We stopped by Casa De Catrina for an early dinner with the kids and had a great experience. Since we arrived before the evening rush, it was nice and quiet, making it perfect for a family meal. Everything we ordered was delicious, from the fresh guacamole and flavorful fajitas to the drinks. The service really stood out--our server was attentive, friendly, and wonderful with the kids, which is always appreciated. read more

See all

The ambience was fun and trendy. Saturday night DJ was playing good music. Had reservations was sat down after a few mins. The staff was friendly and attentive. Ordered the Margarita Flights. Concept was cool but lacked liquor . Let's move to dinner we ordered the Mexican Molcajete -- which included Steak, chicken, shrimp, chorizo, pork chops, cactus, grilled Oaxaca cheese, topped with scallions & served with soft tortillas, rice & beans. *Steak was good. Chicken was ok lacked flavor. Pork chop was very chewy and dry chorizo was mehhh. Shrimp was ok-needed more seasoning. Overall it was alright. If I went back I would probably just order the skirt steak alone. read more

Casa De Catrina - Mexican Near Me - Carle Place, New York

See all

@casa_de_catrina was a WHOLE experience ‍ We pulled up and went ALL IN -- and not one miss Spring Flights -- margaritas with coconut, honeydew melon, pineapple, cucumber & lychee flavors (fresh, fruity, EVERYTHING) San Luis Potosí -- Espolòn reposado tequila, strawberry + jalapeño, pineapple, passion fruit & lime with a tajín rim = sweet + spicy perfection Now let's talk FOOD Pulpo A La Grill -- grilled octopus with arugula, fennel, cherry tomatoes & crispy roasted potatoes tossed in a citrus vinaigrette Queso Fundido -- melted Chihuahua cheese topped with chorizo, scallions & cilantro (dangerously good) Grilled Steak Tacos -- loaded with pico, pickled onions & radish Catrin Steak Fajitas -- sizzling steak with onions & peppers, tortillas, crema, guac, pico, rice & beans Mexican Molcajete -- steak, chicken, shrimp, chorizo, pork chops, cactus & grilled Oaxaca cheese with all the sides The food was AMAZING... but the vibes?? UNMATCHED read more

See all

Yelp Review: Visited Casa de Catrina and it was such a fun experience from start to finish. The atmosphere was lively and perfect for a girls night out with great music and a really vibrant vibe. The drinks were a great way to start the night. We tried the margarita flight which came with five different flavors and it was a fun way to sample a variety. We also ordered a lemon drop passionfruit martini and a raspberry martini, and both were really well balanced and refreshing. For appetizers we had the chicken wings, a tostada, and the chicken flautas. The wings were crispy and juicy, the tostada was flavorful and fresh, and the flautas were crunchy and satisfying. For entrées we tried the grilled octopus, the skirt steak, and the shrimp enchiladas. The octopus had a really cool flaming presentation at the table which made the dish even more memorable. The skirt steak was cooked perfectly and very flavorful, and the shrimp enchiladas had a delicious sauce that really tied the whole dish together. We finished the meal with churro ice cream which was the perfect sweet ending. Service throughout the night was friendly and attentive, and the energy of the restaurant made it a really enjoyable place to spend the evening. A great spot for drinks, good food, and a fun night out. read more

See all

The food was good but overpriced for what you get. I recommend getting the fried tamales, those were delicious. The elote was ok. Very heavy on that true mayo flavor. Needs some spice and lime on the side. The tacos were not worth the price honestly. The lamb dish though was cooked and seasoned perfectly. The churros came with ice cream and lightly dusted with cinnamon sugar. The soft drinks are served via can for $4 a piece. The cocktails are more value for your buck, but even those are quite pricey in comparison to similar restaurants in the area. The ambiance becomes more of a nightclub vibes as the night progresses. So if you're looking for a calmer vibe, come early for dinner. read more

See all

Casa de Catrina is a colorful and festive eatery with nice Latin music. We visited for lunch, the restaurant is roomy with free parking. The menu could be categorized as Mexican, our dishes were delish. They serve a great Margarita as expected, and the Street Corn was the best I had had so far. For dessert we shared the Churros stuffed with caramel and great coffee. Our server was excellent. Give Casa de Catrina a try. read more

See all

Great experience at Casa De Catrina! Everything is over the top and delicious! Ice cream for brunch!? Sign me up ! Food was quick to come out and was delicious. I love chorizo and those churros were insane. Definitely would go back. read more

See all

The food was delicious however for a Mexican restaurant they are very limited w vegan options. (They do have plenty of side orders to pick from) The drinks were spot on I appreciate they give you options for the alcohol type you want . Their margarita flight 10/10 MUST HAVE! Super cute a bit small but cozy restaurant! Decor was spot on (plenty of picture moment backdrops) read more

See all

Came for dinner with my boyfriend. The service was excellent and the food delicious. The music was lively and a vibe. Would definitely come back. Also, idk why they give iPads instead of menus, you can't order or pay on them. Major waste of money if you ask me. Would definitely come back again. read more

See all

Very fun Saturday night dinner spot. As soon as you walk in the DJ is there spinning some great Spanish music all night. I really enjoyed the calamari appetizer which was fried perfectly and came with marinara sauce and chipotle mayo. The restaurant also serves complimentary chips & dip. But the main star was the skirt steak which came with 2 sides. I got the Mexican rice and mashed potatoes. This was easily one of the best skirt steaks I ever had. Cooked at a perfect medium. The skirt steak was so tender and juicy. It sliced like butter. The Mexican rice was flavorful and even better when paired with the aji verde sauce. The mashed potatoes were amazing. You can tell they use real potatoes not the powdered kind, and they did not fill it with sour cream to make it too creamy. It was thick delicious potatoes mashed up. I can't wait to visit again. read more

We decided to try this spot for dinner and honestly left a bit disappointed. I ordered the skirt steak tacos, which came with three tacos, no sides, and a tiny sauce for $28. My husband got the beef birria tacos -- also three tacos, no sides -- for the same price. Both were just okay, not much flavor for the price point. For drinks, we kept it simple with two canned sodas. Service itself was fine; the staff checked in on us a few times, which I appreciated. But when the bill came, we noticed they had added an automatic gratuity. What's strange is that after looking at other Yelp reviews, some people have posted their receipts without the auto-gratuity, so it feels a little inconsistent. On top of that, there's an additional charge if you pay with a card. Between the high prices, lack of flavor, and questionable billing practices, it just didn't feel worth it. Unfortunately, we probably won't be returning. read more

Casa De Catrina - Auto gratuity? - Mexican Near Me - Carle Place, New York

See all

Great authentic Mexican restaurant. The food was great and the decor was beautiful. Really the worst thing I can say about it was that the service was a little slow. But overall, it was a very nice experience. read more

As is my tradition when working out of town, I look for a Mexican place nearby. Unfortunately, I didn't scrutinize the Yelp reviews very closely. While some are decent, my visit leaned towards the negative. Chips and salsa were lacking. Two tiny cups are served with the chips. One red. One green. The red was fair. I didn't care for the green. It took an extended period for the server to bring out my unsweetened ice tea. I also waited much longer than I should have for a refill. The presentation of the chicken fajitas was probably the highlight of the meal. However, I can't eat presentation. The grilled veggies were decent, but the chicken lacked flavor as did the rice. I asked for salt and pepper shakers as there are none on any table. I was never brought the salt and pepper. The rice desperately needed it! On top of all this negativity, $30 for the fajitas is just overpriced. I definitely won't be back. read more

Casa De Catrina - Mexican Near Me - Carle Place, New York

See all

Place is overpriced for the quality of food and service. Beef nachos were terrible and poorly done, a few big blocks of ground beef, and in a bowl which was weird, it's not nacho soup. The calamari was good but basic and the menu says it's $20 but they charged $23 on the bill! Scammers! FALSE ADVERTISING. The tacos were three for $28, no sides, not amazing for that price. Service was slow, they didn't even have the reservation in the computer despite me showing them the email confirmation. Then they have the nerve to tell me I have a 1.5 time limit at the table. By the time we got our food, we were about 30 minutes into the 1.5 time limit so basically I chalked this meal up as a fast food Mexican experience with some really nice murals on the wall and good decor. Wouldn't recommend and will not be returning. read more

Casa De Catrina - The menu says $20 for fried calamari and they charged $23 on the bill without informing us! - Mexican Near Me - Carle Place, New York

See all

Visited here with a few coworkers for lunch. We sat at the bar and were greeted right away. The chips and salsa are warm and fresh. We all did an assortment of tacos which were delicious! Spicy margaritas were on point as well. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Enjoyed everything about this restaurant. From the beautiful artwork on the walls to the tableside guacamole. The service was friendly and polite, not too obtrusive. The food was very good. Skirt steak was a 4, Birria tacos a solid 3.5 and the Guacamole a 4.5. Love that it's made tableside. Cocktails were on point as well. Maybe a little pricey, but the environment doesn't come free. Also, great place for a birthday. They come out and sing and put a big ole sombrero on you. Very fun. read more

See all

Had a great time here. The Happy Hour was a great deal in margs and then we followed up with the flight. After trying 6 flavors now I can say none of the margaritas disappointed. My spicy marg was the perfect amount of spice and the flavored ones were spot on, like drinking the fruit, my favorite being the tamarind. As for the good, the street corn was different, but would 100% eat again. More in the sweeter side but addicting for sure. The birria tacos were also a fan favorite, especially the cheese inside. Shrimp tacos did not disappoint as well. Would definitely come back! read more

See all

A chic vibe when entering this fairly new Mexican restaurant. Love the stylish bar counter and seating with it's IG ready decor. It is quite a lot to take in at first look. The place is brightly lit and has a comfortable layout of tables, makes this a great hang out for date night or a night out for drinks with friends. The entrees menu was simple with a variety of proteins - think salmon, steak, pork, chicken and shrimp, as well as lots of great sharing appetizers. We ordered a bit from each section - started with the grilled octopus appetizer (must try!), queso fundido with chorizo (this was melty goodness), fresh guacamole made table side (slight kick) and for entrees, we shared the cheese quesadilla and salmon tacos (generous size portions of fish and the pickled onions were a perfect compliment to the fish). While the tacos were supposed to be fried as listed, I requested soft ones instead and they accommodated without question. The white Sangria was very tasty and I enjoyed the fresh fruit. For dessert, we ordered the churros with vanilla ice cream - it's so good when it's fresh and made on the spot! The wait staff and porters were always quick to clean, swap plates, bring silverware, and refill drinks. Very hospitable. Also very polite when they interacted with us. They always asked before removing or replacing something from the table. Totally recommend this place for a fun evening out. read more

See all

Had a great lunch here with friends. Very artsy and has great spots to take selfies. The service was awesome and gave us enough space to chat but was always nearby to see if we needed anything. Had to try the chicken flautas and they were really good. Got too stuffed and couldn't finish my enchiladas, but they made great leftovers. read more

See all

The tostada was purely delicious, I was not a huge fan of the enchiladas but the mole sauce is delicious, the service was quick, the decor is really cool, this spot is nice for dates, wheelchair accessible place, they also have kids menu, the margaritas seemed popular as well. We definitely might go back, n the only strang thing, a guy came up to us and asked if we wanted our picture taken, not sure why, it was little akward, i wish they had more options on their menu tho like elote n other favorites read more

Went on a Saturday night and the place was very busy. I had very high hopes. We were sat close enough to our reservation time ( no big deal). The waitress seemed a bit overwhelmed. Here's where the problems start. Took over 20 minutes to get our drinks. Ordered a couple of margaritas ( nothing fancy ). Our appetizer came out before our drinks . No water or anything on the table. Also, I've been to other Mexican spots and I thought it was strange that they don't put anything on the table like nachos or something to munch on. It definitely would improve the experience since the service is so terribly slow. The final nail in the coffin was that my date ordered the skirt steak tacos. There is ZERO chance the meat in the tacos was skirt steak. It wasn't identifiable. They definitely have a lot to improve on. read more

Wow what a great overall experience. Our waiter Angel took great care of us from start to finish. Each dish was better than the next. Can't wait to Bring our family back soon. read more

See all

I had a great meal and Valentina was a great waitress! I would highly recommend to anyone who loves Mexican food.

Do not waste your time or money! Food was terrible took an hour and a half to get our meal and it didn't even come out all together. Music was too loud! Had to send back our meals. read more

Ambiance was very upscale. Food was great. The chicken fajitas were very juicy. The dishes were plentiful. Had leftovers for the next day! Yum!!! My favorite part was the margarita flight. They def don't skimp on their drinks. Servers were very attentative. Will be back to enjoy more of their drinks. Def recommend! read more

See all

Casa De Catrina is located in Garden City, Li which is littered with great restaurants however this New Mexican restaurant is making very big waves! Parking is very convenient as it is located in an " outlet " like area - no valet & it is not needed The restaurant is beautifully decorated & painted with traditional Mexican decor. The bar is lined with top shelf liquor and beautiful green chairs with gold accent - it is eye catching and definitely instagram worthy. I suggest getting there early, we got there around 1pm on a Saturday then around 3pm we saw large groups of families pouring in The food & drinks were absolutely delicious. They offer complimentary chips & salsa; We started with the margarita flight - 5 different flavored margaritas (passion fruit, mango, hibiscus , tamarind & cucumber $30) ALL the flavors were delicious & strong - our personal favorites were the passion Fruit & mango for food we ordered the sweet plantains which was nicely garnished with cojita cheese ($5) tostones which came with a delicious dipping sauce ($5)Birria Oaxaca Cheese Tacos which came with a ramekin of consome ($21) BBQ Pork Rib Tacos ($18) - this pork Rib taco was garnished with grilled pineapples, it was a tad too sweet for us but wasn't a terrible taco. We also had the warm chocolate lava cake which was served with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream & chocolate syrup ($11) ALL the servers were friendly, attentive, and efficient. Special shout out to the bartender Francisco- he too was very customer oriented. He walked around engaging with customers & ensured they were having a good experience We're looking forward to our next meal at Casa de Catrina! And definitely want to check out their Sunday brunch My only recommendation is - possibly add a Saturday brunch 10/10 highly recommend this restaurant read more

See all

Came here for dinner last Saturday with my husband mom & son. We shared the chiccharon guacamole to start - really good I wish It was a bit spicier though For dinner I had the chicken fajitas- portion was huge & was flavorful. It came with a huge portion of rice & beans also - really good! My husband got the steak fajitas - also really flavorful & my mom got the salmon tacos and she really liked them. We finished the meal with warm churros - huge portion & delicious I'd definitely go back again! read more

See all

You got to try casa de catrina!! The food is lit literally and the drinks are real good. The music is on point but must important the staff is so nice and helpful. read more

See all

The decor of this place is so cute and chic! The waitstaff are attentive and personable. My friends and I went on a Thursday night and it was quick to be seated. We ordered a few dishes to share and spicy margaritas - we had the birria tacos which lacked a bit in flavor, the wings which were undercooked, the corn which was delicious and the nachos which were also pretty good. We had hoped to try the calamari but they were out of it. The margaritas were delicious! This place has excellent customer service, we had voiced our opinion about the wings and they took it off the bill and they gave us free shots. I would come back for drinks, nachos and a great atmosphere! read more

See all

New spot in the area, first time here and it went amazing! Food,drinks, customer service and cleanliness were very good! The design was incredible from the wall art and bar area and seating. They will do amazing if they continue what they started. read more

See all

I love the ambience & the decor of this place - so pretty and trendy! We ordered the flights which were made so strong we could barely get through them & I am someone who LOVES a tequila straight & a good margarita. Unfortunately, the food was mediocre at best which was a big letdown because I was so excited to try this place. read more

Casa De Catrina - Margarita Flight - Mexican Near Me - Carle Place, New York

Drinks were great. I'm not a fan of sweet drinks so I was a big fan. The bartender was really nice. He let us get one drink in before happy hour ended. The walls are very nicely painted and really good for pictures. read more

See all

Food was mediocre at best. We got a steak burrito, shrimp tacos & a side of rice & beans. Except for the jalapeño pepper on top of the burrito, it was pretty bland. The shrimp was tasty, but nothing else was. The bill was ridiculously high & came to $80. Thanks but no thanks. read more

I went here yesterday for my husband's 68th birthday. The restaurant was fairly empty at the time we arrived. We went for a late lunch, early dinner but did fill up towards the end of our dining experience. We were greeted promptly by Angel and introduced to our server Jonathan. The restaurant was decorated very nicely in traditional Mexican decor. The food was delicious, hearty portions and we topped it off with a pitcher of Sangria and for dessert my husband was treated to yummy tres leches. The servers sang to him and put a sombrero on him which made his day. Everything was amazing. Would definitely return. read more

Casa De Catrina - Happy birthday to my husband - Mexican Near Me - Carle Place, New York

See all

This Mexican restaurant will have their grand opening in about two weeks. We went on a Saturday evening and were seated immediately. It wasn't crowded. I have a feeling, though, once people hear about this place, it will be jammed packed. It is decorated to welcome you and the music they play makes you feel as though you're in Mexico. My Peruvian son in law loved the salsa music which reminds him of his childhood. The staff is friendly and helpful. They serve chips and salsa upon sitting. I like my chips a little thinner, but they were still good. We tried the chicharone guacamole which was excellent. The portion they serve is huge. Ordered at the table were salmon tacos which were served with Cole slaw and a creamy sauce. The taco shell itself, was maybe homemade. I'm not sure. The chicken fajitas were very good and tasty as was the steak fajitas. They didn't ask how my son in law wanted his steak, but it was cooked perfectly and he absolutely loved his dish. The rice and beans were so good also. They were big beans and were creamy. The rice was cooked just right and very good. I want to mention that the portion sizes for the entrees as well as the sides are extremely generous. The pink and red sangria were both good. Make sure you order the churros which are drizzled with chocolate and served around a scoop of ice cream and whipped cream. Delicious! I'll go back. read more

Tried this New Mexican restaurant with my wife and 7yr old son. Was hoping for better service and food, unfortunately this place fell short of our expectations. The wait staff was under staffed for a Saturday night, I counted three waiters, which made for quite a wait for the food to arrive. The food also was not very impressive but very pricey. I don't think we will be back for dinner any time soon. read more

Casa De Catrina - Grilled Skirt Steak - Mexican Near Me - Carle Place, New York

See all

Came to check out their Taco Tuesday. $5 tacos were small and all of them had the same toppings and tasted the same. Classic margaritas were pretty weak. Service and ambiance were great though. read more

Overall: I love this new restaurant in Carle Place. I Always love Mexican food. The tortilla soup was great. Very light and was not salty. My friend thoroughly enjoyed the Flutas and couldn't finish the meal. He was recommended the raspberry lemon martini and lit up the moment he took a sip. The service was pleasant. every one was kind and in good spirits. I like it when people look like they are happy to be at work. They offered good recommendations and always said thank you. If you look around the designs and aesthetics are sharp and engaging. They are colorful paintings everywhere. My secret favorite takeaway: they have scented candles in bathroom. It makes all the difference. My one downside: they charge too much for the Raspberry Lemon Martini. It was around $16. Other than that, I highly recommend and would come back. read more

See all

Great service Steak quesadilla as an app Rib eye and chicken fajitas for main course Love the place ... restrooms wow ! read more

See all

I decided to make reservations here for a friends birthday due numerous videos saw on TikTok and Instagram. From the videos everything looked amazing we had to try for ourselves. However once sat I realized just how understaffed the restaurant is. There was 1 server for the whole restaurant 2 runners/busters and just one bar tender. Normally I wouldn't have noticed but we did wait almost 20 minutes for our drinks. The food actually arrived long before drinks did. We had to remind our server about our drinks twice before they actually made it to the table.I decided on a frozen marg which is not a good choice. It was clearly sitting at the bar and had separated. Zero strawberry flavor as well. I decided on 2 stars because my food was good and the decor was also nice. The cons of this restaurant is more than the pros. I don't think I will go back but the tik toks and ig posts are all over hyped. I would not recommend to friends in the future. Pros -seated quickly -friendly staff -good food Cons -service was slow -EXPENSIVE!! (I'm taking 250 dollars((before tip)) for 4 drinks and 4 orders of tacos) -understaffed -bathrooms not cleaned read more

Casa De Catrina - Frozen strawberry marg - Mexican Near Me - Carle Place, New York