Ever since the new owners came in this place has been dynamite. My fiancée and I cannot resist…read moretheir buffalo wing pizza. We come from Nj often to visit family and this is our must stop every single time. They have a few staples in my eyes. The sweet sauce isn't too sweet and hits just right! Their uncle guys is a slightly thicker dough, with a great sauce to cheese ratio. Their buffalo wing is just incredible, it's even better on the square. It truly shows how the new owners really care about this spot, they take pride in their pies! I know a lot of people in the area stick to their normal spots but I really think this is a true gem!!

Welcome to Friday night pizza night everyone, today we are visiting "That Guy with The Dough". I…read moreheard, I should have said read good reviews on this place, so I decided it's time to check it out. It's more of a takeout place but they do have two tables set up if you want to have it there. Today's pizza is basic and right to the point, a patron behind me told me after asking what the popular choice it's their sweet sauce pizza was, so that's what I got. Now sitting there, I noticed they do a good amount of take out. I also saw the same door dash guy a few times. Now, how was my pizza you ask? This came out nice and hot, the crust was nice and crisp, the sweet sauce was amazing. I do want to add the employees were very nice being my first time ever here. I do recommend everyone to try this place out. Until next video, be blessed and stay safe. Watch my video review https://youtu.be/D0-VMZ7vZhw check out their online menu https://www.allmenus.com/pa/moosic/728527-that-guy-with-the-dough/menu/

Perfection all around. The pizza is delicious- a thick, yet airy crust with an incredibly good red…read moresauce, good amount of cheese. The service was so friendly, too. Such nice folks, great food; an all around great stop.

Great pizza love the red Always fast service and great…read moreprice We like ordering pizza from Mary lou

We were here for lunch on a Saturday afternoon. The place was not busy at all. We were greeted by a…read moreyoung female staff as soon as we walked in. She told us to sit anywhere we want. An older female staff, our waitress gave us the menu right away. After about 5 minutes or so, our waitress took our order. Took about 20 mins for the food to come out. We ordered the red and the white. The red pizza were decent at most. It's definitely not fresh. It's reheated. Taste like most Sicilian pizza out there. Actually, taste somewhat like a school lunch pizza. The white pizza were delicious though. It's a garlicky bread with cheese filling. Lots of cheese! Service was just decent at most. Our waitress was not friendly or attentive. Not sure if we'll go back. We'll most likely try another spot if we happen to be in the area.

Found Revello's when the other place across the street only had take out. It was a Sunday…read moreafternoon between lunch and dinner, so there was plenty of seating. The waitress/bartender was friendly and service was fast. We devoured a red tray pizza. The crust was crisp, the cheese was creamy, and the sauce had a hint of onion. Having read about the Old Forge style, it represented it well. Would come again!

Our second time here and first time trying the pizza. Love the food, love the owner, love the…read morelocation that it's close to home. We will be back!

Overall a really good place to order food from. Always the same dish, never changes which is really…read morenice.

The pizza here is amazing. We order a tray of red it was really good and the service was great. It…read morethe best pizza around town.

Colorusso's is Casual, excellent food, they have the best pizza! Service is always so nice and…read morefriendly.

Heard Salerno's was for sale or was going to be sold, so when I was back in Scranton my family…read moreplaced a pickup order for old time's sake. This was never the best pizzeria in Old Forge but I've probably eaten here a hundred times and have spent 15 years defending it, so it holds significance in my food journey. The late 2025 experience was between sad and insulting. Flat dough on 3 pizzas, chintzy toppings, only half the soup container was filled and didn't include bread, sloppy sandwich, and the woman on the phone sounded like she wished she had retired five years ago. Nobody ever said that this was the most consistent restaurant in Old Forge, but when your restaurant reaches the point where you're dragging down the reputation of the town's food scene, I think it's time to close.

The red pizza was really good and service was good would recommend them we will be back for more.read more

On a day trip and came across A&G in Old Forge. Had a great meal at the counter. Craig had the…read moremeatball parm and I had a penne dish that included olives, chicken, sun dried tomatoes and broccoli (so yummy). Great service. Chatted with owners. A great experience overall.

One of the better Old Forge style pizzas. Old Forge style is distinct. Not really Chicago not…read morereally Sicilian... it's an old miner's style pizza popular on a Pennsylvania Saturdaynight.... Like Chicago style you either love it or "don't care".... I'm in the love it category... so dust off yer criticisms and be gone... there's a Dominoes in your future... but not here. Good people, good atmosphere, good pizza!!!

Always a fantastic meal and great service. Red risotto is out of this world! My compliments to the…read moreowners and servers

Havent been there in a couple years. Took our kids and their spouses to Rinaldis this time as…read moreopposed to Revellos which has always been great for Old Forge type pizza. First thing we noticed was they no longer make double crusted white. NOT GOOD START. Ordered their open facd white with a large red tray, and yes in Old Forge the pizza comes out in a tray. The white was lousy and the red was even worse. Couldn't even eat the red we brought home and reheated a couple days later. The risotto was fine, and I noticed that all the tables around us were having dinners and not pizza. My first experience with Old Forge pizza was 70 years ago when I was 8 at Ghigarellis so I no what Im talking about. Rinaldis is not the place to go for pizza.

Food is beautiful Service is exquisite especially the owner…read moreIt is cozy and nice It is really fun I love anthonys

I did something stupid and I have zero regrets…read more I knew it was stupid. The waitress knew it was stupid. As did everyone at the bar. And you know what? I'd do it again in a heartbeat. Many years ago, I went on a little tour of Old Forge pizza. We tried the red. We tried the white. We went to the famous places. We went to the dives. But somehow we never made it to Anthony's? Maybe it was their hours? Maybe it was because the Old Forge white was not available by the cut? It's hard to say. But what I know for sure is that I came out of the tour with a deep abiding love for Old Forge white with broccoli. IMHO it needs the broccoli. Regrettably, my old favorites for white with broccoli have fallen from grace, which is a loss. But the silver lining is that I have found Anthony's and their white broccoli is amazing! An entire white broccoli pie is a staggering quantity of food. So when I walked up to the bar as a solo diner, and placed my order of a white broccoli pie for here, the waitress looked a little uneasy and paused for a moment. In the pause, I acknowledged that I knew I was ordering enough food for a crew, and that I expected to be taking much of it home. It also takes a staggeringly long time to bake something that large in an oven. And I knew that going in. So I nursed my Yuengling, and even took a few nibbles of bread and butter that were brought out while I waited. I have to say, that first bite just had me swooning, and I don't swoon easily. The top crust was beautifully seasoned with herbs, spices, and onions. The bottom crust was golden and crisp. The cheese was oozing and broccoli was bursting forth. Please, please, please eat this pizza in the restaurant. It's glorious when it first comes out of the oven. The longer it sits, the less crisp the bottom becomes. Trust me. It's worth it. With the beer, tip, and taxes, the whole thing set me back $33. Obviously there were leftovers too. My original plan had been to offer cuts of the pie to other folks at the bar, but by the time I got there, everyone had already eaten, so I wasn't able to give away a single cut. So it goes. And I did push myself to eat more than I should have. Slice one was a revelation. Slice two a delight. Slice three felt more like a dare. And slice four? That was pure hubris. I only got a couple of bites in and then I had to tap out. But I wanted to tackle at least half of the pie on premise. So it goes. I learned something about myself that night, but more importantly, I discovered a new Old Forge institution, to which I am looking forward to returning time and time again. P.S. I should note I saw lots of food come out, and really all the portions are huge. Just like I could have split this with a couple other folks, the same is true for every dish was brought to the bar.