My family and I had a great experience at CiCi's Pizza! The food was delicious, fresh, and the buffet stayed fully stocked the entire time we were there. James and the staff were absolutely amazing -- super friendly, attentive, and constantly making sure the restaurant stayed clean and welcoming. You can really tell they care about providing great service and a great experience for their guests. We'll definitely be back! read more

new manager doing a great job! Food was hot. Manager very attentive walking Around tables. Remembered us by name

Cicis on Atlantic Blvd is a fun and incredible restaurant. And the owner is kind and understanding. I have been going there for 12 years 3 times a week because it is the best value in Jacksonville! And the food is always hot and fresh with football playing on the TVs. Plus they will make any pizza you ask for so I will continue to go for the next 12 years. read more

Beautiful place. Great staff. My kids favorite pizza restaurant. They make any kind of pizza we request.

Interesting how my previous review did not show up here and the owner tries to send me a message on Facebook to call them. I took my grand children to this location on Sunday October 6th for lunch. As we were walking by the pizza buffet I saw a live cockroach crawling right on the counter. Another customer knocked it to the floor. She told a young man behind the counter. He can around and picked it up with a napkin. If they are crawling right out there in the middle of daylight, you can imagine what is going on behind the counter. I do not need any messages saying you don't believe it and to call you. There is nothing you could say that would change what happened. read more

Oh, what a lovely place this pizza buffet is--if you can just ignore the circus of lousy people that seem to appear every single time I go. Seriously, it must be a talent to gather that many loud, messy, and questionably-behaved individuals in one place. But hey, that's not the restaurant's fault... I think. Now to give credit where it's due--the pizza? Fantastic. It's actually really well made and tastes great every time. They keep it fresh and stocked, and it's honestly hard not to go back for a third (or fourth) plate. Plus, the prices are super reasonable, especially for families. It's a good bang for your buck when you're feeding a small army of kids. The service is generally solid. The staff keeps things running and the tables cleared. That said, I did once get spit on by a cashier who very confidently shouted "hawk tuah" when I tried to pay with Apple Pay. Not exactly the customer service moment of the year, but hey, I guess they were passionate about their payment methods. The vibe of the place is great too. Cartoons are always playing on the TVs (perfect for distracting the little ones--or me, let's be honest), and there's even a small arcade to keep things fun. All in all, it's a good spot... as long as you're cool with some chaos and maybe a little unexpected spit. read more

The employees are helpful and attentive. So much so that I felt bad for not tipping afterward. They don't put out too much pizza at a time, or at least pizza I want I want to eat. They do happily make anything you ask for. read more

This is great kid pizza. So if you need some pizza for a birthday party, or you want to have pizza for the sitter and kids when you go out, this is the place. read more

I've never been to Cici's, I'm from the northwest and we have a place called Izzy's that I figured it was similar to. I wasn't too wrong, but I was a little surprised because for $6.49 you can't beat AYCE pizza, salad and dessert. I had a couple encounters with Bryan (the manager) on Wednesday night and his customer service and hot food control was on point. Hot pizza was consistently put up and so were the cinnamon rolls and brownies. The salad is what I went for but I left knowing I would be back for the pizza and cinnamon rolls. Don't come here expecting a buffet with a plethora of option, you will be disappointed. But what I did get was a clean restaurant (and bathrooms), good customer service, hot pizza and some of the best cinnamon rolls I've tasted. I woke up this morning with Cici's on the brain, that's a good sign.... right?! read more

OUTSTANDING concept!!!! Great food at a fare price!!!!! The people are fantastic!!!!! read more

I haven't had Cicis since my kids were teenagers, all grown now- I just don't eat much fast food/junk food. My nephews were visiting and my adult son loves pizza- mom and I opted to do lunch with the boys here. My nephews are 12 & 14 and very picky eaters & this is a great option to make everyone happy. I was happy to see the salad bar looking fresh. We dug right into everything. The kids definitely ate enough to feel like we got a great value. Mom, Eddie and I all got big salads to start and then hit up the pizza bar to grab various kinds of pizza. I always enjoy their spinach pizza and the kids liked the buffalo chicken pizza best. Dessert pizzas also were inhaled by all. The custard pie and apple pizza were good, but the cinnamon rolls (fresh) were the best. They did a great job keeping the pizzas coming out for the lunch crowd. I would dine here again if entertaining kids. read more

I haven't been to Cicis since I was a kid so for date night we decided to change it up and go here. We do not regret it. The cashier was extremely nice!! We got the buffet. They had a salad bar, chicken noodle soup, pasta noodles with a side sauce of marinara and white cheese which were both soo good! The pizzas were fabulous so was the cheese sticks it tasted so good with the marinara option! My favorite out of the whole buffet was the cinnamon rolls so warm and delicious!! I definitely recommend this restaurant if you have kids or budgeting. If you are a water drinker they no longer have water cups at this location but they do sell 50¢ water bottles. read more

Cicis Pizza - This was my 5th plate which was delicious - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

We drove an hour to get here expecting it to be a decent location, but our expectations were significantly lowered. One of the members in our party has an allergy to onion and garlic. Other cicis locations are able to accommodate and make her a personal pizza. (The red sauce has garlic so they have to remove that) At this location, however, they put hardly any cheese at all on the pizza. See the pics. It was so disgusting she did not want to eat it at all. She then asked if they could redo it with more cheese, but they told her they weren't allowed to make more than one personal pizza for someone; that it would "go against their policy." Since when? We have been many times to cicis pizza and they are always happy to make her another pizza if the first is unsatisfactory. She came into the restaurant starving, and hoping to have a good dinner, but left hungry and very unhappy with the staff's inability to make her personal pizza correctly. Also, this location does not serve water. Only soda. They make you pay extra for a bottle of water, so that was also very frustrating. They also didn't serve any pasta for the entire time we were there, even though many guests kept asking and waiting for the pasta. Hopefully next time we go to Cicis it will be a much better experience. read more

Cicis Pizza - Personal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

This location brings back so many memories. The quality of food is even better than I remember back in the 90s. The place isn't as big as I thought but there's at least a dozen tables occupied by families of 4 or larger and the flow of the environment compliments the quaint space. Melissa was super helpful and very courteous. We haven't been to CiCi's since 2008 and I applaud this location, staff, and product it offers. The arcade is made up of about 10 large games with two huge motorcycle riding games in the middle of the store. I haven't seen a single table with leftover plates or debris nor have I seen any trash on the floor. The only set back for our family is that you don't have access to free water at the drink fountain, my husband drinks a gallon of water at every meal and our 3 & 4 year old don't drink soda. They do offer refrigerated water bottles for .50 so that's good!! They have every pizza you can remember with hot and fresh ones being delivered to the buffet every few minutes. The staff is above the standard for keeping their product high & tight. Delicious flavors, fresh ingredients, and a friendly staff .. what more could you ask for? read more

See all

Affordable delicious pizza with a bunch of varieties along with dessert pizza. Get to play games. It is great you can request when something is not available. A great place for date nights or gatherings with your family. read more

Cicis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

This is the first I've been to CiCi's since I moved to Florida. I was heading to the grocery store and I was starving so I figured I should grab dinner first. Plus the Yelp reviews were positive. I was greeted as I entered the restaurant which I thought was a nice touch. After I made my purchase the associate gave me his name and told me to let him know if I needed anything. The pizza bar was full and I grabbed one piece of three different pies. The flat bread pizza crust was hard, but the other two slices were good. I also ate a salad. All the ingredients were fresh and I was pleased with the variety of salad toppings. Desert was yummy, but the cinnamon bun with icing was my favorite! I would eat here again. read more

See all

I dined in today here, and left very happy. Customer service was great, greeted at the door and was asked if there was anything they could add to the buffet for me. The place was clean. Chad took care to make sure I was happy, I really appreciate that! I usually leave here in a good mood but today was a a nice tempo change. Thank ya'll! read more

When we were standing in line for pizza we saw a cockroach crawl inside one of the pizza boxes they had stacked up in the corner. The pizza taste very cheap and the owner is not kind to his employees. read more

It's been over 10 years since I've eaten at a Cici's! I was pretty skeptical as my previous experience didn't leave me wanting more.. but why not, it's surely changed... The staff members immediately greeted us in unison with a pleasant smile! The interior was revamped and very modern. The cost is seriously the best for unlimited pizza, dessert and salad bar! You can't really come in looking for quality but more of quantity. Enjoyed the personal flat bread pizza (only one personalized) one! read more

the buffet suppose to be 4.99 adults but it's was 4.99 off the buffet and me and my friend on a Tuesday

It's been years since the last time I've eaten at Cici's. My son had not tried it so I took him after a long bike trails ride at Hanna Park. They shout "Welcome to Cici's!" when you enter the restaurant. Friendly and energetic staff. Their buffet is now $5.99. I guess that's dinner price? It's like a party in there. Very busy. Some pizzas are not bad and some tasted nasty. It's like a pizza experiment on some pies. I liked their chicken noodle soup and small salad bar. They also had pasta, but none for me. read more

See all

Food was great! Everything was clean and plenty of pizza. The manger even ask did we want him to make something special. The cost was 23 bucks for 2 adults. You can't beat that. read more

It's coming up a star or two on the place! The renovated the place and it looks great. The salad, pizza and cinnamon rolls were good. The bus boy stopped by our table two or three times. I was too full to try the pasta and sauce or the soup this visit. The Manager that was on duty today was young, energetic and hard working-team playing is what it is all about. CI CI CI you later! read more

See all

i remember coming here when I was much younger just about everyday after Sunday church and even though the options were limited when entering i loved it , i haven't been there in forever but last time i went which was a while ago it brought me euphoria smelling their iconic brownies , seeing people still go there was a relief because i was glad it was still open and ¿seen? since it was a pretty small but spacious place , but overall their soup is most definitely my favorite and this specific place will always be a favorite read more

VERY crowded. they needed staff for the back as well as staff for the lobby. not a pleasant experience. read more

Cicis Pizza - pine apple and ham - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

For the price not bad. I did get a drink. They have an arcade. Friendly staff. Good location on Atlantic

Brought my niece & nephews for pizza night on the cheaper side. We all requested different types of pizza & loved the variety we were able to choose from. Staff was super friendly & bubbly. Had a great experience & night with the family. Just FYI save some room for dessert, the cinnamon rolls were warm & delicious!! read more

Didn't even finish eating bc of how gross the food was. No actually the food was good for the most part but most of the pizza wasn't cooked all the way. The crust was chewy and you could still see the dough inside of it. Brought my gf for the 1st time and talked highly of Cici's (yeah I know I can't believe she's never been either. I think she was raised in a barn, shhh ) just to be proved wrong. Needless to say, she never wants to go back and I can't say I disagree man and I rlly liked cicis. read more

I will give this review as based upon the management. We walked in 8p on a Saturday night and were pleased to see the remodel. The bar was pretty empty and by no way reflected 15 varieties of pizza as advertised but the salad bar looked inviting. Now this place is known for special orders availability when you order the buffet but this manager decided that asking for garlic bread to accompany the pasta WITHOUT CHEESE demanded an additional fee. Seriously?? Needless to say, we left as this was a manager's decision. read more

Cicis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Sometimes, your brain tells you that you want something very specific. I have been wanting cinnamon rolls... But not just any, Cici's. I haven't been to Cici's in like 8 years. I finally convinced my family to go today. I promised that if we didn't like what we see, we would leave. We came in at 4pm. There were 2 other customers inside. The manager greeted us right away. Not having stepped into Cici's in so long, we were surprised that it was clean and updated from what we had been to way back in the day. It's $6.29 for adults and at 3... $20 is all our dinner came to. (No soda or wings for us.) The salad bar is expanded with a few more choices like raw broccoli and carrots. Chickpeas. Beets. They also have a chicken and cavatappi pasta soup (I didn't have any) and cavatappi pasta with red or alfredo sauce (I also did not have this either.) A dozen different pizzas. Breadsticks. Desserts: Apple or Bavarian cream pizza. Cinnamon rolls. Brownies. Also, you can order pizza any way you want. You just grab an order sheet and they will give you a buzzer when it's done. I ordered a flatbread that took maybe 10 minutes from order to pick up. Their flatbread comes out really thin and crispy. While we were there, I sat facing the kitchen. The manager constantly kept the line clean. The staff constantly kept the bar stocked. More and more people came in. The staff continued to keep up with the line as well an individual orders. I alway noticed that when smaller children came up without a parent, the manager helped them get food from the line. (Customer issue though- parents should not let their kids serve themseIves at buffets ever. Luckily, I didn't see any "violations" y'all know what I'm talking about.) I also visted the restroom which was also clean though I feel the soap in the dispenser was watered down (it may just be the formula, I washed my hands twice.) So I have to say, overall. Everything was great. It's cheap and filling. Certainly great for families on a budget. This location is clean and obviously the staff is doing a great job. Oh, and I got my cinnamon bun fix. read more

Cicis Pizza - Personal flatbread. - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I usually love eating at Cici's to get away from home, but my most recent dine-in was a really frustrating experience. The guy who cleans the tables was beyond rude. I'd leave for less than a minute and he just throws away my drink without ANY warning. I pretty much have to wrap my jacket around the cup to make it obvious that I'm not leaving the restaurant. He never once asked "Hi sir, are you finished with your meal?" He'd also glare at me from several feet away, like I'm the messy one. read more

I like my Cici's Pizza, and judging from the crowd yesterday, so do a lot of other people! Even with all the foot traffic and hungry folks, they were able to keep the food coming. The salad bar was fresh and the bar ,as a whole, was clean. For $5.00 you get a full belly! Right now though they are running all kinds of crazy specials. It was down to $3.99 for a while there! The layout of the store seems bigger to me than others I have been in. Maybe it is because of the extra wide windowed store front. The store is as clean as they can keep it and the food fresh and hot. read more

Cicis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Doesn't accept coupons with their name and address on them. "Save around" coupons to be exact. Doesn't allow you to geek free water cups. SAve your money and go elseWhere. read more

Another excellent time at CiCi's! Friendly staff here who keeps the buffet filled with delicious pizza . Don't forget to have you some dessert pizza as well! Driving home may be difficult as you will likely be in a level 10 food coma. read more

Cicis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Horrible experience. Yelp and the website says closes at 10. The manager was letting people come in at 850. He never once told anyone we are cooking anymore pizza. My husband and I got two slices of pizza and that was it. There was a family of about 12 that came in after us. Once again the manager didn't say we aren't making anymore food but took there money. There hours are also not posted on their door. read more

Manager seemed to have an uattitude and sour face. The food was great, however the manager just seemed to be pissed off and didn't even show the slightest smile or enthusiasm almost wanted to walk right out the door just because of that vibe. Pizza 10/10 , friendly atmosphere Eh. read more

Not bad little place to down some pizza. It's not gourmet but it is fresh. Cici's will make you a personal pizza also if you don't want anything that's on the pizza bar. I had the cook make me a personal buffalo chicken pizza. Not bad came out piping hot. Could have used a little more cheese and chicken on it but for an AYCE pizza it was good and for a cheap price. The ambience was nice. I was very happy with the customer service. The restaurant was clean the hot bar area was kept very neat. For 5.99 per person, it's a quick lunch that is affordable. Kid 10 & under eat for 2.99. read more

Cicis Pizza - Personal buffalo chicken pizza made fresh thumbs up for cicis - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Maybe the previous reviewers had to deal with an incompetent former staff, but I can assure you that this is no longer any issue. I was met with probably some of the best service ive EVER had, which was (admittedly) unexpected. They were super friendly, answered all my questions, and the manager was unrivaled in awesomeness, singing whenever a new pizza was finished and happily greeting everyone who entered or left (quote, "Cici ya later!"). Maybe this seems a bit cheesy, but I think everyone there was a refreshing change from the dreary unenthusiastic wait staff I see everywhere else. So what if "it's just cicis"? Good work deserves to be appreciated. read more

See all

Good value for your money. Not great pizza but if your hungry they kick out the slices pretty consistantly. Restaurant cleanliness needs attention for sure and there were several unbussed tables every where. read more

Cicis Pizza - Testing out the pizza buffet bar - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Stopped in for a quick dinner on a Saturday night. The place was busy, but not so busy where we were able to find a table. The buffet was consistently stocked, and the staff was very friendly. You can't beat it for the price! I would definitely return to this location. read more

Cicis Pizza - Stuffed crust pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida