This place is so close to home and we always said we wanted to try this place out. They had an interesting cocktail menu and a very I treating way to order seafood here. You pick your seafood, then your flavor, then your spice level. Such a fun and cool concept! I had the crab and crawfish and the Cajun seasoning is an absolute must try. The place inside was nice and had really cool decor for the kids to check out while eating. Great place and good food. read more

See all

Food: Great! Service: Solid 4/5. The atmosphere is fun and the music is good. This location had an increase of dine & dashers in the previous years and as a result, they charge you before your food comes. Not a problem. My problem is with being charged 20% gratuity that shows up in my transactions, but not on the receipt. We are made aware that a party of 6+ will automatically be charged 18%. I, one person, was automatically charged 20%, that I would've given on my own by the way, and it was wiped from my receipt. I understand paying before we are served, but we as customers deserve to tip as WE see fit, not as they see fit. I still tipped $5 just in case of the off chance that it was a mistake, or that it went to someone other than my server. I've loved this place over the years but there are better places that deserve gratuity, and that would allow me to make that decision on my own. read more

See all

IMO, NONE of the, now ubiquitous, crab shacks in this town deserve 5 stars. But, of all the crab boil joints in Toledo, Cincy Crab is probably the best, and I grade on a normal curve. Therefore, 5 stars!! Maybe it was just that the spirit of Christmas Eve blessed us with good fortune, but everyone in my family had a very positive experience. The wife is VERY picky when it comes to her seafood. Even so, she thought her shrimp cocktail and raw oysters (on the half shell) were excellent. She was seriously surprised by how fresh they were, in both taste and texture. She also had the scallops, Cajun boiled, medium. Her only complaint, as well as mine, is that all of the boil formulations use too much butter (soy butter actually), and butter flavor comes through. Too much. It's much like getting wings with mild sauce...you think you're going to drown in butter. I'm not into the whole "boil scene," not outside of Arcadiana, anyway. So, I ordered Cajun fried rice with sausage. Although the rice was a bit dry, in general, I was quite pleased. The dish was surprisingly tasty! Who cares what the kids got. They ordered some messy, hoty, buttery, seafoody, boily things. They were happy. Beer selection? Not great. But, when I'm eating things that are especially hot, I'm perfectly content with a light domestic lager...specifically, Coors light, baby! Special shout out to our waiter, Tracy. This guy was fantastic. He, and his crew, really went out of their way, on Christmas Eve, to make our meal fun and special. read more

Cincy crab - "Cajun" fried rice with sausage...for those of us not really into the boil scene. - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Came in to order Togo. It was very busy that night but the staff were super friendly and quick with my order. I was pleasantly surprised with the pricing and quality of my meal. Would love to get food from here again. read more

Cincy crab - 2 pounds of Crawfish, 1 pound of Shrimp (Head On), and their sauce mix on the side. (I had my own brown rice on the side) - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Finally made it to Cincy Crab and I'm kicking myself for not trying it sooner. Simply wow! This place is amazing. The staff are friendly, welcoming, & help you with any questions. Nicely decorated and clean. Our server, Anahi, was great! Food was hot, delicious, & not overcooked as can sometimes be the case with seafood boil restaurants. But not Cincy Crab. They do it right! We ordered; snow crab, head off shrimp, scallops, garlic butter & Cajun seasoning without spice & EVERYTHING was delicious!! Oh and the drinks.... Yummy!! We had the peach mojito & the Crab Claw. Reasonly priced and worth every penny! I can't wait to come back. We will be regulars for sure! read more

Cincy crab - Receipt for 2 with drinks - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Kristen was a great server and the garlic butter on the shrimp and snow crabs were fantastic. I also haven't had corn this good in a long time. Sweet and spicy with the garlic butter. I was very nervous at first bc they indicated a bunch of incidents where people don't pay and walk out. It can't be bc of the food bc it was great and reasonably priced. The savanna bananas were playing also. Made me eat a second round. Now to the gym. read more

Cincy crab - Loaded with flavor and in from New Orleans. This buttery garlic sauce is great. Try it. - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

The restaurant it self needs to be properly reevaluated! The "manager" "Danny" is abruptly rude to customers! Manger doesn't greet customers and also doesn't help his staff knowing the restaurant needs more help! The restaurant has a pay first policy! Be aware your food order will not be put in to be made until you pay! (It takes the waiters about 10-15 minutes to come back and take your payment) We sat at the bar yesterday hoping to get some margaritas! We never thought sitting at the bar ment gratuity won't be added even tho it shouldn't because you're at the bar! Danny decides to take the time out his little unhappy day to tell us all gratuity will be added to all checks in a very Ill mannered tone! We knew that! And again we expected to pay gratuity! WE WANTED DRINK From there the experience was very unprofessional! Will not be returning especially if "DANNY" stays the manger he will run the establishment to the ground. read more

Food was delicious. Service was awesome. My go to seafood place over the years, but the atmosphere has went down. Paying for food before service. Allowing bonnets in dress code... gives take out restaurant rather than dine in family restaurant with high prices. If customers that leave without paying and bonnets allowed the prices need to be lowered for clientele or have dress code standards. read more

The crab is really good, the shrimp was not bad too. Good vibes inside and the staff were really nice. Only complaint is that the garlic butter could've been saltier. read more

Cincy crab - Combo 1 - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Food was amazing, The service there was great. Staff is very friendly and the place is very clean

A very good place to have a crab boil I enjoyed every bit of my dinner the only thing I would suggest is get the light butter with extra garlic, but little butter was the best read more

I walked in and was seated immediately. My waitress was nice and provided explanations to any questions. I got 1 pound of shrimp and a lobster tail, which came with corn and potatoes. Everything was delicious. I ordered the mix all medium sauce, and the spice level was just right. There was a lot of shrimp, and the lobster tail was enormous. The decorations were nice and funny. Over all I really liked this restaurant. Best seafood boil in Toledo! read more

There boil wasn't as spicy as expected but even when I asked for extra extra spicy. Server took some time to attend us and get refills but overall pretty well done experience read more

Went with my dad they had good prices, the food was great, service was good definitely going back soon!

I came in to buy a few items off there menu to add to my homemade seafood boil I told the lady I wanna buy some sauce but I never had there sauce before so I asked to try a small sample but I was told I have to buy one pound of seafood in order to even buy the sauce so I said ok I'll do that also I wanted to buy some corn and sausage and eggs but I still wanted to try the sauce she told me no I have to buy the seafood first and had a horrible attitude so I kindly said ok thank you an walked out I will never come back here there customer service is not good an I will also be writing the BBB I would not recommend this place to anyone that has not had it before they won't even give you a sample of the sauce to see if you will like it SMH I just moved to this area an I purchase seafood quite often this place will never get my money Sad to say that and they're right down the street. read more

Great service & wonderful food. Tried the boil with extra potatoes, eggs & extra spicy. Went for lunch with a friend & was we tried for the 1st time. Keep up the good work read more

This restaurant reuses old grease and seasoning for meal preparation, and my order of a bagged crab leg meal had all the old grease and overload of mushy seasoning mixed with my food that caused me to feel sick when I tried eating. The manager did nothing about the issue. read more

Dropped in on a Friday night. The place wasn't busy at all. They seemed to be limited in their wait staff however our waitress did very well given how many tables she had. Others in the restaurant were getting the famous seafood boil which came in a bag with a bib. Looked good we just were not up for the mess. The catfish platter came with plenty of food. The hush puppies were very good. The cat fish was average. Overall a decent place, I would return and try another dish. read more

See all

Our server was amazing! She was friendly and answered all of our questions. Our food was really good. I could eat a million crab balls. I usually eat vegan and am currently eating seafood until mid April. We had the Friday special that lasted all weekend. 5 stars read more

I seen the place was only 2.5 stars so I read the reviews and most of them were just referring to the service lol . But the actual food WAS TASTY AF!! I got snow crab legs which they were kinda smaller then usual with sausage eggs and potatoes . The meal Was great , the food did take a little minute to come out but the waitress was nice and tried her best .. but for the most part I loved it read more

Cincy crab - Crab boil - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

See all

First ever boil in a bag experience and it was amazing!!! Very fun, yummy, and our server was nice the special was enough for two read more

Cincy crab - Wednesday special - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Love. Shall she Cindy crab! the only thing? I wish they would add bread to the menu to go with their wonderful sauce. The help is always friendly and helpful. Going back there this Friday.5/3/24 read more

The best seafood boil i've found in the area! Portions were great and so were the prices. The sauce was excellent and the service was amazing. Our waiter was extremely attentive and did such a good job at guiding us through the menu! Will definitely be returning!! read more

The food was delicious as we read on. Yelp the great ratings. We both order walleye dinners with regular fries and I had the sweet potato fries. The food was hot and delicious. I also ordered the lemon drop alcoholic drink but found it a little too sweet for my taste. It was a lovely dinner & will return again! read more

Food was hot and delicious. Our servicer Skye was amazing and very helpful. I would definitely be back. read more

See all

The staff are very friendly and the food was very good will definitely be returning The drinks were good also

Always love the food and service here. Never seems too busy, hope they are making enough to last. Floor under booth is a little sticky, but not something to get excited about. As always this time did not disappoint. read more

Cincy crab - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

See all

I made this yelp account just for this restaurant. I ordered take out which was $50 dollars for one seafood broil.Then when me and my family got there to pick up my daughter was crying that she wanted to go in so we decided to try to just eat inside. The manager told us it wasn't possible because we ordered to go, even though we offered to buy drinks and dessert. So will not be spending anymore money there ever. read more

I love this place!!! It's expensive but worth it, also most seafood restaurants are, and price depends on what you order!! The king crab legs are amazing! They also have Dungeness crab, and snow crab legs! They steam seafood dishes in a bag with your desired spices, I prefer just plain garlic butter non spicy, but they have various options. Plus, steamed seafood bags come with corn and potatoes. The waiter will mix the bag and dump it on your plate right in front of you, and give you gloves and a bib. You can also get different seafood dishes fried! Furthermore, the appetizers were extrodinary, best lobster bisque ever!!! read more

Cincy crab - King crab legs, potatoes, corn - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Cincy Crab was delicious! My husband and I went for my birthday and it was great. We got the combo #1 with the Cajun and garlic flavor and very spicy. I do wish there was a little bit more for the both of us but it was still filling. They were low on staff because of the pandemic but food came out quickly and they even sang to me and gave me a free little cake which was much appreciated. I definitely enjoyed it and probably will go back. read more

Cincy crab - Combo #1 with 1 lb of snow crab, shrimp, corn and sausage. - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Crab is amazing I always order a pound of snow crab with extra potatoes super spircy and w all the spices etc ... Food is amazing service could be better read more

I ordered from here for the first time. I ordered the Family Combo #1. Seasoning I ordered was garlic and butter. No spice. It was excellent!! Large chunks of garlic. The corn in the cob was tender, the red potatoes were cooked perfectly. The snow crab legs were really good and it was loaded with shrimp. I recommend using the gloves they provide lol and the bib as well because of all the delicious butter it's served in. You will need to transfer it to a bowl or container if you order it for pick up (like I did) because it's served in a heavy duty plastic bag :-) I will definitely order from here again read more

Bruh the seafood is good but what makes me curl my toes and bite my lip and get lil warm feeling down there is there sauce and juices it's all sautéed in read more

We were in town for one night only and stopped in. Excellent service, amazing food, and great nightly specials. We ordered a bucket with crab legs, shrimp, mussels, corn, and potatoes in the garlic butter sauce and both left feeling happy and full. read more

Daily specials and nice menu selections. You decide the spices and heat. Safety measures in place. Hope to return to try more flavors. read more

Cincy crab - Great overall selection of seafood items. - Seafood Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

The place was pretty busy on a Sunday late afternoon so apparently somebody likes it. But my partner and my opinions are that it sucks! We got the snow crab and some shrimp. All you could taste was garlic, enough to kill a vampire! It was terrible. Also, it took almost 20 minutes just to get a waiter. We got water for our drinks and that took almost 15 minutes which is okay but once we got our food it didn't even come with napkins. So to make a long story short the service wasn't any better than the food. read more

Although I miss the big boy restaurant, I am so glad a great seafood restaurant opened up. The crab legs were delicious

Took a long time to get greeted by a waiter so that was frustrating. We ordered the family combo 2. One pound shrimp, one pound crawfish and one pound crab. Wrong order came out. A much more expensive one with mussels and lobster tails. Should have eaten that but we didn't want to eat someone else's order. Took a while for our correct order to come out. Flavor was Ok. But not enough for two people. We will come back and try the fried options but the boil is overpriced for what you get. Service needs a lot of work. read more

Fried shrimp is fake and whiting is too.. both were horrible and over priced! $11.99 for fake, tasteless shrimp and $5 for one piece of nasty whiting fish that was tasteless, hard and over cooked. The 2 egg rolls were ok.. even the pre packed Cole slaw was not good. Wasted $20 and won't ever be back read more

This place is OK, I've been to better. They do have competition.