Floppy, flimsy, greasy, pizza! The pizza always looks like it's been sitting in the glass display all day. I try to avoid, but sometimes have to come because it's close by. To top it off the Spanish lady behind the counter has a serious tude when you point out the flaws. Stay away!!! read more

Vito's Pizzeria - Regular Slice - Pizza Near Me - Westbury, New York

I placed an order to be delivered at 5:58pm. They told me it would be to my house within a half an hour. I still had not received my order by 7:15pm. I called back and they were rude and told me it was delivered to my house and paid for because it was not in the restaurant. It was hard to understand them and they did not get the fact that the food never was delivered to my house. They even repeated the address back to me and said it was delievered. I told them I wanted to cancel the order and they told me I didn't understand that it was delivered and paid for already, at least that is what I could make out as to what she was trying to tell me over the phone. Needless to say, I never received the order, an apology or a call back about the order. read more

this is probably the best pizza on Long Island. It's got that perfect crust with the sticky type cheese that is the perfect chewyness and the taste just bursts. order with extra cheese. read more

Very yummy pizza! Tiny pizza joint in a small shopping center. Doesn't look like much from the outside but once you're inside you'll see a few tables, chairs, and a counter with friendly employees ready to serve you delicious food. Everyone was friendly. The pizza was delicious. read more

Vito's Pizzeria is an old school, no frills place to grab some good pizza and enjoy the culinary wonder that pizza is. How can something with only a few ingredients (dough, sauce, cheese, spices and whatever toppings you crave) become such a beloved institution like pizza has? I guess it's just because those few items create such a wonderful totality. The pizza here is solid. With each bite I was in a cheesey utopia and totally immersed in a wonderful culinary experience. Coming from New Jersey and now living in Florida, I miss pizza this good. This was definitely a culinary high point on this business trip. I would definitely recommend Vito's Pizzeria. read more

Absolutely avoid. Look pass the attitudes of the gentlemen in the place and focus on the food. I was hoping after my 1st experience 4 years ago things would have gotten or similar. Thought I would love love over the years,, but it's gotten worse. We decided to try them again getting simply a plain slice, pepperoni slice, and some garlic knots. I watched them put my slices in the oven however I'm pretty sure they were dumped in water. Jow else could I explain how soggy the dough was. The garlic knots could have been a bit better, but it was the only decent part of it. Not cheap either. Please do not eat here. I love local eats but I travel for pizza because this is unacceptable. read more

The pizza is good, we have to admit. We eat pizza all over Long Island. But...they seem to be a bit inconsistent with their slices. First time I had a slice, the bottom was crisp and perfect. Second time, a floppy oily slice. Stay to the crisp bottom! Some words of advice. Clean up inside a bit. Pizza boxes all over, and flyers just sitting there. They have QR code Instagram flyers just sitting there. Have one or two hung up and thats that. That IG page could be better too. Pay a local company to run it. It has that aged feel to it. Post more food photos and more engaging posts. Coffee pots just there on the left side, sitting there. Hide stuff better. I ordered a slice to go one time. The guy working was also making the pies. Great, someone has to. BUT, he also took my cash for payment. I watched from my car. Didnt wash his hands after the cash transaction. Pretty gross. Do better there, bc MANY people have eyes on that. And all a spot needs is a health inspector to catch that. Price is right and pizza has potential. Just clean up inside and make sure your staff is cleaning hands at all times, ESPECIALLY WITH CASH HANDLING read more

Delicious family-owned pizzeria and does amazing things for the community including the Girl Scouts and Little League.

Ordered delivery from here today and it was the best Grandma pizza I have ever had. My son had a small pizza and he loved it too. I plan to try everything on the menu. Our new pizza spot!! read more

Amazing staff very personable, I've always had a pleasant experience eating at the restaurant. My daughter won't eat pizza from anywhere else Vito's read more

Have ordered from Vito's for 25 years. Love the pizza and wings. Compelled to give a review because they are now serving breakfast, so flipping good. Classic bacon egg and cheese and the tastiest home fries. our third breakfast order in two weeks. read more

very solid pizza place! very tiny and no frills...but excellent pizza. great customer service as well - it's located close to my job so i will definitely be back! read more

Tried a pepperoni slice here while waiting for my kid to come out from classes. Solid slice. Crispy, light pizza. Will be stopping by when in the area. read more

The best white slice you'll ever have. Great Sicilian crust. Bruschetta slice is amazing. Great locally owned spot.

I haven been ordering from Vito's for at least 10 years. Most times good, rarely just okay. Tonight ordered rigatoni with spinach and garlic and oil. It was awesome and worthy of a fine dining Italian restaurant. I couldn't have been more pleased. And on a Monday night no less (most #1 chefs are off). Bravo Vito's! read more

1st timer; ordered the Personal 10" Pizza w/ Garlic knots. Before even gettin' in the house I snatched up one of the garlic Knots & after 3 bites (they're NOT small) I was blown away. In the house, waiting 4 the Puerto ta' cool down, just looking @ it & being a NY'er from birth, I knew it was TOP SHELF!; Olive Oil, Buffalo Mozzarella just right crust an all the right spices. Gravy (imem, "sauce'c 4 all 'ya non-italians) was perfect. This IS A HANDS DOWN SHOW STOPPER. & THEY DELIVER! Prices more than reasonable & varieties of foods more than plentiful!! Definitely call & place your order!!! read more

I was looking for lasagna for dinner. Yelp referred me here. I am glad it did. I live several miles away and never ate here before. I ordered takeout lasagna. It came with warm italian rolls and a side of parmesan topping. They have daily specials. I expect to return. My five stars are based on: 1 - quality ingredients for a delicious dish, 1- large portions, 1- reasonable price, 1- ready when they said it would be, and 1 - well-packaged for delivery. read more

Great local pizzeria. Staff was friendly, pizza was great and the fried calamari, will definitely buy from here more often. I live in the neighborhood. read more

Now I know why our Family doesn't buy from this pizzeria. You get the most recent ad and you order it and then after you order they tell you it's a dollar more than the advertisement coupon! The ad states taxes included ...just to find out they taxed you and it's on your credit card! So they want to cheat you out of a few bucks ....they actually lost this customers and their family and friends business forever. read more

Best pizza ever!! Great food all around. We have been going since we moved to Salisbury 16 years ago !!

We ordered here a few times during COVID closure. Solid pizza joint. You can't go wrong with this place if you are craving for a decent pie or slice. read more

Great pizza, but...... very inconsistent on prices.. large pie is probably a medium at best in other places. Someone needs to show them how to EVENLY cut up a pie.. read more

See all

I used to live around the block from here but live in Las Vegas now. HAD to stop in since I was in town. Used to eat here almost every single day. Best pizza in the county!! Can't wait till next time I'm here in town so I can have more of the menu lol read more

Vito's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Westbury, New York

This place could not be better. The staff is kind to everyone, and the pizza is unforgettable. I am a regular there, and I don't regret it.

If you could appreciate the gruff sense of humor at times, pretty solid place. For the family, the pizza isn't as good for us. The calzone is a winner. If you get the "medium" sized calzone, it's pretty good for the entire family. I had tried the mozzarella sticks, very crispy, very good. I just tried the gyro wrap, tastes pretty good in my opinion. I look forward to trying a bunch of other stuff on the menu, would've gave a five star but I don't know if it's quite there yet since I have not sampled more of their items. It's a solid place - try it out! read more

OMG what a great pizzeria. It's a small pizzeria but their pizzas are amazing. Always fresh and yummy. They have amazing salads and I specially love their grilled chicken. Happy customer and I will keep coming to Vito's whenever I am in the area. read more

Stellar eggplant parm, their slices are good but for some reason the pie was not that great. Really wanted to like it as the guys in there look like they mean business but, if I'm being honest, there are much better options around that area. read more

My GO TO local pizza place. Not only is the food Excellent ,BUT Vito and his staff are phenomenal !! Friendly, efficient ,business like and they know how to get everything right !! Vito's pizza is great and he makes it to your liking. I've eaten his eggplant parm hero's and veal parm hero's Delish . His salads are wonderful as are the speciality rolls.. BUT Vito has the BEST garlic rolls around, full of Garlic ! The reheat great as well. Get a side sauce to dip them into ..yummy. Keep up the good work Vito... read more

New to Salisbury, and we've tried Mario's, Frantoni's, DiCarlo's, Mama Theresa's - and Vito's wins so far. Tastes like pizza we used to get from Queens, crispy flavorful crust, just enough sauce to cheese ratio, and nice crunch on the crust....so happy we found Vito's! read more

I just picked up a Sunday special order that was advertised as a certain price from this weeks advertisement and was not honored and the pizza was not great. We will not be back. read more

This is our local, take out, place. We never eat in, but there are a few tables, no ambience at all. Pizza is ok for the area...but the garlic knots are the best in the world. When we go to a party or the kids have to bring something to school or sports, I order a couple dozen and they are gone in a flash. Never had better, consistantly. read more

Went to eat here for lunch, Had an absolutely horrible experience. MY recommendation DO NOT EAT HERE. I was greeted with a bad attitude, they treated me as if I a nuisance and not a customer who was there and buying their pizza. To top it off they were not very sanitary. read more

Service was OK. I was craving melted mozzarella so I decided to come here and order the spinach roll. I called up and they had to check to see if they had any left? Every other pizza spot will make me a spinach roll fresh if they didn't have one so long as i don't mind waiting. What's the difference then making a new pie? They had one left..still takes 15 minutes to make? They charge $6.25 and i think there is more substance in a slice of pizza. It's the smallest roll I've ever gotten. And there was hardly any cheese, there is more butter on toast then there was cheese in this thing. The taste of the spinach itself was OK, it's totally frozen spinach but at least they sautéed it with garlic. The stars in this review is for their pizza. . Stick to the pizza and garlic knots. read more

Vito's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Westbury, New York

Awesome sauce of a restaurant.... Super staff and amazing owner.... Fabulous food, superior customer service!!! Very very very very charitable and regularly assists my outreach cause with the homeless/displaced and lower socio economic communities by permitting me to rescue food at night's end..... I'm ultra appreciative and authentically thankful..... Fabulous family feel..... Eileen Scanlon Tacchetti FB::: Scanlon's Traveling Salon read more

Great service, and delicious pizza. My first time there, they gave me a slice on the house. read more

See all

Pizza is great !! Not my favorite but right up there we order hero's and platters a lot and the real hidden gem here is the buffalo wings. Put up a fight the first time we ordered from a pizza place but it's the go to spot for them now. read more

I have been ordering food from Vito's for 18 years so I guess you can say I like their food. Like, I love it. My whole family has enjoyed their delicious pizza's. The best on LI and their food is real Italian and the servings reflect this. Trust me if you live in the area try their food. you won't be sorry. A fan, Brandon H. read more

What can I say! I wish this place was like in a open area so everyone can see. there food is absolutely amazing for me. to yelp about it means something. I am a school bus driver for the district of east meadow and when I want pizza this is the place for me. staff is very friendly food is as fresh as it can be this is why I give this place 5 stars. A must go if you want good quality and fresh food. read more

Just ordered 2 regular pies. The crust was super crispy just the way we like it. It reminds me of the pizza from places in Queens. Excellent and delicious! read more

A favorite local place that my mom always raved about . We recently have stopped for a slice - the pizza is excellent - it's their sauce which has a slight sweetness and is very flavorful- the cheese is generous but not over the top . Highly recommended . read more