Every time I'm here. The food is beyond good. The service is also excellent. My only issue is that…read moreit's so darn expensive but they make it up with their fri portion.

When you're craving a classic, no-nonsense, heavyweight burger in York, Five Guys is always a…read morereliable go-to. Whether you're hitting the location on Loucks Road or the rebuilt spot on Haines Road, it's fast, consistently high quality, and they never skimp on the portions. From a Virginia Takeout to York, PA. What makes eating here even cooler is knowing the brand's great origin story. It started back in 1986 in Arlington, Virginia, when Jerry and Janie Murrell gave their sons a choice: "Start a business or go to college." The business route won, and the original "Five Guys" (Jerry and his four eldest sons--later shifting to mean the five brothers after the youngest was born) opened a tiny, no-seating burger joint. Their simple formula of hand-formed burgers and fresh-cut fries cooked in pure peanut oil gained a massive cult following. Fast forward through their franchising boom, and they finally brought that legendary DC-area blueprint to York, cementing it as a local fast-casual staple. If you want the definitive Five Guys experience, here is exactly what to order: Bacon Cheeseburger: This is a masterclass in backyard-style burger execution. The two fresh, hand-formed patties are perfectly seared and juicy, layered with melted American cheese and a generous amount of crispy, smoky applewood bacon. The best part is the customizable toppings--getting it "All the Way" (mayo, lettuce, pickles, tomatoes, grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, ketchup, and mustard) gives you that perfect, messy, flavor-packed bite. Cajun Fries: You can't leave without a brown paper bag stained with peanut oil. Their fresh-cut boardwalk fries are incredible on their own, but throwing on the Cajun seasoning takes them to the next level. They are crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside, and packed with a spicy, smoky, salty kick that builds with every bite. Plus, their "extra scoop" in the bag means you get enough fries to feed an army. It's easily one of the best spots in the area for a quick, massive, and entirely satisfying burger fix.

Love their Club sub with the applewood smoked bacon. The rewards points are great, I've received…read moreso many free subs!

We have not been here for awhile as our last experience was not the best including pricing but we…read morewere hungry for subs and decided to give it another try. Well we will make sure to go to the competition down the street then next time we want subs. The guy seemed to be more interested in taking care of an order of a customer that was not currently there but was more focused on making the sub go that other order perfect while basically ignoring our subs. We both had to repeat ourselves several times with what we wanted as the guy kept asking , including for the Mike's Way as I asked for it to include light on the oregano and my husband asked for light on the oil and this seemed to baffle the guy. Well we get home and my #8 club sub had no tomatoes at all on the entire sub, we both got giant sized, and I am pretty sure he also missed putting the oil and stuff on my sub and we both only had one strip of bacon on both of our giant subs. My husband had a #9 roast beef sub and said it was just okay. But yet that other order that the guy was definitely more focused on I'm sure was perfect as this is where the guy's focus was instead of paying attention to the customers standing right in front of him. Again we will not be coming back and will be going to Jimmy John's down the street where we have gotten good subs and service. The only thing I will say is the place seemed clean and the temperature inside was comfortable. Sorry, your staff's fault

This place is SOOOO good! Was a favorite when I used to live in the area. Came back on vacation and…read moredid NOT disappoint! Was immediately seated, staff was attentive and friendly. Atmosphere is casual and welcoming. Relaxed. The food... did NOT disappoint! The same as I remembered. DELICIOUS! This IS a must hit spot!

For all the years I have lived in York, HOW have I never been to Mexitaly before?? I guess I was…read moreworried it would be an incongruous mixture of the two cuisines- but that is far from the case. Great Mexican, great Italian, great beer, great service, and a perfect hipster ambience. We had our Valentine's day dinner here, and the place was packed but service was still attentive and timely. We had nachos to start and pizza to follow, and washed it down with some craft beers- a positively indulgent college-esque combo, but prepared in a high-quality way. Oh, and they play great music. I loved it.

The subs here are great. Wish I could say the same thing about parking. By definition it's a sad…read moresituation. It's not only the tightest parking lot in east York but it's also used as a road for other cars to get to the grocery store. Some of the most entitled drivers you will ever cross is guaranteed to be in this parking lot. Not being able to make a left hand turn is another part of the hassle in this parking lot. This parking lot is the worst experience in all of east York. If you drive a pickup truck be warned. This parking lot is not for us. I was tempted to eat my food and watch the madness from my truck today but felt like the safer option would be to get out of the sub hazard parking lot.

Great subs always same taste and quality service is fast and efficient Great tasting sub every timeread more

Muy buen servicio y exlentes precios lo recomiendo le doy 10 de 10 pasen para q lo prueben sé q no…read morese arrepentirá

Food wasn't bad but not good service. Ordered draft beer off menu that now is not available. No…read moreapology just told as a stated fact. Had to chase down hostess to get some chips and salsa. Food dropped off with no follow up if needed anything. Had to call out to server to get some cheese since none on tacos.

My sandwich wasn't cooked all the way and it couldn't I don't know what else to say but it wasn't…read morecooked all the way I could have gotten sick

Consistent Popeyes Chicken. No matter what Popeyes you go to the food seems to be the same just…read morelike going to McDonald's but for chicken

Firehouse Subs is a rare sight in Eastern PA, with several closing over the years, so when you find…read moreone it is a treat. This Firehouse Subs is located in the York Marketplace among a strip of other stores. It's large for a Firehouse subs, and has two Coke Freestyle machines. Ordering was fast enough and I went with the Hook & Ladder. It took a while for my food to be ready, but they were not that busy. One of the Freestyle machines was also out of order. As with many places, Firehouse Subs isn't the cheapest place to get a sub, but they are delicious. This one does need a little work, however.

Avoid. Reopened and didn't even have sandwiches that were listed on the menu. Then we paid 27.00…read more(twenty seven dollars !!) for 2 medium subs and a drink that shrank in size to half from the previous owner. Caveat emptor.

Great service and good! Will definitely return. Manager was super hospitable!…read more Our pizza prepper was amazing! my pizza was delicious! This is the place!

I ordered a pizza Sunday night March 8, 2025, to be delivered to my apartment right up the street…read morefrom the store, when the pizza arrived it was cold, then when I opened the box it was the wrong pizza, I ordered thick crust Mad Dog with extra of what comes on it.. I called the store to explain that I had received the wrong pizza, the guy tried to blame the driver for giving me the wrong pizza, when she clearly didn't she read my name on the ticket and gave me the box that had my name, again clearly your mistake in the store because someone wasn't paying attention.. Then the guy hangs up on me and didn't answer when I called back.. I will be there first thing in the morning with the wrong pizza with the ticket that was placed on the box to say that it was my order. So, they get zero starts from me. And I probably wouldn't be so mad, if the guy hadn't hung up the phone!! customer service really!! I nor my family will be eating here anymore. I want my money back since they can't get my order right and then be rude and hang up, who does that!