The food was good - however, the cashier was nasty and has an attitude. When I questioned why the cheeseburger I ordered was charged as a burger with a two dollar slice of cheese - when the menu has cheeseburgers listed for one dollar more than a hamburger. She copped an attitude and said "I don't know what you ordered" and begrudgingly changed the ticket. read more

My husband and I come to this diner at least one day over the weekend for breakfast. We always ask for Lisa , she is a spectacular and out going waitress. We are enjoying all there new updates to the diner, since under new management and owners. read more

See all

While taking a Saturday road trip and growing hungry, we decided to stop at the first restaurant that we came across, which was the Chestnuthill diner. My wife and I decided to split a classic BLT, which came with fries and coleslaw. I will admit the fries were some of the best (right up there with McDonald's), the coleslaw without mayo (we like it that way), and the sandwich was delicious. Virginia M was our waitress, and what a delightful person she was, and she directed our attention towards dessert to finish our lunch. Needless to say, we left a clean plate. I highly recommend this diner, and hopefully, you will be seated in Virginia M's area. read more

Wonderful waitress(Danielle D), fast service, great food. Loved that the Christmas decorations were still up. Had to shelter here in a snowstorm and what a lucky choice! Thank you. F read more

Food and service are always excellent, but they've increased their prices so much it has become unaffordable. Breakfast at 8am was $26.95 for 2 pancakes, 1 piece of scrapple, 2 eggs and home fries and one cup of coffee. When I asked why the prices have risen so dramatically I was told it's because they weren't making any money. Maybe if they stopped adding gaudy decorations inside and outside they'd make more of a profit. We've been customers for over 20 years and now, sadly, we won't go back read more

Large locale located in the middle of busy route 209 with many options to choose from in their menu. Went for brunch and got a Caesar salad wrap that was fantastic. My dad got the eggs Benedict with home fries but the eggs weren't poached and the home fries looked a little sad. The service was great and it was very cheap. read more

Chestnuthill Star Diner - Caesar Salad Wrap - New American Near Me - Brodheadsville, Pennsylvania

I've been to the Chestnuthill Diner twice in the past 3-4 months and I can't say either experience was bad. Parking can be a bit of a challenge because this place gets packed! The inside always seems to have plenty of seating though. The first trip I came I sat right at the bar and had a nice older woman for a waitress. She was friendly and kept me topped off on coffee. The hot sausage, eggs and home fries with some toast was a nice portion and delicious. On the second visit I had sat in one of the dining areas and had a younger woman taking care of me, my son and a neighbor. She was quick with her service, helpful with the menu and took care of us. I had sausage links, scrambled eggs and home fries with toast. Everything again was fresh, delicious and a nice portion. I noticed large groups coming in both times and they always seem to have enough seating for them. Both visit were on a Sunday morning and per person I was spending under $10. The building is a bit outdated, but I think it was pretty clean. It's hard to find a good breakfast spot in the area, so I'm happy these guys are there! read more

Great home cooking and casual atmosphere. We always come here when we're in the area. I definitely recommend this place.

Ordered a catering breakfast order from here a few weeks back. From start to finish it was a EASY. They couldn't have been better about communication, pricing, availability, and the menu. Everything was cooked the morning of (prior to 6am) so I know they came in early to do so. 100% accuracy on everything. It was great. We forgot to buy serving spoons and tongs --- and they actually let us borrow some to utilize until we were finished. Great experience. read more

We had fabulous service. Acceptable coffee and good food. Happy that we stopped in on a whim.

Excellent breakfast. Best home fries I've had in quite some time. They were cooked perfectly. Eggs were good and corned beef hash was homemade and delicious! Coffee was great too. We will definitely be back. read more

Stopped here for lunch after funeral. Lisa waitress was so attentive, caring, and went above and beyond to not only serve our food which was awesome. She explained the prices and what we could expect. She listened to everyrhing i said and it was so nice to talk with her about how to reheat my extra food at home to give it the best flavor by using an air fryer. I wasnt just a person dining but a person she really cared about. That speaks volumes. 10 stars for her. 12/7/24 read more

Food is your typical diner selections. I had the Texas burger and found it to be fairly dry, they definitely skimped on the sauce this thing was suppose to have. Fries were pretty good though. My wife had the veggie quesadilla, she enjoyed it but holy crap was it ever greasy. There was a pool of gease on her plate at the end, which was a little confusing since it was all veggies. Bathrooms are not wheelchair friendly. My wife had to leave hers in the hallway and make the journey to to her stall on foot, which isn't a good time for her. Wish the bathrooms had been more accessible. read more

Chestnuthill Star Diner - Outside - New American Near Me - Brodheadsville, Pennsylvania

Service is slow if not at all. Food was horrible, I gave them a 2nd opportunity to make me want to come back. Not ever again. Arlington Diner in Stroudsburg is the best. read more

I love pancakes! The pancakes here suit me and my craving. The specials board offers a variety of breakfast, lunch and dinner entrees. We usually go for breakfast and the food is made to order and HOT! I usually order the breakfast feast with 2 eggs, hme fries, choice of meat plus pancakes or French toast and coffee, $10. Extra hungry ?, order the hamburger with the fried egg. ALL the waitresses are personable and efficient with service. Three dining rooms and a bar. It may look old yet their health score is consistently "100"!! Try it on your way up the mountains. read more

Great food and good prices. Portions are good also. Service was great and it's a comfortable place to eat and enjoy.

Ordered a Turkey Club sandwich to go. The bread was stale white bread not toasted and no bacon. When I called to complain, the woman said oh you ordered no bacon(not true) and you have to ask to have it toasted. If you want to own an American diner you need to learn how to make American food. I got charged though for a Turkey Club. no money off for no bacon. I won't be back. read more

We haven't had breakfast here in a while, but to our surprise, the food was still great. Bit shout out to Ms.Pat our server she was wonderful and had a big sense of humor. We will visit again soon. Thanks Chestnuthill Diner. read more

See all

Delicious breakfast specials! I had French toast, scrambled egg, bacon, and coffee for under $10. Service was excellent and had a nice, attentive waitress. read more

Chestnuthill Star Diner - French toast special - New American Near Me - Brodheadsville, Pennsylvania

We had breakfast there and followed with dinner. Breakfast was a 5. Outstanding. Returned for dinner, it was a 1. Average 2.5 rounded to 3 for ambiance. Service was great at both. Spaghetti sat in a bowl of water small amount of marinara sauce. Meat balls were delicious. Partner's dinner was a bit greasy. Will go there anytime for breakfast and will. read more

This place was a 5 star, as far as diners go, but they must've changed owners & staff, cause the service is awful and the food is either raw or overcooked, just never done correctly. It's a shame. This place was my favorite local restaurant. read more

Really good spot to hit after a fun afternoon at the nearby winery. The cheeseburger deluxe and coffee were exactly what we were looking for! Would certainly go back, and next time I'm trying one of those pies! read more

Went here for breakfast, service extremely slow, toast soggy! Lots of staff, so don't know why service was so slow.

Where to get started.. So walking in, you know the place has been there for years. Decades. The wait staff in the morning, as much as I'd hate to say it, simply don't get along with customers unless it's their longtime usuals. If you're in your 20's, even 30's, don't bother waiting for even a smile. Now as far as the food goes, it's not bad. Honestly, it's not bad at all. Stay away from anything with a gravy or thickened sauce however. The "cooks" use a lot of flour as a thickener and instead of concentrating their flavors by reducing the liquid, it's thickened obnoxiously with flour which after even 5 minutes of cooling down on your plate, it instantly begins to cake. Aside from these horrors, it's not a bad spot to stop at for some breakfast. read more

Great food for a great price. Staff are friendly and helpful making decisions and or substituting items in meals .

Come here for terrible food, miserable staff and even worse service! We inconvenienced the hostess who was sitting at the bar eating a meal as we walked through the door. She seemed incredibly irritated about having to seat us. When we got to the table it took a pretty long while to be approached by anyone for drinks or our order. Right after our order was taken another waitress approached us requesting our drink order, we politely said that it was already taken and she rolled her eyes and walked away. While waiting for our food (which took an insane amount of time for two eggs, scrapple and a Buffalo chicken wrap) there were already three complaints around us about their orders. When we finally got out food, the eggs were supposed to be over easy, they were more hard, the scrapple was super greasy and the chicken and lettuce were incredibly slimy and left me feeling sick. I normally don't like leaving bad reviews because I get that people have bad days and working in the service industry is not an easy but there was not a single friendly face or disposition in this location and the food was certainly not worth the food or the price. read more

First time going to the Chestnuthill Diner...and definitely won't be the last! We ordered creamed chipped beef and pork roll Benedict...both were outstanding. Spent time talking to the owner who was such a nice guy and really seems to care about making people happy. It was a great first experience and we look forward to coming back. read more

How does this place survive? Are people out here that clueless and without standards? You're better off throwing your money in the garbage can. At least you won't have to eat the food. I believe Stevie wonder is cooking in the kitchen as omelettes come out burnt. Terrible that no one cares what leaves their kitchen. It's supposed to be a privilege to serve someone not a chore. read more

Chestnuthill Star Diner - Burnt disaster of an omelette. It's actually an I don't care. - New American Near Me - Brodheadsville, Pennsylvania

Food was good. Had the $12.99 special...BUT, when I paid I never got my $5 voucher/coupon....The owner said there out of them!!

Lots of seating and parking Food is quick Nice stafff Kid friendly They make really good coffee read more

Chestnuthill Star Diner - New American Near Me - Brodheadsville, Pennsylvania

It normally scares me to see so many options on a menu, but everything my family ordered was delicious! We also loved the view looking out at the wonderful trees! read more

The waitstaff was nice but the food was not good. We ordered simple menu options. Chicken fingers and fries with a salad. The salad was old had brown spots and the grape tomatoes withering I would not eat it! The fries and chicken fingers were over cooked. Husband ordered a burger it was not very good. Our friends ordered burgers as well with fries that we're overcooked. The waitress topped off my friends seltzer with water! Not asking what was in her glass. Hopefully they get better as they were before this plandemic! For how we will eat elsewhere read more

I don't understand the 3 stars, the food is always fresh, the staff is lovely, the prices are more then fair, interior design is like any other dinner but they keep it nice and clean. I often get my breakfast from there, got very sensitive stomach and never got disappointed- therefore 5 stars read more

Best diner in the area. I've been going there since I was a kid, food is above average for a diner. Definitely a early day staple in this area read more

Came at 9:00 with my dad after a night of skiing. Very friendly staff, and a cozy diner atmosphere. Loooots of options on the menu, there is something for everyone!! We settled for a Cajun chicken panini and a chicken sandwich on a roll (deluxe). Both come with fries, coleslaw, and pickles. Our sandwiches were surprisingly tasty!! I'd recommend this place, and will come back again. read more

Chestnuthill Star Diner - Grilled Chicken Sandwich Deluxe - New American Near Me - Brodheadsville, Pennsylvania

See all

Food was awful. Potatoes were cold and old. The shrimp was fishy French onion soup had more croutons than soup

Really a nice spot for a quick lunch. The Vegan food was very well made and we were pleasantly surprised by the variety

Since take over, prices increased. Discontinued Senior Menu. Promised Senior Discount but nobody knows how to ring it up. Told had carrots but when served didn't have & brought out Corn & potatoes (Not ordered) (wasted money). "Remodeled" Bathroom but lock on stalls still don't work. Meatloaf was dry. No smiles from the new owner. Original Chestnuthill Diner used to be our favorite local restaurant. Not anymore. What a disappointment. read more

. Tasted homemade. Fast and excellent sevice.service. we ordered the Mariella omlette and the 2 egg special that comes with home fries. My dad ordered the hash with his eggs and loved it. read more

Food is not the same as it use to be . Nothing comes out as ordered and soup is microwaved! Servers in the evening are rude and do not care about the customers. -1 star . Let me say that the Breakfast servers are still pleasant. read more