our next trip to the USVI's. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Tuna with mushrooms and Thai noodles - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Amazing dinner and fantastic service. We would have eaten here every night of vacation if we knew about it in the beginning on our trip. Best espresso martini on the island! The crab crusted grouper was to die for. read more

Food was really good, would definitely recommend steak and lobster. Food was definitely pricy and on a more fancy type of restaurant level. The service was slow which was really why it's a 4 star. Atmosphere was amazing and would recommend getting desert read more

See all

I went to this restaurant for my birthday in St. Thomas and I was absolutely blown away with the service and the freshness of the food. Here, we get seafood, its seasoned (hopefully) and we devour it. At Caribbean Fish Market, the fish was fresh and tasteful! Fresh... being its their daily catch and they prepare it just for you on request. Tasty... because they use exotic herbs but yet such simple ingredients to flavor it. Dining here was the first time I've ever heard of Grouper. It was buttery, and flaky just like the waitress said it would be. I ordered the tuna and it was surely not your typical tuna out of the can. It was tender and delectable. For starters, we ordered the korean wings and crab cakes. All too delicious! read more

See all

I have enjoyed eating here twice while on the island. It is absolutely delicious. Mr. Big Life / Big Love was wonderful the reviews were not lying there. He was very knowledgeable and very funny. My only complaint is their wine list. It is awful. They need to hire someone specifically to help curate their wine selection. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Ahi nachos and cauliflower - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

Coming here, I felt like this was a *must try* restaurant on St. Thomas. However, after eating there I feel like it was yummy, but maybe not a top of the list priority stop. I just felt like it was a VERY limited menu, and the food was good, but probably not something I would buy again for that price. Great view and a beautiful restaurant. Our waitress was very sweet. I got the crab crusted grouper. The best thing on my plate was a cabbage slaw that was really good! My boyfriend got the Tuesday special, seafood paella; it was very fancy, but again....not something we'd buy again. It was very beautiful and we still had a great night, I just would have loved to read a review like this before we went! So hopefully this can help someone make a decision. We had other food on our trip so far that I would put above our meal here, so all in all, it was yummy but just not something to rave about:) read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Crab crusted grouper - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Wow, this restaurant was incredible. Located at the Elysian, the view is everything and the restaurant itself was so gorgeous. It's definitely one of the more upscale spots and I'm glad we were able to go there for my mother in laws big birthday. The only thing that wasn't so great (this was consistent across all restaurants) they split our party of 6 across two tables, evidently with the pandemic you can't have more than 6 people at a table and that was enforced even if we were all staying with one another. Additionally, the tables although gorgeous, had chairs that wouldn't fit under it together on a single side so someone gets a leg, they were just super wide chairs. The service was good, it seemed that there were waiters and food runners as well. I did get skipped over for a while for drinks but we arrived late. The calamari was some of the best I have had, super crunchy and with fried tamarind rings mixed in. They didn't really have much of a kids menu so we ordered pizza for the kids, one ate one didn't. I had the Chilean sea bass special that was delicious it was over polenta with a sauce. For dessert we had a cake for my mother in laws birthday and they didn't end up charging a cake cutting fee as they just brought he cake, plates and knife to us. My husband didn't get his drink until when we were paying and it had melted ice at that point, but the server gave it to him to go. Overall, awesome restaurant with delicious food and views! read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Chilean Sea Bass special - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

Nice restaurant. Service was excellent, although they do run on "Island Time". Our waiter was "Mr. Big Time". He's got you covered. The menu is quite complete, and they have some very tasty daily specials. I had the Crab Crusted Snapper over mashed potatoes, which was very good. I would return. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

I will say that we ate here 2 times on our vacation to St. Thomas. The first time was our first night here and the second was for Sunday brunch. First things first: don't expect that you will get your food quickly, but once you get it, the food is pretty good! We were seated quickly our first night without reservations, but we were lucky. You definitely should consider getting reservations. I tried the paella the first night and it was definitely salty and bright from the citrus, and the seafood was fresh and cooked perfectly. My daughter had the penne, and while it had plenty of veggies, it wasn't as full of flavor as she would have liked. My husband enjoyed the chickpea tangine stew, and he scarfed it up! I snagged a bite and it was definitely full of flavor! For brunch, we had the chicken and waffle sandwich, brunch pizza, and chocolate chip pancakes. Our friend had the crab Benedict. All of us enjoyed our choices. It did take a long time to get our food, but once we did...it was delicious! My chicken was cooked perfectly...and was still moist. My husband must've enjoyed the pizza because when I looked over again, he had one piece left and within a few minutes it was gone. He did say that the crust was not a normal pizza crust...it was more like a croissant crust. All in all, the views and time to chat will bring you to have dinner or brunch here. It isn't the most memorable food or service, but the portions are good and it is a great place to relax, unwind, and people watch while enjoying a meal on the beach.paellpancakes read more

See all

I sincerely don't understand how every review isn't five stars. Do yourself a favor, get the hot pot. Calamari, shrimp, clams, white fish, a delectable curry seafood bisque with rice. Every waiter is charming. Every drink is delicious. The view can't be beat. We came here both nights and wouldn't change a thing! Seriously. Come here!!! read more

Disappointed! I was looking forward to having brunch here but the food was okay and service was slow (had to wave down our waiter several times to get the check and to-go-boxes). The view is great, but there very few taxis drop-off and pick-ups in the area - so you'd be better having brunch elsewhere. I figure the main reason for the other higher reviews is based on the bottomless brunch option. The cocktails we had (Sunkissed Senorita, Cat 5-Spiced Mule) were alright. Jalapeno-infused flavor in the senorita added some kick to an otherwise standard margarita. The appetizer we shared (hush puppies; 5 count) was the best part. Think of it like a pancake-y ball with sweet maple syrup and savory bacon-cheddar. As for mains, we had the brunch pizza and the tuna brunch poke. - The pizza was very heavy and not what I expected for a breakfast dish. The cheddar-jack cheese flavor is really strong, so the overall finish of the pizza didn't match my imagination of a typical pizza. - The tuna brunch poke was good. I definitely preferred it over the pizza since it was lighter and refreshing to have with the beach view. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Bacon-Cheddar Hushpuppies - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

It was definitely the worst food we had on the island. It was our last meal before leaving was disappointed. The lobster bisque tasted like straight fish and was watery, we didn't even eat it. The pasta wasn't fully cooked and the lobster was over cooked. We didn't finish one dish other than the shrimp salad appetizer. Service wasn't the best either, waited almost 30 minutes for our check. The busboy couldn't even find our waitress for a long time. The best thing was the ambience, 2 stars for that. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Pasta & Lobster - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

A year ago today we started a 9 day vacation at The Elysian and we ended up spending 6 of those nights at CFM. Because of Ambassador. The greatest, most entertaining server and, by the end of the week, our friend. We even used our family photo + Ambassador as our holiday card. Go visit, you won't be disappointed. read more

One of my favorite restaurants on the island, and I would say one of the best certainly in the top three. But, portions are very generous and the pricing is reasonable. Beautiful location on the beach, open air, delicious food, seafood is great, good bar service, and great wine selection. I highly recommend this restaurant, and I have traveled the world and Pinto to many. read more

Set right on the beach which is very nice. Food was ok. For a seafood place, the food wasn't as fresh as I was expecting. service was great though and drinks were good. Maybe an off night. Highly recommend making reservations. read more

See all

The experience I had was not the best but it was really full that night so I won't say it was horrible and will try again. My waiter was kind of over occupied. He barley had time for any of the tables I saw him at which was kind of annoying my my side and you could see it from others as well. Food wise the taste was GREAT (main trying it again). My lobster was well seasoned and really delicious. The conch fritters was more dough but still flavorful. Everyone else enjoyed their meals. Drinks were well mixed. read more

See all

My wife and I tried this restaurant the first night we got there. Beautiful view and a great staff and amazing food. The ambiance was a perfect setting to a sunset, wine, and dinner with my beautiful wife. I would recommend getting there lobster!! You can't go wrong here. Ps.. my server Mr. Big Time was fantastic!!! read more

See all

Great place I have been back several times. Parking was good the view was nice ( not one of the better beaches on Saint Thomas ) but it was good read more

Our experience at Caribbean Fish Market was awesome! Great location on the beach, listening to the waves. All tables are great and service was awesome. We've already visited twice in the 5 days we've been in St Thomas. We started with the tuna nacho, packed with tuna and mango. I had the grouper with crab on both visits, delicious. Risotto side also cooked perfectly both times. Husband had the wahoo on our first visit and enjoyed and had grouper on the second visit. Both times, everything arrived hot and delicious. We also enjoyed the red velvet cake for dessert. Definitely our favorite restaurant in St Thomas. read more

Went here for dinner with friends. Got the pork chop, which was one of my favorite dishes of the trip. The service was great and I loved our waiter! read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Pork chop - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

I was certainly expecting more out of this place, given its location at the Ritz. The food was mediocre at best. We started with the calamari which was a little rubbery and strangely sweet tasting, but was passable for an appetizer. Unfortunately this is where the meal went south. My wife had the steamed lobster and I had the crab crusted grouper. The dishes were prepared shockingly fast, like Jimmy John's freaky fast. So quick that when the waiter arrived with our food I tried to turn them away because I thought it was not possible they could have prepared something in that amount of time, it had been less than 3 minutes from ordering the entree, that must be someone else's food. The meal arrived slightly warm, and tasteless. My grouper was dry and lifeless and my wife's lobster was over cooked. The side dishes were various shades of gross and meh. We paid a premium for these meals and left in a shocking 30 minutes from our reservation time. I would give one star but the host was pleasant and the food was edible, so I'll give two. I won't be going back. read more

Brunch is always special at the Caribbean Fish Market - although the price for Bottomless drinks has gone up. The Benedict choices are superb. read more

Great food and service. Carribean lobster and grouper were great. Will visit again to try more

We have been waiting 3 years to come back, and Caribbean Fish Market still holds up! In 2019, I claimed this as the best steak I'd ever had and in 2022, it's still true. The filet is tender and fantastically seasoned and seared. My husband had rave reviews of his steak and lobster as well. My tequila sunrise was perfect. And of course, the view and ambience is lovely - lighted torches giving the and a pink tint and the calm ocean just a few yards from the table. Our server was very friendly, as were the hosts. The "good vibes only" photo setup in the back is a nice touch. Without a doubt, our favorite place on the island. read more

See all

This place is amazing! I came here for NYE with the friends I was traveling with and we had a great experience! We made an early reservation so we could dine during sunset and also got a table directly on the beach which was amazing and was essentially a private dining experience. Everything we ordered was delish, especially the grilled lobster. The service was very good and our waiter was very informative about the menu along with recommendations. I will definitely return next time I am on the island. read more

See all

Brunch-lunch-dinner, we've had it all over the years of us visiting and it's all amazing! We now consider this a must while visiting the island. It's by far the best brunch we've had on the island. The views are amazing, the staff is great and the food is outstanding! You will not be disappointed. read more

Food for the most part was enjoyable, but the chef is a bit... confused on certain dishes. We were served undercooked risotto and told by the chef it was "al-dente." There is no such thing as 'al-dente' risotto, just an undercooked chef who doesn't know how to properly make his dishes. The server was also a bit much as well and could use a lesson in server etiquette and overstepping. We enjoyed the setting, will try it again on our next trip. read more

Great seafood choices . We had Caribbean lobster and wahoo . Both great . Coconut cake was excellent too. Romantic setting on the beach read more

I came here for my last night in St.Thomas. The ambiance of this place is really nice. We ordered mussels as an appetizer and I was very excited. However, the mussels tasted like buttery water and the bacon pieces inside of the broth were a bad combo for my tummy. I didn't finish them. Now onto the main course, I wanted crab and was shocked as hell when I saw the size. The plate was big yet the food didn't even take up 25% of it. HOWEVER, the first bite redeemed my opinion of the restaurant. The food was delicious, savory and surprisingly filling. This was supposed to be a romantic night for me and my man but I passed out after I got back to my room and slept for the entire night. I would definitely go back. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Drunken Mussels - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

This place is surprisingly good. We loved everything and went back another night. The setting and service is amazing. read more

See all

The shrimp pasta was amazing...the sauce it was in was super yummy. The snapper was okay. The service and the atmosphere was great. Was a little over priced (I thought) for what it was. But it was good. We stayed at The Ritz Carlton and walked down to this restaurant for a nice dinner out,. It was about a 5 minute walk. I'd def recommend if you're looking for a nice dinner out and in the area. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - Shrimp pasta & the snapper. - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

The best!! I ordered the Lamb Lollipops and the Chermula Chilean Sea Bass brought back to my room. Wow I did not like the sauce for the Lamb but the Lamb was very good and the Sea Bass was delicious! Ate half and saved the rest for the next day and they were just as good. Thank you read more

Four stars for food, one star for service. Our disinterested server Karla was either having a bad night or simply a poor server. She checked in once after dropping appetizers, never refilled our waters, and made a second appearance only to drop the bill. We told her one meal (tuna nachos) was too spicy. She didn't offer to make it with less wasabi or ask if we wanted to try something else, just shrugged. I wanted to tip 15% but my husband gave her 20%. After reading reviews about good service I was disappointed with what we received. Go get your conch fritters at Sangrias and try redhook for dinner instead. Karla, sorry you had such a bad day. read more

Great location right on the beach, came on a Sunday night, the overall atmosphere is loud. If you're looking for a place to celebrate a birthday, anniversary, graduation... this is a great place. We had almost every appetizer which were delicious. Everywhere in St.Thomas tends to have a wait so if you can make reservations do. We didn't and waited about 45min for a table, we sat on the beach looking at the stars while we waited so didn't bother us. Prompt and super friendly service. read more

Absolutely the best meal of my life! Cooked to perfection. I could eat this meal every single day. read more

Caribbean Fish Market - The view - Seafood Near Me - St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Best restaurant in St Thomas. It's right on the water and everything is delicious! Watermelon salad was so fresh, mussels are the best I've had, octopus carpaccio was tasty (loved the olives), the wahoo and snapper (not pictured) were phenomenal, but the orange cheesecake is life changing Omggggg. Go here read more

See all

This place serves churn and burn tourist food. Our seafood was over cooked and tasteless. Being in the Caribbean and getting freezer burned, tough and chewy grouper is almost criminal. Giving 3 stars instead of 2 because our server The Ambassador was hilarious and attentive, and the coconut cake was pretty good. For that kind of food and at those prices, we're better off just staying on our resort property for the rest of the trip. read more

Consistently great food and service over the years. Its a pricey meal but we'll worth the $. Great choices for food, wine and cocktails. Make reservations. read more

Reviews were spot on. Great ambiance. We had 4 adults dining. Service was okay and while they made a few mistakes it was still a pleasurable experience. Food was good.... Highlights of meal included the Korean style wings, the ribeye, and crab crusted grouper. Two at our table got the wahoo which was seared ... cold inside .... and desperately needing a sauce to bring it together. Cocktails were fair... the spicy Paloma was not presented well (spices on rim were dripping down the glass). I would stay with straight liquor, beer, wine. The night we went was really windy and they also had the ceiling fans on high....felt like a wind storm. Overall a good experience and we will try again before leaving. read more