Got take out the other night. The margarita pizza, parma, pappardelle with oxtail ragu and the zeppole sticks. Food was soo good and the staff are very friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend! read more

Worst pizza I've ever had. What a rip off. Tried getting pizza here for over a month before I finally tried it. The first time I called they said they weren't taking orders anymore because they couldn't keep up with the ones they had. Put an order in about a month or two later and it was a complete disappointment. Overpriced and really bad. Hardly any sauce or cheese and toppings. It was like chewy cardboard. No thanks. read more

Do not recommend. The restaurant was filthy dirty. The Floors had food all over the place. It looked like the floors have not been swept or washed in months. Food was terrible and not to mention the smell of urine when you first walked in. Flying black bugs over the food. read more

I this restaurant And I must say both times that I have been there have been above standards that I expected. Today we ordered a simple meal of a very basic Pizza and a chicken hero not only surprising prices being 2016 priceslive in Seaford and have only been twice to give or take very reasonable and unexpected in these times where prices are going through the roof. My pizza although basic was tasty and really really something that I would repeat. There are a variety of different pizzas which I'm looking forward to trying the next time I come in and look like a small slice of heaven pardon the joke when the pizza comes. The sandwich we had that I shared with my wife along with the pizza was fresh and tasty and had a sauce on it that I have never tasted before. Meaning it blew me away the sandwich was only $14 and the sandwich if any place else in a restaurant would have been at least $17. The sandwich had more chicken than I expected and between me and my wife who usually have a decent size meal we're full from the pizza and the sandwich. Some of the meals that I saw other people getting looked fantastic the place was packed tonight and a lot of happy faces. I was very lucky to get a table. The staff did their best with the amount of people that they had in the building which was extremely good and management and I forget the gentleman's name was friendly and happy to have seen us. The total of my meal was $34.85 plus an $8 tip I left. Five star food with discount prices. This is the first Yelp review I have ever given and I don't know I'll ever give one again but for what I had gotten this was worth telling the world be well be safe everyone don't miss out on this wonderful restaurant. PS it has a wood brick oven. Wonderful flavor from this and not to worry folks if you worried about a smoky smell it wasn't a drop it was well ventilated. This is a brand new restaurant maybe open 3 months maybe a little more and I wish them great success read more

Charred was meh....you can blame it on me since as a rule, i don't complain at restaurants or send things back. Like some of the other comments, i noticed as well that some of the stuff we ordered didn't equal the description on the menu. That's a nono, bad quality control. It is sad this is the level of restaurant my budget allows, i continually get disappointed. read more

I have been eyeing this place for awhile and decided to finally go and try it out but to my disappointment it was not a great experience, seems to be run by a bunch of kids with no professionalism, their was no manager on premises over all I can say it's one place I wouldn't recommend to my friends and family Unfortunately the Service was unacceptable . read more

I was really looking forward to trying this restaurant out but what a disappointment! For starters my food came out cold and the staff was very unprofessional and it seemed to be everyone's first day at work. They were very unorganized, and I waited 2 hours to get 3 appetizers. My family and I were sitting next to the kitchen and I could hear the staff laughing and having a great time while I wait 2 hours for my food. I asked for a manger and I was told there is no manger or supervisor on the premises. I honestly wouldn't even give them a star but I have to in order to write this review. read more

Charred Brick Oven - Pizza Near Me - Seaford, New York

Food was delicious , and reasonably priced. Their dish "money bags" was super tasty and incredibly unique. Their rice balls were equipped with a perfectly crispy outside and a delicate and creamy inside. I wouldn't drive over 30 mins to try it; but, if you are in the area you must give it a shot! read more

The wait time made me question my decision. The food proved to be worth the wait. The Pizza , the truffle oil, the appetisers. .., everything was absolutely phenomenal! read more

Such a welcoming and warm environment! Joe was our waiter and he was amazing. The food was great! Definitely a new family favorite & luckily its close to home ! read more

Absolute 10/10. Gianna and Tyler made the experience even better. Top 3- money bags, eggplant tower, and fried zango. Literally the best meal I've ever eaten. The triple derby! read more

stopped in here for a quick meal over the weekend. we ordered the fennel and orange salad which was on special....i enjoyed it my husband did not. the pizza was absolutely delicious. we went with a simple marghertia pie, so good! would come back here again. read more

Usually love this place but today left feeling unimpressed. The mussels were just okay and the pizza was extremely soggy. read more

Charred Brick Oven - Mussels - Pizza Near Me - Seaford, New York

See all

not one to ever write a review but I feel this poor experience from a first and last time customer should have been better than a 1 star (0 stars if I had the option). I call to order take out, the girl answers the phone I'm assuming mid order with someone else, as she's talking about asparagus, a second of silence and then I hear "hello" to me I say hi. she proceededs with "are you still ordering?" I said "I haven't started ordering yet." She puts me on hold, not a problem, I patiently wait as I brush aside the attitude and inconvenience of my phone call to her or so it seemed. She answers the phone to take my order with a "hi" I excuse the fact AGAIN that she greets me with an attitude like my phone call is a bother. She starts taking my order and I ask for Buffalo calamari (as I've seen it on their Instagram) she nastily says "what is that. I've never heard of that" I look at my bf as if I'm saying calamari wrong and i say "I'm not sure I've seen in on your Instagram", she doesnt care enough to help just says "don't know never heard of it" I'm like ok...regular calamari is fine, and a pizza. She says "ok.." I then say "that's everything" She says "ok goodbye." now I work in customer service as I've worked in a pizzeria and 1) would handle a phone call better and more politely but 2) would give a price and a time, not "goodbye" as if you can be doing better things. I pick up my order and was more hungry than I was mad. Aa I'm sure me telling her I'm never coming back here wouldn't effect her life in any way. I just wanted to eat my dinner. Let's just say the burnt or "charred" to sh*t pizza and the bland calamari would have tasted a lot better if the $40 would have stayed in the wallet and we would have gone somewhere else for dinner. Work sucks and no one WANTS to be working, I get that. But they should hire individuals with a bit more personality and a little leas attitude. Losing me as a customer wont effect this place, having people like that working there will lose a lot more customers than me. Save yourself the headache and the $. read more

Charred Brick Oven - Pizza Near Me - Seaford, New York

After a long work week, my friends and I met at this establishment for a relaxing dinner. We were aware that the restaurant does not take reservations, so we sat at the bar and had several drinks while we waited for a table. After we were seated at a table we placed our orders, my friends ordered chicken entrees and I ordered a pizza. My pizza was delivered to the table long before their entrées. I began to eat my pizza while my friends waited for their food. They were hungry so they asked for bread. Instead of bringing us the bread, the manager (Craig I believe his name was) came to our table and arrogantly told us that they do not give bread to people who order pizza. My friends explained that they ordered and were waiting for their entrees. He then rudely told us that bread is only brought to the table after entrées are served. As we looked around the surrounding tables, many of them had bread with no entrees so we were quite confused. As teachers and professionals we certainly understand mistakes happen, but instead of acknowledging the error and bringing the bread, the manager was rude and doubled down on his excuse. While the food was good, we will not be going back due to the poor customer service. read more

Great food and great staff. Everything we tried was delicious. Baked clams, Margarita Pizza & Shrimp Parm Platter. Will definitely be going back often. read more

The food is good but the staff (minus our waiter who was a delight) treated us poorly. We walked in, spoke to the host who was incredibly rude, asked to wait, we did at the bar, and we're literally ignored for 15 minutes by the bartender who didn't acknowledge us until we flagged her down. The Drinks she made were disgusting and all syrup as well. This is at 4:45pm on a Friday, not prime time. I'm so disappointed as I heard great things but to be treated so poorly from the second we walked in was a really downer and set the tone. We sat near the back of house and saw the staff being spoken to poorly as well by management. Real bummer. I won't be returning due to the poor experience, which stinks because the food is so good! read more

This Place by far has the best dinner drinks and pizza.. When you think you can't get something better than what you're eating at the moment there comes some thing else absolutely delicious staff is very friendly oh and I forgot to mention the desert is to die for. read more

Been here twice recently. Both times we had different pizzas and they were all excellent. My only complaint is the house wines are undrinkable. I just don't get this. Pizza with a decent glass of red wine is the best. I've tried the cab, chianti and merlot and they were all horrible. Had a martini instead. You can buy a decent red retail for $12 which means the restaurant could buy it for $6 or $8. Just no excuse not to have a decent house red by the glass. read more

Had a good dinner last night! Started with Buffalo chicken wings and the burrata and prosciutto. Shared the speck pie, money bags, and calamari with peppers. The money bags stood out and would highly recommend but they are very creamy. Overall would recommend having dinner here! read more

Food was delicious. The waitress (young lady at the bar, we sat at a high top) on the evening of 7/15 was incredibly friendly, helpful, and have great service even though it was getting very busy. And who I can only assume is the manager/owner greeted us when we first came in and was so nice when he checked in on us. Great place! read more

We tried this place last night. Outdoor seating was perfect for us and the food was incredible. We had the capellini cakes (phenomenal), cacio e pepe, lobster ravioli, a pizza, the dessert waffle, and zeppole sticks. Everyone loved their food and we would for sure go back. read more

Wouldn't consider their pizza "Charred" or even close to well done. Pizza was very flimsy. When picking up a slice, all the toppings slid right off. The cheese wasn't fully melted and the crust was very doughy. I will stick with Anthony's Coal Fired pizza. They do it right! read more

Ordered the mortadella pie -- one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten. It was also interesting watching them take it out of the oven and assemble it. Will definitely return. The restaurant loons lovely for dine-in, too. read more

My fiancé and I have eaten here upwards of 10 times and it's a 5 star place every time. We've never tried something that wasn't excellent and we've tried over half of the pizzas and appetizers on the menu. It's our favorite local spot! read more

Delicious food, perfectly made drinks. We had good service and the prices were very fair. The place has a good vibe. I will be a regular.

I want to edit my first review. The second time we went the service was much better. The server was right there to get us drinks. The owner was scouting the restaurant and making sure all the customer were happy. My pizza was so excellent and my husband had fish and all was cooked perfectly! read more

Food is good at Charred, but service/management is not. It seems if you know the manager, it's better. Waitress had an annoyed attitude, not friendly. as did the Manager. A very busy place, that does not take reservations, not good customer service with long waits and seeing empty tables? Had a big check including drinks, apps, dinners. No water or bread put on table at all, until we asked. No refill of either, until we asked. That is part of servicing a table. And...check dropped at table, without us even realizing it and not asked if we wanted anything else--and we felt like an after dinner cocktail--foolish. There were a few issues at our table, no accommodation from Manager, and he had an annoyed attitude as well. Usually leave a big tip, especially during Covid, but everyone agreed it just wasn't deserved. All agreed, we will not be going back- there are plenty of restaurants in the area where both food and service are good, along with the management. read more

DO NOT GO HERE!!!! TERRIBLE EXPERIENCE!!!! We went on a Saturday night. The hostess told us there was a one hour wait, so we waited, but it ended up being a two-and-a-half-hour wait!!! People kept walking in and getting seated because they knew the owner. They would kiss, hug, and shake hands, and get seated right away! Terrible! This restaurant does not take reservations, which is absurd, yet if you're well-connected with the owner, you get seated right away!!! Not right at all!!! We finally get seated and order the grilled octopus as an appetizer! The most disgusting octopus I have ever eaten!!! It was pasty white, mushy, and clearly not fresh! I believe it was frozen and defrosted. The sausage in my pasta dish was clearly way undercooked to the point that I felt sick!. The sausage was red!!! When I asked the waitress, she told me that it was supposed to be that way! I guess if you want to eat raw meat...anyway, as if this meal could get any worse, it does! They brought my brother the wrong pizza, so we asked them and she says she made a mistake. At this point, we're really annoyed and frustrated to say the least, so when she offers to put in a request for the right pizza, my brother tells her to forget about it. She leaves the pizza on the table, but we didn't touch it. At the end of the meal, she takes all 3 pies that were ordered, but only boxes up the two that were partially eaten. The third pie was not charged to the bill, but she did not offer for us to take it home. Will they serve that pie to another customer?!?! That's DISGUSTING AND UNSANITARY!!! Or would they RATHER throw the pie in the garbage THAN give it to us for free even though THEY are the ones that messed up our order in the FIRST place?!?! If this restaurant had EVEN ONE OUNCE of good customer service, they would have acknowledged their mistake, apologize, not charge us for the wrong pizza, and let us take it home, but they did not!!! Overall, an AWFUL experience!!! We will NEVER return here and only hope that people will read this review and avoid this place!!! There are many, many better restaurants than this one!!! DO NOT MAKE THE SAME MISTAKE WE DID!!! As for the quality and taste of the pizza, it's just okay. It's nothing special, not terrible, but not good either!!! There are so many better options out there!!! DO NOT GO HERE!!! read more

Average at best. They claim to be a brick oven pizza. It's just regulator old plain slice style of pizza. And for $18 for a plain regular old personal pizza I have 20 places for large pie for the same $18 that are 1,000,000 times better. read more

Wow, this food was as mediocre as it gets. Pizza was tiny and way overpriced, but more importantly, it was uninspired. This place wants to make a buck, not great food. The 4 star reviews you are seeing are fakes, I assure you. read more

Tried this spot a few nights ago. Not only was the pizza extremely under whelming (Pizza was very doughy) we also ordered some appetizers that were completely unappetizing. The meatballs were filled with fatty bits and tendons and the ricotta was extremely grainy. All of this under whelming food after waiting an extra 20 minutes inside picking up our take out after already waiting the approximate 30 minute wait time they gave us while ordering. Sadly a brick oven pizza place that misses the spot, we won't be returning. read more

Actually pretty disappointing. We ordered for a specific time. While we were on our way, about 10 minutes before that time, we got a call saying the order was ready to pick up- so in reality they called to tell us our order would be cold, which it was. We had a pizza and a calzone. First, despite the prices, the pizzas are tiny. The one we had was also overly salty and sparsely populated with cheese and basil, to the point that one of the 4 slices had almost nothing but sauce on it. The second star is for the calzone, which was pretty good, but not nearly good enough to warrant a second visit. The food needed to be very good to make it worth the prices, and it just wasn't. read more

Got there at 6 on a Friday night. Had about a 15 min wait. Not too bad. Not many tables at all. We went to the bar to get a drink, well it took the bartender that whole time to acknowledge us. She had about 8 people sitting at the bar. She was not friendly at all. We ordered one of their specialty cocktails but they were out of one of the ingredients, so we ordered something else paid our bar tab and then was sat at our table. The food was really good, but overall the service was horrible. read more

Love the pizza here! and I am a pizza fanatic. Chris makes the best pizza and the other entre choices are delicious. Service is great and so is food. So glad to find such a good pace so local. read more

Came here yesterday for the first time with three of my friends. First of all, service was phenomenal and our server/bartender Alyssa was attentive and sweet. We ordered 4 appetizers, 4 cocktails, 4 entrees and espresso to top off the night, and the bill was very reasonable. Everything was amazing. My favorite thing to hit the table were the ricotta balls that came with a truffle cream sauce. I had the gnocchi bomb which came in a bread bowl and it was to die for. We also had the Buffalo chicken pizza which was delicious and the smokiness from the oven was a perfect touch. I will definitely be back for those ricotta balls and some pies. Thank you! read more

The more popular brick oven spot on Broadway (no names mentioned) was booked with orders until closing so I decided to give charred brick oven a chance. This was my second time ordering here. First time was a forgettable eggplant pizza. Tasteless mushy eggplant, barely any sauce and cheese were on that pie (crust part is made too big). But on trying this place again I was happy with the mambo italiano (half marg pizza, half calzone). The dough they use is top notch, and I'd even argue might taste better than the other guys on broadway. You won't find such good tasting pizza dough and crust anywhere else on LI. It has a more charred flavor and better consistency in many ways. So all in all, it was a good experience except that the eggplant pie was not great, and they make the pie with too large a crust. I would like to see the cheese and sauce go further to the end. Solid 4 stars. read more

Amazing food!!! However the service is not something that would make your night, we order water and we finished the appetizers fist. The server never show up with our drinks. Even they hostess had an attitude. I'm sure if the work on the service the experience could be much better. read more

disappointed. unfriendly staff, food was underwhelming. never again will i be spending money there.

The place opened during the pandemic and I thought they were crazy. They knew what they were doing and had a great take out menu. It is my favorite go to place and the food is delicious. My favorite is the pesto pizza. Everyone that works there is very friendly read more