Amazing food, all food was fresh and hot, flavorful, great service, waiter was on top of the table all the time, and made sure all of our drinks were filled all the time. Exceptional bartender. read more

Absolutely awful! I see the reviews are good and that's why we tried it. Never again! The pasta was a bunch of mushy garbage along with dog food chicken. Flavorless awful food. read more

See all

I did a family dinner for 15 people and they didn't excellent job. The food was amazing. The service was outstanding and they executed exactly what I wanted perfectly. I would highly recommend going to this restaurant. read more

While Long Island has no lack of Italian eateries, not all of them deserve five stars - or even the time of day. Happy to say that Casa di Fratelli offers a stellar dining experience with delicious food, gracious service and fair pricing. Cocktails were refreshing and potent. Shared a dozen baked clams to start, the tender bivalves topped with bread crumbs resting in a pool of lemony butter, just excellent. My veal marsala with chestnuts entree was so yum. The tender pounded meat was topped with a sauce that tickled my tongue with a symphony of flavors; tangy sundried tomatoes, sweet chestnuts and rich mushroom gravy melded into a divine elixir. Veggies, often a mushy afterthought at other establishments, were well sauteed and crisp. My partner's lobster ravioli was stuffed to the gills with sweet meat and topped with a rich creamy sauce. He polished it off quietly and quickly, always a good sign. Portions were ample, enough for leftovers devoured at lunch the next day. Service was friendly without being overbearing. Plenty of parking in the back. Discount price fixe dinner menu offered Tuesday through Saturday from 4:00 - 6:00. Reservations recommended. Thank you fellow Yelpers, for steering me to yet another winner that I had overlooked before. read more

See all

I had a great time eating here, the pasta was delicious. This Bolognese was more liquidy than others I've tried, but it was just as good. The service was great, we had a reservation set for 8 pm and there were no issues upon arriving. Ambiance: nice for a family dinner / date read more

Casa di Fratelli - Rigatoni Bolognese - Italian Near Me - Westbury, New York

Had dinner here last night for the first time. Everything was great from the service to the food. Servers were all friendly and attentive. Water glasses were always filled. Food was delicious. There were four of us. We shared the beet salad and truffle buratta. Both were delicious (i put some buratta on one piece of the complimentary bruschetta and it was so good). I had Chicken Paillard- had vegetable medley instead of mashed potatoes. The rest of my party had chicken parmigiana with spaghetti, Eggplant Parmigiana, and Pappardelle Siciliana. I only took photos of my food. Everyone loved their meals. Portions were great. Ended the meal with cappuccino and coffee. As we were finishing near closing, they were unfortunately out of the chocolate mousse we ordered. Next time. Will definitely be back!! read more

Casa di Fratelli - Cappuccino - Italian Near Me - Westbury, New York

See all

We went for Mother's Day with my son, his wife, my grandson and my husband and I. The restaurant was beyond crowded and loud. We ordered our food. The prices were higher than usual as we had been there many times before. The service was terrible. I think they were short staffed- the waiters were cleaning the tables. Our dirty plates from appetizers were sitting for a while. Everything that was ordered was watery and tasteless. We had pasta bolognese, fusilli with shrimp And spinach, chicken fingers for my grandson (he refused to eat them- they were tasteless and well done). My son had far disclaimed pasta with lobster and seafood. My dil ordered a salad with salmon - it was drenched in dressing. I'm really disappointed in this place. I won't be coming back. We spent $250 on dinner that was horrible. The waiter never came to see how things were after we were given the main dishes. Not sure he wasn't too busy. I'm not going out on Mother's Day again and I'm certainly not eating here anymore. I'm very disappointed. read more

First time dining here and we were very impressed! The service was very attentive and the food was delicious. They have a very good sunset menu with plenty of options which we tried. We both had the grilled pork chops....huge, tender and very tasty. We will definitely be back. read more

Great Italian restaurant with a fabulous 3 course dinner special that's priced perfect. Service was quickly and attentive. Ambiance was clean, efficient and properly appointed. Had a great time and truly enjoyed the food. Peaked into the kitchen and it was extremely clean! Will be back read more

Went here today with my family as a treat for my birthday! Casa di Fratelli is located conveniently on Old Country Road and when we walked inside we were impressed with their beautiful Christmas decor (the perk of having a December birthday)! We were promptly greeted by our server who gave quality service throughout our visit. We had the hot antipasto for 4 which came with generous portions of fried calamari, baked clams, etc. Me and my sister both had the chicken monte bianco for our entrees and it was so tender you could cut it with a fork! Our mother had branzino and our father had linguine with lobster and we were wowed by the portion he received! Dessert was delicious as well!! We will be back for the next birthday celebration for sure! read more

Can't say enough about the quality and and preparation of the food. Whatever one orders is wonderful, plentiful and fairly priced. Service and ambience are fine and eating at the bar is a fun alternative. read more

I have eaten both lunch and dinner at Casa di Fratelli and enjoyed it both times. The menu has many options and the food is excellent while the prices are more than fair. We had a party there this past weekend. Since they don't open on Saturdays for lunch we had the whole restaurant to ourselves. Everyone enjoyed the food and cozy atmosphere. Brissa, the manager is wonderful to work with and the staff is respectful and kind. If you haven't been there yet I think you'll be happy to find this gem opposite the Samanea mall on Old Country Road! read more

We were three and all loved it. They put out an Italian bread basket with wrapped pats of butter and one bruschetta per person. We split two starters: lobster bisque soup (with chopped shrimp); and mussels "posilipo" in a soupy tomato sauce. Both were delicious and we used the bread to wipe our plates and bowls. My veal "carciofi" was three small thin cutlets topped with lots of artichokes, heirloom tomatoes, garlic, and almond slivers with sides of mashed potato, broccoli, zucchini, carrots, and asparagus, all in a light sauce - wholesome and eye opening, let me devour these popping tastes feeling. My son also had veal cutlets, but in a chestnut sauce with similar results. My wife had the branzino "meuniere" topped with spinach. We were full and couldn't order dessert. Service was courteous and friendly. We had a nicely set table near the bar, but it was relatively quiet and allowed soft spoken conversation. Price was moderate and worth it. I must've passed this restaurant 100 times and never noticed it, but learned about it from two fellow Yelpers - thank you! read more

Casa di Fratelli - Veal Carciofi Veal Carciofi Veal Carciofi - Italian Near Me - Westbury, New York

Since I last came 3 years ago I have tried a ton of dishes! I actually had hosted a luncheon hosted here and It was delicious. Staff was amazing and the food was great. Last night I went back for dinner and did the star lite menu. For 35$ I had an app, entree & desert. We ordered all diff apps (3 ppl). Caprese salad, baked clams & pasta fagiole soup. So delicious! For entrees we had pork chop, chicken franchises @ rigatoni bolegnese. All delicious and the waiter was great! Highly recommend. read more

See all

We had a dinner for 15 people at the restaurant. The ambiance is warm and comfortable. The service was very good. We had a 5 course pre planned meal. Everything was delicious and plentiful. All of my cousins enjoyed the dinner and wanted to book the restaurant for next year's annual cousins dinner that night. read more

Was looking for a new place for dinner and for a friend's birthday celebration. Friend found Casa di Fratelli and made dinner reservations, which I highly recommend doing. Parking lot is in the back of the restaurant. Overall service and staff were good. Fairly large dining room - good for parties. Full bar to watch sports and eat. Started off with complimentary bread. Bruschetta and foccacia were good. Regular bread was on the hard size. Appetizers to share: Grilled octopus was good. Avocado tower was a bit on the bland side though presentation was nice. For entrees, we had farfalle con rabe, duck, chicken francese and lobster ravioli. All were good, however, the lobster ravioli was very thinly filled. That made the dish a bit disappointing. Note: If you pay by credit/debit, there will be an addiional 3.75% surcharge. read more

See all

Service was a little slow , but waiter was fine , Nice sized portions , eveything was delicious and big menu to choose from , Will deff go back read more

Dope service Dope food Dope wait staff And most importantly I felt at home eating at the establishment. That's the most important part. We didn't even finish the sangria. They actually give you beyond your money worth! read more

See all

We gave this place a second chance. We should have gone to the Cheesecake Factory across the street. We waited 25 min for our drinks and the bar was empty! The lobster bisque was very watery. The food was nothing special. Our waiter seemed to be very forgetful. Will not be going back. I wish it was different read more

I recently visited Casa di Fratelli for a baby shower of my friend. There are two entrances for the restaurant from the Main Street and the back lot. The restaurant itself is a cozy feel. The main area of the restaurant was sectioned off for the event. We were dining from a preset menu and there were a good amount of options for the guest. They also were nice to make an adjustment for the main if the guest requested it. The guest next to me saw that the menu listed veal parmigiana, but not chicken and they made it for her. The food was very delicious. I had the garden salad for the appetizer then the salmon for the entree. The wait staff was really nice and serviced everyone well. I would probably come back to see how regular dining service is. read more

Following thru on a recommendation, we have been here a few times personally . Every visit has been a 5 , from food to the service. I just recently hosted a Holiday party for 27 people and it did not disappoint. Brissa was amazing to work with, so accommodating to our needs. I'll definitely be back and they have absolutely gained some new customers from some very happy guests that I had. read more

We came to Casa di Fratelli for Restaurant week and the food was amazing. The place was packed on a Friday might at around 6:30 pm. They have a small parking lot in the back which is very convenient. Our waiter came and introduced himself and said he would come back. Service did take a little longer than usual but that it expected considering how busy they were. The food here is pretty good. The mussels were amongst my favorite. The chicken was also pretty flavorful. We did get some drinks, I wouldn't necessarily come here for drinks and next time I would probably stick to just wine. Overall we had a delicious and filling family dinner. We will def return to Thai establishment. :-) read more

See all

Awesome, and then some....Wow, first visit here was during restaurant weeks and I could not have been any happier with the experience. Located right on Old Country Road across the street from the old Fortunoff's. I found a great spot right in front but not to worry, they also have a parking lot in the back, and a rear entrance to the restaurant The restaurant is a good size and the full windows in the front give it great lighting. Plenty of tables with plenty of room between them. They have a great bar with plenty of standing area just to 'hang out.' Our lovely waitress came over to our table right after we sat down to introduce herself and take a drink order. Moments later, bread was on the table along with an table order of bruschetta. We came during restaurant week so we were given the abbreviated menu from which to order. We started out with an order of Baked Clams and Muscles. I could have made them my dinner. Both just so good. My wife ordered Pork Chop and I had the Sole Fancaise. Both dishes were OUTSTANDING. I mean over the top great! My wife's pork chop was cooked perfectly and was tender and tasty with a rich marsalla sauce. My sole francaise was amazing from the size of the piece of fish to the freshness and overall cooking. When I checked with the owner he explained that he does not alter the portion size during restaurant. He wants people to get the full experience, not a reduced one. What a great philosophy and reason why we have been back twice since than and brought a group of 18 people too. Great job here and a fun family dining experience. KUDOs to the team a Casa di Fratelli read more

See all

Pulling up to this place the exterior looks unassuming. Once you walk in, it's the total opposite. I was happily surprised with the vibe. On this Friday evening in October 2021, the dimly lit bar area was already filled to capacity. The dining room, with its contemporary decor, had tables filled with happy, chatty diners. Towards the back of the dining room, our team of smiling, co-workers congregated and milled around the fairly spacious 18 person table setup. This restaurant is the type that if one table is celebrating a birthday or special occasion all patrons are a part of that celebration. For instance, it seemed the entire restaurant chimed in for some unknown diners 'Happy Birthday to you...' Plus, at our table the Guest of Honor had to stand up and take a subtle bow as all the diners cheered on this evenings milestone. Pretty cool. Food was fair. Everyone seemed to enjoy their massive entrees. Our one waiter, plus one server, handled our crowd effortlessly. No glass went unfilled, plates served and cleared without any intrusion. It was obvious both waiter and server were pros. End result. Fair food, good service, nice vibes. We'll be back. TIP: Located opposite The Cheesecake Factory read more

See all

Casa di Fratelli brings the aesthetics of a run of the mill fine dining establishment. White table cloths, classical pictures, multiple forks for your different meals, yet it doesn't fail to deliver from a bang for buck approach. The portion sizes are enormous for the entrees (except for the penne ala vodka) and you really can't go wrong here. The main dock on its Potential five star review is the time it takes to get your food (it's on the slower side...!). And partially the quality of execution on a couple of items that was served. Let's dive deep into what we had! Appetisers: 1) avocado tower - 3/5 - no wow factor here, tastes as it looks, could use a bit more Acidity and flavour 2) Grilled Octopus - 4/5 - grilled well and spot on, the pieces are scattered throughout and a bit inconsistent though 3) baked clams - 4/5 - your classics stuffed baked clams 4) lobster bisque - 4.5/5 - definitely get this! You get small bits of shrimp and it can be considered on the salty side, but it pairs extremely well with bread that they provide you 5) Calamari - 4/5 - standard, can't go wrong here Entrées: 1) lobster linguine - 4.5/5 - super large portion, you get half a lobster, a lot of mussels and other bits 2) Sole Francesce - 4.5/5 - cooked spot on and to perfection, the only dock is on the lemon, adding it kills the dish with acid, lemon squeezer beware!! 3) braised beef - 4.5/5 - stewed beef left on bone, falls off nicely! It could use a bit more seasoning, otherwise it is spot on too 4) penne aka vodka - 3/5 the pasta tastes as it looks, the portion is on the smaller side, might not recommend this for the growing one In summary, it's a place worth eating at and if you have extra time to spare! read more

Casa di Fratelli - Lobster Linguine - Italian Near Me - Westbury, New York

See all

I have been to this restaurant once before and I thought the food was average. Well I was wrong. The food was below average. After an afternoon of Black Friday shopping. I decided to give this restaurant another try. The restaurant's interior was clean and modern. Nothing extraordinary. A TV showing a basketball game was on over an empty bar. My gal pal ordered the lobster bisque. It was the special soup of the day. I saw on the special menu that it was top with shrimp. I said why is the lobster bisque topped with shrimp. My fried calamari arrived hot and fresh but had way too many tentacles. About ten minutes later the lobster bisque arrived. The soup was very hot but it was lacking in taste. The soup did not have any seafood taste. The soup had a watery texture not like a bisque. The one shrimp was the only seafood flavor I tasted. Next my gal pal ordered the veal chestnut. Veal scaloppine with mushrooms and chestnuts. The veal was pounded so thin that it was like a White Castle hamburger. I have never seen veal pounded so thin. The veal was smothered in mushrooms. She couldn't find the veal under the pile of sauce and mushrooms. I ordered another special Pork Chop Pistachio. Supposed to be encrusted with pistachios. It had pistachios and a light cranberry sauce. The pork chop was double cut. The meat was dry. The cherry brandy sauce lacked flavor. Then my gal pal had so much mushrooms on her plate she asked the waiter to wrap it up. She wanted to toss some pasta with the mushrooms for lunch the next day. After I paid the bill I asked the waiter where my leftover mushrooms were. He ran back to the kitchen to get it. Shaking my head. I would have been better off eating at the Chessecake Factory across the street. read more

This is my 3rd time back to Casa di Fratelli for Valentines Dinner which didn't disappoint! I visited on 02/14/2023 for dinner & the service, ambience, decor & obviously the food keeps me coming back! Brava Casa Di Fratelli! I'm upping my star count & adding new pics read more

See all

My wife visited this restaurant for the 1st time and we were both pleasantly surprised! The food and service was great! We noth had chicken dishes that were outstanding. The food comes out piping hot and was delicious! It can get a bit noisy so come a bit early! Jack n Wanda read more

There were 6 of us at our table and another unrelated group of six at another table and one waiter. We ordered from the luncheon menu which included an appetizer, entree and dessert. The appetizers and entrees were received in a timely manner and the food was excellent. When it came time to order dessert, three ordered special coffees, one ordered nothing and my husband and I ordered coffee and dessert. The three special coffees arrived and then our waiter disappeared. About 20 minutes later we caught just eye and asked about our desserts and coffees and he looked at us bewildered. So my husband said to forget it and just bring the check. I can't imagine what would happen if there were more than two tables occupied! It wasn't like they were super busy and the luncheon Menu was small - just a choice if 4 appetizers and four entrees and a couple of desserts!. How hard is it to write down 5 dessert/coffee orders? Was really disappointed. read more

I live in the neighborhood and this is was my first visit to this establishment. The decor is nice but not sure what it poked like before covid. The staff was very welcome and nice. We were seated immediately on a Saturday afternoon for lunch. They brought bread to the table and I love a nice piece of bread lol. The basket was nice and the bread with crispy on the outside and soft delicious inside. My husband had the shrimp oreganata and I had a salad. The shrimp was cooked well and the flavors were on point. He enjoyed his dish. I had a nice fresh salad with cheese and cranberries, it was a balanced salad. A pleasant experience we plan are coming back for dinner in the near future read more

Casa di Fratelli - Italian Near Me - Westbury, New York

Normally a decent restaurant in which we have been going for years, today on Mother's Day they dropped the ball. We were there almost 2 1/2 hours and after initially ordering drinks, our food just never came. The restaurant didn't seem overly packed so I'm not sure why. After an hour we had to ask where our food was, and again after an hour and a half. No one seemed to have any idea when we would get it. When it finally arrived, 2 people out of 7 enjoyed their meals. The salmon was so dry I had to drink water to swallow it an it had almost no flavor, the shrimp scampi had a very watered down sauce, and the halibut was so salty it went uneaten . We waited so long that an early person in our party left to sit in the car while the rest of us finished. We asked for the bill while we were still eating to ensure that wouldn't be another line wait, but we were wrong. They asked us if we'd like dessert and we told them not after 2 1/2 hours. They did say it was on the house but at that point we just wanted to leave and refused. My mother in law was so excited to try this restaurant and I felt safe because we had ate there for years. I was totally embarrassed. Bill was high, night was a wash out, and no one seemed you enjoy it. Mother's Day ruined read more

Great little spot with a very unassuming exterior - we stopped in here for dinner one night during a business trip after making a reservation a few hours prior. We were seated promptly and attended to quickly. They brought out 3 different kinds of bread, which were amazing. We started with the grilled octopus - it was grilled perfectly, but a little more charred than I would usually go for. The red sangria was just alright as it was definitely too far on the sweet side for me. I still give 5 stars because I really think those are just personal preference and may be exactly to someone else's liking. For my entree, I ordered the pistachio and cranberry pork chop off the special menu - outstanding. I'm definitely hoping to duplicate it at home, but I'm not sure I'll be able to. They served it with some mashed potatoes that had a light crust on them, and a pile of steamed veggies. I wish they would have included a fresh vegetable like asparagus with it, but I certainly wasn't complaining. When we finished we noticed that staff was cleaning up, so they were evidently closed but didn't say anything to us as we finished our meal with a few other tables. As we were leaving, we got about half way down the block on the way back to our hotel when our waitress came running up to us to deliver my colleague's to-go box that he had left on the table. This was so above and beyond, it really shows how much they care about their customers. If I'm ever back in the area, this will be a must-visit. read more

Casa di Fratelli - Pistachio and cranberry pork chop - Italian Near Me - Westbury, New York

Very lovely staff anxious to please. Igreat quality for the money early menu up until 6 PM. Many many choices. Nice open dining room and good location. read more

Really a 3.5 experience, but can't do half stars on Yelp, and I don't feel it was worth rounding up. Came here on New Year's Eve with a friend. We had an early dinner reservation, and were seated promptly. When we sat down we were given a bread basket, butter and some bruschetta. The bread basket was pretty basic. The bruschetta was good. They were only serving off the New Year's Eve me h they had put together. So we weren't able to get things that we wanted off the regular menu that we looked at before arriving. Prices were also higher on the holiday menu, but that's expected. To drink I had a Peroni and my friend had Zinfandel. They didn't have a lot of (good) beers to chose from at all. No drink menu either for speciality cocktails or drinks. For an appetizer we shared baked clams. Although small, they were good. The breadcrumbs were nice and a nice crunch. I did find it odd that the sauce the clams were sitting in was overpowering with lemon. Not the type of sauce I'm used to when getting baked clams. For my entree, I forgot the name of it, but it was tasty. It was seared chicken with mozzarella and shrimp on a bead of spinach. The sauce was a white wine sauce. It came with a scoop of mashed potatoes. The mashed potatoes seemed out of place. I have never gotten mashed potatoes at an Italian restaurant before. I am not a fan of them at all, so I can't talk about the flavor. My friend ordered chicken martini. I never thought I'd say chicken and martini in the same sentence. She said it was good and tender. I couldn't even tell you what it was though. It came with veggies and mashed potatoes. For dessert she ordered creme brûlée. They didn't "fire" it at the table and it didn't crack when she took the first bite. I ordered a cannoli. I was expecting a normal sized cannoli, considering the $8 price tag. What came out was two little and thin cannolis. Very overpriced for what was served. Other than the dessert, the rest of the meal was delicious and worth the money. Service was good as well. read more

See all

I would like to begin by stating that the food and service was very good. I have been to this restaurant about 5 times. my displeasure was the manager. I had originally made reservations for 6 people and a few days later I wanted to add 2 family members. ( 10 days before the date reserved) The woman manager told me they couldn't accommodate us. A busy day. I insisted on adding to reservation and she relented but actually scolded me. We all enjoyed our meal ( very slow service) Atleast an hour wait before getting our meal. Our bill was approx $600. As soon as our desert was delivered and bill paid the female manager told us we had to leave. People were waiting for our table. I was astounded. there were other empty tables. she was so rude and left such a horrible feeling in all of us. sorry to say , we will never go there again. The owner Gio should know that his representative is so rude and disrespectful. read more

Came in to participate in restaurant week last minute with my sister after work. We made a 7:30pm -last possible reservation since they close at 8:30pm. We were greeted and seated in less than a minute. The waitress was quick and to the point which I appreciated. We ordered from prix fix menu $42 for an appetizer, Main course and dessert. See images for the food and menu. We ordered one drink each. Overall the food was good quality, large portion, decent seasoning and flavor. Would recommend for dinner. Cute interior. Little bar towards the back end was a nice touch if you wanted to watch the game and have a quick bite. read more

See all

Excellent food many choices, most have been excellent, have enjoyed going here for a number occasions but it can become very loud at times. Service has always been very good. Have a parking lot behind the restaurant. read more

Great restaurant- good food, nice staff and huge portions! I had the lobster ravioli, a special that week, and it was amazing. The lobster flavor came out so well in the sauce, as well. My son had the chicken Parmesan and the portion was humongous, he could've eaten it for two more meals! The marinara on the chicken Parmesan was also really good, and had a nice "homemade" feel to it. They also give out a unique bruschetta with focaccia bread which was a great start to our meal. There menu is huge, so there's something for everyone. Free Parking available at the back too! read more

Casa di Fratelli - Lobster ravioli - Italian Near Me - Westbury, New York

First time here at Fratelli's restaurant. What a nice experience. Victor our waiter was excellent as he came over to greet us and take our order. He brought us wine to start. For appetizers, we ordered the fried calamari (rings only) which were delicious, lightly fried and tender, served with a side of marinara. We also ordered the avocado crab salad, which was excellent. For dinner, I had my usual...veal parm. The portion was huge and delicious, I ate half! We also ordered the Veal sorrentino and 2 chicken dishes, milanese and a special item, montebianco. All was delicious. Te restaurant is a nice size and very pleasant. read more

See all

I went here with 2 other people on Saturday night. The restaurant is nice inside, inviting. We were seated, the waiter came and took our drink orders and then we were immediately served with bruschetta, pizza bread and Italian bread. The bruschetta was absolutely delicious. I loved all the fresh, shredded basil in the dish. The pizza bread was delicious as well. Two of us ordered the zuppa di pesce. It comes with a very generous size lobster tail, which I was certainly surprised. It was cooked perfect. There were, I think, 3 large, butterfly shrimp, clams, mussels, and calamari. All was perfectly cooked; however, I didn't care for the mussels as they had a gamey taste. My husband loved them! He thought the calamari was rubbery; I thought it was perfectly cooked. We both agree the shrimp, clams and pasta was delicious. The sauce was also very, very good. We just love the fresh basil spread throughout the whole dish. My daughter ordered the risotto funghi, which had mushrooms and was in a cognac sauce with a bit of truffle oil. The rice was creamy and perfectly cook, as was the mushroom. It was absolutely delicious. For dessert, my daughter and I shared the creme brulee, which was perfect! It was creamy with a nice, hard, crispy crust. Absolutely want this dessert again! My husband ordered the tortoni and it brought back memories of the tortonis we had many years ago at the Wheatly Hills Tavern. So good! We can't wait to go back here. Their menu goes on and on and we want to try everything. We definitely recommend this restaurant. read more