I was visiting my cousin in Port Washington NY and I was Jonesing for a good NY thin crust pizza. In Arizona good NY style pizza is hard to find. The crust was good but I should have asked to have it in the oven another minute or two. It had ample amounts of cheese and after adding extra garlic, shake on Parmesan cheese and oregano. The pizza was perfection. I definitely recommend Carlos pizza when you are in the Port Washington area. read more

See all

One of the best pies on LI! Comes out in 15 minutes fresh and hot, my go to spot for anyone craving a NY slice. Prices fairly reasonable too. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

See all

Fry fry Fridays, been living in Manhasset for over 20 years and folks tell me this pizza is the closest you can get to an authentic NYC slice. The true test would have been to get a plain slice and eat it reheated, hot out of the pizza oven. No time for that today, ordered the Carlo's "Special". Took it home, heated it for 3 minutes on a non-stick pan, came out perfectly . All in ~$35, 8 slices of yummy . read more

Carlo's Pizza - Carlo's "Special" - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Place was spot on. Nice people. Super clean and the pizza OMG one of the best on long island anyone complaining about the price is just a poor cheap loser. Loved it Highly recommend this spot. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Great pizza. We enjoyed our slices and the service was friendly and fast. I would recommend trying anything from here. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

My friends recently moved to Port Washington and as they were exploring the Main Street in this town, a delicious smell led them to this pizzeria. After hearing this story, I was curious to try as well! We ordered two pies over the phone as we were driving there and we parked a block away. When we got there, it was all ready for us. The place is very clean and has a good amount of tables and seats with air conditioning on a hot summer day! For a pepperoni pie and a cheese pie it was $45 cash. We sat and ate them fresh. The pies were smaller than other large pies I've had and it was not as cheesy as I would like. The texture was a bit different and reminded me of the hot oil pizza from Riko's. Overall, it was a decent local pizza place and the employees were very friendly! Would come by to try other things on the menu aside from pizza. read more

See all

Pretty solid pizza for NY! It did not disappoint. We got a large pizza, half cheese and half pepperoni. We ate the pizza at the restaurant which I recommend since it tastes best fresh. They were pretty big slices and the cheese was gooey but had enough of a crust to balance that out. Service was fine and the pizza came out in a reasonable time. It's our go-to when we want a quick bite in Port Washington! read more

Carlo's Pizza - Half Pepperoni Half Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

amazing pizza, really old school, quick service, lovely people and food. Ambiance is very old school.

I love Carlo's pizza. They have been our go to pizza place for a few years. Last night, we wanted something a little different. We ordered a Sicilian pizza plain. WOW, this was one of the best pizzas we ever had. The dough was thick but airy not like the belly busters of dough that after one or two slices it feels like you ate the whole pizza. The custard was crispy and very tasty like a grandmas pizza. My wife and I were very happy with the meal and will be ordering this again. Thank you for the very well priced and delicious meal. read more

Always make it a point to grab a slice when I'm back in town. Hands down best slice in Long Island!

Carlos is the absolute best ! Ordered 20 spinach twists for my party as it's my favorite food (from Carlos only) and it was a total hit none left! Not to mention it was last minute and they totally manages to get the job done and make my day! I have known the owners my whole life here in port and I'm so thankful to have their food and families like Danny and Roberto's in this community! It's also my go to regular slice! Love you guys!!! read more

Best pizza in Port Washington! For years friends in the town raved about Carlo's Pizza but I stubbornly stayed with my old standard Gino's. What a pleasant surprise. My friends were right and now we're hooked on Carlo's. Lots of TLC goes into their pizza. Delicious! read more

Hole in the wall type place, had it for the first time paid 45 for a pizza because toppings are expensive. But worse was it was burned and then crammed into and steamed in The box so very limp slices. I did not think much of it, but it was my only time ordering from there so maybe I received bad pies. read more

Absolutely classic. Thin, correct cheese to sauce, just like the old days. Perfection. read more

While staying in the hospital I decided to order from a pizzeria nearby. I was researching for really good slices and this restaurant had great reviews for it! Unfortunately my food came cold & my Snapple wasn't cold but good thing the nurse was able to warm up my food for me. I never eat cold pizza but I decided to not warm up the pizza cause microwave pizza is gross and wow! I was blown away by how good the slice was and it wasn't even hot! The wings were good but I definitely thought to myself on how I should have 3 slices lol! read more

Carlo's Pizza - Pepperoni slice Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Amazing food and amazing staff!! LOVE THIS PLACE!!! Food is always fresh and on time.

Growing up in Brooklyn I ate damn good pizza. It was everywhere from L&B to Franks(RIP) to Delmars to Pizza Di Amore Lennys etc. In the Southern Brooklyn of my youth resplendent with Sicilian immigrants, good pizza was everywhere. Some of the newer slice joints succeed splendidly like Pauline G's Belluci SCarr to a lesser extent and soon to try Baby Luc's.. Carlo's is a perfect slice. It speaks loudly and tastes of a time honored recipe. Crispy crisp crust and lots of good olive oil. I don't eat a lot of pizza and this was my second this week. SCarr's was my first and Carlo's was better. It's that instant yum that cuts through everything and at $3 a slice it is a little slice of heaven. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Stellar slice - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

I've been a big fan for years! I think they have the best pizza in Port Washington. The service is always prompt and courteous. The ambiance is very much like a traditional pizzeria. Every time I travel and then return to town, our first order is always Carlos delicious pizza. Always arrives quickly and feels like it is fresh out of the oven. Their hero's and pasta fagiole soup are the best. Definitely order from here! read more

Great NY slice, thin crust, fold it and it doesn't flop over, not greasy and very tasty.Well done.

Visited for lunch on 11/15/22. First time here. Nice little local pizza joint. Pretty solid regular slice and the chicken cesar slice was awesome. Owner was a gentleman and the service was great. If you're in the neighborhood and in the mood for some no fuss pizza, I'd recommend stopping in. read more

Best sausage pizza ever. The sauce, the crust, the cheese, Oh My! Perfection.

My family and I have been eating at Carlo's since we moved to Port Washington in 1999. They are wonderfully consistent! Their red sauce is very good, a touch sweet, which makes their regular pie and Sicilian pie very good! We also enjoy the white spinach pie and the spinach pin wheels. Used to be cash only but now take credit cards too. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Spinach 16" Round White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

The pizza here is the greatest. Please don't change a thing. DON'T do doordash. DON'T get computers. Old school is the way to go. No need for extra fancy shit. The pizza is legit and authentic. Does not need modernizing or anything. You want pizza from an app, call dominos. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Always fantastic pizza. Long tradition of feeding Port Washington by the slice and the pie. Super service as well. Much love - JGD.

They make the best baked ziti I recently started working around the area and when we order from here this is my go to read more

Carlo's Pizza - Baked ziti - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Great place for a slice. Did not disappoint. Friendly staff and super fair prices. Highly recommend.

Great pizza! Tried the buffalo, cheese and margarita slices. Its thin and crispy! The place has a very old school pizza place vibe. The cheese slice was nice and thin and cheese with the right amount of tanginess in the sauce. I dont typically travel to this area but wouldn't mind just to grab a slice. read more

the whole pie weighed less than a pound complete bs, looked like a pie from domino, glen head your getting scammed, totally ridiculous read more

Pretty slick they don't put the total on the "receipt" for deliveries. If you don't ask for the total when you place the order, the driver can basically charge you any amount. read more

Carlo's Pizza - "receipt" - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Hands down the best pizza in Port Washington! Crispy thin pies, great salads and specialty pizzas. Meatball heroes are delicious. I've been going to this restaurant since the mid 80's. Never had a bad experience, never. read more

Best regular cheese slice. Perfect thin and nice regular slice. 2.75$ Cash for two slice total 5.50$ read more

Carlo's Pizza - Regular cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Port Washington, New York

I think the service was amazing. Sat down there with my family and got a Large Plain pie. Came out in 10 minutes and the pizza was great. One of the best pizzas on Long Island. Will be coming back to this place. The ambiance was nice with older style seats. read more

Best pizza in town! I grew up in the city, and really love Carlos slice! Best if you eat it there, still good at home! Guys behind the counter are friendly. It's your run of the mill pizza joint! Enjoy! read more

Best plain slice on Long Island 10/10 . Everything there is good but the plain cheese pie is the best

CARLOS IS KING. PERIOD. Classic amazing regular slice and solid Italian staples. Their specialty pies like the spinach artichoke is to die for. Staff could not be friendlier. As a third generation Port Washington native, I really do love how consistent Carlos has remained not only with their food, but with their appearance as well -giving you the timeless feel of what a well loved and lived in old school pizzeria should be. read more

Order by the pie for the best results. In my opinion the best plain pies in Port. That's saying a lot with Salvatore's down the block.

Vodka Sicilian pie is freaking amazing. Def will have to try other stuff but I can't stop ordering the vodka pie.

The garlic knots were SO good and the pizza is really great and it's just a great pizzeria

Really good thin crust pizza. Sauce is semi sweet, but not overwhelming. Good amount and distribution of cheese

The best no matter what you order service is great and friendly been going there forever