TERRIBLE experience, and not just for us. Bar was nearly empty when we arrived (fewer than 10 patrons), had the World Cup game on mute despite advertising it on the door, and refused to turn up the volume when asked. A patron next to us asked just before we did and got refused too -- then was abruptly cut off and denied service shortly after talking to us about their own bad experience there. ANOTHER patron, came in after we did, was also treated rudely and refused service. My own issue: ordered a lemon drop with tequila (not vodka.. it makes me sick). First one was fine. After a bartender shift change, the new bartender -- who was actually the shift lead -- made my second one, and it was clearly off; I suspected vodka was used. I asked for it to be fixed, was refused.. So I sent it back, and asked for it off the bill. Paid my tab in full, then noticed at tip time the charge was still there. Server said the bartender wouldn't remove it. When I spoke to him directly, he blamed me for ordering something "nobody knows what it is," and when I said I'd dispute it with my card instead, he attempted to snatch my card off the table. I refused to engage further with him, asked for someone else (refused AGAIN) so I left.. I will be disputing the charge with Amex since he was the only one with register access. Multiple tables treated poorly in one night. SKIP THIS PLACE!! Smug and disrespectful bartender pictured.. read more

Castlebay Irish Pub - Smug and disrespectful bartender.. - Irish Pub Near Me - Annapolis, Maryland

See all

Came in wanting a delicious, cold beer? And these a-holes sneezed in my drink?! Never coming back, unless I'm forced to. At. F***ing. Gunpoint. read more

Castlebay Irish Pub - Irish Pub Near Me - Annapolis, Maryland

Worst customer service on the planet. We came because the advertised the World Cup game. The waiter said they would put it on but the music would stay on. Everyone coming in wanted the volume on. We decided to leave but expressed our concern for advertising the game and not turning volume on. Waiter said the owner was set in his way. Decided to leave and they turned volume on because more people came in. Then decided to stay at waiter said. Bartender cut us off. We had one drink only but he didn't like our attitude. What a jack ass move. Stay away from this stinky weird ass place. I think if we had gotten another drink they would have sneezed or spit in it like other patrons have said in reviews! read more

Annapolis houses the Naval Academy, but a visit to Annapolis would not be complete without a stop to Castlebay Irish Pub. Visited with a bunch of guys after touring the Naval Academy campus...a short walk from the campus, it's a great Irish pub with a great ambiance and selection of Irish beer on tap (Guinness, Harp, Smithwick, Kilkenny) as well as the usual American brand. In addition, it houses a great selection of whiskeys: Irish (Bushmills, Jamesons, Red Breast, etc. - the different varieties), bourbons (to include Pappy's, Blanton), scotch (MacAllans), etc. The dining experience pairs well with the beer and whiskeys. The meat for the reuben sandwich and traditional corned beef are selected and prepared in a traditional manner making it delicious. If you are lucky, you will meet the owner of the establishment, who will regale you with stories about past Academy graduates who would return to the pub after graduation or even about his playing in a rock & roll band. Great food, beer, whiskey, atmosphere, and if lucky, great stories and an experience. When visiting the Naval Academy, take a yonder down the street, you won't regret the visit. read more

See all

Great local Irish pub that made us feel welcomed. Nikki was our bartender and treated us like we were friends. The burger was delicious! Caramelized onions made just right by Kenny the cook! Thank you for the exceptional experience!! See you next time read more

Castlebay Irish Pub - Nikki serving up Irish coffee shots! - Irish Pub Near Me - Annapolis, Maryland

See all

The staff were super friendly to us. The food was great. We really enjoyed the fish and chips. Loved the music too. We'll be back for sure

DO NOT GO HERE! I just went here for lunch like an hour or so ago with my boyfriend. Service was good, but food was terrible. My boyfriend got the crab Mac and cheese and it did not look appetizing. They melted sliced cheese on it. Noodles were so orange but the sauce was white and the crab had no seasoning. I had beer battered chicken tenders and fries and the beer was so intense. Right after, my boyfriend did not feel too good. I was fine for a bit, then my stomach started not feeling well. I ended up throwing it all up. Pretty sure we got some sort of food poisoning. So please don't go here. read more

The bartender with the long beard is in the wrong business! Refused to serve me because I made a comment that he was not very friendly! Went in for an after dinner coffee. Ended up at Galway Bay across the street and got a better coffee drink with VERY FRIENDLY BARTENDERS!! read more

service closes over an hour before the listed hours! don't walk all the way here for nothing, even on a saturday.

Great Irish Whiskey selection and properly poured Guinness. Lars is an excellent Bar man

Ordered the fish and chips. In an area of fresh fish, this dish was underwhelming. The 'chips' were wedge potatoes which were each a quarter of a russet potato so felt more like eating a baked potato than fries. read more

See all

Order was a baked brie, French onion soup and beef stew. Also a black and tan. The beer was perfectly poured and as expected. The baked brie was about 1/4 wheel served with bread, honey and apples. It was warmed and tasted pretty good. French onion soup was very generic buy not bad. You're probably wondering why this got a 2 star.... the beef stew was extremely lacking. Literally, 5 small pieces of beef, 5 tiny potatoes, 1 tiny carrot and 1 tiny piece of celery in a thin gravy. It was supposed to be (and was priced as) a meal, but it scored about 10% as a soup. I wouldn't have served this to my mother-in-law. read more

See all

Popped in with colleagues after bar hopping. Great place to hangout and socialize. Very spacious. The bartenders and servers kept the drinks coming. read more

It was ight good ambiance and pretty lowkey but the food was pretty meh. Nothing really special to write home about and I couldn't tell why the Irish Burger was Irish read more

Castlebay Irish Pub - Irish Burger - Irish Pub Near Me - Annapolis, Maryland

Birdie is the best bartender in annapolis, what a great guy. Didn't have food here just drinks before going out on the town for food. Good decently priced drinks for the area. Would def revisit. read more

HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE!!! Very poor service, bartender quite rude! Waitress unable to fill simple order of water and crab soup! Sat here for 30 minutes waiting the order while others arriving after us were served. Being totally serious! Would not recommend! read more

We were here visiting my son for his induction to the Naval Academy and we had the most amazing time with these bartenders! So polite and professional and FUN! Cheers to Annapolis! read more

Castlebay Irish Pub - Irish Pub Near Me - Annapolis, Maryland

The bartender with the long gray beard was rude, rude and rude! We ordered a first round and one Sammy to share. He NEVER checked in/back. He never asked if we wanted another drink or if we needed anything. He was the worst and we showed him what we thought by leaving a poor tip! We love to tip having been servers in our past lives --but not here. And the food was just very meh! read more

Horrible service. Rude bartender. Food was cold and the staff seemed to be annoyed we were there

I visited Annapolis for the first time last Saturday to celebrate Veterans Day and wandered around until I because thirsty for a cold pint of something...I discovered Castlebay Irish Pub after peeking into at least 4 other Irish Pubs and not finding exactly the atmosphere I was seeking. Castlebay reminded me of pubs in Ireland, a great atmosphere for families and solo drinkers alike. The ciders and beers were about 2$ more than they should have been ($6-7 each) so that was disappointing although manageable. I would have stayed for lunch however was not offered a menu, but that was fine. I asked the bartender for some seafood suggestions and he told me of a few places in the area where I could get a nice bite to eat. (I followed his advice and was thrilled with my lunch selection). Aside from one douche bag, everyone there seemed really nice and cool. I would go back in a heartbeat if I visit Annapolis again. read more

Been here for drinks a few times, but came in to eat around 6 on a Saturday evening. It wasn't particularly busy but service took far too long. Ordered calamari which was chewy and bland, and a Irish Rubin that they apparently forgot to put corned beef on. I kid you not there were 3 small chunks on the whole sandwich and about half a pound of sourkrout. It was an $18 sandwich for goodness sake, the least you can do is give me a little bit of corned beef. If I could rate this dining experience 0/5 I would. Won't be coming back. read more

Great vibe in a old school Irish bar ! Lots of decor stained glass windows ect. Stopped only for one round of brews but I enjoyed it. If I'm in Annapolis again I would gladly come back for some more brews. read more

Super chill dive bar! Was hanging out with a friend and some of his colleagues a few days ago as they were wrapping up their last few days in Annapolis! I really have only been to Annapolis maybe two times in my entire life and I'm a Marylander (shame I know!). So when I was invited to come hang out, I was thinking, what's there to do in Annapolis? Now I know. On a Thursday night, this place was packed and it was apparently karaoke night. I wasn't hungry so I can't speak on the food, but the drinks were nice and strong! Everyone seemed to have a good time : ) read more

Castlebay does an excellent job showing off the type of mediocre restaurants you will find in Annapolis. There are a number of them so you really need to read the reviews carefully. The high rated reviews for food for this place are either friends of the owner or intoxicated reviewers. But aside from the food, that is if you are just drinking, the place gets a higher rating. Very good bartenders and occasionally some outstanding live music. It is in the located towards middle of Main Street so you are right in the middle of all the action. I suggest drinks before or after you find better food.n read more

There is an emergency order extending licenses that have expired during Covid to be VALID FOR GOVERNMENT ID through the 30 days after the emergency order ends. Emergency order isn't ended yet. I got told my license- normally expired on 9/30 but covered by the emergency order right now valid for driving and identification- wasn't good for ID by their company policy. I'm 27. Not even remotely fake ID. Thanks for making me not want to dine out and help a small business during a hard time. I have my MVA appointment in November since everyone is trying to get it renewed right now. I'm sure I'll never return here read more

An empty Irish Pub.....can you imagine on a Saturday afternoon? Well, after eating our weight in crabs at Cantler's, finding a parking spot in downtown Annapolis and making the trek up Main Street we were ready for a cool brew. Castlebay is a nice spot to sit, check in on the first official day of college football and banter about with the Bartender about the superiority of our favorite pro teams...of course my Pat's win! The bartenders were the best of the day, and as we winded our way up and around the streets and bars of Annapolis on Saturday.....part of me wished we had just stayed put at Castlebay! read more

Castlebay Irish Pub - Irish Pub Near Me - Annapolis, Maryland

Nice irish pub we definitely enjoyed the crowd last night. You walk in and it screams Irish Pub, wood decor, booths, tall bar tables, there's a seat in the window that looks like it would be real fun to sit int and you can also sit outside. We went for the libations rather than a meal and I was taken care of promptly, the barkeeps did a wonderful job of taking care of everyone and the waitresses found a way though the maze of people to still wait on their tables. I understand the food is pretty good here and we will definitely be back to eat, the service was good, and the crowd was good, not too young on a Friday night. I was paying $6.00 for a captain (rum) and coke. I even spilled a whole glass full of the stuff all over the bar, they replaced it so quick I barely noticed it missing. OH and it is of note, the bathrooms were pretty clean, I was impressed. read more

Castlebay is A GO TO. My friends and I always go here for cheap drinks. The first time we sat down, we could not believe the price of the drinks. The service is great. I wouldn't go for party vibes or a crazy, exciting dinner. The place is well suited to grab a couple drinks with friends and hang out. I haven't tried the food, but if it's as good of value as the drinks, I'd say go for it. read more

Ok so I've had bad experiences with run down dives on the coast trying to rip off the hungry desperate tourists. I was trying to avoid putting a damper on our day trip like that and Castle Bay did not disappoint. Great beers on tap, prices were not bad for the area, and the food was fresh-tastic. My favorite thing about the pub was the kooky decor. I'm a big fan of tacky and fun and this is as good as it gets. Think "Irish Adams Family". See my pics for details. I had the Crab Cake Sandwich and my partner-in-dine had a burger. The fries were better than the coleslaw but both were tasty in their own way. My sandwich beat the heck out of the burger too! Although the waitress seemed distracted, tired and bored; she did her job well. She could not answer a few questions about the food but that's all good....must be new or something *shrug*. It was a nice little lunch in a nice little pub in a nice little coastal town. Definitely will come again when I'm in the area. read more

See all

I eat here after a soccer game and to watch a soccer game. The food was good and well priced. We were able to get the discount that is offered before the Red Skins game started. Waiter was a douche but the game and the good was good. I had the Guinness burger, and the loaded fries. They also have a good selection of wings. read more

Castlebay Irish Pub - Wings, Guinness Burger, Loaded Fries - Irish Pub Near Me - Annapolis, Maryland

My cousins took us here for lunch. Im not a big fan of pub food but the menu was traditional Irish food and Im always a fan of ethnic eats! Typical pub, not the cleanest, with nice atmosphere. We sat right next to the window which was nice for me as a tourist. We had the baked brie to start and it was delicious. My cousins husband had bangers and mash, I had an irish ruben and loved it! My cousin had a chicken sandwich and my mom had the fish and chips (she said it was tasteless) Overall I was happy with the meal but yet again, I was jealous we didn't get to try one of the many other places on the strip for lunch. read more

See all

Good food, excellent service and good price. Ate outside and it was very pleasant. Recommend you give it a try.

I consider myself an Irish pub expert, and have been coming to this great pub for several years, and always have enjoyed the exemplary service, excellent Irish food, and the best Guinness in town. I recently held a Happy hour at the pub for my Naval Academy Company at our Class Reunion , and everyone had a blast. Highly recommended! read more

This place has the best atmosphere; it's low key and not over done. It seems like everything hanging up has a story and the owner is super friendly. If you get a chance to try their Irish coffee, it is the best you'll ever have with hand whipped whipped cream. The whisky to coffee ratio is on point. If you love Irish pubs, the has got to be on your top visits in MD read more

Castlebay Irish Pub - A soldier brought this back from Afghanistan and donated it to the bar- how cool is that?! - Irish Pub Near Me - Annapolis, Maryland

My boyfriend and I went to this place for the first time. Wonderful service, food, and drinks. The owner was very helpful and always checked on our table. Especially during the pandemic, he was very attentive, as well as the server. Great place if you want to relax and enjoy a good irish beer. Awesome ambience. See for yourself, I guarantee you'll love it! read more

The grilled chicken sandwich tasted subpar at best: the Chicken was tasteless, the sandwich came with a plain supermarket bun, and the toppings were very basic. Not worth 11$. The management really needs to consider changing this option. However: We also got the grilled shrimp appetizer that was great and the ruben sandwich which was also good. read more

Went here for happy hour and it was amazing! Had the best waitress named Anna!!! Drinks were a great price for happy hour. Got the Guinness burger which was amazing! Fun atmosphere, I believe it was the owner doing live music. Playing Irish songs in an Irish pub is probably one of the most fun thing to sit and enjoy. We really enjoyed it! Did go back around midnight though for drinks on a Saturday night and they didn't have any live music and the bartender was so unbelievably rude and cynical. Wish it could of been a great experience all around. read more

Castlebay Irish Pub - Guinness burger was so delicious! - Irish Pub Near Me - Annapolis, Maryland

Found this place using google maps on a phone. Definitely a cool pub. They make a mean all-irish black and tan with Guinness and Smithwick's. They also brew their own 3-nuns ale, which is a delightful nitrogen-pulled cream ale with hints of carmel and strawberry. Check it out the next time you're in Annapolis. The fish and chips was amazing despite being served with a plastic foodservice cup of tarter sauce. read more

Food was ok. Wings were not so good. The wings tasted more like fried chicken than chicken wings. The curry fries had too much cloves or cumin spice. Didn't taste right. The burger sliders were ok. The beers were great. The restaurant smells like a pub, so if its pub atmosphere you're looking for, you will get it here. read more

This place is alright, I am on the verge of giving it two stars except I realize there is little else like it in the area. The beers are priced like they are in Boston (~$5-6) and whatever you do, don't order the alfredo with chicken and broccoli. Literally a big pool of oil made the dish really impossible to eat and it was a whopping $14. It wasn't even anything that inventive. I'd go for the non-pasta dishes. My friend got the chicken pot pie and that looked quite good. Our waitress was also very nice, personal and attentive, albeit a little too apologetic for everything! read more