Catania&#x27;s Pizza

70

557

4411

2 months ago

7/15/26- wow as said before the best you can have . So so good . In the same family. I came a long way to get these. read more

Catania's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Catania's Pizza - 1- cheese 1- meat - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Catania's Pizza - Slice double cut - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

linda s.

3

23

0

11 days ago

Great pizza once again. The best pizza in Yonkers! Lots of cheese & lots of pepperoni! Fast, friendly service.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Betsy T.

72

137

318

6 months ago

This was my first time trying Catania's- my aunt suggested it and it did not disappoint! We ordered a pizza that was half meat lovers/half eggplant and it was so good! I also ordered a full Sicilian Marinara pizza but only received a single slice- we ordered through Uber Eats and they made it right with zero issue! The calzones are unique and so good! The dough was almost flaky like a pastry and the fillings were excellent! I also would have ordered more of them if I had realized how good and how small they were! read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Eugenio L.

Elite 24

381

297

1222

7 months ago

What can I say more about this pizzeria institution in these parts of Yonkers that hasn't been said before..... good classic freshly prepared deliciously scrumptious Italian pizzeria and everything is simply unabashedly GOOD! I'd like to add that it's been in business serving fresh pies since 1976! See below for my official critique. Service: good Ambiance: homely Calzones: Supremely Heavenly!! Large Plan pie 18$ for 8 slices! I forgot the prices of the veal and peppers, meatball and ricotta calzones because I was trapped in the heavenly glow of their baked goodness! I just looked at the menu and these calzones are 4 frogs a piece. If your ever in these parts of Yonkers do yourself a flavor.... Forget the other Pizzerias, and grab the calzone, you won't regret it. I guarantee it. Buon Appetito, good people of the Earth. read more

Catania's Pizza - Inside from the island in the middle of the pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Catania's Pizza - Front counter - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Catania's Pizza - Da Pizza Pie --oooooooooooooh! Fighetaboutit! - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Catania's Pizza - Delicious veal & peppers Catania's calzone - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Helpful 8

Thanks 4

Love this 8

Oh no 0

D V.

0

8

0

1 month ago

Take out - The pizza is always delicious. Fresh ingredients, seasoned just right and always ready when promised read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dan L.

0

8

7

3 months ago

Place is cool. Feels like an old school pizza shop. Guy behind the counter was super friendly. Great service. Pizza wasnt great tho. 4.3/10 slices. read more

Catania's Pizza - bbq slice and buffalo slice - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dori D.

2

78

41

9 months ago

I spent the day in Yonkers my son in law. This place was a place that he goes to often. The place was nice. The service was excellent. I really enjoyed the thin crust pizza. Very good. I can't wait until I get a chance to go back, give it a shot. You'll enjoy it like I did.. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 2

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Sadri B.

5000

5041

500

7 months ago

A very good pizza joint in yonkers on central Ave that serves plentyl types of pizza toppings and more ..I was looking at the menu which is long ,but wings , salads , calzones , rolls , pasta dishes and entrees all look good and I bet taste good but before I grab a seat in the corner I will go old school and order 2 cheese slices and a bottle of diet Coke as I always do or mostly what I always do .Good tasty pizza and my boys want a large pie and wings which they have to wait for cause I want to enjoy my pizza at a snails pace . 4.5 stars on my yelp meter. read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Danny Z.

0

57

0

4 months ago

Catania's pizza has been around for a very long time. It's a classic spot in Yonkers and it's a great NY joint! By far one of the best spots when it comes to parking...they've got plenty available. As far as the food's concerned...they make a great pie! Like I've said in other reviews...every pizza joint has their own specialty, and Catania's is no different. Generally I like to go for their Sicilian Marinara Pie that is loaded with fresh garlic! If you love garlic and you love pizza...then you'll LOVE this! They also offer another signature piece...their meatball calzone. They are awesome! Every time I order from here...those are the 2 choices I get. You really can't go wrong. Now...there's a couple of things that I think are worth mentioning. Their pizza and food in general is definitely on the oily/greasy side. They're definitely heavy handed with the oil. They need to ease up. The other thing is the delivery service. The service at the counter is always friendly...but the delivery drivers I noticed are definitely on the impatient side. I don't like that. And...I gotta tip them on top of it?! The hell with that. So I usually just order for pick up. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Colette H.

383

1476

14619

3 years ago

I was looking for a snack and was close to this place; I looked up Catania's on Yelp. It looked like they had good pizza and reviews, so I stopped by. There was a short line. People were ordering to go and a few people were sitting in the booths there. It seemed like a busy place. There were 3 people behind the counter who were cooking and running around the shop. I ordered a Sicilian and a vegetable slice. The slices were pretty large; these will last me the next few days. Each slice was two portions and bigger than the average slice. I grabbed two slices to go and tried them. They were fresh and hot. Their slices and pies go quickly. I'd recommend ordering ahead. There were also an array of calzones and other options available at the counter. I'm in the area frequently, and I'd definitely stop back again to try more of their options. read more

Catania's Pizza - a slice of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Catania's Pizza - a man standing in front of a pizza counter - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Catania's Pizza - a slice of pizza with broccoli and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 1

Howard F.

0

11

0

8 months ago

Always great! Service excellent! Veggie slice the best!! Music right on. Calzones always great!

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Toni M.

0

1

0

10 months ago

The best calzone ever! The service was quick and the staff is very friendly. My first order was a pickup but I wouldn't mind eating there as well. Small but very welcoming and clean. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jean O.

115

134

375

3 years ago

Typical pizza place with a few tables if you opt to eat in. Every time I come home, I always try to make it here for a slice of the salad pizza. Nobody makes this pizza as delicious as Catania. My online order was quick took only 20 mins and my order was ready to be picked up. read more

Catania's Pizza - Salad pizza - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Brandon C.

6

33

64

2 years ago

The pizzeria is really nice and well kept. There is plenty of seating and everything is well lit. The food is amazing! The pizza tastes amazing and the meatball calzones are delicious! The owner Chris is awesome. He is very quick with service and extremely kind. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jim G.

61

490

580

4 years ago

So good. Not a place you would necessarily notice driving up Central Avenue, but this pizzeria is a gem. The mini-calzones are amazing. The place does offer a small number of seats for in-house dining, but the majority of the business is take-out. On a Friday night at 6pm this joint is hopping, people are flying in and out picking up their orders. Some like it so much they just sit and eat a slice in their cars. They have a garden salad slice that is enormous. The slice has garlic, mushrooms, spinach and sliced tomatoes. Almost an inch thick this slice will guarantee that you have gotten a full serving of veggies in your diet. I really enjoyed the crust. They prefer cash, but will take credit cards. I have Catania's on my top ten list of places to eat whenever in the Yonkers/Westchester area. Plenty of parking, it is located next to the Auto Zone. Buon appetito! read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 1

Love this 3

Oh no 1

Elise M.

11

206

340

6 years ago

Got the lasagne pizza. So good!!! Just the right amount of cheesy and doughey goodness that I love. read more

Catania's Pizza - Lasagna Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Fran L.

134

112

3

5 years ago

In this world how often do you find someone who will go that extra mile for another person. Haven't been to Catania's in a while and yet I was greeted with a handsome smile and when I explained what kind of Sicilian pizza I needed not only was it made but it was delicious. Finally s Sicilian I can eat at least twice a week and a special act of kindness I truly appreciate. Thank you so much and everyone this reviewer for Just reviews highly recommends Catania for five star pizza. Fran Lewis just reviews/ MJ network blog talk radio read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Eddy M.

0

104

0

2 years ago

This place has been around for years been going since I was a kid,old school pizza that is good.

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Alex G.

1

60

14

4 years ago

Garbage pizza. First of all, $7.00 for two plain slices????? Are you kidding me??? That's $3.50 a slice for PLAIN pizza no toppings. I could almost forgive that if the pizza was any good. But it was oily, soggy, floppy, and borderline undercooked. I will never be returning to this spot ever again. And the to go box the pizza comes in. Showing pics of movies that came out over 10 years ago!!!!!!!! LOLOLOL!!!!!! Get with the times guy. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Elddis G.

0

2

0

3 years ago

Excellent taste on real Italian flavors, good amicable people, very clean and reliable restaurant. Safe and quiet. Will keep going always for a great Spaghetti and meatballs. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mike W.

1

19

1

3 years ago

The best pizza and sandwiches!! Forget the rest if you want the best! Great neighborhood spot

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Doug D.

6

10

17

6 years ago

Neighborhood staple for many years & best pizza spot around. Will always eat here till I die. Run by great people that are family oriented and make food with love. read more

Catania's Pizza - Fire Sicilian corner - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Helpful 2

Thanks 2

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Dina B.

Elite 24

117

102

320

4 years ago

Catania's has the best little calzones stuffed with fresh, delicious ingredients. Been going there for probably 40 years! My favorite calzone is the pork and peppers while my kids love the meatball and cheese calzones. The pizza is delicious, as are their rolls which are stuffed with things such as broccoli rabe and sausage, eggplant, chicken etc. My all time favorite item on their menu is the "Marinara slice". If you love fresh grated cheese and garlic and sauce, you MUST have this pizza! Any time I am in the area and my husband knows, he always asks me stop at Catania's to get him a few slices and a few calzones. The staff is always friendly and willing to describe all the items they have for the day. read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Rob L.

12

25

5

3 years ago

The best Sicilian slice , when I'm in the area it's a must have , also the meatball calzones .

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rob P.

Elite 26 All-Star

18

82

105

9 years ago

I lived nearby in Westchester for 30+ years and had another pizza spot that I love for slices, but as far as calzones go? Catania's is unique in their little calzone squares in 3 types, cheese, veal & peppers and meatball. They are pricey, each one sets you back about $3.50 and I can eat 4-5 for a meal but they are so worth it. I can only tell you they are like nothing you've tried before and would highly suggest getting them. Any time I'm in the area to visit I stop by and order 15 to take home with me. Tip: Pay with cash. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Rashan H.

Elite 24

144

239

222

5 years ago

Solid pizza ... as close to BX pizza I've had up here. Mini calzones are a great finger food. Sicilian is great, crunchy bottom... way I like iit. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Barbara B.

0

6

0

3 years ago

Food is always consistent & very good. Service is great & the staff so nice. Decent seating. Love the mini calzones.

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tom W.

2

80

9

7 years ago

Best pizza and calzones in Yonkers. Hands down. Friendly staff. Don't pay attention to the surroundings, just enjoy. Excellent Italian ice too. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ryan C.

121

205

16

6 years ago

Catania's Pizza has been around for a long time. This small place, has great pizza and also a small seating area (nothing fancy.) If you happen to check this place out, there chicken rolls are amazing. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Eddie G.

0

6

2

6 years ago

Been eating here for over 25 years, love the Sicilian pie, and the rolls!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tere N.

9

38

44

6 years ago

I have been a customer for many years and highly recommend Catania's ! Their staff is attentive and they keep the place clean. Their food is delicious! The best calzones, pizza and chicken Marsala rolls and eggplant rolls to name a few. They did change ownership but within the family. Try it for yourself before you take anyone's opinion! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Juan C.

0

26

0

6 years ago

Enjoyed a nice Sicilian slice and a mini meatball calzone then went back the next day and had a chicken parm roll with sesame seeds. The chicken was grounded but they don't skimp on the amount. Will definitely be back... read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Charles M.

127

7

1

5 years ago

Grew up in Yonkers but haven't been down in a while. Catania's has the best pizza hands down. The owner runs the place like a champ. Veal & Pepper roll is lip smacking. Slices were cheesy and the sauce has perfect amount of spice. I would give it ten stars if I could. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joseph C.

2

33

9

8 years ago

My Dad would always take me here when I was yonger for the cheese calzones SOOOO GOOOD . Just ordered two trays of mini calzones for my co workers and they loved them. Perfect for watching the big game read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 2

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Lauren M.

186

168

33

15 years ago

Nothing but love for this place. It might be because of their delicious mini calzones. Or their meat slice. Or their fruit punch. Or the fact that I grew up going here and they were the sponsors of my 1989 girl's softball team. (What a great season that was - celebrating our wins with pizza!! Dang, I miss being eleven years-old!) Tip: If you order a whole pie, you can ask them to make it with sesame seeds on the bottom of the crust. This makes for a really uniquely good (think nutty & crunchy) pizza. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Ben M.

Elite 21

578

77

43

7 years ago

If you're in Yonkers and you're thinking there's not good NY Pizza in the area, let this place change your mind! The pizza here is actually really good, and pricing isn't too bad. This is in a small shopping complex but worth it! I got a pepperoni slice which is always solid and a bacon chicken and ranch pizza that was phenomenal. GO HERE if you want good NY pizza!!!! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Chantit S.

0

2

0

5 years ago

I've been coming here for a couple of years now and the pizza is absolutely great! I highly recommend if your in the area to grab a slice or sicillian. On your way out, order a pie to take home! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rita B.

35

38

12

4 years ago

I've been getting pizza here for years! The ingredients they use are fresh. The quality has been pretty consistent over the years. The staff is very friendly and helpful. Definately will continue go there! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Barbara R.

30

17

1

9 years ago

The pizza box was saturated with grease, the pizza pie was dry. What's up with that? If you don't have enough respect for your customers to make them a fresh pizza pie, you have a problem. Here is my advice... SELL OUT OR THROW OUT!!! Your pizza was gross, we won't be back. Yonkers Restaurants suck, just like your pizza! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Kristina H.

0

2

0

6 years ago

We ordered the most basic order and the plain pizza and buffalo wings were both burned. Tried to eat it but the burned flavor was so strong. Will not buy from here again read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Page 1 of 3

See more reviews

More info about Catania's Pizza

2260 Central Park Ave
Yonkers, NY 10710
Directions
(914) 779-5105
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order

Full menu

Hours

What time does Catania's Pizza open?

Catania's Pizza opens at 11:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Catania's Pizza close?

Catania's Pizza closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Catania's Pizza closes at 8:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon-Sat 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMSun 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Catania's Pizza take Bitcoin?

No, Catania's Pizza does not take Bitcoin.

Does Catania's Pizza take credit cards?

Yes, Catania's Pizza takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Catania's Pizza have catering options?

Yes, Catania's Pizza does have catering options.

Does Catania's Pizza have a happy hour?

No, Catania's Pizza does not have a happy hour.

Does Catania's Pizza serve alcohol?

No, Catania's Pizza does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Catania's Pizza have TVs?

No, Catania's Pizza does not have TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Catania's Pizza have bike parking?

Yes, Catania's Pizza has bike parking.

Does Catania's Pizza have outdoor seating?

No, Catania's Pizza does not have outdoor seating options.

Does Catania's Pizza have parking?

Yes, Catania's Pizza has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Catania's Pizza wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Catania's Pizza is wheelchair accessible.

Does Catania's Pizza have free WiFi?

No, Catania's Pizza does not have free WiFi.

More Info

Health Score

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 59,636 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Capri Pizza

4.3(31 reviews)

2.8 mi

It's just your neighborhood pizza joint. Nothing fancy just pizza and a couple of hero's on the…read moremenu. There's sporadic parking outside, it is more of the kind of place you walk to, and get takeout there. There are three tables with about 10 seats altogether. We're not talking to Michelin stars here. But, it's not a greasy spoon either. Simple and unassuming.

Ode to Capri You have always been there for me, your pizza…read moreand calzones are delicious in my tummy The NY Italian husband is picky But you always deliver Thin crust, Can feed a crowd Cheesy and toppings evenly spread Try the thin cut, fried eggplant on a cheese pizza- welcome to perfection

7/5/25 - where the pizza's made. Menu above

7/5/25 - slice with sausage

See all

Jan. 2026 - the menu

Gino's Pizzeria

4.6(112 reviews)

5.2 mi

This place was voted best pizza in Yonkers and I had to check it out. It's a small space with three…read moretables. They used to be cash only, but now they take card (with fee). The pizza was delicious!

Gino's Pizzeria is a true South Broadway staple and a go-to spot for consistently good food. The…read morepizza is perfectly seasoned--savory, satisfying, and always hits the spot whether you're grabbing a quick slice or ordering a full pie. What really sets Gino's apart is that they offer so much more than just pizza. Their menu includes favorites like fresh, hot zeppoles, indulgent fried Oreos, crispy chicken tenders, flavorful beef patties, and plenty of other comfort-food options. It's the kind of place where everyone can find something they're in the mood for. The service is friendly and welcoming, giving you that classic neighborhood pizzeria experience where you feel like a regular even on your first visit. Reliable food, generous options, and great service make Gino's Pizzeria a Yonkers classic that continues to stand the test of time. Definitely worth stopping by if you're in the area.

July 1st

Pizza slice, garlic knot, and Chicken Parm Roll

See all

Large cheese slice

Roma II Pizza

4.2(50 reviews)

2.6 mi

I love this place. I try to go every weekend for a slice. They also have great little chicken…read morecutlet sandwiches with fresh mozzarella and balsamic on garlic knot looking bread. From their salads & grinders to pizza and dinners everything is hand crafted into perfection! Franks and his workers are friendly and quick. This is definitely a neighborhood stable in the community. It's mostly to-go orders although they have 4 tables and I normally eat here. It's at like one big family between the staff and the patrons. It's clean and they normally have sports on the TV. Thanks Frank we appreciate you & your workers and your reasonable prices!

This place is hands‑down one of the most consistently amazing pizza spots around. The ooey‑gooey…read morecheese, the perfectly thin crust, and that special New York sauce you just can't find anywhere else--it all comes together every single time. The ingredients are always fresh and generously piled on, and the slices are absolutely huge. Frank is the owner and takes pride in his creations. Even after moving to Rockland County, I still travel to Westchester/Yonkers just for this pizza. It's my go‑to spot and the standard I compare all other pizza to. Nothing else comes close.

Chicken Parm slice

See all

Bella Rosa Pizza

4.5(60 reviews)

2.0 mi

If you find yourself in Yonkers this little neighborhood pizza parlor offers up a perfect NY slice…read more Thanks for treating this Seattle native to a wonderful meal this evening.

Yonkers & ALL of Westchester... LISTEN UP! If you haven't pulled up to @bellarosapizzayonkers , you…read moreare seriously missing out Let us put you ON! What we ate (and devoured): PestoRoni Pizza - pesto, pepperoni + hot honey magic Chicken Parm Dinner w/ vodka sauce & penne Chicken Marsala - perfection Cavatelli, Sausage & Broccoli Rabe - elite combo Dark Horse Chardonnay to sip Homemade Tiramisu - chef's kiss And the WEEKDAY DEALS!? UNREAL. You do not want to miss these: Mon: Pasta Night - $10.99 Tues: $65 for 1 app, 2 entrées, 1 dessert & a bottle of wine Wed: $1 wings (no explanation needed) Thurs: Thirsty Thursday PLUS -- they host cooking classes, paint nights, and are available for private events! Perfect for date nights, birthdays, work events... you name it. Run, don't walk. Your taste buds (and your social calendar) will thank you ‍

Garlic knots

See all

Tiny piece of cheesecake

Dom & Vinnie's Restaurant

3.8(145 reviews)

3.0 mi

•$$

Awesome food nice service don't sleep on the entrees there is much more than pizza. Highly…read morerecommend the Bolognese and speciality personal pies

On 8/26/26 I went to D&V after not going in about a year, as I worked across the street and had…read moreretired. I was SOOOOO looking forward to a couple of slices of Sicilian as theirs is the best. When I asked for it, the man behind the counter said they don't have any. I asked if they may have it tomorrow. His [nasty] response: "How would I know about tomorrow, World War III can start tomorrow". What a rude response. I asked if he was the new owner; he said 'yes'. I turned and walked away. That's how you treat [any] customer? After so looking forward to once again enjoying the pizza, what a disappointment. I will NEVER go back. He doesn't deserve my business. Anyone else get such a rude response?

Love me a bread basket

See all

A & V Pizzeria

4.0(152 reviews)

3.0 mi

Pizza is amazing great slice shop with lots of options. Some of the best NY style pizza you will…read morefind.

Women-STAY AWAY-the second they see you, they give you smaller portions. Every time I go in I see…read morethe guys getting regular sized portions but when they give me my order it's always less. Regardless, they still charge me exactly the same as the men.

See all

Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

3.7(850 reviews)

0.8 mi

•$$

4.5 true rating So I…read morelast went here six years ago and dined inside. I remember being unimpressed. It wasnt so great that visit and I felt no urge to return. Well my husband is from CT and he wanted to give it a try six years later (again). Reluctantly I agreed after looking through reviews. I have to say. We did half plain half and pepp. I wasn't a fan of the way their pepp came out but the plain was delicious and I would certainly order it again. For some reasons the pizza was cut into kiddie slices which I don't understand. It may have tricked my brain bc i felt hungry after. The pizza was thin, crispy, and flavorful. A power combo. Only downside was very burnt crust ends which I couldn't eat bc they were so burnt even though I was still hungry. Would def try again and sooner!

I really wanted to give Frank Pepe's another chance, especially considering its reputation…read more The last time we ordered from here, we had a horrible experience. To be completely fair, management did make an effort to make things right. We were given a refund as well as a $20 coupon to come back and try them again, which we appreciated. So, we decided to do exactly that. This time, instead of having our pizza delivered, we went directly to the restaurant. We ordered at the cash register, waited for the pies, picked them up ourselves, and brought them home. The photos attached are the pizzas we received. At this point, I really don't think I need to say much more. I'll let the photos speak for themselves. Take a look at the pies and decide for yourself what you think. I'll refrain from picking the pizzas apart ingredient by ingredient because the pictures show exactly what came out of the boxes. After a disappointing first experience, followed by a refund and an invitation to give them another opportunity, we genuinely hoped the second visit would change our opinion. Unfortunately, this was our second chance experience. At least the crust was tasty.

Frank Pepe 's Original Tomato Pie

See all

Inside seating

Montebello's Pizzeria & Pasta

3.1(33 reviews)

2.7 mi

We order a large chicken Parm pizza for delivery and it is delicious. We get it delivered and it…read morearrived hot. I tried their broccoli rabe calzone and loved it, although I thought it was pricy at $12.00.

As a 60-year-old Pizza-holic - Montebello's takes the spot - for the ABSOLUTE worst Pizza I've ever…read morepurchased. They put so little cheese and sauce on my $23.00 large pepperoni pizza - it was like eating sawdust. Horrible. What's worse - this is New York where we know how to make good pizza. I threw half the pie in the trash - which I've NEVER done before. They told me 15 minutes to pick up - I arrived at 20 minutes and stood until 40 minutes when my pizza was finally ready. Steer clear - it's bad.

See all

Full Moon Pizza

3.7(25 reviews)

2.4 mi

Very average pizza. Fluffy crust? Very airy. Fast service but not a ton of flavor. More of a Geno's…read moreguy for takeout Pizza in Bronxville. Have not been to the Arthur Ave location, so not sure how it compares. You a can eat in or carry out. More than just pizza.

I just popped in yesterday and met Larry, the new owner…read more He's a terrific guy and the food was equally terrific. I picked up a few pies for my wealth management business office around the corner. I particularly loved the white pizza with spinach and the Margarita pizza. Larry is even bringing in some new menu items. Miguel is still here and he is a helpful and charming asset to this great pizza parlor. Today I had the chicken parm, my wife Jane had the Linguini with clam sauce, and my daughter Janie had the Penne a la Vodka. All delicious.

Zepolis

Inviting

See all

Dunwoodie Pizzeria

4.2(130 reviews)

4.0 mi

one of the Top 3 pizzas in Yonkers. perfect balance of sauce cheese and crust…read morecooked properly

What can I say.... Dunwoodie Pizza is the Gold Standard for…read morewhat pizza should taste like everywhere. Crispy crust that doesn't flop when you pick it up, melted cheesy top without being burnt. A++++ The decor is nostalgic 70s pizzeria. Friendly staff so you can enjoy one of the best pizzerias in the world, not just Yonkers.

@ Dunwoodie, Yonkers, NY

See all

Waiting for my pie!!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

David K.

Elite 14

264

201

556

14 years ago

CATANIA'S JUST CAN'T SEEM TO CAPTURE THAT OLD SPARK! Welcome to the Tanglewood Shopping Center in North East Yonkers. Former home of the Tanglewood Boys, present home of wannabe gangsters who have watched Goodfellas one too many times. The scene is your typical Italian pizzeria in another Westchester County strip mall on Central [Park] Avenue. Depending on the day, you're likely to see a different member of the crew posing as the front thug for this suburban outpost. Over the past 35 years the neighborhood has changed, and unfortunately so has this pizzeria. From the earliest days of my childhood, this was always my neighborhood pizzeria. How much of a better location could this place be? Across Crisfield Street, Nathan's Hot Dogs and it's arcade sit in the next lot. This was where it was at when you just wanted to grab a slice and hang out. Whether just for a family of four or for your entire kindergarten class, this was the place where you got your pizza. I would brag to my friends and family that bar none this was where you'd find old style New York City pizza. That was until my cousin, Derek M. (Midlothian, VA), opened my eyes and told me that he wasn't really all that impressed. I took a hard look at my slice and realized that indeed it did lack that flavor which I had always known and loved. When ordering my pizza and getting an extra dose of attitude, you better be on top of your game. But lately it seems like their pizza has gotten too greasy while their dough has gotten too gummy. Anyone who has something good to say about this place brags about the calzones, but I'll always think of pizza as the heart and soul of this place. I think Pete (the owner) has to get back in there more often and let the crew know who is boss because they've long since forgotten who they are cooking for. This goes out to every kid who has peddled their bike around Beaumont Circle. Or anyone who has raced their car on Central [Park] Avenue on a Thursday night or maybe just parked their car at Nathan's and came to watch the show. Maybe you used to hang out on Bradlees before the cops closed it all down. If any of this sounds familiar or takes you back 15-20 years ore more, then you remember the days when Catania's was at its best. Tell Pete to get back there and show these guys how it's meant to be done. Tell the wannabe wiseguys to leave the gun and take the cannoli. read more

Brandi W.

22

10

0

9 years ago

I went to Catania's for lunch. It's a small "lunchy" type of pizzeria, not a place you would bring the family to for a sit down dinner. This is why I kind of hoped that the pizza would be amazing. Maybe if my hopes weren't so high and if I wasn't so hungry I wouldn't have been as disappointed. The man there was nice and the prices seemed average. I went there in search of the perfect New York pizza. Well it's not here. It wasn't too too bad but far from perfect. The calzones did look good but I was only there for the pizza. I would go back for lunch I suppose but would probably give that calzone a try or maybe even the Stromboli, that looked pretty good as well. read more

Aay K.

4

2

0

7 years ago

we used to eat their pizza quite often. But after trying EuroItalia's, across the street (which is better tasting and less expensive and better customer service ), we decided not to go their any more. read more

Denise M.

0

4

0

7 years ago

The chicken parm wedge is good and you can easily split it with someone for a filling lunch. They are always friendly and courteous when I visit. read more

Arlinda H.

0

1

0

7 months ago

I love the Pizza so much I have been eating at Catania's since I was a little girl and I love how they brought back the fruit punch

Vick P.

0

6

0

17 years ago

The best pizza outside of the Bronx. Their sicilian is off the hook!

Gussie W.

0

1

0

15 years ago

Just had delicious pizza and fantastic mini calzones here!!!

Catania's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Catania's Pizza also viewed

Cosimo & Johnny’s Pizzeria

4.2

(65 reviews)

The pizza was absolutely fabulous! A good old original slice the size and style that I grew up…read morewith. The people were so friendly and helpful in selecting as well! Can't wait to go back and try more!

We moved away from Westchester about 10 years ago and when we were visiting family here, we were…read moretold THIS was now the best pizza place in town. Boy was I disappointed... The crust was too thin, the cheese was sparse, and the sauce underwhelming. 1/10 for their pizza. It doesn't come close to CRESTWOOD PIZZERIA, which in my opinion is the GOLD STANDARD. Do not waste your time and money here. Crestwood was, is, and forever will be the pizza champion in this town.

Happy Days Pizza Place

4.1

(47 reviews)

Happy Days Pizza has been around since I was a child, this place was a staple in Eastchester -…read moreeveryone knew & loved it!

I happened to be in the area with my sister and, like always, we needed a lil something and decided…read moreon pizza (it's our weakness). My sister is a pizza connoisseur, so we've made a fun thing out of trying different spots all over New York. I found Happy Days Pizza on Yelp, and decided to give it a try . I called in a pickup order and about 20 minutes later we were grabbing it. I have to say, I've never had a plain slice like this in Westchester County. Westchester tends to lean heavy on ultra-thin crust, and this was different ,it genuinely reminded me of a Queens slice. Perfect balance, great texture, and you can taste the quality of the ingredients. Simple, classic, done right. The place itself is small, cute, and no-frills exactly how a good pizza spot should be. Keep in mind parking is not easy and it's tough to stop, but honestly... it's worth the effort. (They might have parking I did not see it ) If you're craving a real New York style slice and find yourself nearby, this is a must!

Italia Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.7

(75 reviews)

Food was very good as was service.. Store was very clean and…read morewell kept. I will definetly go back!

I love this place. My family and I love their pizza and the service was very good. The restaurant…read moreis in the Thornwood town center, has very big parking area, and is very convenient.

San Gennaro's

3.4

(90 reviews)

This is my Go-To Pizza joint for when I want a Buffalo Chicken slice/pie. Small in size, with…read moreyour typical pizza counter w/a few small tables ambiance, the employees have always been pleasant & professional, and the prices very fair. If you're a Buffalo Chicken fan def try a slice or two here. Ask for extra Buffalo sauce on side & either drizzle or dunk as you go. Heavenly!

Yea this pizza was worth it not like other spots this pizza had a crisp edge and a really nice…read morecheese pull. I also got me a Philly cheesy steak. Freaking beautiful. Fresh wedges the bread was nice and soft definitely worth the stop

Broadway Pizzeria of White Plains

3.9

(103 reviews)

Love coming here, always the first stop on my trip home. Cesar salad pizza is my favorite, but they…read morehave so many options that look amazing. The napkins have been changed since my last visit to paper thin, so thin the air conditioning was blowing it off my table if I didn't put the salt shaker on it. But the quality of the food and the quickness of service make this my favorite pizzeria.

My co worker recommended this spot to me last summer and I been coming here since, We ordered a…read morepenne Vodka pie for the game it was delicious!

Gianfranco Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.8

(92 reviews)

The Tuna Pie. That's all. Just go get one. I dream about this pizza. I love when my husband brings…read moreone home on his way home from work. It's so delicious! Busy place, so he makes sure to order ahead of time, and they always have it ready. Great service, great pizza. Super crispy crust, delicious Tuna salad with lettuce, super thin sliced tomatoes, and oil and vinegar. It's absolutely to die for. Love it. Always craving it!

This is always a solid pizza!…read more Friendly service and warm atmosphere! The restaurant area is nice and the food portions are good! Two thumbs up here!

Roma II Pizza

4.2

(50 reviews)

I love this place. I try to go every weekend for a slice. They also have great little chicken…read morecutlet sandwiches with fresh mozzarella and balsamic on garlic knot looking bread. From their salads & grinders to pizza and dinners everything is hand crafted into perfection! Franks and his workers are friendly and quick. This is definitely a neighborhood stable in the community. It's mostly to-go orders although they have 4 tables and I normally eat here. It's at like one big family between the staff and the patrons. It's clean and they normally have sports on the TV. Thanks Frank we appreciate you & your workers and your reasonable prices!

This place is hands‑down one of the most consistently amazing pizza spots around. The ooey‑gooey…read morecheese, the perfectly thin crust, and that special New York sauce you just can't find anywhere else--it all comes together every single time. The ingredients are always fresh and generously piled on, and the slices are absolutely huge. Frank is the owner and takes pride in his creations. Even after moving to Rockland County, I still travel to Westchester/Yonkers just for this pizza. It's my go‑to spot and the standard I compare all other pizza to. Nothing else comes close.

Pizzarelli's Pizza & Pasta

4.3

(100 reviews)

•$$

Ate here yesterday. The food was good. I had a Philly cheesesteak with mozzarella cheese and a…read moreslice of cheese Sicilian. Hubby had eggplant rollatini with sautéed spinach and garlic knots.

My go to spot all the time, no matter where I'm at, either I'm in Bklyn, BX, Qns, New Rochelle ,…read moreDobbs Ferry, Mamaroneck all I have to do is schedule my ETA in an advance through their Web/ App , and Voila, simple as it could be, by the time I arrive, my order is ready to go; fast & quick service , awesome staff, you can dine in, during the spring & summer , able to dine out, average noise surrounding , the food is fantastic, freshly made with passion. Well prepped dough. Parking meter in front, I love their cannolis , the kids loves their zeppoles Deep fried just right , covered with powdered sugar all around, Their portions is enough to keep you full, must try their specialty slices, many varieties to choose from. A pizza shop for all travelers, commuters , bring your coworkers or a quick date . Just right off the Scarsdale train station on the Harlem Line .

Capri Pizza

4.3

(31 reviews)